Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think it’s unfair single-sex schools aren’t an option for many (perhaps even most)?

408 replies

patienceandprudence · 02/10/2021 22:59

I have one single sex state school (and in fact there is only one private) in my county. It is in the county town, which we are not in the catchment for. It would take an hour and half to get to by public transport anyway.

Since it has been proven many times over that girls do better in single sex schools, why on earth aren’t there more options for those of us not in 11+ counties? I think it’s a great shame, and it doesn’t seem to be a thing that’s even being thought about.

OP posts:
Namenic · 03/10/2021 07:06

I’d support choice. I would probably rather my kids went to mixed schools; but I went to all girls school and enjoyed it. Different kids suit different settings.

I did find it hard to flirt with boys at uni, but in a work setting I have no issue.

Ashville5 · 03/10/2021 07:00

All my children girls and boys are at single sex schools. The girls school couldn’t be faulted in many ways but if I had my time again I would never ever do it again. For several reasons.

The main one is mental health. Mental health problems seem to be a big issue at the girls school and eating disorders far too common. When I look at the support and information re mental health in the girls school it makes no sense. The school is very much on it. I firmly believe the all girls environment without the dilution of boys breeds it.The behaviour outside of school as regards risky behaviour also concerns me too. So many “hook up” with boys they’re forced to meet online as opposed to meeting in an everyday situation. Sex tapes, pics, sexting etc is rife. Girls harass boys too. My sons have experienced it.Teenage girls naturally want to meet up with boys and vice versa.They seem to do it very early on into meeting online and I think part of this is due to not being able to meet in person. Socialising outside of school seems to happen less with the huge use of phones too so no access to the opposite sex in the everyday environment compounds the issue.Then you get issues re young people you don’t know at 11 when picking schools which come to light further down the line- sexuality, neuro diversity, personality etc. Teenagers are their own people and they develop. Many won’t suit single sex schools. Finally you get the damage caused by all boys schools which are a breeding ground for toxic masculinity, homophobia and misogyny. It’s not fun for many boys attending such schools and frankly not great for society.

Single sex schools are wrong on so many levels. We need better protection and education in coed schools. Life is coed

Hiyawotcha · 03/10/2021 06:58

@PennyWus

NB DD’s single sex school also down the rabbit hole. Loos reframed as gender neutral etc and 4 girls in her year identifying as boys. Not so much at ds’s mixed school - that I know of.

It’s an interesting phenomenon that I have many thoughts on - I do wonder whether in single sex spaces where there isn’t an “other” in terms of sex, girls may be more inclined to express their sense of unhappiness with puberty or whatever as them being boys. Or that it’s more palatable to identify as a boy than as a lesbian. And the school is brilliant generally with empowerment across the board, which translates to utter acceptance, cheerleading and empowerment of trans just as much as pushing girls to do STEM.

Whereas in the mixed school, one would not only be identifying as “other” in relation to ones cohort of girls, but having to identify WITH the other of the cohort of boys. Perhaps more tricky and “real” to negotiate.

Anyway - massive digression.

Hiyawotcha · 03/10/2021 06:47

I went to a single sex school for the first 5 years of secondary. I loathed it. Horrible atmosphere, bullying and just general weirdness. Went to mixed sixth form which was a breath of fresh air.

Dd chose to go to single sex secondary. Despite my misgivings It was fantastic for her, she thrived and has a group of really solid girlfriends.

So my take on it is that is entirely depends on the school. Mine was awful, hers was great. Having single sex option doesn’t equate to better experience in all cases. You might have a single sex catchment school but it might be like mine was, or might be like hers. Or maybe she got lucky with her cohort, and I was unlucky with mine.

Both ds chose to go to a mixed school. Seems to be working for them, but then have friends with boys at the local single sex schools who seem happy. Much of this relates to the fact that local schools are generally pretty good. Non-grammar area, but we live “in catchment” for I suppose 2 ss girls schools, 2 ss boys schools and 2 co-Ed. Suburban area with solid comprehensives.

Bunnycat101 · 03/10/2021 06:41

I’m in an outstanding state primary but I’m seriously considering withdrawing my daughter to go to the private single sex schools. I’d rather not tbh at this age but at the age of 5 she is already complaining about low level disruption and more recently being hit by some of the boys. It’s quite a worry for me tbh as she always seems to be partnered with the more challenging boys and I’m getting fed up if it.

garlictwist · 03/10/2021 06:39

There are a few state girls school in my city but they tend to be largely muslim children. Not that that is an issue necessarily but I went to one as a child and did feel, as a non Muslim, that I didn't really fit in.

