Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think it’s unfair single-sex schools aren’t an option for many (perhaps even most)?

408 replies

patienceandprudence · 02/10/2021 22:59

I have one single sex state school (and in fact there is only one private) in my county. It is in the county town, which we are not in the catchment for. It would take an hour and half to get to by public transport anyway.

Since it has been proven many times over that girls do better in single sex schools, why on earth aren’t there more options for those of us not in 11+ counties? I think it’s a great shame, and it doesn’t seem to be a thing that’s even being thought about.

OP posts:
pontefractals · 03/10/2021 07:59

I went to a mixed sex state school, thirty years ago. Sexual harassment was rife, as was blatant discrimination. There were enough computers for half the maths class - guess which half ended up hogging them every lesson? The boys in our GCSE English class refused to read one of the proposed books because of its "feminist agenda" - ie, one of the main characters was female. The teacher did try to convince them but eventually put it to the vote and we ended up with Lord of the Flies (in which the ONLY female character is pig, who is chased and killed). I was threatened with rape on a regular basis and didn't bother telling anyone because I was sure they would either not believe me (wolf-whistles and catcalls were seen as a compliment, I thought they'd say I was too plain to have that sort of problem) or would make things worse if they DID try to deal with it. By the time I left I was completely broken. It certainly didn't teach me any healthy ways to interact with boys or men.
I don't know what the answer is for all of society, and how you balance everyone's needs, but I think a single sex schooling might have been better for me personally.

GabriellaMontez · 03/10/2021 07:58

Yanbu.
I work in a co Ed. My daughters attend single sex (free, state school). I'm so happy.

They still travel there with boys, socialise with boys etc. But their education isn't disrupted by boys in the classroom, and they aren't harassed by boys in lessons and corridors.

Phineyj · 03/10/2021 07:56

Leaving aside all the social aspects, it's the case that girls' single sex schools have proportionally larger numbers taking STEM subjects and Economics, Politics etc (I assume the converse may be true re boys taking Humanities and creative subjects in boys' single sex ones...but it's not something I've researched). So for that reason alone I'd choose single sex if my DD was strong in those subjects.

I think there's quite a bit of research suggesting mixed at primary, single sex up to 16 and mixed at sixth form achieves the best overall outcome, but admissions-wise that would be hard as many areas have got mostly mixed or mostly single-sex options.

Mixed sixth forms would address the issue of girls not mixing with boys, although I was one of those (no brothers, no close male friends) and it didn't take me long to adapt at university. So by the time I discovered some boys like to talk over you in discussion, I already had the good grades in the boy dominated subjects. I got a First, maybe as I got to do more listening Grin.

I have had students tell me that they won't apply for certain university courses after looking at the female/male breakdown, which I think is a shame, although understandable.

EllieSattler · 03/10/2021 07:55

@sashh

I would never send a child to a single sex school, they screw you up in many ways, great results but not much else.
I grew up in an area with mostly single sex schools. Went to an all girls school. Strangely all my friends managed to go to uni and make male and female friends and have healthy romantic relationships. Several of us work in traditionally male dominated fields, and I definitely think that was in part not facing sexism when it came to selecting gcse and A Level subjects and then degree courses. So, I can't agree with this opinion at all.

If I can get my daughter into the single sex grammar half an hour away I definitely will do. She deserves an education where she doesn't have to worry about being groped in the corridors, being distracted by boyfriend dramas, or talked over and dissuaded from STEM subjects by the boys. If it turns out to be the wrong environment for her then she can always move schools.

gogohm · 03/10/2021 07:54

Society isn't segregated by sex so I don't understand why state education is. My local state comprehensive school was single sex so I sent my DD's further afield - the single sex school has a good academic record but unless you are a girly girl you don't fit in, they don't even have football pitches (my dd plays football and rugby) .

Notdoingthis · 03/10/2021 07:54

I meant segregation is NOT an alternative to education and formation on sexual harrassment!

