Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think 2 car households are totally normal these days.

166 replies

Karleeb30 · 02/10/2021 18:03

I appreciate not everyone can afford to run 2 cars but it is a necessity in our case.

We live rurally with no public transport links. Dp works unsociable hours, I'm currently off work but have needed it for work previously , just not currently.. We have two dc who both have sen so needed for appointments when dp is at work. I'd also be very isolated without a car living where we do. We have thought about just having one buy it would be a struggle with appointments and no public transport links.

Basically we have dp's 15 year old trusty car he's had forever that he uses for work. He's had it for years. It's not suitable for us as a family as only a 3 door and small and wouldn't be great for dc.

Then we have a 6 year old (that we bought second hand last year ) family car which I use more than him but dp drives too at the weekends. Previously we had an older car as a second car.

It is a struggle to keep both going at times but both are pretty reliable so far (hopefully don't jinx it here) and haven't cost us much other than your average costs for a car.

I have recently received remarks off a family member. Saying we must be rich if we have 2 cars especially if I am not working (which is degrading tbh, people have no right to judge us in our current circumstances and they don't work themselves which is the funniest thing about it so they are very hypocritical.

We are not rich, we get by but living month by month especially down to one wage currently, we do struggle. We don't have any other luxuries!

We are fortunate we can keep 2 cars running because I know not everyone can but like I said we don't have much else in the terms of luxuries.

Aibu to think 2 cars is not a luxury in most cases but a necessity and people should
Keep their beaks out where it's not needed?

We are in that middle between rich and poor where we aren't rich (I wish) and we aren't poor either.

OP posts:
Redwinestillfine · 03/10/2021 08:59

Not really. We are a one car household and I know lots of no car households. We don't live in a city.

JackieWeaverHandforthCouncil · 03/10/2021 08:58

If I want to take my family to visit people or places I don’t want to catch a bus to get to train station, pay £££ get off miles from where I want to be, lug the kids in the rain to a bus or cab from the station to friends house. It’s far more convenient to drive to their door especially as my car is electric and hardly costs anything to charge.

There are also many places in the Home Counties e.g. Epping Forest which have no public transport. Went to the Midlands last weekend to stay with friends. Very easy to chuck our bags in the car and set off.

But I don’t know why I’m bothering to justify my weekend car usage to strangers anyway.

nameswap48 · 03/10/2021 08:55

We haven't been able to be a one car household since we left London. We lived rurally with us both working out of the village, bus service was entirely scrapped. Trains cost £50+ per day (and would need to get to the train). We then moved to a town and hoped to get rid of a car, but kids were placed in schools 4 miles the other side of town so even though I am fully working from home I still need a car to get them to school (bus isn't feasible as it would take too long out of my day and I do need to work, kids too young to go on their own). DH works out of town literally no public transport within a 3 mile radius of his work location (and an additional 20 miles to get there).

Our town has no catchment for schools so very likely to end up miles away from secondary school despite one on our doorstop (severely oversubscribed) so I'm faced with either keeping second car or paying up to £2000 a year to bus both kids to school (yes £2000) and our car is cheaper to run than that- plus three after school activities etc. We might be able to get to a closer school but I won't know until allocated.

We've moved around a lot over the years, and the only place I've lived where public transport could be feasibly relied upon and was affordable was London (it's the only major city I've lived in just to add, I'm hoping other major cities have good transport too!)

vdbfamily · 03/10/2021 08:54

my reasoning for 2nd car is that oldest 2 now wanting to learn to drive and our car is not really suitable so we bought our neighbours old Suzuki for£1000 which is so basic it will be a great learner car.

vdbfamily · 03/10/2021 08:52

We have 3 children, both work and have been married 20 years and live rurally. We bought a second car for first time a couple of weeks ago. This is because we now have an 18 and almost 17 year old. It has been interesting as now he had a car at home, most days my husband nips out in it. Before, if he needed a car urgently he would either run me to work or I would arrange a lift. The kids would know they could not do anywhere to I was home so worked around that with their plans. When DH committed to London from our previous house he cycled to the station. Before that, with 3 small children and me at home, I used to catch the 1 bus an hour to town and pick up car from where he had left it and then collect him later. It is hard to manage with one but we must have saved a fortune and I have definitely seen from last 2 weeks that when it is there, you use it a lot more. Whereas DH used to shop in evenings and order DIY stuff to collect on a Saturday etc, now he nips out each time.

