Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think it’s unfair single-sex schools aren’t an option for many (perhaps even most)?

408 replies

patienceandprudence · 02/10/2021 22:59

I have one single sex state school (and in fact there is only one private) in my county. It is in the county town, which we are not in the catchment for. It would take an hour and half to get to by public transport anyway.

Since it has been proven many times over that girls do better in single sex schools, why on earth aren’t there more options for those of us not in 11+ counties? I think it’s a great shame, and it doesn’t seem to be a thing that’s even being thought about.

OP posts:
Phineyj · 03/10/2021 17:43

Surely the fact that violent crime incidents are 10× more prevalent in the male than female population is sufficient to indicate the scale of the problem Confused.

Phineyj · 03/10/2021 17:40

posting you can do that exact sum with the rough stats I provided? 3? But those are population level stats so it's not like you could just just pick a random group of 100 males and say there you go, there's the three (for any characteristic).

I don't know what you mean by 'aristocracy' in this context.

Twizbe · 03/10/2021 16:45

Where we live most of the schools both state and private are single sex. We're struggling to find co Ed for our two (one boy, one girl)

What has happened here is that the girls schools are doing well but the boys schools are all requiring improvement. I don't want to send one kid to a failing school just because he has a penis.

AngelsWithSilverWings · 03/10/2021 16:31

I chose my daughters state academy because although it was a CoEd school the lessons were taught in single sex groups.

I went to a single sex school that went CoEd in the final two years and I remember how the lessons and the classroom experience went downhill very quickly after that so I was keen for my DD to have the chance of a single sex classroom environment.

She had problems with boys at primary who dominated the lessons and openly mocked anyone who got answers wrong. My DD's confidence wasn't great at a result.

The first year at the state academy went really well and DD was happy. Then at the end of Y7 the school announced that the government had forced it to go completely CoEd. The head told me that the school were no longer legally allowed to offer single sex classes. The government only allows exemptions for faith or grammar schools apparently.

Y8 was awful. My daughter was immediately bullied by one boy , laughed at and called thick , had inappropriate comments made about her body and her appearance by others and a mean girl culture developed among the girls almost overnight. In the end she was so frightened of negative comments about her face that she refused to take her (Covid) face mask off even to eat. She just stopped eating or drinking at school. Her mental health suffered and she experienced severe panic attacks and anxiety. An eating disorder started. It was a nightmare.

Eventually I had to pull her out of the school. The only single sex options in our area were faith schools or grammar schools , none of which are available to my DD.

We have found a private school that suits her instead and she is much much happier and getting counselling for the issues caused by her experiences in Y8.

Needthesun · 03/10/2021 16:02

@sashh

I would never send a child to a single sex school, they screw you up in many ways, great results but not much else.
See this is just a ridiculous generalisation.

I grew up in Ireland with, I'd say, 80-90% of people at second level being educated in single-sex schools (that may be lower now, but is still a vast majority).

If single-sex education truly "screwed everyone up" then we'd be a non-functioning society of weirdos (we're not, in case you're wondering).

Of course, not every school suits every person, but that isn't an indicator of the benefits or drawbacks of a certain way of schooling on a population level.

aSofaNearYou · 03/10/2021 14:24

@Phineyj

Using publicly available statistics (ONS, BBC), 1.2m violent incidents a year in the UK (2020) 93% of them committed by males, 33m males, so about a 3.4% chance in the case of any particular male; although I've used total number of males (all ages) and the violent incidents is probably 18+, and no doubt there are serial offenders.

Equivalent figure for females 0.07 × 1.2m ÷ 33m = 0.3%.

It also doesn't account for unreported crimes and microaggressions, of which there are many.
postingfortraffichere · 03/10/2021 14:17

@Phineyj I'm interested to know what the aristocracy is of males as a whole. So I'm a classroom of 100 boys - how many likely to be predators. ThT will tell us how wide scale the problem is .

Phineyj · 03/10/2021 14:15

Also I didn't dig in to see how they were defining 'violent'.

