Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Cultural appropriation...how bad is it?

495 replies

malificent7 · 02/10/2021 10:58

So Rhianna is under fire for braiding white model's hair. What if a black model wanted to straighten and bleach her hair?
I love african wax print fabric but don't want to be accused of cultural appropriation if i wear a bit of it. I also own sari fabric clothes.

Aibu to ask mn who may or may not be from different ethnic backgrounds would they consider Rhianna or my behaviour inappropriate and what constitutes real cultural appropriation?

This is not a racist thread as dd is mixed race.

OP posts:
TintinIsBack · 04/10/2021 10:37

It also makes me wonder, can a white british person open a curry house?

Curries are coming from India but no one there eats curries the way they are here.
Curries have been part of the british diet for nearly 2 centuries (first curry house opened mid 1800 if I remember well).

So are they still ethnic foods that only indian/pakistan people can cook? Or are they now part of the british staple diet the same way than fish and chips?

TintinIsBack · 04/10/2021 10:31

So many typos in that last part. I hope you can get what i mean Grin

TintinIsBack · 04/10/2021 10:30

@Covidworries, I can see what you mean.

But the reality is:

  • it's impossible to cook exactely the way you would do it 'at home' in a another country just because the ingredients are all avaialable
  • If you want to 'attract' customers from that country, you will probably also have to adjust the cooking to their tastes too.
So is that still an 'authentic' chinese restaurant?

eg there is a chinese restaurant I really like.
When I go there, the staff is NEVER proposing the little bowls to eat the rice with chopsticks whereas they always give them by default to the chinese looking customers.
There is a menu and it's also vey clear that they have a different 'menu' for the chinese people with things that are not on the 'normal' menu.... I am assuming they get the 'real proper' chinese food when we get the modified chinese food???
If a white person (who might well have lived in china, blablabla) opens a restaurant and delivers the meny esterners get, si that cultural appropriation seeing that its' not the traditional chinese food anyway? Rather it's what british people re ikely to expect and like from the vast choice that chinese food has to offer.

Covidworries · 04/10/2021 10:17

@TheKeatingFive

I have explained and explained about the misuse of our language/culture many , many times with examples.

Going to a chinese meal to an authenyic chinese resturant not apropriation. Opening up a chinese resturant and pretending it authentic when you cant cook chinese food correctly is appropriation

UsedUpUsername · 04/10/2021 09:56

@MarshmallowSwede

I can appreciate people asking about cultural appropriation, but it’s always a conversations that will go around in circles.

White people are always going to find a way to justify it, so I don’t even understand what any person of colour even has the patience to try to educate. I find it exhausting myself… if you all had the same energy to help improve things for WOC and improve racism as you did to be outraged that you can’t just steal things and demand no one use “Karen” or “cool girl” then intersectional feminism would be in a much better state. You’re extremely tiresome and I’m sure your “black friends” think so as well.

This is exhausting.

Perhaps you should stop trying to ‘educate’ people.

I mostly see those braids in the context of MMA fighters, loads of whom are not even Westerners. This novel use makes sense to me, harder for your opponent to grab and keeps them out of your face/eyes.

mustlovegin · 04/10/2021 09:47

demand no one use “Karen” or “cool girl”

Usually people will react first (and more strongly?) to what impacts them directly. It's human nature.

In some circles the concepts of intersectionality, 'allies' etc maybe commonplace and part of an ideological construct, but most don't adhere to these IRL (though they may feel and express empathy obviously)

MarshmallowSwede · 04/10/2021 09:36

I can appreciate people asking about cultural appropriation, but it’s always a conversations that will go around in circles.

White people are always going to find a way to justify it, so I don’t even understand what any person of colour even has the patience to try to educate. I find it exhausting myself… if you all had the same energy to help improve things for WOC and improve racism as you did to be outraged that you can’t just steal things and demand no one use “Karen” or “cool girl” then intersectional feminism would be in a much better state. You’re extremely tiresome and I’m sure your “black friends” think so as well.

mustlovegin · 04/10/2021 09:34

Dying and straightening our hair is not an important part of white culture

Hair styling is an important element in every culture

MarshmallowSwede · 04/10/2021 09:32

As a Swede.. I’ve never seen anyone mention the fact that Vikings braided their hair whenever the topic of white people braiding has come up unless it’s in an extremely disingenuous way.

Please keep the Vikings out of this and use your own ancestors to justify your cultural appropriation.

You aren’t copying Viking or Scandinavian braiding… people are copying the hairstyles of black women and this is about the specific styles of black women being copied. And anyone acting like “oh these are just viking braids” is a liar.

