Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

15yr old girl died of covid

311 replies

Louiselady500 · 02/10/2021 22:22

www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-england-hampshire-58772671

Will this make people reconsider allowing their teenagers to have the vaccine.
Yes or No?

It’s made me think a lot about it even though my child isn’t old enough to be vaccinated yet. If the times comes I think I will be much more convinced than I maybe was before.

OP posts:
EasterIssland · 05/10/2021 11:54

*world

EasterIssland · 05/10/2021 11:51

do you know what causes a lot of problems with covid? not vaccinating people.. but not in the uk, in india, indonesia, Ghana or many other countries that dont have access to the vaccines.. it's very good saying that I've to vaccinate my 3yo just in case he catches it and unluckily dies, but until not everyone in the word is vaccinated or has access to vaccines then we wont be over this pandemic. it makes more sense to use many of the vaccines the uk is using in other countries to avoid future variants that are resistant to the current vaccines.

EasterIssland · 05/10/2021 11:49

@herecomesthsun

The expectation is that everyone will be exposed to covid now, certainly anyone in education in schools.

Vaccine: tiny dose of medication designed, as far as medical science is able, to provoke an immune response and do no harm.

Covid: new pathogen which has killed 150k+ in the UK alone, including a small number of children, with the potential to cause an overwhelming infection, and well documented potential for organ damage.

You can guess what we chose.

out of those 150k how many were under 18s?
herecomesthsun · 05/10/2021 11:49

The expectation is that everyone will be exposed to covid now, certainly anyone in education in schools.

Vaccine: tiny dose of medication designed, as far as medical science is able, to provoke an immune response and do no harm.

Covid: new pathogen which has killed 150k+ in the UK alone, including a small number of children, with the potential to cause an overwhelming infection, and well documented potential for organ damage.

You can guess what we chose.

Aorh · 05/10/2021 11:39

That argument doesn’t stack up. The principle is the same for both, there is no certainty, it’s just a case of where you fancy your odds.

You get the vaccine, you put yourself “in the firing line” for side effects, but you still have to be one of the people who gets the side effects before you can be impacted.

You don’t get the vaccine, you are “putting yourself in the firing line” of being one of the people to get COVID and with bad symptoms.

I know which odds seem better to me.

MissConductUS · 05/10/2021 11:28

If you don't get vaccinated you still have to catch covid before you can have any side effects from covid. If you're taking other precautions it's possible you may never catch it and so avoiding all side effects on offer

Short of living alone in a cave, the likelihood that you will eventually be exposed to the highly contagious delta variant approaches a certainty. You will then have to fight the virus without the benefit of vaccine-induced immunity. This is why the vast majority of patients hospitalized with covid are unvaccinated.

Countries are giving up on the idea that they can prevent the spread of the delta variant.

www.cnbc.com/2021/10/05/zero-covid-strategies-abandoned-in-the-face-of-the-delta-variant.html

theemperorhasnoclothes · 05/10/2021 11:28

@LargeYorkshirePuddingAndGravy

Well yes, that would be ideal, but my DDs secondary school has 30 children in classrooms. No masks, no co2 monitors, no air filtration, no social distancing and windows that only open a crack. They move classrooms for every lesson and mix with different children every lesson. There are 180 children in the year group (and then obviously other year groups that use those same classrooms, adding to lovely airborne mix of pathogens no doubt).

I have spoken both here and IRL to headteachers and my MP at great length about the options for mitigation of covid risk in school and no-one cares - they are taking steps to actively infect as many as possible. The risk assessment for the school is laughable, it's all about handwashing.

The whole year did a half hour activity in the hall last week (180 kids, well probably less than that as quite a lot are off with covid) which has no windows.

They've had to cancel lessons this week due to lack of teachers (off with covid) and a significant number of children are off sick. We are not told if it's covid by the school but parents talk and I know of at least 2 of DDs friends off with covid at the moment, one of whom is really very ill.

So at the moment in state secondaries, there is no option of not being exposed. Which is why I want to know what the risks are of having a vaccine within 28 days because some of the kids in that school will have covid asymptomatically at the moment 100% certainty.

Only a small number of kids are doing LFTs as well. I can see why, the only reason to do it is to protect others and since no-one's obviously bothered about protecting them it gives the distinct message it doesn't really matter if you catch covid. So why bother? Children (in my experience) don't like doing it at all, it's invasive and unpleasant. Since it doesn't stop exposure only tells you once you've caught it, why bother? (I am doing it for the sake of CEV parents and children, but most aren't).

My heart goes out to the CEV parents and children who will exist in every large school.

Covidworries · 05/10/2021 11:26

but they may not get them and even if the do they may not be badly effected

bumbleymummy · 05/10/2021 11:25

@Covidworries or perhaps she’s vaccinated her children against diseases that are actually risky in childhood?

Covidworries · 05/10/2021 11:22

@LargeYorkshirePuddingAndGravy

but that's the same for any illness that has a vaccination> So i take it you haven't immunised your self or your child for anything?

bumbleymummy · 05/10/2021 11:20

@CornishGem1975 would people still have their children vaccinated after they’ve been infected? The JCVI only found a marginal health benefit against risk, so surely that gets tilted even further away from benefit if the child is already immune after infection?

LargeYorkshirePuddingAndGravy · 05/10/2021 10:54

It's not a straight either/or between having the vaccine or having covid. There's a third scenario, where they don't have either which nobody seems to talk about.

