Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think 2 car households are totally normal these days.

166 replies

Karleeb30 · 02/10/2021 18:03

I appreciate not everyone can afford to run 2 cars but it is a necessity in our case.

We live rurally with no public transport links. Dp works unsociable hours, I'm currently off work but have needed it for work previously , just not currently.. We have two dc who both have sen so needed for appointments when dp is at work. I'd also be very isolated without a car living where we do. We have thought about just having one buy it would be a struggle with appointments and no public transport links.

Basically we have dp's 15 year old trusty car he's had forever that he uses for work. He's had it for years. It's not suitable for us as a family as only a 3 door and small and wouldn't be great for dc.

Then we have a 6 year old (that we bought second hand last year ) family car which I use more than him but dp drives too at the weekends. Previously we had an older car as a second car.

It is a struggle to keep both going at times but both are pretty reliable so far (hopefully don't jinx it here) and haven't cost us much other than your average costs for a car.

I have recently received remarks off a family member. Saying we must be rich if we have 2 cars especially if I am not working (which is degrading tbh, people have no right to judge us in our current circumstances and they don't work themselves which is the funniest thing about it so they are very hypocritical.

We are not rich, we get by but living month by month especially down to one wage currently, we do struggle. We don't have any other luxuries!

We are fortunate we can keep 2 cars running because I know not everyone can but like I said we don't have much else in the terms of luxuries.

Aibu to think 2 cars is not a luxury in most cases but a necessity and people should
Keep their beaks out where it's not needed?

We are in that middle between rich and poor where we aren't rich (I wish) and we aren't poor either.

OP posts:
Newmum29 · 02/10/2021 20:44

I actually disagree (not a typical poster who disagrees with every OP to make a point!)

My husband and I both earn good money and he’s constantly suggesting we get a second car but to me we just don’t need one and I do think they’re a bit of a luxury.

We have a LO and can use public transport to work but he prefers to drive. I just don’t see why we’d need two unless we had more children who needed ferrying about.

When I was on mat leave he kept apologising for leaving us stranded without a car when he went to work but it really didn’t bother me, we walked in the pram and saw people from my mothers group who lived locally or PiL would drop by.

OldTinHat · 02/10/2021 20:39

Just before I left home (1992!!!), between my DPs and DSis, we had four cars. DPs had a drive long enough to fit three behind each other. Number four had to park on an A road with no spaces for cars to park. It's just how it was.

There's sod all parking where I live now.

Xmasbaby11 · 02/10/2021 20:34

We live in a city and have 2 cars. It is luxury which makes our lives more convenient. We could manage with one but would have to cancel some kids activities and would lengthen my commute by a hour a day. It would also fall to me to do without as dh is a social worker who drives around a big area doing hime visits which are usually 3-6pm.

It's a shame because the school and childminder are both 5 mins from home, but the timings of our jobs and other things make logistics v hard without a car. I do feel like it's a luxury having 2 cars though. I didn't own a car til I was 35 and I'm 45 now, so I don't take it for granted.

julieca · 02/10/2021 20:23

@Lottieskeeper is that an income of £20k but inheritances and family gifts? Or £20k always earned very little and have no other money behind us?

Fupoffyagrasshole · 02/10/2021 20:21

Depends where you live!!
I’m in London and I know nobody with a car !!

Lottieskeeper · 02/10/2021 20:18

I cannot imagine having only 2 cars.
We have 4 cars between me and my husband.
1 what we call modern (18 years old) German estate car for family duties and 3 old British cars ( some people would call them classic) that take it in turn to be broken. My husband uses an oldie to get to work every day and I'm a SAHM.

I love the crazy idea that you have to be rich to afford more than 1 car; Our household income is under 20k PA.

When they are over 40 years old they get free tax and don't need an MOT

I'm sure it's far better for the environment to keep old cars going than to buy new ones. Reuse, Reduce, Recycle all that.

Larryyourwaiter · 02/10/2021 20:16

I live somewhere central but the public transport is shit. It’s really gone downhill in the last few years. Lots of the bus routes have been amalgamated so they take ages to get anywhere.
I was a very late learner to drive but I had to because I couldn’t cope with it anymore.

julieca · 02/10/2021 20:13

People choose where they live usually. So people are choosing to live somewhere you need to drive. That is fine, but just own it.

Onthegrid · 02/10/2021 20:12

We have 3 cars as DD has one, but she has moved out to a city where she walks everywhere or uses public transport and has no parking so we will sell it.
DH has to use his to commute to work everyday, and sometimes for longer periods if he is away for work. I am not waiting until after 7 to go out.
Do I need a car, not every day, as I work from home, but I have medical appointments, live at the top of the hill with a random and unreliable bus service and have elderly parents who live in the middle of nowhere.
I have had a car since I was 17 and it’s my independence

Lou98 · 02/10/2021 20:11

@Pixxie7

It’s up to you how you spend your money and people shouldn’t judge but to say 2 cars is a necessity not a luxury is wrong, particularly when you consider that a lot of families can’t afford to eat or heat their homes.