TheKeatingFive · 04/10/2021 08:23

Dress how you like, celebrate what you like and eat what you like but always treat people with respect.

Yes that gets to the heart of it

thepastisanothercountry · 04/10/2021 08:21

I think the more cultures are mixed the more cultural approtiation will go on. Its not just about clothes and appearance. We think nothing of going out for a curry or a Chinese. i think nothing of sending Eid gifts and presents to my neighbours. I've worn Asian clothes to Asian weddings and both me and DP speak enough Urdu to greet people - DP can even have a short conversation.

DD and DS both celebrate Eid and Dawaili with friends.

We don't think anything of it if people of other cultures wear Western dress or eat fish and chips - do we??

Dress how you like, celebrate what you like and eat what you like but always treat people with respect. We are fortunate enough to live in a society with so many options and opportunities so lets embrace it rather than keep putting barriers in our way all the time

TheKeatingFive · 04/10/2021 08:18

What i do not want is people to misuse our culture

What does this actually mean though?

If you're talking about using someone's culture to make fun of it, then yes everyone agrees with you. That's straightforward racism though, isn't it?

Or do you mean something else?

In terms of the financial gain point, again most issues I've seen that are problematic are mostly about the inherent inequalities of capitalism rather than anything else.

Covidworries · 04/10/2021 08:10

To me its not a contradiction through.

I want to be considered and treated equal, because i am.
I want people to see my culture which is beautiful and interesting and amazing. I want people to see us. I want people to learn about our culture and language in a way that is mutually beneficial.

What i do not want is people to misuse our culture and language to their own gain which further oppresses us and further removes our voice.

TheKeatingFive · 04/10/2021 08:04

There is a real contradiction in wanting an oppressed group to be seen as equal, and not wanting their culture to be seen as interesting or compelling or to have cultural power.

Quite.

Underamour · 04/10/2021 07:59

Among the younger generation it’s just styling though. I’ve seen white girls called out for braids but I’ve seen of black people with straight mohicans , for example, or in fact any hairstyle. It’s called fashion.

TintinIsBack · 04/10/2021 07:56

There is a real contradiction in wanting an oppressed group to be seen as equal, and not wanting their culture to be seen as interesting or compelling or to have cultural power.

👏👏👏

TintinIsBack · 04/10/2021 07:55

@CorianderAndCream

Dying and straightening our hair is not an important part of white culture. It's just fashion whereas braiding, locs etc are culturally significant to other cultures.

So you can't appropriate hair straightening because it has no meaning for us beyond style.

Or it’s just the best way to style that type of hair……
DillonPanthersTexas · 04/10/2021 07:51

*This is the kind of cultural appropriation that should be encouraged imo. Supporting a heritage industry and local craftswomen whilst making something new and different with the fabric. What’s not to like about this?£

Because you just know that if Lallybroch did make her jacket and wore it out there would be a handful of offence takers who will not bother to maybe check the sourcing of the fabric they will just see a white women wearing an African print jacket and scream 'cultural appropriation'. They don't care about the fabric really, they just like the idea of adding another line in their protest credentials CV.

UsedUpUsername · 04/10/2021 07:39

@Lallybroch

I buy African print fabric from a couple who go out to Africa to buy the fabric. They can even show you a photograph of the woman who dyed and printed it. I feel by buying the fabric it supports the heritage and protects the income of those people involved. As someone who loves textiles in all shapes and colours I want to celebrate the skill of the artist who designed and make this fabric.As a woman (who happens to be white) I want to use this fabric to make myself a jacket but does this now mean I am culturally appropriating this fabric?
This is the kind of cultural appropriation that should be encouraged imo. Supporting a heritage industry and local craftswomen whilst making something new and different with the fabric. What’s not to like about this?
Covidworries · 04/10/2021 07:12

Here is a different example.

If you require medical treatment in the UK and you dont know English an interpreter is called. If you are deaf BSL user this is also meant to happen but too often does not. A lovely lady i know died last yr because the hospital did not provide an interpreter and the extend of the problem wasnt know in time.
BSL uers continue to be oppressed and not provided with language in the same way as other non English or English users are.
Families of deaf children are discouraged from this language still. Those who choose BSL have to find and fund these courses them selves and are continually questioned on why they are using BSL. Despite the researched and acknowledged benefits and need for sign languages.
Meanwhile children born hearing (with and without other needs) are celebrated for learning to sign.
Baby sign, makaton, signalong, sign songs, sign for dementia etc etc is seen as amazing while the native language users are still oppressed.
Deaf led/fluent BSL users companies, courses and resources are pushed aside by items run by those with little to no understanding.
When these novices are challenged over these courses/materials other novices rush to their defense with comments like

