Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think it’s unfair single-sex schools aren’t an option for many (perhaps even most)?

408 replies

patienceandprudence · 02/10/2021 22:59

I have one single sex state school (and in fact there is only one private) in my county. It is in the county town, which we are not in the catchment for. It would take an hour and half to get to by public transport anyway.

Since it has been proven many times over that girls do better in single sex schools, why on earth aren’t there more options for those of us not in 11+ counties? I think it’s a great shame, and it doesn’t seem to be a thing that’s even being thought about.

OP posts:
Pinkyxx · 04/10/2021 07:55

Having been to one myself, I agree they can be a hotbed for vicious woman on woman bullying, and things like eating disorders however much depends on the school and the child.

I sent my DD to a single sex school. The pastoral support is 2nd to none, and they are all over very low level bullying such that it never really gains root. They have plenty of social opportunities with boys, as it's understood it's important they mix. I can honestly say she's absolutely thriving there, but I acknowledge not ever girl would.

The local co-ed in our catchment is failing, with drug/anti-social behavior, and little emphasis on the subjects she's interested in (STEM) so it wasn't right for her. The year she joined secondary there was an incident where a year 7 girl was assaulted at the school by a boy in year 8. This happened during the first 2 weeks of term and I just knew I'd made the right decision.

timeisnotaline · 04/10/2021 07:23

That’s not to say other studies in the list aren’t state school based, just it isn’t obvious. I have no idea what the Norwegian system is like, and don’t know enough about girls day schools in the uk which is another one of them.

timeisnotaline · 04/10/2021 07:22

@lljkk it’s a fair question. Studies 2 and 9 in the list in the article I linked are I think completely done in state schools. I tried to look up % engineering students at Sydney university of technology from private schools but couldn’t see that information, I expect it’s high though whcih would mean the majority of the data is comparing private single schools with private coed schools for that study.
Tricky in my state as I’m not aware of any non selective entry single sex state high schools, but there are probably initiatives with girls classes and similar. Private schools are a mix of single sex and coed.

lljkk · 04/10/2021 06:31

My first thought was about Ed Hussein saying the roots of him becoming a radicalised extremist was in being sent to a single sex boys school.

I thought about sending DD to a single sex girls school. Decided that it felt like an anorexia pressure-cooker.

What are the statistics comparing achievements from single sex state schools only to single sex co-ed schools?

timeisnotaline · 04/10/2021 06:21

Here is a collection of studies over the last ten years showing more girls study stem subjects and do better at them in single sex schools. Of course the source is biased being a girls schools association, but I had no luck finding studies saying the opposite on stem and plenty of this type of study in a quick search. Not arguing academia is everything but it is important to me that it be strongly supported in conjunction with developing well rounded children.
www.agsa.org.au/why-a-girls-school-the-research/gender-atypical-subject-selection-statistics/

Winecrispschocolatecats · 04/10/2021 02:15

I went to an all girls school and, while it may have been slightly more beneficial academically than a mixed school, what it didn't do was teach kids how to navigate relationships (whether platonic or romantic/sexual) with the other 50% of the human race. University was a complete eye-opener, and it's fair to say I made quite a few serious (potentially life-changing) mistakes in a very short time. Steep learning curve.

Where we live now also has the 11+ system and DD could have gone to a single or mixed grammar. She was adamant about wanting a mixed school and she's thriving - and also has a much more grounded and sensible attitude towards boys than I did at her age. She's learned how to be assertive, to speak up with confidence and take no nonsense, which I think is priceless.

Curerofsouls · 04/10/2021 01:50

I had a lovely group of friends at my very wonderful big standard high school. Both lads andcgirls which I wouldn't have hlad at a single sex school.
I had two nale friends at an excellent boys school near me and a female friend at the girls version of the same school.
All three struggled in tbeir release into the world at uni to mix with the opposite sex. All fine now but education is not all about academia.

aSofaNearYou · 03/10/2021 23:57

@shallIswim

I get what mothers of girls are saying about abuse. I have a girl and a boy. But the worst trouble, and the thing that left the longest lasting scars for my DD was the bullying she received from other girls. Awful.
The thing is, the issue of sexism and the issue of general bullying are separate. Of course there is still bullying amongst both sexes, but the sexism girls experience is in addition to that and needs tackling in it's own right.
timeisnotaline · 03/10/2021 23:30

