Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Cultural appropriation...how bad is it?

495 replies

malificent7 · 02/10/2021 10:58

So Rhianna is under fire for braiding white model's hair. What if a black model wanted to straighten and bleach her hair?
I love african wax print fabric but don't want to be accused of cultural appropriation if i wear a bit of it. I also own sari fabric clothes.

Aibu to ask mn who may or may not be from different ethnic backgrounds would they consider Rhianna or my behaviour inappropriate and what constitutes real cultural appropriation?

This is not a racist thread as dd is mixed race.

OP posts:
kinzarose · 03/10/2021 14:34

@Balonzette who is calling for a separation of cultures? I gave my example of the hijab being used as a fashion accessory. It is a religious symbol, which many women in the UK have been discriminated against for. IMO seeing it used as a fashion accessory, with the sole purpose of money making by large fashion designers crosses a line. I'm not saying no one else should wear it, just saying why it can seem triggering. I for one love new cultures and think sharing ideas/ways of life is great. That isn't what is happening here though - someone has introduced a 'new concept', been applauded for it and made a lot of money from it - except it's not new, Muslim women have been wearing it for centuries but have gotten disdain for it.

BoredZelda · 03/10/2021 14:29

Is it the same as an English person wearing clan tartan

No it isn’t.

Balonzette · 03/10/2021 14:24

@kinzarose

Someone up thread said it's mostly 2nd/3rd gen immigrants that get most worked up is right I think, for good reason. When our parents arrived in UK, they had a very demarcated culture from White Brits.The second generation are a mish mash of the cultures, and often get bullied in school for their "foreign" element. Take the hijab for example - I was beaten up as a teen girl, ridiculed and spat at for wearing it. In recent years it has been worn in the fashion industry as an accessory by non Muslims. For me, it being paraded as a mere fashion statement is a bit of a kick in the teeth and almost minimizes my struggle, if that makes sense? To see my bullies oohing and ahhing over a model wearing it because now it's own trend is a very bitter pill to swallow. What I wouldn't have any issue with is a non Muslim wearing it on National Hijab Day (I've seen people here claiming it is CA) as to me that is an act of solidarity, rather than a whimsical fashion move.

At the end of the day people should wear what they want, but should be mindful of the reasons that some others might find it triggering or offensive.

I understand this, but times change and people evolve. It's awful that you were bullied for something that is a part of your culture. But in order for a society to be multicultural, people need to accept that it's not JUST second or third generation people that are a 'mish mash' of cultures. It's the whole of the UK. The country is a mish mash of cultures. Insisting on this new type of segregation is NOT going to help things. It's just to make it worse. If we all share and celebrate and blend our cultures then we end up in a more open and understanding and educated society.
Balonzette · 03/10/2021 14:20

@GoOnDoAnASEyeroll

Great posts (and username), Balonzette!
Thank you GrinGrin
SparryG · 03/10/2021 14:20

@GoOnDoAnASEyeroll

Thank you for this reply it is really insightful.

Covidworries · 03/10/2021 14:11

@NovemberWitch

Exactly very limited experience means you are unable to define and understand the full benefits of BSL. You have been sold the makaton misconception that BSL isnt suitable without having enough knowledge of BSL and exactly why it is the best option to meet all children who need or benefit from sign communication regardless of all and any additional needs

VladmirsPoutine · 03/10/2021 13:57

@kinzarose I agree with you on that. Some of my relatives arrived in the UK with pretty much a backpack, a friend's address and a few hundred pounds. They had sometimes 2 / 3 jobs, worked very long hours in strenuous jobs. Survival was their focus not whether some white women were wearing saris or wax prints.