Macncheeseballs · 03/10/2021 08:45

Trains also go to the home counties

JackieWeaverHandforthCouncil · 03/10/2021 08:43

I find the comments that if you live in London you shouldn’t have a car strange. I live in zone 3, many many families have a car. We don’t all live in zone 1 and only stay there walking around museums and Oxford Street.

We do leave London to go to the Home Counties. It’s also quicker to travel from East to West London by car as most tube links take you into the centre and not across so you have to go in and back out and pay £££. We cycle to work and walk around locally but we use the car every weekend.

Macncheeseballs · 03/10/2021 08:41

Iggly, it is for me, I would choose a closer one over a 'better' one any day, the thought of getting kids into a car every morning is hard to fathom

Iggly · 03/10/2021 08:38

@Macncheeseballs

Why do so many choose things like nurseries so far away from their homes, little kids being ferried around every morning in toxic traffic
Maybe they don’t have any decent ones nearby. Surely that’s not hard to fathom
Macncheeseballs · 03/10/2021 08:20

Why do so many choose things like nurseries so far away from their homes, little kids being ferried around every morning in toxic traffic

CounsellorTroi · 03/10/2021 07:46

We managed for years with one car. For a while we were working in adjacent buildings. Then I changed jobs, so after driving to DH’s office I’d catch a bus the rest of the way. It made sense to do it that way as DH had a parking space. Then when MIL died we inherited FIL’s old banger. Having 2 cars made things so much easier especially after my DM went into a care home and I could visit her on the way home from work. We’ve had 2 cars ever since even though we don’t really need 2 as we are both more or less retired.

Mooloolabababy · 02/10/2021 23:58

I'd rather just have one car but dh has to go in to the office once a week (60 odd miles away). We live in the arse end of nowhere and we have one bus running through our village that starts at 8am and finishes at 6pm, it runs every 2 hours and doesn't even take you to the city, you have a choice of 2 local towns, both of which are crap. I have to drive dc to school as too far to walk.

HadEnoughofOtherThreads · 02/10/2021 23:51

Average earner and high earner in London. Had two cars until Summer last year. Now sharing one car. Was both WFH during lockdown. DP back at office 2 days & WFH 3. I’m still WFH school hours. Car used for AM school run unless DP needs it to travel to early meetings. I walk 30 mins or cycle 10 mins for PM school run. DP needs car for evening and weekend commute for another business. Planning to get a 2nd car during the next few weeks. Couldn’t have managed without 2 cars if youngest was still at nursery in an adjacent town. Worked further away then. Started a new job closer to home just before lockdown. Parking restrictions have increased near my office during lockdown so parking near office will be even trickier when I do go into office. Likely to be in office 1-2 days pw. Hybrid working was encouraged for all staff before lockdown.

It’s no one’s business how many cars you have or how you fund them, unless they are paying!

Macncheeseballs · 02/10/2021 23:14

Dalmatian- why does 'working bloody hard', mean you should all have cars?

Fizbosshoes · 02/10/2021 23:03

@julieca

People choose where they live usually. So people are choosing to live somewhere you need to drive. That is fine, but just own it.
Often peoples choices about where they live are dictated by budget. Where I live the main towns have a station with fast trains into London, the surrounding villages are generally significantly cheaper because they don't have a station, or secondary school or multiple shopping facilities . So people priced out of the towns might look to the surrounding villages...but need a car for schools, supermarkets, or getting to the station (if they commute)

These places, by the way are not "very rural" but you actually don't need to be all that rural to find a car essential if there isn't reasonable public transport

ToykotoLosAngeles · 02/10/2021 22:42

Because sometimes when OH is at work with a car, I need to go out and get something in the other car.

