Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

15yr old girl died of covid

311 replies

Louiselady500 · 02/10/2021 22:22

www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-england-hampshire-58772671

Will this make people reconsider allowing their teenagers to have the vaccine.
Yes or No?

It’s made me think a lot about it even though my child isn’t old enough to be vaccinated yet. If the times comes I think I will be much more convinced than I maybe was before.

OP posts:
lljkk · 04/10/2021 20:45

I won't decide what I want my teen to do based on fate of one 15yo, no.

I suppose I might base the decision on fate of > 1000 teens who got myocarditis, & thousands of 15 yr olds who had asymptomatic infection.

Grapewrath · 04/10/2021 20:45

Very sad and also very rare
Really feel for the family but it’s still a no for my kids. Kids die from complications of usually mild illnesses snd it’s very sad but also unusual. Teenagers get breast cancer but we don’t rush to start mammograms at 15 because in adolescents, it’s rare. Complications from covid are also rare

herecomesthsun · 04/10/2021 20:39

There is also substantial uncertainty around the long term health risks of getting covid.

Which is one reason that other countries opted for vaccination & mitigations as far as possible rather creating a situation in which teenagers are inevitably exposed to covid infection.

bumbleymummy · 04/10/2021 20:21

@PurpleDaisies

Teens were offered the vaccine because of impact on school closures not because they benefit overall from the jab.

Yes, but the JCVI still did acknowledge that the benefits of being vaccinated on pure health grounds did outweigh the risks by a small margin.

Not enough to recommend it for all teens though, particularly because “substantial uncertainty remains regarding the health risks associated with these adverse events.”
herecomesthsun · 04/10/2021 20:03

They made some good calls earlier in the pandemic, admittedly.

EileenGC · 04/10/2021 19:57

I find it fascinating that people keep defending the JCVI. So was the rest of Europe wrong then, in vaccinating all teenagers before schools went back? Now the vast majority of over 12s are fully jabbed, schools aren't as disrupted and children aren't dropping like flies out of school for endless isolations and waits for tests.

If the vaccine is so bad, why has literally every other country authorized it in under 16s? How many hundreds of deaths from the Covid vaccine in European teens are you seeing in the news?

theemperorhasnoclothes · 04/10/2021 19:43

I feel very cross at the JCVI and the government. They could have said they thought people should have the choice, whilst saying they thought it was a finely balanced risk. People could have really taken 'personal responsibility' and parental responsibility then.

Instead they blocked it and blocked it until it was too late to provide any protection when the new term started.

The vaccinations will be too late for too many kids.

I hope the JCVI feel awful. But I doubt they do because they're in their ivory towers and it's not their kids that are suffering.

Saoirse82 · 04/10/2021 19:23

@Porcupineintherough

Covid infection is 6 times more likely to cause myocarditis in younger people than the Pfizer vaccine. Worried about myocarditis? Then get vaccinated against COVID.
@SweetBabyCheeses99 This!
herecomesthsun · 04/10/2021 18:59

I completely agree with @theemperorhasnoclothes

We have been way behind other developed countries worldwide in offering vaccines especially to vulnerable children, and some of those children will pay a very high price, a few will pay the highest price for that.

theemperorhasnoclothes · 04/10/2021 13:23

@Verite1

Suggesting that the decision is a no brainer is just offensive and off-putting. The decision is finely balanced - that was recognised by the JCVI. Nor is all the research one way. I have read the new scientist research. But I have also read the report that stated that the risk of myocarditis is 3.7-6.1 higher than the risk of hospitalisation in boys aged 12-15.

www.medrxiv.org/content/10.1101/2021.08.30.21262866v1

It is extremely difficult to make a decision when there is such conflicting information and the suggestion that those parents who chose to wait have not done their “research” is simply untrue.

I'm pro vaccine in the UK because covid rates in kids are so insanely high.

But I do agree with this.

The criminal thing is denying parents the choice of vaccination and doing absolutely nothing else at all to prevent covid spread in schools - getting rid of bubbles and isolation of close contacts. It was obvious what was going to happen and yet again we've discovered that the 2+2=4 of covid is true again. I.e. indoor, close contact environments with no mitigations lead to incredibly fast spread.

In fact the government's stance looks suspiciously like trying to deliberately infect kids with covid.

No-one's discussing viral dose either. The evidence shows wearing a mask reduces viral dose and lower viral dose has been correlated with less severe covid (which makes logical sense). Put 30 kids in a classroom with no ventilation, then have another 30 kids in that same classroom for the next hour. The viral dose in classrooms will be high.

