Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To say yes then no ?

89 replies

stillvicarinatutu · 02/10/2021 23:35

I've been good friends with someone I really do love and value for a few years although she is quite demanding as a friend , and quite needy / bossy

Recently this got worse as her marriage ended - her dh asked for divorce . She lives in a 2 million £ house , has cleaners , gardeners etc and doesn't work .
I rent a one bed place , work and am independent.
She asked me if I'd like to move in with her when she moves- she says I'll
Have own room , lounge and bathroom. She wants me to fund some renovations and says well both make money .
At first this sounded like the answer to my prayers - I'm in a rental . She said she would stay home and look after our pets , we'd split the bills so would keep the cleaner , have a great standard of living . I'd be secure new place has a pool , tons and tons of room . Large gardens . .

But the more I'm getting into this arrangement the more precarious it seems . She will be moving abroad as she has a home abroad - she wants me to fund renovations and then when we sell (she sells) well both make something from it . I aren't worried she would rip
Me off or anything like that . But she's needy , demanding, bossy and a drinker . She has a teenage girl who I do adore but I live alone now as both my kids are adult . I love my own space and being my own boss . She's determined this is happening despite when or if I say I have reservations and I've realised without someone else's money she couldn't maintain her standard of living,

We're both single but I've tried to broach the subject of what happens if we meet anyone?
What happens to me when she sells ?
What happens if I can't get a mortgage that's funds the renovations?

She dismisses it all . I'm sure we could live together happily if we do indeed have our own space but I'm getting cold feet and do t know how to
Broach this now because she tells me I'm being silly , being a witterer, a washer woman etc etc and that it will all be fine and to leave everything to her .

Am I being stupid and looking a gift horse in the mouth?
I do love her and I've said I will not put our friendship at risk . She says I'm being daft .

OP posts:
stillvicarinatutu · 05/10/2021 23:23

I messaged a very gentle but honest message earlier this morning. I said I was saying no for the right reasons and from the heart because I don't want us to fall out .

I've had nothing back all day .

This is unusual for someone who rings me 7 times a day

I've sent a
Further message saying I hope we are still friends .

I've messaged because she is domineering and would try and talk me round and because I'm working 12 hours a day at the moment and can't talk .

I'm a bit sad and I know she will be absolutely raging with me but if she ends our friendship over this so be it .

She was texting me at 3 am this morning despite knowing I was up for work at 6 . I feel if we lived together she would be sitting on the edge of my bed instead of texting .
And I can envisage her being "off colour" on a morning and me taking her daughter to school.

I've done that . My kids are very much adults . I enjoy my time alone .

I could be giving up a lovely opportunity but my gut says not to do this because she is demanding, won't take no for an answer, drinks and smokes her way through at least 35£ worth a day . Probably more . If she doesn't respond I'm fine . I like her but hey ho. She isn't always the nicest person to be around and I've stuck around because I know I can go home when I need to.
I think we'd be miserable living together and she would hold the cards . I've told her there is no way she should put a property worth half a million into joint names and I actually do t want to be beholden to her . It would feel like I'm married again ! And I've said what if I do meet someone- I couldn't bring a fell home with her teenage daughter wandering around. It's just too weird . So I've said no , I've said it early so not pissing her about . If she doesn't want to speak to me so be it .

OP posts:
vajingleberry · 05/10/2021 09:32

This has "car crash" written all over it.

The letters are 2 metres high in fluorescent pink paint.

Don't even think about doing it.

QueenBee52 · 05/10/2021 02:03

STOP THIS INSANITY NOW...............

tell her..... this does not work for you... the end Flowers

romdowa · 05/10/2021 01:59

Just no, for all the reasons outlined up thread. It's complicated and has the potential to get very messy , very quickly.

1forAll74 · 05/10/2021 01:49

T,ke a chance if every single thing appeals to you. But you have already stated that she is bossy, very go ahead, and a drinker to boot. She seems to be full of great ideas, that are tempting to you, so decide if you can keep up with her,and all her plans.

saltinesandcoffeecups · 05/10/2021 01:11

Oh this doesn’t sound great.

Look I can see where it sounds like a good idea in the ‘what if’ stage, but I feel like it’s going to fall apart in the ‘oh shit this is happening’ stage.

First and foremost this is a big financial risk for you. What would plan B be when it goes tits up?

What happens when you don’t agree on something financial?

How is your investment protected?

If it were me, I would use the ‘I don’t want to mix business and friends’ line to back out of this. Someone who isn’t using you will be disappointed but will understand.

GiantHaystacks2021 · 05/10/2021 00:56

This is mental.
I can't believe anyone would sign up for this.

SueblueNZ · 05/10/2021 00:21

I cannot imagine how you would get a mortgage as you wouldn't have the collateral the bank would need. Let's say she buys a 800k house and you apply for a mortgage for renos of, say, 50k, what security can you offer the bank? It is extremely naive for her to say she would buy the house in joint names considering the tiny fraction of equity you could contribute. Her solicitor would caution her against that.
How old are you both?
Why doesn't she just buy a nice house that doesn't need renovation, have you there as a tenant and flog it off (at a likely profit) when she is ready to move overseas?
Like everyone else here, I think this plan (fantasy) is a disaster in waiting.

DroopyClematis · 04/10/2021 22:25

Is she using you to prop her her immediate lifestyle?
What if she tires of it and she decides to sell? Where will that leave you?

Solid legal advice is what you need... just hope that your friend agrees to this!

