Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

15yr old girl died of covid

311 replies

Louiselady500 · 02/10/2021 22:22

www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-england-hampshire-58772671

Will this make people reconsider allowing their teenagers to have the vaccine.
Yes or No?

It’s made me think a lot about it even though my child isn’t old enough to be vaccinated yet. If the times comes I think I will be much more convinced than I maybe was before.

OP posts:
Balonzette · 03/10/2021 02:18

Children have died from vaccine side effects, and become disabled.

Also, the vaccine doesn't seem to be very effective in stopping people getting covid, so I wouldn't risk the vaccine when the vaccine doesn't even stop the risk of covid.

ThinWomansBrain · 03/10/2021 02:16

from ONS stats to 17 Sept, 3 children less than a year old died from covid, 8 under 14 and 44 people under 24.
I found the age groupings interesting - implies that ONS counts 15+ as adult.

HerRoyalNotness · 03/10/2021 01:56

@Covidworries

86 Uk children have dies of covid so far. 1000s are suffering from long covid.

Its all very well saying 1000s have just had mild symptoms if your child is one of the lucky ones but have some compassion for the families that have not been so lucky.

Have some comprehension that no one can predict how their child could be impacted by covid.

This is how I feel. Your child could sail through a mild case, have a severe case, get long covid, or die. No one knows. It’s all very well to say the risk is small, but someone’s child is dying. The death of a child broke me completely and I could not live with losing another.

I’ve read a study previously about the loss of taste and smell this disease causes is actually causing damage in those areas of the brain. Long term they think it may lead to Alzheimer’s. For me that’s not worth the risk of catching it as we don’t know how our specific body will react to it.

Clocktopus · 03/10/2021 01:27

Not that I could see but their consultant should be able to discuss that with you on an individual basis, presuming they have one?

One of my DC has a medical condition that has increased risk of infections and their consultant was happy to discuss future vaccination risks with me after DC got an infection in the vaccine site of a previous vaccine (basically the site where the needle broke their skin got infected, I didn't even know that was a thing until it happened).

Covidworries · 03/10/2021 01:21

@Clocktopus

Thank you for stats. Was there any stats on risk in children at an increase of Mycarditis from congenital heart disease?

Clocktopus · 03/10/2021 01:16

She died of myocarditis. Can be caused by viruses inc. covid or can also also be caused by Pfizer vaccine. It’s a reason not to get it.

Vaccinations with Pfizer have a risk of 4.3 myocarditis cases per million doses and 3.8 pericarditis cases per million doses.

Contracting covid gives a risk of 450 per million COVID-19 cases for males aged 12 to 17, 601 cases for males aged 12 to 15 and 561 cases for males aged 16 to 19. For females aged 12 to 17, the myocarditis cases were estimated to be 213 per million COVID-19 cases, 235 per million cases for females aged 12 to 15 and 708 per million cases for females aged 16 to 19.

This is from the gov.uk website.

Vaccine definitely carries a lower risk of myocarditis than actually catching covid.

TableFlowerss · 03/10/2021 01:13

@silkience

As for the everything is dangerous brigade, do you say that on all threads or is it just the COVID ones?

@SinisterBumFacedCat nobody's really interested in starting threads about the very small number of children who die from flu, chicken pox etc, it would seem that potential risks of covid are the only risks worth discussing

This. Isn’t this the truth.
TableFlowerss · 03/10/2021 01:12

@AlexaShutUp

I don’t think you can compare this to small pox…

No, of course, it's different. But the point still stands - any parent would bitterly regret not vaccinating a child against a disease that ended up killing them. I'm very glad that this particular family won't have to deal with that regret, at least.

Yes, I agree with that and I understand where you’re coming from in that respect, regarding the family.
silkience · 03/10/2021 01:10

As for the everything is dangerous brigade, do you say that on all threads or is it just the COVID ones?

@SinisterBumFacedCat nobody's really interested in starting threads about the very small number of children who die from flu, chicken pox etc, it would seem that potential risks of covid are the only risks worth discussing

AlexaShutUp · 03/10/2021 01:07

I don’t think you can compare this to small pox…

No, of course, it's different. But the point still stands - any parent would bitterly regret not vaccinating a child against a disease that ended up killing them. I'm very glad that this particular family won't have to deal with that regret, at least.