That's "driving at the same time". As in, using the cars at the same time. I didn't understand either!

DecadentlyDecisive · 02/10/2021 22:41

@Pixxie7

It’s up to you how you spend your money and people shouldn’t judge but to say 2 cars is a necessity not a luxury is wrong, particularly when you consider that a lot of families can’t afford to eat or heat their homes.
This is tosh - if a couple need a car each to get to work and earn money to pay taxes towards subsidising the poor, then its a necessity.
DecadentlyDecisive · 02/10/2021 22:38

If you don't both drive at the same time why do you need the second car? I don't quite get what you're saying

Because sometimes when OH is at work with a car, I need to go out and get something in the other car.

Or at weekends sometimes we'll go out in one, other times we'll go out in the other - depends where we're going & what we're doing....

At the end of the day, as long as I can afford to tax & insure them (and I can) it doesn't matter if I have 10 cars sat on the drive does it??

BigFatLiar · 02/10/2021 22:26

If you don't live in a town with good public transport then multiple cars would I suspect be the norm, especially if your children can drive.

greenlynx · 02/10/2021 22:22

I can’t understand your problem, you need 2 cars : one for your husband to get to work and one for you to get around with DC. You need them, you can run them, you have space to park them so you have 2 cars. What’s the problem?
Your relative is commenting? It’s nothing to do with cars it’s just because he/she is this sort of person and probably never have to get a SEN child to medical appointments in a bus. You will get rid of one car and he/ she will be arguing that you’ve got too many children and it’s bad for environment or too many bikes or your beds are too big…Ignore.
We have one car because we don’t need two atm.

SuperCaliFragalistic · 02/10/2021 22:20

Look, you don't have to justify your lifestyle choices to anyone but yourself and the typical MN competitive poverty on this thread is tedious. You have 2 cars because you can afford it and it works for your family. Own the decision and stop trying to make out that your circumstances are vastly different to anyone else's.

EmilyEmmabob · 02/10/2021 22:19

2 cars here, 3 including DH's work van. His work doesn't allow passengers in the van and it is on a tracker so he can't use it for the school run. School is close and the DC are in breakfast club but the time it opens and DH's start time are very close so he has to drive them.

My work is too far to walk and I need to be there by 7.30am.

I cannot imagine having to rely on public transport. We've had a lot of bus services cut and no train station near by, even taxis are unreliable here. Everyone has at least one car each here, it's essential because of the lack of childcare provisions and public transport links. Northern town.

HelloDulling · 02/10/2021 22:08

I live in a city, I walk to work, kids walk to school. We have one car, but I cannot think of another family we know with only one car.

Karleeb30 · 02/10/2021 22:01

@MissChanandlerBong81

Also - some households drive two shit cars while some households drive one flashy car, which basically comes to the same thing!
That's true. Neither are particularly flashy 😅 they are reliable cars just not anything top end!
OP posts:
Karleeb30 · 02/10/2021 22:00

Thanks all. I appreciate we are lucky to just about afford 2 cars and I totally get the environmental bit but no choice but to drive here really (not just us, but most people around here). It's very self limiting not being able to drive living here. I have grew up locally and I don't want to move.

When I say there is no public transport there really isn't. I don't think anyone who hasn't lived rurally fully understands how isolating it is. Nearest train station is 20+ miles away. No buses (not even the bleddy school buses pick up secondary kids here and parents have to take them to another Stop or drive them to school). Taxis are ridiculous. Apparently it's £40 to go to the nearest town 8 miles away. Cycling is always an option but dp's shifts would mean cycling at 4am or 10-11pm on dark narrow lanes which he doesn't want to do for safety reasons. I don't have any family around to help with lifts 😒

OP posts: