Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think 2 car households are totally normal these days.

166 replies

Karleeb30 · 02/10/2021 18:03

I appreciate not everyone can afford to run 2 cars but it is a necessity in our case.

We live rurally with no public transport links. Dp works unsociable hours, I'm currently off work but have needed it for work previously , just not currently.. We have two dc who both have sen so needed for appointments when dp is at work. I'd also be very isolated without a car living where we do. We have thought about just having one buy it would be a struggle with appointments and no public transport links.

Basically we have dp's 15 year old trusty car he's had forever that he uses for work. He's had it for years. It's not suitable for us as a family as only a 3 door and small and wouldn't be great for dc.

Then we have a 6 year old (that we bought second hand last year ) family car which I use more than him but dp drives too at the weekends. Previously we had an older car as a second car.

It is a struggle to keep both going at times but both are pretty reliable so far (hopefully don't jinx it here) and haven't cost us much other than your average costs for a car.

I have recently received remarks off a family member. Saying we must be rich if we have 2 cars especially if I am not working (which is degrading tbh, people have no right to judge us in our current circumstances and they don't work themselves which is the funniest thing about it so they are very hypocritical.

We are not rich, we get by but living month by month especially down to one wage currently, we do struggle. We don't have any other luxuries!

We are fortunate we can keep 2 cars running because I know not everyone can but like I said we don't have much else in the terms of luxuries.

Aibu to think 2 cars is not a luxury in most cases but a necessity and people should
Keep their beaks out where it's not needed?

We are in that middle between rich and poor where we aren't rich (I wish) and we aren't poor either.

OP posts:
Karleeb30 · 02/10/2021 18:23

@EatYourVegetables

We are in that middle between rich and poor where we aren't rich (I wish) and we aren't poor either.

People who say that are usually rich. You can look up charts to see where you are in terms of percentiles.

It’s not really your relative’s business how you’re financing the cars, so they should butt out.

Two cars are horrible for the environment. Only you know how much you really need them, but I don’t believe all MNetters “live very rurally” as they claim they do.

We are far from rich. Dp earns just over 30 grand a year which is actually decent salary where we live but now high compared to some areas and dc also get disability benefits which helps with added costs but we don't get anything means tested. We live in a small 3 bed house we bought for £140000 a few years ago but now likely worth £200,000. But that's totally off topic.

We live very rurally but also near the coast. There are no good public transport links in the whole county live in - let alone our village.

I know it's terrible for the environment. My car is meant to be economical (£20 road tax a year). Dp could cycle to work but I don't feel it would be safe at 4am on an early shift or 10pm on a late shift on dark country roads.

OP posts:
MilduraS · 02/10/2021 18:22

We have two cars, as do most of our neighbours (where there are two adults). The only exception on our road is a retired couple and one couple where the SAHM drives husband to and from work then has the car for the rest of the day. We're in bog standard 3 bed terraces but fortunately most have off road parking.

Cadburycup77 · 02/10/2021 18:17

We are a one car family and I would say it's the exception. Most families I know have two or more cars.

We could probably "manage" without our car completely. But it's convenient. And having grown up with no car, much preferable.

yellowgingham · 02/10/2021 18:17

We recently moved from a city to a village. In the city most people only had one car but out here it's much more normal to have two.

We'd really struggle out here if we only had one car, not sure we could actually manage it unless we made some big life changes (different jobs etc). In the city we probably would have been ok with no car at all most of the time.

Cheeseycheeseycheesecheese · 02/10/2021 18:17

I would still class multiple cars as a luxury in most cases.

However it is location and profession dependent.
We're a one car family, have been since dh and I moved in together as we moved walking distance from my then job, dh has spent the last 18 months working from home, and I've changed jobs, I need to drive to work now and drop ds at nursery on my way. However, it looks like dh is on a gradual return to the office, meaning we're going to have to look at our options because our hours don't quite line up.

SantiagoSky · 02/10/2021 18:15

It’s cheaper to buy a house with no public transport, but then you’ll have to spend extra money running one or even two cars.

burritofan · 02/10/2021 18:14

Entirely depends, doesn’t it? There’s no “normal”. Everyone I know is either a one- or zero-car household. But we’re all in London and Brighton where having a car is rank madness. Imagine families in rural areas without decent public transport with 2 working parents have an entirely different set-up.

Just ignore other people’s commentary on how you run your life.

Dishwashersaurous · 02/10/2021 18:13

Just ignore.

Some people run no cars.

Some people run two.

Some people holiday in the Caribbean. Some people camp.

Everyone has different incomes and different priorities .

Why do you care?

DelilahDingleberry · 02/10/2021 18:13

We only have one but both work from home. We couldn’t manage with one if DH went back to work in an office because there are no buses or trains to the children’s school.

EatYourVegetables · 02/10/2021 18:13

We are in that middle between rich and poor where we aren't rich (I wish) and we aren't poor either.

People who say that are usually rich. You can look up charts to see where you are in terms of percentiles.

It’s not really your relative’s business how you’re financing the cars, so they should butt out.

Two cars are horrible for the environment. Only you know how much you really need them, but I don’t believe all MNetters “live very rurally” as they claim they do.

AFuturisticalSound · 02/10/2021 18:12

What do you mean by these days, having 2 cars isn't a new thing. It was normal when I was a child and it's normal now.

Who cares what anyone else thinks about the number of cars you have, are they short on stuff to concern themselves with?

MrsKDB · 02/10/2021 18:12

We can’t afford a second car so make do with one. Walk / cycle / train when required. Links aren’t great (not London) but we are used to it and get on with it. From observation, those who get used to the convenience of two cars cannot then go back to one.

AuntieMarys · 02/10/2021 18:12

We have 2 cars. Dh works, I don't....I have a 14 year old runaround which gets to the supermarket, gym, meeting friends and walks in the country.
We live in a city but transport links are shocking....a bus takes 50 mins to do a journey I can do in the car in 15.
We use dhs car for breaks/ days out.
Neither of us are " into" cars...we just want one which is economic and reliable.
And we are not " rich"!!

Dancingbugbadge · 02/10/2021 18:09

I don’t see how it’s anything to do with your family??
We are definitely not rich but are a 2 car household. Both our jobs require that we need a job (I do home visits across a county) and my husband does shift work with no public transport options at the times needed. We also both have days that we have to collect my son from childcare (we wouldn’t have time to reply on public transport after shifts ending) I agree what what you are saying. In some cases it’s a necessity. I certainly wish we didn’t need 2 cars it would certainly save us some money! But in order to keep our jobs it’s essential.

Poetrypatty · 02/10/2021 18:05

Depends entirely on where you live and where you work and what the public transport options are. If there are alternatives then one car should be enough eg if you live in a city.

monkeysox · 02/10/2021 18:04

Yanbu