Phineyj · 03/10/2021 14:14

Using publicly available statistics (ONS, BBC), 1.2m violent incidents a year in the UK (2020) 93% of them committed by males, 33m males, so about a 3.4% chance in the case of any particular male; although I've used total number of males (all ages) and the violent incidents is probably 18+, and no doubt there are serial offenders.

Equivalent figure for females 0.07 × 1.2m ÷ 33m = 0.3%.

aSofaNearYou · 03/10/2021 14:00

[quote worriedatthemoment]@Evesgarden I am also as a mother entitled to not label my son without just cause on his behaviour as some are clearly advocating on here.

[/quote]
Can you really not see what an enormous block you are putting to the feminist cause by refusing to allow people to discuss the statistics and trends around sexism perpetuated by males, because you feel upset that they MIGHT include your son in that? They're not talking about your bloody son! Jumping to that weirdly defensive conclusion is slowing down change that could improve things for girls and women, which is far more important than the vague possibility that somebody might be unduly wary of your son specifically.

BonneMaman15 · 03/10/2021 13:54

My (awful) exh said that he & his mates used to target girls who went to single sex schools because they were naive & inexperienced in dealing with boys 🤢
I think if girls don't have male siblings, it's valuable for them to attend co-ed.

funinthesun19 · 03/10/2021 13:38

@funinthesun19 where do people think the money comes from to do this though realistically ?
We provide a state education in the uk thats it , if you live in an area that has one fine , some areas only have maybe 1 / w schools full stop in the area

That’s very true. My area has no same sex schools at all apart from one private one. There are plenty of state schools in my area, so you could argue that there isn’t a need for any more schools (including same sex ones) to be built and the council have done their bit.

Good idea on paper to some people to provide plenty of same sex schools. Not simple to just go ahead and do.

worriedatthemoment · 03/10/2021 13:30

@Evesgarden I am also as a mother entitled to not label my son without just cause on his behaviour as some are clearly advocating on here.

worriedatthemoment · 03/10/2021 13:20

@Evesgarden yes of course someones sons are , but I can read The stats like that what i can't find is that stat in men in total
As in 10% of all men , 20% of all men as some commit multiple crimes

Evesgarden · 03/10/2021 13:17

[quote worriedatthemoment]@over2021 statistically maybe not but there are some and they all seem to be rising, I have a right to not assume my son will be not be a murderer etc as well .
As statistically how many men are rapists , murderers ? I can find if the crimes how many are committed by men , which is high but not the percentage of men

As in is it 20% of all men commit a crime or 10% etc
[/quote]
You need to look at how many women get murdered, raped/sexually assaulted. 2.5 women get murdered a week

Although the prison system is good place to start. 18% of male prisoners are in their for sexual based crimes. even that figure is misleading though as we know how hard it is to get a conviction for rape and murder. ( just look at the high profile cases recently where men have strangled women to death but got away with it because they said it was sex same gone wrong) Although the allegations of rape have risen the conviction rate has fallen to a record low and there will be women who dont report at all. In the year to the end of March 2020, 58,856 cases of rape were recorded by police forces in England and Wales.
These led to just 2,102 prosecutions, compared with 3,043 in the previous 12 months. 56000 thousand allegations thrown out.

Now even if you argue a percentage of those allegations are false ( suspected at 4%) that's still over 50000 sexual assault victims left with out justice - A YEAR

Some ones sons are doing it.