Aphrodite31 · 03/10/2021 06:37

Having said all that, I think so long as it's a day school and there's significant socialising with boys outside school (sports, friends, family, etc), then nowadays single sex might at least have the advantage of allowing girls to concentrate better at school and be in an environment where they are allowed to function as people, rather than being categorised as female.

Aphrodite31 · 03/10/2021 06:31

@caketiger

Schools socialise you for adult life. Single sex schools do not. I went to one. Didn't know how to deal with boys at all.
@Evesgarden
  • why do you find this strange? Your comment is like raised eyebrows - it suggests the poster is odd.

So you'd think I'm strange, too, because I totally agree with @caketiger

And I'd add that if your self-confidence and
sense of self - a lot of your ego - is allowed to develop without the intrusion/confusion of your own sexual/romantic response to the opposite sex, then this can cause real problems when you get into the mixed real world.

You can come out super sure of yourself, take one look at a boy and be paralysed with embarrassment/insecurity and a whole host of other unresolved and very strong feelings and physical responses.

You haven't learnt how to deal with this by being around them all the time, and growing up with them, and it can be a real shock - at an age (18, mixed university) when you had really thought you knew who you were.

IMO it's a dangerous risk. Not all girls feel like that, but many do to some degree. Maybe better to come out a fully-formed, functioning person in a world of two sexes. Part of your teenage development is learning how to deal with the opposite sex.

So I'm not at all sure I'd be behind widespread availability of single sex secondary education. School isn't just about exam results.

lannistunut · 03/10/2021 06:27

Co-ed is outdated IMO, and you can often tell later in life who went to single ed settings.

We need aggressive attention devoted to tackling the harassment of women and girls rather than segregation. Unfortunately I don't think will get this Angry, but I still would not favour segregated education.

Suitcaseseverywhere · 03/10/2021 06:22

My town has single sex state schools. My youngest DD went to the girls school and I was really glad that she wasn’t being subjected to the atrocious management and attitude of the SLT at the boys school.

Then they merged and it all fell to an arse. And she really suffered.

It’s the school ethos, not the single vs co-Ed that makes the difference.

icklekid · 03/10/2021 06:15

I went to all girls grammar- no issue socialising with boys, the boys was next door went on same buses, joint drama clubs etc. The biggest benefit for me which I didn’t realise until uni was there eas no gender stereotypes for subjects- of course girls subjects physics/maths/further maths for example- it enables everyone to make the choices they wanted without peer pressure or being the only girl for example!

PennyWus · 03/10/2021 06:14

I went to an excellent selective co-ed, 60% boys. I had friends but the girls could be very, very bitchy and bullying especially in years 7 to 10. Having boys there didnt help as they didnt really want girls hanging out with them until Y10 to Y12.

I'm sending DD to a local comprehensive which is all girls until Y12. Of course I'm aware of the pitfalls: potentially bitchy and cliquey, not spending time with boys as you grow up. But the academic results are always excellent, there is no gender bias in STEM subjects, there is masses of opportunity in extra-curricular groups for girls. And yes, a big factor is much lower chance of sexual harassment when not faced with boys every day.

The alternative is a very well-regarded, Ofsted outstanding co-ed comprehensive, whose intake is 60% boys, where the results are less impressive and not a single girl is sitting Computer Science or Further Maths A' level in Y12 or Y13, and yet all the pupils taking English Lit A level are girls! The school blame this on self-selection and say there's nothing that can be done about it, they have tried but girls just don't want to do maths or computing. I got told by the senior Computer Science teacher that the only girls who ever opt for the subject "have to be a very strong character and prepared to put themselves out there"... why? I can only guess because they are stuck in a classroom of boys who behave in a way that is intimidating and off-putting. In the neighbouring girls' school the STEM subjects are very popular, it doesn't occur to the girls there that whole areas of the curriculum are off limits.

Plus the co-ed school has gone down the rabbit hole regarding Trans children, and is fully supportive of social transition and I'm really not there yet.

It is depressing as I would probably ideally like a co-ed for my DD but I'm not putting her in an environment that is possibly even MORE gender-stereotyped than when I was at school!