RedMarauder · 03/10/2021 07:53

@Ashville5 that depends on the school. There are two single sex girls schools near me and one is known for its long standing issues with mental issues and eating disorders.

Notdoingthis · 03/10/2021 07:53

So the arguments are results and sexual harrassment? If those are your top priorities I guess.
But I firmly believe, as many have said, segregation is an alternative to education and formation on sexual harassment.
I went to co ed, and my experiences with mixing with boys were overwhelmingly positive. I still have great friendships with wonderful boys and girls from my school days. I could never deny that for my children.
We must address the sexual harassment problem, but not by segregation.

Ashville5 · 03/10/2021 07:51

I also think the assumption that all girls are bright and ambitious is setting up mental issues right there. Can’t girls just be. When did we all become bright and ambitious and why do we all have to be? Girls vary hugely.

Ashville5 · 03/10/2021 07:49

WomanIsTaken
Your experience is different to mine.rolled up skirts and make up worse in the girls school. And making friendships for your teen isn’t your responsibility. Young people need to make their own friendships. How does one engineer teen mixed friendships anyway?Confused Extra curricular activities are often expensive and most teens I know have pretty definitive ideas of want they want to do outside of school themselves and who they socialise with.

MrsArchchancellorRidcully · 03/10/2021 07:46

Dd is a quite bright and hot horribly bullied for being 'a geek' by the boys at her primary. The girls at her single sex school seem very supportive and equally bright and ambitious.

sashh · 03/10/2021 07:46

I would never send a child to a single sex school, they screw you up in many ways, great results but not much else.

MrsArchchancellorRidcully · 03/10/2021 07:42

Our local coed comp is really good but we lives 45mins from grammar schools and there's a bus. Dd has just started yr 8 and is thriving in an all girls atmosphere. It's definitely the right choice for her. DS will hopefully go to the all boys grammar in 2 years.

WomanIsTaken · 03/10/2021 07:41

My DDs attend a single sex academy. Being in bottom sets across the board, one DD describes these classes as small, mutually supportive learning environments where every girl is engaged and encouraged. She's switched on to learning in a new way. I doubt this would have been the case had she gone on to the local mixed secondary and been in bottom sets with some of the boys from her primary school, who would possibly have carried on dominating and disrupting learning interventions in much the same way as in the last years of primary.
A PP also makes the point about girls dressing for the male gaze from a young age at mixed schools. I really like that at DDs' school, girls really don't seem to give two hoots about rolling up skirts, wearing sneaky make up etc as the girls I see walking to the mixed school. Lots of sensible haircuts, sensible shoes and also things like un-cool bags which I think they'd get viciously teased about at a the mixed comp. It's like an oasis of not having to please anyone but themselves.
And of course they have male friends and boys they see for extra curricular activities, the sons of my friends and male neighbours of a similar age. That's my responsibility.
A friend's DD has just started Y7 at a specialist, partially selective, massively oversubscribed mixed secondary, and has already reported the boys sending eachother porn clips which they watch on their way to and from school and try to get the girls to view. Disappointing.

RoyalMush · 03/10/2021 07:40

I loved girls’ secondary school and that was pre mobile phones so less pressure all round I would say. Yes there was some meanness (I don’t like ‘bitchiness’) but it wasn’t usually based around internalised misogyny and competing for boys’ attention. Or desperately seeking to avoid the boys’ attention. We competed to get good marks in school. The culture was about focusing on the work. I went to a mixed sixth form college for A level and the culture was around dating. Academic work was an afterthought.

Afterwards I can ‘see’ and I resent and try to challenge sexist behaviour where I can, having been relatively free of it over the years aged 11-16. I’m so grateful for that protected time. If I didn’t know that life is not always so hostile to women , I would have really struggled. I wish that state single sex school was an option for everyone.

MsTSwift · 03/10/2021 07:38

My girls are thriving in their single sex state. Free to speak up in lessons very feminist ethos. So unlike my mixed comp where the boys dominated I basically kept my head down for 5 years.