LeaveHomeNow · 03/10/2021 01:06

Ah stats are already in this thread - 1 in 6000 from the vaccine, not covid, is what I am aware of.

TableFlowerss · 03/10/2021 01:06

When I say exactly, I’m referring to the waiting for more info. I’ve not heard any negative reports about vaccines I must say.

Covidworries · 03/10/2021 01:06

There is freedom to choose through. Vaccine isnt compulsory

TableFlowerss · 03/10/2021 01:05

@LeaveHomeNow

I heard there is some damning stats coming out about the vaccine and myocarditis and young people. I judge no one but am waiting for more info.
Exactly. People should be free to chose. People shouldn’t be passing judgment as if they’re somehow morally superior because they’re getting their child vaccinated Hmm
LeaveHomeNow · 03/10/2021 01:02

I heard there is some damning stats coming out about the vaccine and myocarditis and young people. I judge no one but am waiting for more info.

TableFlowerss · 03/10/2021 00:53

@AlexaShutUp

This argument always baffles me. If that statistic is your child, would you be comforted that their death was statistically rare, when there was something you could have done to reduce even that minor risk?

I'm reminded of the bit in Benjamin Franklin's autobiography where he talks about the death of his four year old son from smallpox and his bitter regret at having decided not to vaccinate him. Vaccine hesitancy is not new, and neither are the tragedies arising from it.

I don’t think you can compare this to small pox…
OrganicBagel · 03/10/2021 00:51

I don’t say this from an anti vax stance, but rather from a data analysis point of view. I recently looked at ONS figures for deaths in the 15-19 age group in 2021 compared with the 5-year average from 2015-2019. In the 12 weeks prior to rollout of the vaccine to vulnerable children (and I think possibly also the 16-18 age group at the same time) there were slightly fewer deaths than the average over those 5 years. In the 12 weeks after the rollout began there was a 21% increase in deaths compared to the 5-year-average! I removed the number of covid-related deaths in that age group during that time (nine) and the increase was still around 16%. I checked the deaths in the younger age groups that weren’t yet vaxxed at that time (as far as I am aware) and in the 10-14 group and 5-9 age group the were around 12.5% fewer deaths than average. In real terms it was 35 (15-19 age group) deaths more than the average over the 12 week period compared with 8 fewer deaths in the younger age groups over the same period. I shall be watching the statistics with interest over the coming weeks as the rollout in schools has taken off. If these excess deaths or due to the vaccines then that will become very apparent when the 10-14 age group suddenly sees a huge increase in deaths having been less than average over the whole year so far.

TableFlowerss · 03/10/2021 00:47

@BoredZelda

Children will tragically die of complications but it’s statistically so rare.

This argument always baffles me. If that statistic is your child, would you be comforted that their death was statistically rare, when there was something you could have done to reduce even that minor risk?

Surely you would look at the risk of your child dying from Covid v the risk of your child dying from the vaccine. More children have died from Covid in England, than have died from the vaccine worldwide.

I was first faced with the “statistically” argument when it came to chicken pox. Would I deliberately try and expose my daughter to chicken pox to get it over with at a time that suited me, and when she was young enough, or would I try to protect her. She eventually caught it at nursery when she was 3 and she was really, really ill with it, resulting in a hospital stay. If I had done that to her I would have felt incredibly bad no matter how statistically low the chances of that happening were. As it was, I discovered later we could have had her vaccinated privately and I felt like a failure as a mother because I didn’t know that was possible.

It shouldn’t baffle you, because until a few weeks ago, it wasn’t deemed appropriate to give children a vaccine that was ultimately not to protect them.

Do you honestly think that if it affected everyone of every age, the same same way as it affects children, that there would be a vaccine??!! There absolutely wouldn’t. Covid wouldn’t be a word we would even know.

As it’s been pointed out already, any child could die of any virus, flu, chicken pox etc but we don’t rush out to vaccinated because it doesn’t affect that vast majority of people.

So let’s not pretend that vaccine is to protect children, it’s to protect the wider society, particularly the vulnerable!

If people are happy to be vaccinated then good for them, but some people would prefer to take caution.

Using your example about regret, a child could have a allergic reaction to a vaccine (not necessarily a covid vaccine - it could be a flu one) and die. So surely the same argument you used, but for the opposite scenario, when the parents regretted it.

To add, both my children have had covid and we’re absolutely fine. One was asymptomatic.

