Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

15yr old girl died of covid

311 replies

Louiselady500 · 02/10/2021 22:22

www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-england-hampshire-58772671

Will this make people reconsider allowing their teenagers to have the vaccine.
Yes or No?

It’s made me think a lot about it even though my child isn’t old enough to be vaccinated yet. If the times comes I think I will be much more convinced than I maybe was before.

OP posts:
herecomesthsun · 03/10/2021 12:05

@Toty

Yes, vaccines have risks. Catching Covid is far riskier, for any age group.

'The assessment by the Joint Committee on Vaccination and Immunisation (JCVI) is that the health benefits from vaccination are marginally greater than the potential known harms. However, the margin of benefit is considered too small to support universal vaccination of healthy 12 to 15 year olds at this time.'

Marginally in the case of children, not far riskier as you state.

It depends what risks you take into account. Other medical and health experts, including the CMOs, think the benefit is strongly in favour of offering vaccines to age 12 +, considering all health risks and potential disruption of education etc.
herecomesthsun · 03/10/2021 12:02

[quote OrganicBagel]@herecomesthsun

These are the actual figures over the four weeks in question. Yes there are much higher numbers of deaths in the very elderly vaccinated groups, however weren't those the age groups that the vaccine is supposed to be protecting, by vaccinating the younger age groups and preventing (or limiting) spread?
Also, my point is that these figures don't seem to correlate with figures coming from the US, where they say that 90% of deaths and CASES are in unvaccinated people. If only 30% of the US is double vaccinated then yes, naturally you'd expect at least 70% of cases to be unvaccinated anyway, even if the vaccine didn't work.[/quote]
Ok to (I think) repeat my point again, hopefully more clearly.

The groups of vaccinated and unvaccinated people would need to be matched for age and risk, if you wanted a scientific comparison of mortality across them.

If you have a lot more 90 year olds and people with blood cancers in the vaccinated group, then you might get some people who will die with covid anyhow.

However, if those people had got ill without being vaccinated first, a shedload more would have died.

So if you are doing a comparison, you need to compare like with like.

(I haven't read up much about US figures, but from what you say, it sounds as though a disproportionate number of deaths are in the unvaccinated, which is broadly what you'd expect).

middleager · 03/10/2021 11:56

I'm so deeply saddened by this story.

Both my 15 year olds have had Covid. One is asthmatic and was in bed for a few days with it last week. He passed it on to me (double vaccinatrd, 48) and I was also bed bound, still not right, now. I was so worried we had passed it on to my 75 year old mother.

The notion that Covid is mild/asymptomatic in children isn't the case. He won't be eligible for the vaccine now. If they had been rolled out in the summer I wonder what schools would look like now.

theemperorhasnoclothes · 03/10/2021 11:51

@duffeldaisy

Well explained.

Basically the government has decided to try herd immunity in our children knowing FULL WELL that this would mean some kids would die.

As Prof Christina Pagel said, a tiny tiny fraction of a very big number is still a big number.

I.e. if hundreds of thousands of kids have covid, even if the risk is tiny, some kids will be the ones to suffer. But actually if you care about general health and not just deaths (since when has that been the metric we measure ourselves against?) then the estimates for the number of children getting long covid are quite high.

No mitigations in schools at all. It's disgusting. They could have vaccinated 12-15s in the summer, they could have ensured every classroom had a co2 monitor and windows that opened properly, they could have installed air filtration devices - all of that would have made a huge difference not just to how many kids caught covid but also how many got really ill (viral dose does matter). They did nothing, they removed the mitigations of bubbles, isolation when a contact etc.

One of my DDs friends was kept off school after extremely close and prolonged contact with a person who tested positive. The school said to send her in while asymptomatic. She tested positive for covid 3 days later. That parent, risking a fine, kept her kid off for the benefit of others but not everyone would be confident enough to do that when the policy is otherwise. She probably saved a lot of people from catching covid, but it's not what you're supposed to do now.

duffeldaisy · 03/10/2021 11:35

@Generalpost.
It's because mitigations have been removed in schools. Plus, vaccines have been put out in order of vulnerability (which is by age). So, while children have also been having it since the start, when it went into care homes at the beginning, that was again because a lot of vulnerable and unvaccinated people were mixing.

Over the last year and a half we've had home-learning, and until this term, in our school we still had masks, staggered starts, pupils in bubbles that didn't mix, one-way systems etc.
All of that's been removed without any vaccines, so it's just spreading like wildfire. Meanwhile, many adults are still working from home, wearing masks, they've been double vaccinated, etc. so the virus just can't spread as well through that age range.

It's not the virus changing its mind (although the Delta is far more contagious), it's adults changing the levels of risk.

Generalpost · 03/10/2021 11:30

Can I ask a question?