A lot of our parents had quite precarious status in the UK so were often on their 'best behaviour'. They tried to assimilate and not ruffle too many, if any, feathers. 2nd / 3rd gens give absolutely no fucks and are very vocal about these things - good for them!

kinzarose · 03/10/2021 13:42

Just to add, I have no issue with chefs saying "this is my spin on " but for them to purposely butcher a dish and then claim it is authentic just comes across as I'm eating "foreign muck".

kinzarose · 03/10/2021 13:36

What reaaaally bothers me is chefs making and adding completely non traditional ingredients, whilst claiming it is "authentic". Jamie Oliver is notorious for this. Does anyone remember the chicken rendang debacle on Masterchef? This is exactly what I mean.

NovemberWitch · 03/10/2021 13:35

[quote Cornettoninja]@Covidworries my only experience of Makaton has been in cases where there have been other considerations, although sometimes in conjunction with, hearing loss (blindness, learning difficulties, brain injury). I’m not entirely comfortable in writing it off as ‘not a proper language’ when there are many people for whom it is their only means of communication and they’re unlikely to move onto BSL full time even if they regularly use some BSL in their communication.[/quote]
That’s my only experience of Makaton as well, being used by children with learning difficulties who are unlikely to be able to access BSL.
It worked as a means of communication for them, along with visual aids and other support materials.

kinzarose · 03/10/2021 13:33

Someone up thread said it's mostly 2nd/3rd gen immigrants that get most worked up is right I think, for good reason.
When our parents arrived in UK, they had a very demarcated culture from White Brits.The second generation are a mish mash of the cultures, and often get bullied in school for their "foreign" element. Take the hijab for example - I was beaten up as a teen girl, ridiculed and spat at for wearing it. In recent years it has been worn in the fashion industry as an accessory by non Muslims. For me, it being paraded as a mere fashion statement is a bit of a kick in the teeth and almost minimizes my struggle, if that makes sense? To see my bullies oohing and ahhing over a model wearing it because now it's own trend is a very bitter pill to swallow.
What I wouldn't have any issue with is a non Muslim wearing it on National Hijab Day (I've seen people here claiming it is CA) as to me that is an act of solidarity, rather than a whimsical fashion move.

At the end of the day people should wear what they want, but should be mindful of the reasons that some others might find it triggering or offensive.

Covidworries · 03/10/2021 13:19

I think BSL should be used to optimise the best outcomes for all young people. Those already started on makaton should recieve skilled support to give them the best outcomes and develop their skills in an individual appropriate way which isnt limited by makaton alone.

Cornettoninja · 03/10/2021 12:46

So you don’t think makaton has any place at all @Covidworries?

Aria999 · 03/10/2021 12:13

@Balonzette

I have a beautiful sari my sister bought me when she spent a year living in Nepal. I have never dared wear it. (None of us has any relevant heritage). It makes me sad that things are this way these days.

Covidworries · 03/10/2021 12:13

BSL can be used extremely effectively with all those you mention.

I write as someone with extensive knowedge of BSL, makaton, signalong and supporting people with a variermty of needs

NumberNineTwo · 03/10/2021 12:12

Supporting black led buisnesses is not cultural appropriation
What about if the product they sell is something that is part of black culture and/or from a country where the people are black? Is it ok for white people to buy and use that product? Eg the aforementioned Nigerian clothes being sold in the UK?

Cornettoninja · 03/10/2021 12:09

@Covidworries my only experience of Makaton has been in cases where there have been other considerations, although sometimes in conjunction with, hearing loss (blindness, learning difficulties, brain injury). I’m not entirely comfortable in writing it off as ‘not a proper language’ when there are many people for whom it is their only means of communication and they’re unlikely to move onto BSL full time even if they regularly use some BSL in their communication.

Covidworries · 03/10/2021 11:58

@Carnayshun
This is always the responce discussions about cultural appropriation get.

Supporting black led buisnesses is not cultural appropriation. Appropriation is setting up a white led buisness selling a black cultural product at substandard quality and therefore causing quality black led provision to flounder just because you can

Covidworries · 03/10/2021 11:45

Because BSL would also help them. Makaton isnt a language so has a limit. Often children get to the point where makaton isnt enough and then are told to move onto BSL but its harder to learn BSL if picked up so many mistakes through makaton. So why not just promote good quality BSL support for all.