It isn't "wrong" to say that, to some people they definitely are essential - some people need their cars for work, think taxi drivers, delivery drivers etc - without their car they wouldn't be able to make a living. Of course they're not an essential for everyone but it's silly to say they're never an essential

Lou98 · 02/10/2021 20:09

YANBU OP! We have two cars. My DP has a 16 year old car, he travels for work so needs it. I have a 7 year old car, I'm currently on maternity but normally drive to work.
We live in the country in Scotland, there's no train station near by, the closest one is a 20min drive, there is one bus that comes through once every 2 hours that goes to the nearest city (Glasgow) but it's very unreliable, often shows up late, sometimes not at all, especially in the winter with the bad weather. I definitely see both of our cars as essential.

Also, probably an unpopular opinion, but I didn't spend all the money I did learning to drive to then still have to rely on public transport (which also isn't cheap) - I learned to drive for a reason, I wanted the ease of being able to go where I want when I want without waiting about for buses that sometimes don't show or spending a fortune on taxis to the nearest train station🤷‍♀️

julieca · 02/10/2021 20:05

That can be why places like that struggle to recruit. My nephew works in an amazon warehouse and gets lifts from family. He can't afford a car.

Pixxie7 · 02/10/2021 20:04

It’s up to you how you spend your money and people shouldn’t judge but to say 2 cars is a necessity not a luxury is wrong, particularly when you consider that a lot of families can’t afford to eat or heat their homes.

KingdomScrolls · 02/10/2021 20:00

I actually think it's more likely you'll need two cars in lower paying jobs, my aunt is a night supervisor for a supermarket, my uncle works as airport security, both work shifts in different places at times when there is no public transport even though it's a reasonably urban/suburban area so need two vehicles. My other aunt is a self employed consultant in electrical engineering and her husband works in IT they have one car, can WFH fairly regularly or either afford extortionate train fares cross county or bill them to a client. My old next door neighbour when I lived in a flat was a binman had to get to work before the buses ran their needed a car, there's a huge Amazon depot about twenty miles from here again shift work and buses don't run between 8pm and 7am and it's not a rural area so people need cars/motorbikes to get there

Jangle33 · 02/10/2021 20:00

We only have one. I’ve actively made a choice to live somewhere with good public transport links. Never mind the cost what about the environmental impact!

trilbydoll · 02/10/2021 19:59

Everyone I know has 2 cars, I'm astonished it's only 12%. Even our retired parents still have a car each!

The delicately balanced house of cards that is 2 working parents and school runs / clubs etc only works because we have 2 cars. If we started having to factor in time for cycling or catching buses we'd have to put the kids in wraparound care 5 days a week while we spent loads of time travelling.

TheCanyon · 02/10/2021 19:58

There was a guy that posted on the Glasgow subreddit yesterday about his and his wife's cars had been stolen, someone replied that they must be rich to have two cars Grin utter bitterness

We've no cars, several couple friends share a car or have one each. Makes no odds to me.

CosmicComfort · 02/10/2021 19:58

We only have one car but we are the exception in our overflowing street. The driveways are only big enough for one car but most people have at least 2 so parking is a bit tricky. Growing up in a more rural area, every adult that could drive needed a car really. At one point my mum and day had 4 when my dbro and I learned to drive!

We do have public transport so as long as you work ‘regular hours’ you can get away without a car. I work shifts so would not cope without a car. DH used to get the train, now he is working from home.

I think we would struggle to afford 2 cars but the car we have is very new and not cheap so it’s all about priorities.

Larryyourwaiter · 02/10/2021 19:57

@julieca like I said it’s school hours. I wouldn’t make it on time by the time I could leave.

Fizbosshoes · 02/10/2021 19:57

we have 2 pretty old cars (both over 12 years old)
If I'm honest we dont really need 2 cars. We barely drive either of them during the week but tend to do different things at the same time at the weekend.
Almost all the houses on our road has (at least) 2 cars although not that that has any influence over our decision.

julieca · 02/10/2021 19:53

@Larryyourwaiter an hour on a bus to work is unremarkable if you are too poor to run a car.

julieca · 02/10/2021 19:52

12% of households have two cars.

lachy · 02/10/2021 19:51

We have 2 cars. Mine is the family car and I use it daily on the school run (we're fairly rural - DD's school is 10 miles away)

DH has an old banger, which refuses to conk out and because of his shifts needs his car. He has ocassionally cycled to work, but again, because of shift patterns it's sometimes not feasible and there's no guarantee he'll finish work when he should. (emergency services)

It's not ideal but we do need them both.

Larryyourwaiter · 02/10/2021 19:51

I don’t get that we have one big and one small car. DH regularly uses mine for short journeys, to his mate where parking is difficult.

DH works somewhere with zero public transport and my school hours job wouldn’t work as it would take me over an hour on the bus.

I do have a friend who recently got rid of her second car. She’s moved to wfh and her husband works abroad/wfh so they had stopped using them.

Ednadidit · 02/10/2021 19:43

Ooh, also:

I used to live next door to a couple who each had a Ford Focus. They had almost matching reg plates because they bought them on the same day. That baffled me - surely if you need two cars, you get them to suit different needs, rather than two different colours? 🤷🏻‍♀️