SusannaM · 03/10/2021 13:15

@worriedatthemoment

Often enough. But I'm done justifying to you.

aSofaNearYou · 03/10/2021 13:09

[quote worriedatthemoment]@SusannaM so you regularly hear schoolboys talking about hardcore porn all the time? Not my experience where I am.
Accusing teachers of also not caring ?
None of my teacher friends would tolerate this , maybe you do need to look at a different school for your dd if her school is ignoring all this behaviour and report them to ofsted as well , so they take action [/quote]
Oh for God's sake, you cannot discount wider, societal trends and statistics with repeated retorts of "well my friends don't do this". These things happen, they are well known to be a serious issue, why do we have to keep defending even saying that they happen?

vinoandbrie · 03/10/2021 13:07

My DDs are at a single sex school, it’s non negotiable for us. I think every child should have the option of single sex school.

worriedatthemoment · 03/10/2021 13:04

@SusannaM so you regularly hear schoolboys talking about hardcore porn all the time? Not my experience where I am.
Accusing teachers of also not caring ?
None of my teacher friends would tolerate this , maybe you do need to look at a different school for your dd if her school is ignoring all this behaviour and report them to ofsted as well , so they take action

aSofaNearYou · 03/10/2021 13:02

[quote worriedatthemoment]@aSofaNearYou how can girla grow up completely away from boys
They have dads, brothers , uncles etc and if we go down the statistical route aren't more crimes committed by those we know
I would say all children are very different and some will benefit from all girls / boys and some mixed
I had chance to go to an all girls school years ago , I didn't as i knew some older girls and the bullying was rife from them so it wasn't for me, my co ed school I had no issues at so for me that was the right choice .
The reality is though as a country we cannot afford to have choice , only way would be all single sex schools as years ago but then thats going backwards in my opinion [/quote]
I never said I wanted them to grow up totally away from boys or men, just that at least having their learning space away from all that, and in an environment less likely to normalise messages of boys being better/more important than girls, can be a good thing.

Yes there will be good schools and bad schools of both type, no doubt. I'm merely talking in abstract.

worriedatthemoment · 03/10/2021 13:00

@SusannaM yet when I was at school some of the girls did some of these things to as they do now, they can be bitchy about things , take piss out of girls who don't have breasts yet etc
I split my trousers once unbeknown to me , boys were sat behind me and one of them whispered to my friend so I could cover up with my cardigan, i had wondered why earlier when i walked passed some girls they had sniggered , obviously they had seen the hole .
Again did your friend report those boys conversations as if underage etc would be a safeguarding concern

hapagirl · 03/10/2021 12:58

I changed my DD to a girl's high school (private) this year. She loves it, lessons are quieter, she said she can leave her books on the desk and not come back to them being doodled on by boys. Girls ask questions without worries about being ridiculed. Girls are less distracted. She is being assessed for ASD at the moment and easily led so I feel she is safer in single sex environment. I have 2 other DDs in mixed schools and they are currently fine but would still consider single sex for them too if it comes up.
One of the reasons I moved her is that I found the boys in her school intimidating. It had a uniform but the uniform policy went out the window with covid and I just saw groups of boys with their hoodies up and masks on walking around in the gloom of winter. I mentioned it to the school to no real avail...

SusannaM · 03/10/2021 12:56

@SusannaM so your one friend means thats what happens is it ? So I assume your friend has then reported these conversations ? As that is what she is doing

Huh?

I hear it from my DD and her friends. I hear it from my friend. I hear it with my own ears when I have to get the bus with schoolboys.

DD has long since given up as it just makes her a target and teachers don't care about the low level stuff, in fact they didn't care about the bigger stuff until the police were involved. Friend pulls the kids up when she hears it. No way am I going to tackle a group of teenage boys.

worriedatthemoment · 03/10/2021 12:55

@aSofaNearYou how can girla grow up completely away from boys
They have dads, brothers , uncles etc and if we go down the statistical route aren't more crimes committed by those we know
I would say all children are very different and some will benefit from all girls / boys and some mixed
I had chance to go to an all girls school years ago , I didn't as i knew some older girls and the bullying was rife from them so it wasn't for me, my co ed school I had no issues at so for me that was the right choice .
The reality is though as a country we cannot afford to have choice , only way would be all single sex schools as years ago but then thats going backwards in my opinion

postingfortraffichere · 03/10/2021 12:53

@worriedatthemoment I completely agree.

I'm also as other posters are suggesting not personally offended at all - I don't have sons. I don't have children! But I can still see how problematic some of the views on this thread are, I don't need children to see that.