How comes before it was older/middle age/adults getting it. children/teenagers were hardly getting it /effected by it. Now suddenly they are?

It's as if covid has decided to group everyone into age groups and infect them 1 by 1. Starting with the oldest

duffeldaisy · 03/10/2021 11:26

@Toty, as you must know, the JCVI only had an extremely narrow remit, and they didn't take long covid, which affects 1 in 20 children who catch it, and can last for months, and do massive damage to organs, cause T1 diabetes etc.

That's why they didn't make the final decision.
But anti-vaxxers keep using that as some reasoning for the vaccine not being very good. And that's just not true.

OrganicBagel · 03/10/2021 11:25

@herecomesthsun

These are the actual figures over the four weeks in question. Yes there are much higher numbers of deaths in the very elderly vaccinated groups, however weren't those the age groups that the vaccine is supposed to be protecting, by vaccinating the younger age groups and preventing (or limiting) spread?
Also, my point is that these figures don't seem to correlate with figures coming from the US, where they say that 90% of deaths and CASES are in unvaccinated people. If only 30% of the US is double vaccinated then yes, naturally you'd expect at least 70% of cases to be unvaccinated anyway, even if the vaccine didn't work.

Toty · 03/10/2021 11:19

Yes, vaccines have risks. Catching Covid is far riskier, for any age group.

'The assessment by the Joint Committee on Vaccination and Immunisation (JCVI) is that the health benefits from vaccination are marginally greater than the potential known harms. However, the margin of benefit is considered too small to support universal vaccination of healthy 12 to 15 year olds at this time.'

Marginally in the case of children, not far riskier as you state.

WhatsitWiggle · 03/10/2021 11:16

My 13 yo had already agreed she wanted it, we're waiting for the school rollout. But if she hadn't, this would make me strongly encourage her.

theemperorhasnoclothes · 03/10/2021 11:15

And actually, as far as vaccination goes, I'm pro vaccination but mainly because the covid rates are so out of control in school aged kids that it's almost a certainty they'll get it sooner or later and the risks of complications like myocarditis are higher with covid than with the vaccine.

If I lived in a country (and there are so many) who were keeping rates of covid low with basic mitigations, I'd probably be less keen on vaccinating, particularly if I had sons.

Both of my kids are too young to be vaccinated so I don't even get that choice at the moment though. It's a choice between the risk of isolation if I homeschool (plus the fact that would mean I couldn't work) or sending to school to be infected and just hope they're not affected too badly.

theemperorhasnoclothes · 03/10/2021 11:12

Rest in peace Jorja. You had your whole life ahead of you and you were let down by this government and the adults in schools who did nothing to control a controllable risk.

Generalpost · 03/10/2021 11:11

Why is their always this anti vax/ covid deniers . There is such a thing as being in between?

I do wounder about the research of stuff I mean you can research day any night you can't (know) what you have read is 100% true. And if the government don't want you to know something then they will make sure you don't find out .

My 19 year old had it twice. He was really ill the first time not enough for hospital. The 2nd time was a bit milder but was still quite ill. His sense of taste has never been what it used to be. He's had both his jabs. I do wounder if he would have had anti bodies ?

Dd who's 11 got it. A few weeks ago . Hers was very mild . Just had paracetamol. And she was her normal self felt like she was bunking off.

I do find it odd that it's highly contagious but yet you can have DH and DW sharing a bed and only 1 gets it.

CornishGem1975 · 03/10/2021 11:09

To be honest, yes it has changed my mind. Well, I was on the fence and letting my teens decide for themselves. One wanted it, one wanted to be led by me. After reading the article this morning, I've told them both to have it this week.

ghostyslovesheets · 03/10/2021 11:07

Hasn't changed her mind (I've given my 12 year old the right to make her own choice) she has always wanted to have the vaccine like her older sisters have.

Sadly she had Covid 2 weeks ago and while she was generally not to bad it's knocked her off her feet with tiredness and she's also been vomiting on and off since she had it - so she's missing a lot of school - it's nasty

theemperorhasnoclothes · 03/10/2021 11:06

Including the media who should be compiling and reporting on the statistics and not just individual cases.

theemperorhasnoclothes · 03/10/2021 11:04

@duffeldaisy

It's so tragic, my heart goes out to her and her family. But it's not a one-off case. 10 children died just in England in September. If that continues, that's 120 in a year. (Hopefully that number will go down as vaccinations are rolled out). But if that number were dying of something else that's avoidable there would be uproar. This is avoidable with ventilation and masks in schools - and a faster rollout of vaccinations. It's so sad and it's so unnecessary when we do have things we could do to prevent this.
100% agree.

If 10 children had died because of fires in schools that had no fire risk mitigation in the last month there would be uproar.