If everyone with a girl who is into maths/science sends them to a girls school, then it perpetuates the problem. My DD and her friends are strong mathematicians, and I suspect her year group, at any rate, do not see maths as a boys' subject
That’s not quite how it works. I would have excelled at maths in any class, but some of the other girls who did it with me and were reasonably good but not straight As without trying would have either not done it as it’s too full of boys or done worse then they did because the boys got all the attention. The year group effect you describe is very difficult to obtain in a mixed school. Every boy I knew did maths because boys do to get to university, that was far from the case for girls.

theSunday · 03/10/2021 23:01

So glad we start to agree on something @postingfortraffichere I like what you say This is about educating young boys to behave differently. That is down to teachers and parents in the main. That is who most of the responsibility lies with, at least that we can control - we can't clock our fingers overnight and have sexism removed from mainstream media and society - but we can change our children's mindset for future generations. And I see that as our responsibility as individuals. The parents, teachers and friends of our sons

Where we differ is that I honestly think strengthening our girls in an environment without sexual harassment and male micro aggressions could make them equipped to become 100% confident women from the get-go who stand their ground once they get into 6th form and out in the workplace.

I think this could work.

Also boys benefit from single sex because they can explore the humanities, English, poetry etc without being muscled out by the girls.

Separating them whilst encouraging them to overcome gender stereotypes is IMO a possible solution to this.

lanthanum · 03/10/2021 22:50

@AnUnlikelyCombination

If I found a mixed school with as many girls doing Further Maths A level as boys, I’d consider it. I haven’t yet.

And that proves to me that mixed schools haven’t managed to stamp out the stereotypes that boys are best at Maths / Physics and girls at History / English. I’ve got a tomboy who is excellent at Maths - I want her in an environment where that makes her one of many, not an uncomfortable exception.

I was in a further maths set that was majority girls. (Okay, so I'll admit that it was unusual, and I got a bit of a shock when I went to an inter-school maths thing where there were 2 of us in a room of 30.)

If everyone with a girl who is into maths/science sends them to a girls school, then it perpetuates the problem. My DD and her friends are strong mathematicians, and I suspect her year group, at any rate, do not see maths as a boys' subject, because the evidence that girls can do maths is right there in front of them.

I think there are both push and pull factors when it comes to choice of A-levels. I think there are more boys who rule out "essay" subjects, so they gravitate towards maths and science.

theSunday · 03/10/2021 22:34

@SheldontheWonderSchlong

Jesus, do we really have to begin everything with Not All Boys Are Like That and Girls Do It Too? Happy now?
Grin Brilliant

No-one is saying ‘all boys or men are sexual predators’.

These issues can be only resolved if we all stick together.

postingfortraffichere · 03/10/2021 22:17

@theSunday I completely agree but I don't think anyone is denying it's a problem.

I think some posters, or me at least are just saying the same sex schools isn't the answer.

It's like going backwards - it doesn't solve the issue at all it just temporarily postponed it because you're still going to find sexism in the workplace and every other place within society - even if you send your child to same sex school.

This is about educating young boys to behave differently. That is down to teachers and parents in the main. That is who most of the responsibility lies with, at least that we can control - we can't clock our fingers overnight and have sexism removed from mainstream media and society - but we can change our children's mindset for future generations. And I see that as our responsibility as individuals. The parents, teachers and friends of our sons.

Of course we see sexism engrained throughout society but we can only start making small changes as individuals which eventually leads to collective change.

theSunday · 03/10/2021 22:10

@MissChanandlerBong81

Also, I have a teenage boy. That doesn't stop me from acknowledging that teenage boys as a group of people represent a threat to teenage girls.

Agreed - I have two boys but don’t see it as ‘boy bashing’. I can remember my own experience in co-ed secondary vividly enough to understand exactly why parents of girls may have some concerns.

I agree with you both and I also have a boy.

The first step in creating a society where kids grow up feeling safe is to acknowledge this fact. Instead of closing our eyes or get all defensive and say ‘MY boy isn’t like this’.

It’s how the whole toxic masculinity is made possible, by parents looking the other way.