I’m pleased they’ve got a vaccine and I’m pleased children are allowed it now. If parents feel better for giving their child it then great, but thankfully parents are allowed to weigh up the pros and cons and done decide they want to wait and see and there’s nothing wrong with that approach under the circumstances, given the chance of dying from covid is about 1 in a million. Another reason it’s taken this long to be offered because it was questioned morally………

Staffy1 · 03/10/2021 00:42

It’s so difficult to find information about this that isn’t conflicting. Does covid cause more cases of myocarditis in children than the vaccine? If so, why is there so much made of the fact that the vaccine causes it in this age group? When it’s mentioned as a side effect of the vaccine it’s always described as “very rare”, but depending on which source you believe, it’s as high as 1 in 6000 in boys aged 12-15 after the second vaccine. That’s not what I would call very rare. After the first vaccine it’s more like 1 in 83000 which I would feel more comfortable describing as “very rare”. Try as I might I can’t find anything much on how often it occurs as a result of covid in this age group except for one lone article that says it’s 6 times higher than after the vaccine. I really would like to know as after agonising over it my son has had his first vaccine, but I still don’t know if it’s likely to be safer for him to have the second or not. (Not that you could ever be sure, but comparable statistics would help with the decision). (He can have a second vaccine as he has special needs whereas most others in this age group aren’t being offered a second jab anyway).

DeeCeeCherry · 03/10/2021 00:31

I hope a child's death isn't going to be used here to harangue and challenge and scaremonger people who've chosen not to have the vaccine. It's in very poor taste.

How sad that she lost her life. Im glad her parents were able to be with her to the end, well according to reports anyway.

Perspective, please.

Mango101 · 03/10/2021 00:27

[quote Takingabreakagain]@PeachesPumpkin
It's put on the death certificate if they tested positive in the last 28 days. There can be more than one reason on the death certificate[/quote]
It has to contribute to death to be on the death certificate. eg wouldn't if died in car crash.

AlexaShutUp · 03/10/2021 00:24

I am just thankful that, in this very sad case, the child was clearly going to be vaccinated, so at least the poor family won't be reproaching themselves about that.

EasterIssland · 03/10/2021 00:23

@Covidworries

86 Uk children have dies of covid so far. 1000s are suffering from long covid.

Its all very well saying 1000s have just had mild symptoms if your child is one of the lucky ones but have some compassion for the families that have not been so lucky.

Have some comprehension that no one can predict how their child could be impacted by covid.

@covidworries Think everyone is sorry about the death of this girl. Isn’t that compassion?

I’ve had the vaccine. I volunteer in a vaccination centre. I work every day in something that helps the nhs delivering the vaccine. So I don’t consider myself antivax

However , my son is nearly 4. If the studies on his age is a group Of 2000 people like 5-12 then I won’t rush til I know full well that the vaccine is safe. He’s been 3-4 times with someone that has had the virus either he hasn’t caught it or if he has he was asymptotic. I can’t currently trust it with only 2k on the trials. How many have died because of az ? How many have had problems with their periods? Do we know how pfizer will affect those girls periods who are around 15? Do we know how long term those boys affected by Pfizer will be ?

We’ve always been told that kids don’t get so ill and that they weren’t so much carrying the virus … now suddenly we have to vaccinate them because many are dying or having long COVID ? Give us a bit of time to the parents to understand the big picture and the implications of our kids having this vaccine. I’m pretty sure many of our kids will end up having it sooner or later … but don’t tell us we’re not respecting those that have died because it’s not true

Whatever we do in life there is always going to be a risk , not only with COVID.

AlexaShutUp · 03/10/2021 00:23

This argument always baffles me. If that statistic is your child, would you be comforted that their death was statistically rare, when there was something you could have done to reduce even that minor risk?

I'm reminded of the bit in Benjamin Franklin's autobiography where he talks about the death of his four year old son from smallpox and his bitter regret at having decided not to vaccinate him. Vaccine hesitancy is not new, and neither are the tragedies arising from it.

BootsScootsAndToots · 03/10/2021 00:17

I know a woman whose two year old died of chickenpox. Fucking chickenpox. But I didn't rush out to vaccinate my dc against it, and most parents don't.

Well I don't understand why you wouldn't vaccinate against chickenpox. I paid for both my DC to receive it when we lived in the UK because the fact they don't offer it, doesn't mean you shouldn't take it.

It just means the NHS saves money.