Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think it’s unfair single-sex schools aren’t an option for many (perhaps even most)?

408 replies

patienceandprudence · 02/10/2021 22:59

I have one single sex state school (and in fact there is only one private) in my county. It is in the county town, which we are not in the catchment for. It would take an hour and half to get to by public transport anyway.

Since it has been proven many times over that girls do better in single sex schools, why on earth aren’t there more options for those of us not in 11+ counties? I think it’s a great shame, and it doesn’t seem to be a thing that’s even being thought about.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
dottiedodah · 05/10/2021 07:40

It depends I think. I went to a mixed school and was mostly happy there.my dc went to state single sex schools .ds loved it ,dd less so. The thing is boys and men will be at work mostly, so girls will be used to them . At 11 on though maybe girls would be better off without boys being stupid and sexist .a lady on here recently said her dd had been bullied on the school bus by a boy showing her unpleasant pictures on the school bus . Similar things on our school bus as well 20 odd years ago

orangeautumnleaves · 05/10/2021 07:28

@SusannaM

Oh god no! I was unfortunate enough to go to an all girls school and it was bloody horrific. A total bitch fest.

There is an awful lot of nastiness amongst the girls in DD's school, even in the Sixth form there's still a ridiculous amount of what really amounts to bullying. The boys don't help the situation. I went to an all girl's school and it was nowhere near as bad.

Maybe you had a good cohort? Or maybe your school was on top of bullying more so than mine.

I know the local schools near me the co Ed ones are fantastic and have a very strong stance of bullying. The only all girls school around here is very focused on academia and not known for its pastoral care. I have known many parents to take their girl out and move them to the co Ed's where they have been much happier.

It's likely more a reflection of the individual school than anything else. But each to their own. My good friend plans on sending her daughter to all all girls school where I won't. To me it's not natural, it's not life, and like others have said segregating based on gender is potentially more damaging than not. And those who think your girl is safer away from abuse of boys, do you think girls in an all girls school don't hunt out local boys after school. I can tell you many are more vulnerable to abuse as they become more sheltered from the opposite sex.

SusannaM · 05/10/2021 06:23

Oh god no! I was unfortunate enough to go to an all girls school and it was bloody horrific. A total bitch fest.

There is an awful lot of nastiness amongst the girls in DD's school, even in the Sixth form there's still a ridiculous amount of what really amounts to bullying. The boys don't help the situation. I went to an all girl's school and it was nowhere near as bad.

theSunday · 04/10/2021 23:19

It’s a lazy and misleading argument to compare racism to the separation of boys and girls into different schools.

They aren’t the same thing.

Despite many positive reports of mixed schools on this thread which are great, there have been thousands of reports of sexual harassment (for example on the ‘everyone’s invited’ website). We know this reality hasn’t changed in decades.

Some choose single sex schools to get out of the problem and they create confident and well-rounded girls in my experience, I can’t speak for the all boys’ schools.

As adults we have to help our boys grow into rounded personalities as well. They need good role models, less isolation and the easy access to porn is very harmful.

orangeautumnleaves · 04/10/2021 23:15

Oh god no! I was unfortunate enough to go to an all girls school and it was bloody horrific. A total bitch fest. At soon as GCSEs were done I got out of there to a co ed 6th form college!

Not all girls do well in single ed, some may, but just hope you get a good cohort for the year she goes!

My dd would absolutely hate an all girls school and yes I have asked her.

Essexgirlupnorth · 04/10/2021 23:07

I went to a all girl school there is one that is a possibility for our daughter but would rather she went to an co-ed school.
My all girls school was very bitchy years 10 and 11 were especially bad. Things improved once the ringleader left after GCSE's. I stayed for 6th form and enjoyed it but did mix with boys out of school.
First time I was in co-ed education since 11 was when I went to uni. I did a female heavy course (biological sciences) and lived in a single sex flat in first year and will all girls in my second year. Did go a bit boy crazy when first started uni though was in a relationship from my second term throughout.

OverTheRubicon · 04/10/2021 22:53

@timeisnotaline

Bame girls are still girls, not part of the dominant sex that numerous studies have shown attract the teachers attention and time, not bigger and stronger and learning to live with teen testosterone or who grow up to be the sex that commit 98% of sex crimes. Some of our private girls schools here are half to majority Asian background, they are just girls like any other, as I’m sure overtherubicon realises. Presumably you don’t want any single second adult spaces either as that would be ostracising men?
That wasn't my point. And nor was whether there should be single sex spaces for adults or at all.

My point was that we wouldn't deal with racism by making all-white schools to keep others 'safe'. If anything, it would intensify division and extremism for the future.

VestaTilley · 04/10/2021 22:18

YANBU. If I had a DD it would be my preference too.

Mixed sex schools aren’t especially safe or pleasant places for girls in my view.

Ashville5 · 04/10/2021 22:14

No child should dominate any class. Many girls dominate. Many boys don’t. A skilled teacher deals with it. Those that dint need more training and support.