Biscuits1 · 04/10/2021 22:02

I say go for it. You are not financially secure now if you are renting so you have nothing to lose and only able to gain with putting your money into property. Just make sure you have it all drawn up with a solicitor. It sounds like you will have a lovely place to live and she will be abroad a lot so you will have chance to have your own space.

WildfirePonie · 04/10/2021 21:50

Hi Friend,

I have decided that I can no longer go ahead with the renovations as planned.

All the best,

Then block and give yourself a breather for a few days/weeks/month.

DragonDoor · 04/10/2021 21:39

Don’t give up your independence to effectively be a lodger in someone else’s home/ renovation project.

HalzTangz · 04/10/2021 21:29

Unless you buy the property jointly with her, then you won't get a mortgage to do the renovations. Is she offering to sell you a share of the property, or is she solely buying, but wants to to fix it up with no names on the deeds.

If the latter, don't do it, you may think she won't rip you off but no one knows what the future holds. She could boot you out the minute the work is done and you'd have little comeback from it

stillvicarinatutu · 04/10/2021 20:52

I've tried to talk about my misgivings , my friend is now suggesting she put it in joint names from the off. This is difficult because at first it sounded fun and I got swept along but it's clear that this was her only plan in order to keep her nice lifestyle. I'm fairly sure even with the place in joint names , my own spaces etc I have misgivings about living with anyone . I've just got home to a silent , quiet , calm house and I like it more than I realised . This feels like it has so much potential to go wrong . She's back peddling on moving abroad , everything and I feel so awful about it .

OP posts:
merryhouse · 03/10/2021 09:41

The important thing to note is that she wants to do this because she can't afford the lifestyle she wants

If bringing you in is going to change that, then, by definition you are handing over money

Why don't you suggest she buys two houses with her share? - one maybe not as big or nice as she wants but nice enough, the other to rent out to someone (possibly you) in order to pay her expenses.

Quitelikeacatslife · 03/10/2021 09:37

No, she is trying to find a way to keep her lifestyle. Splitting bills could be a major flashpoint. She is not used to compromising on cost or budgeting I imagine. Also she should pay 2/3 if has daughter there too.
Maybe she buys something she can afford to run herself and you buy a smaller development together? Or you rent something together so both get a nicer house but not so fancy.
If you can't afford a cleaner, fancy house and pool between you then you just can't.
Your savings are precious to set you up, they could get frittered away. I can imagine she will say everything must be top spec etc. Have her previous developments been overfunded by husband?

movpov · 03/10/2021 09:36

It would be a huge no from me. Why does she need you to fund renovations when she has a £2 million plus house which can either be sold and proceeds split, or she can be bought out? Has she thought about getting a job herself?

I think you'd be mad to give up your independence; this will not work out and It's likely you'd be left with nothing. If you do decide to give this serious thought, at the very least speak to a solicitor to protect yourself

billy1966 · 03/10/2021 09:26

@Aquamarine1029

It's bonkers. It's the very definition of bonkers. Investing your money into a property you don't own, in the hopes that your bossy, controlling, drunkard friend won't fuck you over and leave you with nothing when they sell up and fuck off out of the country. You have expressed serious misgivings. Listen to yourself.
This.

Word for word.

Mother87 · 03/10/2021 09:20

Sorry if I've missed something here
"Together we could run it easily , live a rather lovely lifestyle and both make money on modernising it and she would do it properly with me buying in etc"

Where's the bit where YOU make or even RETAIN your investment? What are you actually BUYING into/would that be contractual (your share) etc... Maybe just be a lodger & enjoy all - it's HER property so she can upgrade/re-model as much/little as she wants...

Mother87 · 03/10/2021 09:15

Aquamarine29 @ MadameMonk have covered it all...👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻

Mumoftwoinprimary · 03/10/2021 07:53

It could work but you two need spend the time together to “What If” it to death.

Everything from what if one of you meets someone to what to do in a zombie invasion.

I would suggest for the first year that you don’t invest any money but instead just have a normal lodger type agreement that means either of you can give one months notice. Then either one of you can get out fairly easily if it doesn’t work.

If she isn’t willing to do the “What If” ing then don’t do it.

KikoLemons · 03/10/2021 07:32

MadameMonk is spot on.

Maskless · 03/10/2021 01:07

Your gut instinct says no.

Listen to it!

This has disaster written all over it, sorry.

She's far too pushy.

stillvicarinatutu · 03/10/2021 00:32

Madame

Thank you . Incredible advice . Makes perfect sense.

OP posts:
MadameMonk · 03/10/2021 00:28

You need to talk through the plan with a professional or two. Financial advisor, accountant, a solicitor too for sure, etc.

What will happen is that you will get a clearer picture of your personal financial future and how this plan might (or might not) fit. You be given different questions to ask her, and to answer for yourself. You’ll start to fill in a spreadsheet with actual numbers and months/years marked on it. Details will need to be thrashed out. Along this process you can afford to be very positive to her about the plan to co-habit. You’ll also see that you have 10 solid reasons why although you’d have loved to, it just isn’t possible. Blame the advisor if you have to. But I guarantee that starting to plan properly will throw up plenty of issues you (and she) haven’t yet considered. Maybe some opportunities too?

At the moment you only have her desperate desire to not have to work, and your half-hearted daydream of sitting by the pool. Since you say you value the friendship so highly, isn’t it time to give it respect by doing proper due diligence? You can tell her that too. And retell her every time she accuses you of just looking for an excuse to back out.

My instinct is that it won’t work out, because of your friend’s attachment to her old life. She can’t just slot in you and your limited funds but hope to otherwise go on as before.