When someone has the vaccine they are putting themselves in the direct line for side effects. They may not get any but they also might.

If you don't get vaccinated you still have to catch covid before you can have any side effects from covid. If you're taking other precautions it's possible you may never catch it and so avoiding all side effects on offer

CornishGem1975 · 05/10/2021 10:44

@theemperorhasnoclothes

I think it's too late for a lot of kids to get the vaccine, given it's not advised to have it within 28 days of infection. So many will have to wait until they've got past that point. And if, in England, they're only doing the vaccination in schools how will these children even access the vaccine?

What if a child has the virus asymptomatically? Is there a risk to the vaccine then? Why do they advise 28 days post infection? It's so incredibly out of control in schools I can't see many children escaping for much longer: some of them will be asymptomatic.

I believe there's going to be a catch up...and the teams will go back into the schools in a month or so to pick up those who couldn't have it first time around.
Rainbowheart1 · 05/10/2021 09:39

It’s sad but not changed my mind. How can I let my children get a vaccine when we don’t even know yet what the side effects are?

I missed 3 periods from having the vaccine! (It was AZ, I had it before they then claimed my year group will now have PZ and not AZ!!) No good telling me AFTER!

theemperorhasnoclothes · 05/10/2021 09:37

Given the JCVI didn't want to give the green light to the vaccine over the summer so most kids could have it when not in school and less exposed, I wonder what their view is on the risks (if there are any?) of giving the vaccine to kids who've had asymptomatic covid infection within 28 days. Given the lateral flows likely won't pick up a very large number of them.

I don't even know if it's a real risk or they're just being precautionary (which would be grimly comic really given the lack of precaution in taking steps to deliberately infect as many kids as possible).

MarshaBradyo · 05/10/2021 09:36

@theemperorhasnoclothes

I think it's too late for a lot of kids to get the vaccine, given it's not advised to have it within 28 days of infection. So many will have to wait until they've got past that point. And if, in England, they're only doing the vaccination in schools how will these children even access the vaccine?

What if a child has the virus asymptomatically? Is there a risk to the vaccine then? Why do they advise 28 days post infection? It's so incredibly out of control in schools I can't see many children escaping for much longer: some of them will be asymptomatic.

You have a point and we are doing LFT for yet to be vaccinated

Why do they advise against it? Ie what are the issues that might arise

theemperorhasnoclothes · 05/10/2021 09:35

And that, of course, is why the innova lateral flows were banned by the CDC in the USA. Because of the risks of over reliance on a very inaccurate test with high false negative rate.

theemperorhasnoclothes · 05/10/2021 09:32

I don't think they will. The false negative rate on lateral flows is very high, 50% when not done by nurses I've read. I know my daughter doesn't really try and get a deep sample, but she finds it distressing but it's uncomfortable to do it so often and I just keep hoping I'd at least get a faint line if she were positive, but I know so many people who've had negative lateral flows and been positive on PCR (and symptomatic).

I have a nurse friend who tested positive on PCR and negative on 4 lateral flows even though part of her job is swabbing other people, so she was definitely doing it correctly. She had symptoms so did a PCR via work to double check. Positive.

AlexaShutUp · 05/10/2021 07:48

@theemperorhasnoclothes

I think it's too late for a lot of kids to get the vaccine, given it's not advised to have it within 28 days of infection. So many will have to wait until they've got past that point. And if, in England, they're only doing the vaccination in schools how will these children even access the vaccine?

What if a child has the virus asymptomatically? Is there a risk to the vaccine then? Why do they advise 28 days post infection? It's so incredibly out of control in schools I can't see many children escaping for much longer: some of them will be asymptomatic.

Hopefully most of the asymptomatic ones will be picked up by the regular lateral flow tests if people are doing them properly?
theemperorhasnoclothes · 05/10/2021 07:42

I think it's too late for a lot of kids to get the vaccine, given it's not advised to have it within 28 days of infection. So many will have to wait until they've got past that point. And if, in England, they're only doing the vaccination in schools how will these children even access the vaccine?

What if a child has the virus asymptomatically? Is there a risk to the vaccine then? Why do they advise 28 days post infection? It's so incredibly out of control in schools I can't see many children escaping for much longer: some of them will be asymptomatic.

Covidworries · 05/10/2021 07:01

@lljkk

The british heart foundation os advising children get the vaccination

Ellabella222 · 05/10/2021 05:47

My 15 yo has been off sick for 2 weeks with Covid and has been extremely poorly. This is not always a mild illness in children.

lljkk · 05/10/2021 05:33

I have cardiologist colleague and a friend had pericarditis so I know what that experience was like for her. So yes I know a bit about it. I follow this guy on Twitter who is unhappy about bouts of it being deemed benign, too.

DumplingsAndStew · 04/10/2021 22:15

@lljkk

Do you even know what myocarditis is, and what the actual risks and outcomes are? Very, very few people with myocarditis are ill, few even know they have it.

Which is pretty much the same view some have of Covid.

Stop acting like myocarditis is a death sentence.

bumbleymummy · 04/10/2021 21:36

@herecomesthsun

There is also substantial uncertainty around the long term health risks of getting covid.

Which is one reason that other countries opted for vaccination & mitigations as far as possible rather creating a situation in which teenagers are inevitably exposed to covid infection.

Not so much uncertainty with over 18 months worth of data.