They are amazing ive learnt so much
Why wouldnt you want people to learn sign
They are only trying to help
Deaf people/BSL users can set up if they want
Just be grateful someone is using sign
Thats different as the person is a baby/old/disabled etc so cant learn BSL Hmm

There are courses advertised on social media every day. Often these courses even have a lovely picture of someone doing a sign - a sign that isnt even a real sign for anything. The courses mislead participants in what that course is. Meaning too often people end up paying money for a cpurse which at best isnt recognised and at worst will teach wrong. This is not fair on authentic courses, it is not fair on BSL langauge users and it is not fair on the poor person who has speant time and money on it.

There are people posting videos 'teaching signs' which they have learnt from a book or google. There was a video last yr which was a mix of BSL, ASL and non signs. Lots of non signers raving about how brilliant it was and how much they had learnt. Poster with 1000s of likes etc.
When someone posts explaining the mistakes and with linls to genuine resources. They are jumped on by supporters. Private message politely explaining and with info on where they can learn are ignored.

Many people learn BSL and it is hoped it will soon be part of the curriculum. The issue isnt people learning/using BSL. The issue is people setting themselves up as an expert, producing a product which a already exists, that theirs is not just substandard but damaging to the language and culture.

Somepeople genuinely make mistakes and are approachable and willing to learn and either step back to promote the expert courses, services, product that already exists. Or of it is a genuinely new and useful concept they will work in collaboration with the language ecperts to ensure that the product is authentic and acurate.

Those who continue to ignore and do their own thing despite it being explained are appropriating.

LobsterNapkin · 04/10/2021 01:09

@CorianderAndCream

Dying and straightening our hair is not an important part of white culture. It's just fashion whereas braiding, locs etc are culturally significant to other cultures.

So you can't appropriate hair straightening because it has no meaning for us beyond style.

Are you sure that we don't? I think that's untrue, there is some real cultural significance around hair in English culrure, as well as other European cultures. Women putting their hair up at a certain age, women having their hair shaved as a way to shame, men joining the military, or the tonsure, wearing long hair in the 60s as a sign of rebellion. All of these are associated with certain hairstyles that have been common and there are some specific European examples too. We also have certain styles associated with European hair customs, from the chignon to ratting.

And what do you mean by "culturally significant" here? I am positive that many cultures that use braiding don't have some sense of it being special beyond what I've described above. They might have different traditions, and ones that reflected hair type and available resources, and their particular history.

But in neither case does that make it inappropriate to have a cultural transfer.

Aria999 · 04/10/2021 00:43

@LobsterNapkin

There is a real contradiction in wanting an oppressed group to be seen as equal, and not wanting their culture to be seen as interesting or compelling or to have cultural power.

This sums it up perfectly.

CorianderAndCream · 04/10/2021 00:11

Dying and straightening our hair is not an important part of white culture. It's just fashion whereas braiding, locs etc are culturally significant to other cultures.

So you can't appropriate hair straightening because it has no meaning for us beyond style.

LobsterNapkin · 04/10/2021 00:11

[quote Covidworries]@PickUpAPepper

Well they could but would you be able to understand them?

Also English language users havent been punished or had their language banned to my knowledge. Many other languages have been oppressed by English so sadly English has actually been forced on a lot of us[/quote]
English is a mish-mash of languages, many brought by conquering forces who were imposed their regime on the earlier inhabitants, and ultimately changed their language. Pure language, pure culture, and pure DNA are ideas that properly belong to eugenics apologists, and it's very puzzling that they have gained so much force in the last twenty years.

LobsterNapkin · 04/10/2021 00:06

@mbosnz

Interesting point PickUpAPepper. The Maori language almost died out, due to children being beaten if they used it in schools, their parents being taught that the way of the future was English, so discouraging their children from speaking it at home.

That is the difference between a dominant culture, which takes what it wants, and has little or no respect or care for other cultures, and a non-dominant culture, which is supposed to sit down, put up, and shut up - and of course be terribly flattered if the dominant culture decides that something of its culture is sufficiently worthy that they wish to appropriate it.

There is no such thing as a pure language, and there are always losers/non-dominant cultures in the mix.

That's how language works and that is also how culture works.

Any time a group moves from being seen as somehow lesser, and becomes more accepted, powerful, etc, it will begin to spread its culture to other groups around it quickly. Because it is beginning to influence the shared cultural space.

There is a real contradiction in wanting an oppressed group to be seen as equal, and not wanting their culture to be seen as interesting or compelling or to have cultural power.