BlusteryLake · 03/10/2021 07:30

More popular than girls schools, clearly! Excuse the typo!

BlusteryLake · 03/10/2021 07:29

@Insert1x20p

The problem is that single sex boys schools are far less popular than single sex girls school, so, as a previous poster indicated, if you have single sex schools, then it tends to skew the ratio in the co-ed schools because more girls go single sex than boys. That becomes an issue for councils so they’d probably rather it was all co-ed for max admissions flexibility. I imagine that outweighs the potential benefits/ parental choice.
I would be interested to see your source for the assertion that single sex boys schools are less popular than single sex boys schools, because that doesn't seem to be the case where I live. The non-selective Ofsted outstanding boys' school near me is hugely over subscribed, with people choosing it for their sons over closer mixed schools.
Ashville5 · 03/10/2021 07:28

I also think some girls want, need and prefer male friendships and company. Kids change dramatically from 11-16 and you can’t predict the future.Forced segregation can be pretty miserable for many of both sexes.

I find it interesting that at our single sex schools the exodus at 6th form to coed seems to be greater from the girls and less from the boys.

Beautiful3 · 03/10/2021 07:26

I went to a mixed school then moved to a girls school, it was much better. I loved it as there were no disruptions or silliness. My husband went to a single sex school too, he liked it. We live near those schools and planned to send our children there. However the number of children going to those schools has declined so much, that one closed down to merge with the other. My daughter goes there, she does enjoy it and can't imagine it without boys, as they're all friends.

AnUnlikelyCombination · 03/10/2021 07:26

If I found a mixed school with as many girls doing Further Maths A level as boys, I’d consider it. I haven’t yet.

And that proves to me that mixed schools haven’t managed to stamp out the stereotypes that boys are best at Maths / Physics and girls at History / English. I’ve got a tomboy who is excellent at Maths - I want her in an environment where that makes her one of many, not an uncomfortable exception.

MissChanandlerBong81 · 03/10/2021 07:19

The bitchiness thing always gets me. Do people think that girls are nasty all together but are calmed by the presence of boys?

Yep. More than a whiff of misogyny about that.

FawkesThePhoenix · 03/10/2021 07:11

I've attended both. I started year seven in a mixed school and I absolutely hated it! I found the girls were horrible and seemed intent on making sure that they were popular and the boys fancied them, while putting the other girls down. Studying seemed to be the last thing on everyones minds. I also found the boys annoying and immature. I used to cry every night. Eventually I refused to attend and my mom quickly found a place for me at our local girls school.

I never had a problem there and settled in very quickly. I felt so much more relaxed!

I think its whatever suits the individual child. I am able to speak to men perfectly fine and function well in life despite the fact that I was educated away from males.

whiteroseredrose · 03/10/2021 07:09

I went to a girl's school as did DD. Both of us thrived there.

No bitchiness, just a huge pool of potential friends.

The bitchiness thing always gets me. Do people think that girls are nasty all together but are calmed by the presence of boys?

We have found the opposite. A good friend's DD has developed an eating disorder due to nasty comments from the boys in her class. Lots of girls dressing for the male gaze from a young age.

DD hated the boys in her primary school, possibly because as a sensible girl she was always next to the disruptive boys.

All girl's secondary was a relief. She's very STEM as are her friends. Lots of classes of girls doing Maths, Physics and Chemistry A Levels. I went to a mixed 6th form and there were only 3 girls doing Physics A level.

OP, my family moved boroughs so that I could go to a girl's grammar. Would that be an option?

MissChanandlerBong81 · 03/10/2021 07:09

I was at school a long time ago. But I went to co-ed schools throughout and at secondary level the sexual harassment of girls was off the chart. Having your arse or tits groped and having your appearance appraised or rated was a daily occurrence. Many male teachers were complicit in it.

I’d naively assumed things would have changed in 20 years but recent news reports suggest it’s worsened, if anything.

I agree with the poster who said that single sex schools would be commonplace if it had been shown that boys fared better in them.