HadEnoughofOtherThreads · 03/10/2021 22:02

postingfortraffichere

‘Thing is someone is raising these sons? That are so sexist and vicious that we should have same sex school options - but who? Who is raising these boys I wonder?’

^Exactly!

postingfortraffichere · 03/10/2021 21:54

Thing is someone is raising these sons? That are so sexist and vicious that we should have same sex school options - but who? Who is raising these boys I wonder?

timeisnotaline · 03/10/2021 21:46

@MissChanandlerBong81

I have sons and no daughters. I don’t understand why some parents of sons seem to be unable to discuss sexism without interpreting it as a personal insult towards their son or sons. As parents of boys it’s our responsibility to do our best to bring them up to acknowledge, recognise and address sexism and respect girls and women. Not deny that our precious little princes could ever possibly be part of the problem.
I have sons and daughters and agree absolutely.

@EasterIssland thank you for your kind thoughts. I have no intention of blaming any other children for how my daughter turns out. She may however not be an A+ student, it’s too early to tell but I plan to love her just the same. Hth.

shallIswim · 03/10/2021 21:41

I get what mothers of girls are saying about abuse. I have a girl and a boy.
But the worst trouble, and the thing that left the longest lasting scars for my DD was the bullying she received from other girls. Awful.

EasterIssland · 03/10/2021 21:41

Hope many of your daughters end up being clever and bright ! You won’t be able Blame the oposite sex if they don’t end up getting A+!

LexMitior · 03/10/2021 20:39

@vinoandbrie

My DDs are at a single sex school, it’s non negotiable for us. I think every child should have the option of single sex school.
Completely agree. I don't want my daughter to navigate all that extra shit that co-ed with boys brings. She's there to learn, and she will do better without.

The world is full of men, its no bad thing that she gets some years free from with the endless primacy of male importance.

ANameChangeAgain · 03/10/2021 20:33

Also what do you mean risk being naive and being unsure of coping with boys? Are you sending your dd to a coed school so she can become 'street wise' to boys and be able to cope with them through negative interaction? no of course not @Evesgarden, you are reading too much into what I said. The fact is the girls only option locally is 15 miles away and private, so hardly viable. Please don't be concerned about my daughter, she has a brother, and is the only girl amongst male cousins, I just want her to grow up to be comfortable with different genders / sexes (related is hardly the same) / religions / colours / backgrounds.

aSofaNearYou · 03/10/2021 18:27

@MissChanandlerBong81

I have sons and no daughters. I don’t understand why some parents of sons seem to be unable to discuss sexism without interpreting it as a personal insult towards their son or sons. As parents of boys it’s our responsibility to do our best to bring them up to acknowledge, recognise and address sexism and respect girls and women. Not deny that our precious little princes could ever possibly be part of the problem.
It's a big relief to see some mothers of boys are able to see that!
MissChanandlerBong81 · 03/10/2021 18:20

But it's not just about being assaulted- it's all the other sexist micro aggressions that girls face from boys at school- being shown porn (or hearing boys talk about it), being 'rated', talked about sexually, laughed at or humiliated for being on their period, judged for what they wear or how popular they are with the boys, being talked over etc. All the little things that must make a school day exhausting.

I have to say this is a pretty accurate description of my experience of a co-ed secondary school - daily groping, running commentary on girls’ developing bodies, being called ‘frigid’ if you said no to boys, being a ‘slut’ if you said yes, etc. And in the recent report on rape culture in schools it doesn’t sound like much has changed in 15 years.

MissChanandlerBong81 · 03/10/2021 18:15

I have sons and no daughters. I don’t understand why some parents of sons seem to be unable to discuss sexism without interpreting it as a personal insult towards their son or sons. As parents of boys it’s our responsibility to do our best to bring them up to acknowledge, recognise and address sexism and respect girls and women. Not deny that our precious little princes could ever possibly be part of the problem.

SheldontheWonderSchlong · 03/10/2021 18:11

[quote postingfortraffichere]@aSofaNearYou a poster has associated this with only boys;

judged for what they wear or how popular they are with the boys, being talked over etc.

it's madness [/quote]
I used it as an example of micro aggressions that girls may regularly face from boys at school.
Perhaps you need to re-read my posts if you think I am 'vilifying boys to the point where it's weird'.