Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

15yr old girl died of covid

311 replies

Louiselady500 · 02/10/2021 22:22

www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-england-hampshire-58772671

Will this make people reconsider allowing their teenagers to have the vaccine.
Yes or No?

It’s made me think a lot about it even though my child isn’t old enough to be vaccinated yet. If the times comes I think I will be much more convinced than I maybe was before.

OP posts:
theemperorhasnoclothes · 03/10/2021 10:34

What is the most sad about this is she will have been in a school with no mitigations (leading to a very high viral dose probably), and this government is allowing covid to run rampant in schools because 'children only get it mildly'.

One death because of this strategy is one death too many.

MITIGATE THE RISK IN SCHOOLS. They could have CO2 monitors, air filtration and ventilation before you even get to masks and they are doing none of this, they are risking children's health when they could put in place mitigations.

MLMbotsno · 03/10/2021 10:33

@Porcupineintherough

Covid infection is 6 times more likely to cause myocarditis in younger people than the Pfizer vaccine. Worried about myocarditis? Then get vaccinated against COVID.
This.
EileenGC · 03/10/2021 10:31

@SinisterBumFacedCat

It would be surprising if anti vaxxers were pro mask.

Antivaxxers don’t need masks. They are protected by keeping their heads shoved in the sand.

Funnily enough, my anti-vaxxer father, who is also a Covid-denier, happily wears a mask and pulls others up on it.

It makes absolutely no sense. He gets Covid and then blames the rest of the family for bringing it to him - but he thinks Covid doesn't exist?

He is afraid of getting the jab but also afraid of going to spaces where people aren't wearing masks properly - but then I think this is his need for virtue signaling that comes out on top here.

There are many insane people around, and the way they reason makes absolutely no sense whatsoever so it's not worth it trying to understand them.

SuperstarDog · 03/10/2021 10:30

Antivaxxers don’t need masks.

All the unvaccinated people I know, including me, are all still wearing masks.

museumum · 03/10/2021 10:29

The risk from myocarditis is much higher from covid than from the vaccine.
Just like the risk of blood clots is much higher from catching covid than from the vaccine.
The only “safe” way is to not be vaccinated AND exposed at all by full isolation and that’s close to impossible in the U.K.

toomuchlaundry · 03/10/2021 10:27

@SinisterBumFacedCat Grin

SinisterBumFacedCat · 03/10/2021 10:26

It would be surprising if anti vaxxers were pro mask.

Antivaxxers don’t need masks. They are protected by keeping their heads shoved in the sand.

piscis · 03/10/2021 10:25

That's tragic but it is a case in a million, so I don't think that will change the decision of most. if someone doesn't want the vaccine for their kids, they still won't have it. A small number of kids also die of chickenpox each year in the UK and the vaccine is not even on the vaccine schedule (it is in other countries and the vaccine exists).
I am not an anti vaxxer by any stretch of the imagination, but you cannot based any decision in anecdotal cases. The reality is that for the vast majority of teenagers, covid is very mild.
Of course there is going to be deaths from every single illness, I am sure there are some teenagers that have die from flu too but also really rare and not on the news.

EileenGC · 03/10/2021 10:22

Vaccines save lives. Vaccines prevent serious illness for those who weren't at risk of dying.

Countries where teens aged 12+ are now all fully vaccinated, are seeing less cases amongst that age group, less school disruptions, less cases overall.

My 16 year old brother currently has Covid, in the form of a mild cold. Our vaccinated mother has only lost her sense of smell. Our Covid-denier father was put on oxygen last week in the hospital. He's now home but can't stand for longer than 20 minutes before having to take a nap again.

The two teens from Covid-denier families they all caught it from - ages 15 and 13 - were in bed for one week and are still feeling pretty weak. These were two healthy, active and strong teens. Their parents didn't allow them to stay home when they were ill, instead dragged them to friends' houses even when the girls said they wanted to rest. They still won't vaccinate themselves or the kids.

Yes, vaccines have risks. Catching Covid is far riskier, for any age group.

Ponoka7 · 03/10/2021 10:21

It's the middle category that we are aiming to make the outcome better for.

Ponoka7 · 03/10/2021 10:21

Just to add it's sad but there's little that we can do to protect some categories of people from what will be to them, serious viruses.

Porcupineintherough · 03/10/2021 10:21

@OrganicBagel thats now. The thing in the uk is, most peolle are vaccinated and most (vast majority) of unvaccinated are young, so deaths are going to mostly be in the vaccinated population because covid is more serious in the elderly. But we know vaccination works to prevent deaths as we are not seeing death rates like we did last Jan, even though the rate of infection is similar.

In the States vacination is a political issue and you have vaccinated and unvaccinated people of all age groups and its predominantly the unvaccinated who are dying. Vaccinated people do die, of course, but at nothing like the same rate.

Ponoka7 · 03/10/2021 10:19

@OrganicBagel,
"The data shows that whether you are vaxxed or not, if you catch covid then you are statistically equally likely to die."

If you have certain health conditions or are over 85. Those data is being compromised by the very elderly and frail who are double jabbed. If you look behind the data. Those who are younger and healthier are having more hospital admissions, ICU and being left very unwell etc than their peers who are double jabbed. But more importantly it's stopping the build up of circulation to a level were we will get mutations. We are trying to avoid a mutation that will affect children more than it does at present.
The data shows that boys are more at risk from complications of Covid than the vaccine. Every boy will eventually be catching Covid, somewhere in their school life.

LindaEllen · 03/10/2021 10:17

@Mummabug18

People are dying from it with and without having had vaccs. Make the decision for you and yours.
Look at the death rates since people started getting the vaccines, though. You might have reservations about the vaccines, but the facts are there that they have and will continue to prevent many, many deaths. It's incredibly stupid to come on here claiming otherwise.
herecomesthsun · 03/10/2021 10:12

@OrganicBagel

I’m surprised by the differences in the figures relating to covid coming out of the US compared with those coming out of the U.K. PHE published a document recently showing numbers of COVID cases split by unvaccinated/partially vaccinated and doubly vaccinated over a four week period up to mid September. I excluded under 18s as they are mass tested and very few vaccinated, so not comparable across groups. There were around 87,000 unvaxxed cases but over 270,000 double jabbed positive cases. There were 730 deaths in unvaxxed people and 2284 in double jabbed people. They used the “estimated” unvaxxed and vaxxed populations as denominator when giving rates per 100,000 people, which have a higher rate in the unvaxxed population as it is estimated to be very small. However, using the actual number of positive cases in each population as the denominator gives virtually the same rate of deaths per 100,000 cases, which came to 835 in the unvaxxed group and 825 in the vaxxed group. That’s a tiny difference and absolutely not statistically significant. The data shows that whether you are vaxxed or not, if you catch covid then you are statistically equally likely to die.
But are they comparing like with like?

As people with vulnerabilities would have been more likely to get vaccinated & would have been vaccinated first?

And they would be a lot more likely to die of covid whichever way, but especially if they hadn't been vaccinated.

OrganicBagel · 03/10/2021 10:10

LarkspurLane
Haha, no, I literally downloaded the data yesterday and analysed it. Do you have a link? Clearly there are more than just me looking at this data.

OrganicBagel · 03/10/2021 10:09

Porcupineintherough do they specify a time period for that 90%? Is it current deaths or deaths since the pandemic began?

LarkspurLane · 03/10/2021 10:08

@OrganicBagel

I don’t say this from an anti vax stance, but rather from a data analysis point of view. I recently looked at ONS figures for deaths in the 15-19 age group in 2021 compared with the 5-year average from 2015-2019. In the 12 weeks prior to rollout of the vaccine to vulnerable children (and I think possibly also the 16-18 age group at the same time) there were slightly fewer deaths than the average over those 5 years. In the 12 weeks after the rollout began there was a 21% increase in deaths compared to the 5-year-average! I removed the number of covid-related deaths in that age group during that time (nine) and the increase was still around 16%. I checked the deaths in the younger age groups that weren’t yet vaxxed at that time (as far as I am aware) and in the 10-14 group and 5-9 age group the were around 12.5% fewer deaths than average. In real terms it was 35 (15-19 age group) deaths more than the average over the 12 week period compared with 8 fewer deaths in the younger age groups over the same period. I shall be watching the statistics with interest over the coming weeks as the rollout in schools has taken off. If these excess deaths or due to the vaccines then that will become very apparent when the 10-14 age group suddenly sees a huge increase in deaths having been less than average over the whole year so far.
Did you write the article published on the Expose/Daily Sceptic about this?
OrganicBagel · 03/10/2021 10:08

Porcupineintherough that’s exactly why I said..

I’m surprised by the differences in the figures relating to covid coming out of the US compared with those coming out of the U.K.

Porcupineintherough · 03/10/2021 10:04

@OrganicBagel thats not what data from the US shows at all. One third of population vaccinated, 90% of hospital admissions and deaths from COVID are unvaccinated.

EasterIssland · 03/10/2021 10:03

That’s our point @changingstages
Weren’t kids at risk before their chance to be vaccinated arrived ? Are they dying now that it’s their turn to get vaccinated ?(same as the pregnant women)

Media plays with who has to get vaccinated now and focuses on those that have problems. A pregnant women was at risk a year ago but if someone died it’d not have been so much in the media as it’s now. Same as with kids

mrstrickland · 03/10/2021 10:02

The ignorance around vaccinations on this thread is incredible. You think after all this time that people would know not to trust word of mouth or media. Do proper research. Read scientific papers. Then come back and say why you won't be letting your kids get vaccinated.

ICU is full of young people, previously healthy, who are now struggling to breathe. Do you really want that for your kids? Honestly I wish people could come spend time in hospital to see what covid is STILL doing to people before saying they aren't getting vaccinated.

I always think its interesting that the majority no doubt got their kids their routine vaccinations throughout childhood. Did you do all your research then? Or were you one of the ones that autism was caused by MMR ? Hmm

Lovemusic33 · 03/10/2021 10:01

My dd1 (17) caught covid after the vaccine and was quite poorly, she’s still not fully recovered and now has the awful cold that’s going around too. I was double vaccinated and caught covid too. Dd2 (15) is un vaxxed and didn’t catch it despite me being her full time carer. I will not be getting her vaccinated and have refused too. Half of her class also refused it. She’s had extreme reactions to vaccinations before, the MMR landed her in hospital having seizures.

I’m fed up of people posting threads trying to encourage people to vaccinate their kids and slagging off people that decide not too. Of course it’s awful that a 15 year old has died but this is one case out of millions of teens that have contracted it. The chance of a teenager dying of covid is so tiny, there’s more chance of a teen dying from suicide or a RTA than there is covid.

No one should be judging parents for vaccinating or not vaccinating their children.

People that are vaccinated are still dying from covid and are still getting long covid, yes it reduces the risk but it’s not stopping covid.

OrganicBagel · 03/10/2021 09:59

I’m surprised by the differences in the figures relating to covid coming out of the US compared with those coming out of the U.K. PHE published a document recently showing numbers of COVID cases split by unvaccinated/partially vaccinated and doubly vaccinated over a four week period up to mid September. I excluded under 18s as they are mass tested and very few vaccinated, so not comparable across groups. There were around 87,000 unvaxxed cases but over 270,000 double jabbed positive cases. There were 730 deaths in unvaxxed people and 2284 in double jabbed people. They used the “estimated” unvaxxed and vaxxed populations as denominator when giving rates per 100,000 people, which have a higher rate in the unvaxxed population as it is estimated to be very small. However, using the actual number of positive cases in each population as the denominator gives virtually the same rate of deaths per 100,000 cases, which came to 835 in the unvaxxed group and 825 in the vaxxed group. That’s a tiny difference and absolutely not statistically significant. The data shows that whether you are vaxxed or not, if you catch covid then you are statistically equally likely to die.