Covidworries · 04/10/2021 12:53

I can just see future threads. My child had mycarditis and was fine. Some people make such a fuss etc etc Hmm

Covidworries · 04/10/2021 12:51

Mycarditis caused by vacc can be treated at home with antibiotics or resolve without treatment. So thats like comparing apples and oranges. What % of people will need treatmeny of some kind from covid compared of treatmeny from Vacc

Verite1 · 04/10/2021 12:42

Sorry - that should be risk of myocarditis after the vaccine is 3.7-6.1 higher.

Verite1 · 04/10/2021 12:41

Suggesting that the decision is a no brainer is just offensive and off-putting. The decision is finely balanced - that was recognised by the JCVI. Nor is all the research one way. I have read the new scientist research. But I have also read the report that stated that the risk of myocarditis is 3.7-6.1 higher than the risk of hospitalisation in boys aged 12-15.

www.medrxiv.org/content/10.1101/2021.08.30.21262866v1

It is extremely difficult to make a decision when there is such conflicting information and the suggestion that those parents who chose to wait have not done their “research” is simply untrue.

theemperorhasnoclothes · 04/10/2021 11:53

@myheartskippedabeat

I saw this and it's utterly heartbreaking 💔 I feel so sorry for this young girls family and friends there really are no words 😶 at a time like this but hopefully those who for whatever reasons don't want their kids vaccinated will have a "re-think" as no family should have to go thru this.
I agree it's heartbreaking but I think what's heartbreaking is the lack of mitigations in schools - ventilation, air filtration at the very least. Isolation of close contacts. All when children have not been able to get the vaccine even if they wanted to.

Jorja was due to be vaccinated the day she died - that's early, most children around here don't get the chance until at the earliest mid October. And it's 3 weeks from vaccination until they get any protection - all the while they're in covid petri dishes with no mitigations and no isolation of close contacts.

Jorja never had the chance to be vaccinated, she was going to, but because the JCVI delayed for what seems to be mainly political reasons she didn't have the choice. If she'd had the choice things could have been different.

No-one has to have the vaccine, it's a choice and it should be a free one (i'm not a fan of vaccine passports for this reason).

I think it's criminal they denied parents and children that choice over the summer before schools went back at a time when most countries were allowing families that choice.

Essentially they were denying parents and children 'personal responsibility' because how can you take responsibility when you have no choices to make?

They sent kids back into environments with no mitigations at all without the option of taking up the vaccine knowing full well that tragedies like this were very likely as a result. Doctors in other countries have been talking about protecting their children, and politicians agreeing, and here we have a minority of the tory party pushing for 'back to normal' with no mitigations at all, for purely political reasons.

They are responsible.

SuperstarDog · 04/10/2021 11:42

From a teens point of view, if they remain unvaccinated, they are unlikely to be very ill if they get covid. They are quite unlikely to get long covid.
If they have the vaccine, they may still get covid, they are less likely to get very ill if they get covid, but they weren’t likely to get very ill anyway. They may still get long covid. But they also may face short term side effects of the vaccine and don’t know what the long term consequences will be, although again I think they’re unlikely.
They’re only being offered 1 dose, so they don’t get the benefits of being classed as fully vaccinated such as easier travel to some countries.

My teens have chosen not to have the vaccine and I can understand why. Equally I wouldn’t be concerned if they chose to have it.

They have both been exposed to covid, one had close contact with 3 people that all tested positive a couple of days after spending a week with them and never got it. My kids don’t think they won’t catch it but they don’t think it’s inevitable that they will.

REDHERO · 04/10/2021 11:09

@user1481840227

What exactly are you scared of , what long term effect scares you so much that you ignore all the data after millions of people have been vaccinated.

myheartskippedabeat · 04/10/2021 06:46

I saw this and it's utterly heartbreaking 💔 I feel so sorry for this young girls family and friends there really are no words 😶 at a time like this but hopefully those who for whatever reasons don't want their kids vaccinated will have a "re-think" as no family should have to go thru this.

Nancydrawn · 04/10/2021 05:29

@ all user1481840227 And for some of us on the other side of the debate, it boggles the mind that you would be more afraid of covid than the vaccine.

I will repeat, "People who are not fully vaccinated are eight times more likely to test positive, 41 times more likely to be hospitalized, and 57 times more likely to die compared to people who are vaccinated."

We know that most reactions to vaccines (we have decades of historical data) are immediate, not longterm.