People have their head in the sand.

duffeldaisy · 03/10/2021 11:00

It's so tragic, my heart goes out to her and her family.
But it's not a one-off case. 10 children died just in England in September. If that continues, that's 120 in a year. (Hopefully that number will go down as vaccinations are rolled out). But if that number were dying of something else that's avoidable there would be uproar.
This is avoidable with ventilation and masks in schools - and a faster rollout of vaccinations. It's so sad and it's so unnecessary when we do have things we could do to prevent this.

theemperorhasnoclothes · 03/10/2021 10:55

I can even understand why people don't like masks in schools because I can see how it impedes communication. But while rates are so high it is a huge failure of those adults in charge to allow children to just be infected ESPECIALLY when vaccination is within reach for so many.

But at these rates of infection most children will be infected by the time they can be vaccinated and have protection (3 weeks after vaccination). My DDs school won't start vaccinating until end of October, plus 3 weeks is mid November. It's rampant in schools now - my DD had lessons cancelled last week because they didn't have enough teachers.

TableFlowerss · 03/10/2021 10:53

@mrstrickland

The ignorance around vaccinations on this thread is incredible. You think after all this time that people would know not to trust word of mouth or media. Do proper research. Read scientific papers. Then come back and say why you won't be letting your kids get vaccinated.

ICU is full of young people, previously healthy, who are now struggling to breathe. Do you really want that for your kids? Honestly I wish people could come spend time in hospital to see what covid is STILL doing to people before saying they aren't getting vaccinated.

I always think its interesting that the majority no doubt got their kids their routine vaccinations throughout childhood. Did you do all your research then? Or were you one of the ones that autism was caused by MMR ? Hmm

Is it?? What’s your definition of young people with regards to this post? I don’t think ICU is full of children at all now is it??!!

For someone that’s started their post off with ‘research’ and ‘ignorance’, I’m astonished to think you could proclaim ICU is full of children when it’s not.

EileenGC · 03/10/2021 10:49

@SuperstarDog oh gosh yes, he is ill, that’s a fact. Refuses any help, but he’s not mentally well and we all know it.

Luckily I live thousands of miles away from him but he’s still spouting all this nonsense on a regular basis.

He wears a mask because he believes he’s better than everyone else at complying with rules, so he needs to follow them. He’s tried many explanations as to why he tested positive for Covid - the staff at the hospital injected it into him (when he actually needed an IV for fluids due to Covid), my siblings are friends with people who are ‘in the system’ and use their kids as transmission vectors for this government-controlled virus.

He is not well. I just wanted to give an example of how someone can be both an anti-vaxxer and/or Covid-denier and still wear a mask and comply with other rules.

Luckily I know these are isolated cases and I have many other friends and relatives who haven’t been vaccinated. They are all sane, normal people who had their own reasons for it, and are still behaving responsibly and decently.

TheReluctantPhoenix · 03/10/2021 10:49

It won't change my mind as I was always going to have my children vaccinated as soon as possible; to protect them, to protect others, and to improve their chances of not having their schooling interrupted.

I do think that this, sad as it is, though, is an incredibly rare event, and a child's chance of dying of COVID is vanishingly small, and far less than getting run over, for instance.

I do feel that there is whiff of propaganda in the publicity it is getting, even though it is in a good cause.

YouJustFoldItIn · 03/10/2021 10:48

People are dying from it with and without having had vaccs. Make the decision for you and yours.

A tiny, tiny, tiny, tiny percentage of people still dying are dying of covid in spite of having had the vaccine, or are dying and ill as a direct result of the vaccine itself rather than from Covid. I honestly cannot fathom how people are still too thick or pig headed to understand and acknowledge this simple fact. Nothing in life is ever entirely risk free but you and your children are statistically much safer vaccinated than unvaccinated by ANY measure you care to use.

SuperstarDog · 03/10/2021 10:41

EileenGC

Clearly your father isn’t making any sense at all.

I’m unvaccinated, know covid exists, wear a mask, don’t judge others for their choices on masks or vaccination status and I’m not insane. 😬

I don’t know anyone like your father. It’s hard to believe this is true to be honest. He’s covid denier but wears a mask, have you asked him what he’s wearing it for if covid doesn’t exist? How can he blame others for giving him something that he says doesn’t exist? Again have you asked him. I’d be questioning him as I think he sounds like he is very ill if it’s true and needs medical assistance.

Of course there are people that say people like this exist to try to make unvaccinated people seem insane.

MLMbotsno · 03/10/2021 10:37

@SinisterBumFacedCat

It would be surprising if anti vaxxers were pro mask.

Antivaxxers don’t need masks. They are protected by keeping their heads shoved in the sand.

🤣🤣