BSL like all languages has regional variations. That isnt the issue here.

BSL and all sign languages across the world was banned by oralist movement. with deaf people being terrible punished for using signs. A hearing oralist who was anti BSL set up makaton using signs from a language she didnt agree with and from a community she had no respect for. Believing as a hearing person she could cherry pick aspects of this language to make it more like english and therefore superior.

Tyrantosaurus · 03/10/2021 11:45

I think hair braiding is a bit tricky, just because black women directly face discrimination for their hair, so for someone white to have that hairstyle, when they can do so without the same judgements, is problematic.

Ah but white people who were to braid or lox their hair do face judgements because it's associated with black peoples and negative stereotypes e.g. 'ghetto' etc.

Although you're right they wouldn't be discriminated for it. But white people doing things like that will get frowned upon by both black and white people in response.

People always use the kardashians as an example of white privilege and appropriation blah but you're average Dave walking down the high street with locs is a different matter

Carnayshun · 03/10/2021 11:40

I buy clothes by Kemi Telford because I love them
I notice the newly released autumn collection is mostly modelled by a white lady. It’s ridiculous to suggest that a black-owned business should refuse to sell their products to 95% of women in the UK because they’re not of African heritage.

beastlyslumber · 03/10/2021 11:23

@Covidworries

Makaton isnt a language, it has however taken the signs from BSL and many many people dont think there is a difference.

So using the signtaken from BSL but passed on wrong because the creator learnt from a book and misunderstood the diagram is not the same as someone speaking spanish or English which are 2 seperate languages. Its more like someone taking words from English but teaching the wrong pronounciation or spelling. When someone challenges this they make excuses that this spelling is easier so that why its used. Would you really think its acceptable for your child to be told off for spelling cat CAT because the teacher thinks it shoult be KAT as that is easier for them

I know it's not a language. But it's very, very useful for people in certain situations. Why shouldn't they be allowed to use it if it helps them?

There are plenty of versions of English that are not "standard" but are widely spoken and some also have non-standard written versions of the language. Even between the UK and US there are differences in spellings, usage, grammar and vocabulary. I think in any given context we should agree which language or which version of a language we are using and follow those conventions. E.g. in a British school, I would object to children being taught American spelling, or being taught 'Spanglish' as though it's standard English, but that doesn't mean it's wrong in itself for those versions to exist, or wrong for people to be taught them in general.

I don't think people should be told they're using BSL when they're actually using Makaton, and can see how that would piss people off. But tbh I've never known anyone who thought they were the same thing. Surely there's enough information and resources available now that people can work out that there's a lot more than just one sign language or sign system. If they're interested enough to learn Makaton, I would think they'd be able to quickly see that it's not a language like BSL or ASL.

MimosaFields · 03/10/2021 11:17

I buy clothes by Kemi Telford because I love them. I don't want to stop buying clothes with African designs just because I'm white. That would be ridiculous and detrimental to many small businesses

Covidworries · 03/10/2021 11:14

Makaton isnt a language, it has however taken the signs from BSL and many many people dont think there is a difference.

So using the signtaken from BSL but passed on wrong because the creator learnt from a book and misunderstood the diagram is not the same as someone speaking spanish or English which are 2 seperate languages. Its more like someone taking words from English but teaching the wrong pronounciation or spelling. When someone challenges this they make excuses that this spelling is easier so that why its used. Would you really think its acceptable for your child to be told off for spelling cat CAT because the teacher thinks it shoult be KAT as that is easier for them

GoOnDoAnASEyeroll · 03/10/2021 11:08

I agree people shouldn't try to fool others about the extent of their abilities. But if you're in a place (e.g. a little village in the middle of nowhere) where you're the only person who speaks a bit of English, then you'll inevitably be an expert compared to everyone else!

Yes that true (as is your post too). As always, there's always some nuance to these things, depending on the circumstances.