But even if you think there might be long-term effects, we also have no idea what the long-term effects of catching covid are, let alone covid that is so bad you're hospitalized.

And once more, for the people at the back, you are 57 times more likely to die of covid if you are unvaccinated. This is real data, taken from Seattle, playing out in real time.

I am far more afraid of covid than the vaccine.

ElizaDarcysDeeds · 04/10/2021 01:18

Our school has mitigations - masks, distancing, sterilising, windows open. The numbers are still sky high. Probably because parents and older siblings are going to concerts and events and overall acting as though Covid no longer exists.

The government and the schools have been clear vaccinations for children is prompted by a desire to have continuity of education. But that push for continuity is what's causing the problem.

DCs are being sent to school when their siblings are positive. Three days later, they test positive. The children they sit beside no longer have to isolate because suddenly they're no longer contacts. Then they test positive, take it home to their families.

The fallacy that vaccinations have changed the definition of contacts is pushing the numbers through the roof and putting children and vulnerable adults at risk.

We're in contact with medical professionals because of underlying conditions. They're bemused that so many adults are acting as though Covid transmission has changed just because the government changed the rules regarding contacts. They're also gearing up for the numbers to keep rising because that's what happens when the government tells contacts to go out to work or into class and adults pretend they don't understand they're putting people at risk.

SeaAndTea · 04/10/2021 00:38

Fgs just get your bloody kids vaccinated. And if you are too cowardly to take that decision then at least butt out of their lives so they can access some real data and make an informed decision to have it independently, without you whimpering in the background.

Hmm
MrsPsmalls · 04/10/2021 00:36

Fgs just get your bloody kids vaccinated. And if you are too cowardly to take that decision then at least butt out of their lives so they can access some real data and make an informed decision to have it independently, without you whimpering in the background.

user1481840227 · 04/10/2021 00:26

@MissConductUS

The long term data for the vaccines DOES NOT EXIST yet, so to say that people have no sense is not accurate at all. We could say the same about your side.

So do you think we should have waited for five or ten years before we started vaccinating people and just surveilled the clinical trial participants? Do you have any idea how many unnecessary deaths that would have led to?

The problem is that there's no escaping risk in this situation and our brains are wired to do nothing in the face of imperfect information. But by taking your chances with the virus you've accepted a larger risk to avoid, through inaction, a smaller risk. It's like staying in a burning building hoping the fire department will put out the fire before it reaches you.

@MissConductUS

I'm not necessarily saying that we should have waited 5-10 years before offering the vaccination to people, a lot of people wanted to take it after all!!
I'm just saying that people who want to wait for X amount of years shouldn't be bullied into it or talked down to like they're idiots because they want to wait and they certainly shouldn't be coerced into taking it by not being allowed to participate in certain parts of life until they get the vaccine.

It is arrogant to assume that taking the vaccine is the correct decision because as I said the long term data does not exist yet.

I believe in choice...and I believe that the governments and vaccine manufacturers should be more transparent and honest.

I refused the swine flu jab while pregnant for the same reason that I'm refusing this one, the lack of long term data. I know a woman who suffered severe vaccine injury from the swine flu jab and I've witnessed the effects it has had on her so of course I am reluctant to take this jab or let my children have it.

Your metaphor isn't really accurate, it's more like there's a burning building and if you go one through one door you could burn to death and if you go the other way you could die from smoke inhalation.

There are risks both ways and we all should get to choose for ourselves what to do.

MissConductUS · 03/10/2021 23:13

The long term data for the vaccines DOES NOT EXIST yet, so to say that people have no sense is not accurate at all. We could say the same about your side.

So do you think we should have waited for five or ten years before we started vaccinating people and just surveilled the clinical trial participants? Do you have any idea how many unnecessary deaths that would have led to?

The problem is that there's no escaping risk in this situation and our brains are wired to do nothing in the face of imperfect information. But by taking your chances with the virus you've accepted a larger risk to avoid, through inaction, a smaller risk. It's like staying in a burning building hoping the fire department will put out the fire before it reaches you.

MissConductUS · 03/10/2021 23:08

[quote user1481840227]@MissConductUS

I don't think that covid myocarditis is an official condition? Surely it is just myocarditis no matter what has caused it?[/quote]
Myocarditis just means an inflamed heart and can have different causes, just as pneumonia refers to inflammation of the lungs without specifying a cause. Pneumonia, for example, can be viral or bacterial. If the hospital attributed it to the virus it's likely the result of a serological exam of a tissue sample from the heart. That wouldn't be definitive, but it would establish a high probability of the cause.