I went to uni with lots of boys and girls from single-sex schools, yes a few (notably from the big-name public schools) were awkward or behaved in a peculiar way around the opposite sex, but mostly these were confident, well-adjusted and not really different to the other people I knew. And obviously hadn't lived in complete isolation from the opposite sex, via siblings and extra-curricular activities.

On balance I've come down "for" all girls schools, to my complete surprise. And I'm glad we have the choice in my town.

Mumobag · 03/10/2021 06:08

I'll be sending DD to our local girls high school if I can get her in. DH teaches there and they do a lot of extra sport and STEM stuff, and their results are consistently excellent.
I'm unconvinced by people arguing that single sex educated adults don't know how to talk to the opposite sex - surely they can still mix socially in extracurricular clubs, youth groups etc.

Insert1x20p · 03/10/2021 05:58

The problem is that single sex boys schools are far less popular than single sex girls school, so, as a previous poster indicated, if you have single sex schools, then it tends to skew the ratio in the co-ed schools because more girls go single sex than boys. That becomes an issue for councils so they’d probably rather it was all co-ed for max admissions flexibility. I imagine that outweighs the potential benefits/ parental choice.

Aroundtheworldin80moves · 03/10/2021 05:55

I went to an All girls sixth form after mixed Secondary, studying Maths and Sciences. It wasn't until I was there I realised how much the boys just dominated the classroom talked overwhelming girls etc. We just didn't bother trying to answer. It was overall a lot more pleasent experience.

HarebrightCedarmoon · 03/10/2021 05:48

It's more unfair that only a small number can access smaller class sizes, more attention to their individual needs, fantastic facilities, excellent teachers, and a wide range of extra curricular activities.

timeisnotaline · 03/10/2021 05:43

My daughter will absolutely go to a single sex school. Space to focus and develop as girls, encourage stem without being crowded out by boys, to both attempt and achieve at sports without being the lesser team.
I went to two single sex high schools, have very close girlfriends I still chat to most days from both and it’s not because I was even remotely cool or queen bitch that I loved them. I went onto study and work in stem and having for most of my life since I was 18 been the only or one of a small minority of women in the room/team, I’ve never had any issues getting on with boys/men. Make your assumptions if you like that we are all hothoused half developed half people who have no idea that men are people too, but it’s not correct.

RedMarauder · 03/10/2021 05:17

@caketiger

Schools socialise you for adult life. Single sex schools do not. I went to one. Didn't know how to deal with boys at all.
Didn't you have any hobbies?

Didn't you have brothers?

ohnana · 03/10/2021 01:36

Are you sure about that op? I only ask as I know where I am, the single sex schools always present the results v co-ed completely as it often shows higher results, but if you take only the girls results out from the co-ed schools they are usually higher than the girls only schools. All how they present the data.

elenacampana · 03/10/2021 01:20

@patienceandprudence

I remember desperately wishing to go to a girl’s school and one of my DD’s recently said she wished she could. It’s never going to be perfect because a couple hundred teenagers are never all going to get along, but it’s surely better to put up with ‘bitchiness’ (hate that word) than to deal with the co-ed environment which is quite frankly boy-dominant and rife with sexual harassment.
I didn’t experience any sexual harassment at school from the boys. I did experience years of bitching and bullying from the girls that left me a bit of a tormented soul for a very long time and that took years of therapy to go some way to fixing. I’m expecting a daughter myself, she won’t go to a single sex school. For me, segregation of anything is not the answer.
TableFlowerss · 03/10/2021 01:18

Single sex schools? Are you winding me up? The way things are going these days, they will be a thing of the past very soon. Women/girls allowed their own space?…. Nahhh won’t be allowed soon 🙄

theSunday · 03/10/2021 01:14

At the end of the day, single sex/mixed is just a debate and everyone has their personal choices, but someone unthread was spot on saying that we need resources to change society, do you think that could happen?

Anniissa · 03/10/2021 01:08

Sorry in phone so can’t quote but absolutely not minimising the risks in school which were very clearly pointed out in the Panorama programme just acknowledging that being in a single sex school does not mean no exposure to sexual harassment and grooming and pressure to send sexual images etc.

theSunday · 03/10/2021 01:07

@Valhalla17

over2021

What a scumbag you are to say such a thing. My son wont be like you, that's for certain.

Why are you so annoyed about this comment? It wasn’t an attack it was just stating something. I have a son too and it’s always good to have open eyes.
Nancydrawn · 03/10/2021 01:05

So very very glad I went co-ed.

That said, I know some women who loved their single-sex schools.