Seriously hang around outside an all boys school.It’s just laughable such a naive ridiculous idea is being pedalled. You want boys to respect girls more, the last thing you want to do is segregate them and make boys spend their most formative years devoid of female contact. 😂

Herecomesthesun70 · 04/10/2021 22:13

@purplecarrot23

I went to a Girls secondary state school and really Liked it! Where I grew up there were only single sex schools available apart from 1 failing co-Ed. I now have a DD and DS, and where we live there are only co-ed state schools which I am struggling with
Sounds exactly like my area
timeisnotaline · 04/10/2021 22:00

Bame girls are still girls, not part of the dominant sex that numerous studies have shown attract the teachers attention and time, not bigger and stronger and learning to live with teen testosterone or who grow up to be the sex that commit 98% of sex crimes. Some of our private girls schools here are half to majority Asian background, they are just girls like any other, as I’m sure overtherubicon realises. Presumably you don’t want any single second adult spaces either as that would be ostracising men?

aSofaNearYou · 04/10/2021 21:17

@SheldontheWonderSchlong

I think it's very different. For a start racial abuse is a hate crime and should be treated as such by a school, misogyny isn't a hate crime (which is absolutely disgraceful).
Yes, this.
SheldontheWonderSchlong · 04/10/2021 21:03

I think it's very different. For a start racial abuse is a hate crime and should be treated as such by a school, misogyny isn't a hate crime (which is absolutely disgraceful).

postingfortraffichere · 04/10/2021 20:57

@aSofaNearYou majority BAME is not the same as all BAME like all girls/boys as you are suggesting

postingfortraffichere · 04/10/2021 20:56

@OverTheRubicon

It's sexism women and girls suffer from, not sex segregation. How can you say with any authority that more single sex school's would make things worse

BAME children are frequently victimised by white children at school too. Do you think that creating all-BAME and all-white schools would create better outcomes, or risk far worse ones?

Exactly my point - completely agree
aSofaNearYou · 04/10/2021 20:52

BAME children are frequently victimised by white children at school too. Do you think that creating all-BAME and all-white schools would create better outcomes, or risk far worse ones?

Personally I think the two issues are considerably different as the way in which low level stuff is tackled is very different. However, there are lots of schools that are majority BAME students and I don't think that makes for worse outcomes for BAME people.

OverTheRubicon · 04/10/2021 20:34

It's sexism women and girls suffer from, not sex segregation. How can you say with any authority that more single sex school's would make things worse

BAME children are frequently victimised by white children at school too. Do you think that creating all-BAME and all-white schools would create better outcomes, or risk far worse ones?

CatsArePeople · 04/10/2021 19:52

Single-sex education "protects girls" just as much as school uniforms are supposed to cancel economic inequality - an outdated practice which exists because of tradition, rather than any practical sense.

aSofaNearYou · 04/10/2021 19:49

In what way does informing children - by virtue of same sex schools - that their sex separates them into two separate categories, help them to learn more about respect for each other?

I think you are being really obtuse here tbh. Girl and boy's schools already exist and the students don't think it's a punitive measure. I don't think it needs to be mandatory but as an option, it's better than simply banging our heads on the walls and saying "no, you're not different from one another" while they continue to blatantly treat each other as though they are.

Also it's not respect for each other, is it. It's boys respecting girls. It's not a mutual disadvantage.

And how is it also not a hostile environment for the boys, both those who will be even more vulnerable in a more male environment, and those who will be indoctrinated into the standard set of beliefs you get with large groups of young men together, in the current culture.

I'm bemused by this. Why is it that you think having girls there would improve things for boys? Is that you acknowledging that boys are more unpleasant than girls? Seems a bit odd. Girls suffer specific things from boys that other boys do not. They are the victims of the sexist behaviour.

And they can learn about respect for women in the same way they learn about most things in school's - theoretically. They will meet women and girls outside of school. It doesn't HAVE to be during school time, conveniently at the crucial time that leads to worse educational outcomes for girls. Those awful beliefs happen in coed schools anyway, girls have never been able to prevent that.

It's not about sacrificing girls. It will be making their lives worse if we intensify sex segregation.

It's sexism women and girls suffer from, not sex segregation. How can you say with any authority that more single sex school's would make things worse?

OverTheRubicon · 04/10/2021 19:38

Can someone tell me how this is so different from: "Some of the new immigrant children arriving in our schools have strong negative beliefs about women, gay people and Christian people, that can result in violence and abuse. As a group they also perform less well academically and make my child distracted and get less attention from the teacher.

I am therefore going to advocate for more schools that cater only those groups, including the many among them who actually have some of the characteristics that will get them picked on.

My sweet Christian child will remain unmolested, and I will pretend to believe that somehow these schools will help increase equality, instead of fomenting inequality and misunderstanding and poor outcomes on a societal level."

There are lots of things that might benefit individual children but lead to worse outcomes on a national level, which is why they shouldn't need to be government funded.

OverTheRubicon · 04/10/2021 19:27

Boys go to lovely girl-free schools. They then turn up at 6th form or higher education with manners and without a sense of entitlement. Yes oddly I was educated with some of these boys and young men plus have them in my own family. It isn't individual girls job to sacrifice her eduction and future job prospects by being educated in a hostile environment.

In what way does informing children - by virtue of same sex schools - that their sex separates them into two separate categories, help them to learn more about respect for each other? And how is it also not a hostile environment for the boys, both those who will be even more vulnerable in a more male environment, and those who will be indoctrinated into the standard set of beliefs you get with large groups of young men together, in the current culture.

It's not about sacrificing girls. It will be making their lives worse if we intensify sex segregation.

TaraR2020 · 04/10/2021 19:18

I think Briony might be making a point that the Taliban 'protects' women from sexual violence by segregating them and that single sex schools are not the answer to protecting our girls.

An extreme comparison though!

SheldontheWonderSchlong · 04/10/2021 18:27

Briony - thanks for your insightful input in to the debate, although I'm not sure the Taliban have the safety of girls at the front of their minds - maybe you know something we don't.

I'll be sure to look for comparisons when I visit the local girls grammar school on their next open day though.

aSofaNearYou · 04/10/2021 16:20

The Taliban would be proud of you!

What a bizarre and extreme thing to say.

Briony123 · 04/10/2021 16:00

@SheldontheWonderSchlong

Totally agree - there should be far more all-girls schools especially as the rates of sexual assaults in schools are ridiculously high. Frankly I view them as necessary to keep our daughters safe.
The Taliban would be proud of you!