Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Cultural appropriation...how bad is it?

495 replies

malificent7 · 02/10/2021 10:58

So Rhianna is under fire for braiding white model's hair. What if a black model wanted to straighten and bleach her hair?
I love african wax print fabric but don't want to be accused of cultural appropriation if i wear a bit of it. I also own sari fabric clothes.

Aibu to ask mn who may or may not be from different ethnic backgrounds would they consider Rhianna or my behaviour inappropriate and what constitutes real cultural appropriation?

This is not a racist thread as dd is mixed race.

OP posts:
Jaxhog · 02/10/2021 12:12

Where do you draw the line though?

Is it ok to 'appropriate' some cultures, but not others?

How about men in drag or using Chinese characters as tattoos if you aren't Chinese? Or making Pizza if you aren't Italian?

Culture also changes and evolves over time. At what point does adopting 'old culture' become cultural appropriation by 'new' generations? Do the rules change if cultures merge?

ElvisPresleyHadABaby · 02/10/2021 12:10

@JesusInTheCabbageVan

Would anyone like to buy a MN 'is this racist?' bingo card from me?

Squares include:

Woke
They shouldn't be so sensitive
They shouldn't be so ungrateful
My friend is black and says it's fine
Whataboutery
White people are victims of racism too

Before I buy, could I just check that mentioning mixed race family members would come under "my friend is black and says it's fine"?
ElvisPresleyHadABaby · 02/10/2021 12:09

@YourFinestPantaloons

I'm also very much in the "just fucking listen" camp. If POC en masse are telling us cultural appropriation is damaging, how about we listen to them? Would that be so hard?
Completely agree.

It's very nuanced, the most we can do is listen. There was a big falling out at DD's school when a white girl in her year got her hair done in cornrows and an extremely dark tan, along with using vernacular most commonly spoken by black and mixed race communities. It was pretty outrageous, but many couldn't see what was wrong with it.

BrimfulOfBaba · 02/10/2021 12:09

@2389Champ yes, I think using a crucifix as a meaningless fashion accessory would be appropriation. Cultural appropriation is all about co opting symbols, styles and practices to appear fashionable or knowledgeable without actually paying respect to the appropriate communities.

Chickenkatsu · 02/10/2021 12:06

I think that its gone a bit far, I don't see why Chinese people can't sell bubble tea:

www.reddit.com/r/PublicFreakout/comments/pt1tix/black_woman_accuses_a_bubble_tea_shop_of_stealing/?utm_medium=android_app&utm_source=share

Namenic · 02/10/2021 12:05

It depends on the context. If unsure, best to check. In some cases (eg weddings), it is encouraged for people not of that culture to wear the culture’s traditional dress - but it might not be like that for all people in a minority culture - I’m sure people wouldn’t mind being asked if it is appropriate. I don’t get offended unless someone is intentionally making fun of my culture, but I know relatives who are more touchy.

BrimfulOfBaba · 02/10/2021 12:05

@Funnylittlefloozie your example is clearly not cultural appropriation. This whole thread is full of people who can't understand the difference between appreciation and appropriation and seem to want to be indignant about it.

2389Champ · 02/10/2021 12:03

@Funnylittlefloozie

Most accusations of "cultural appropriation" are basically total bollocks. Its really not a thing in normal life. My white English mother used to wear a sari when she visited my Indian father's relatives. Thats not CA.

Cultural Appropriation is a nasty woke version of 'stay in your lane'.

What a very wise comment - absolutely spot on.

If we go down the road of, ‘white people can only wear this, POC can only dress this way’ we have done a full circle and returned to the dreadful days of segregation/apartheid.

BrimfulOfBaba · 02/10/2021 12:00

A reminder that if you think having a mixed race child means you are automatically not racist, or that if you think ethnic minorities asking for some respect is being 'woke'...

You have some problems.

JesusInTheCabbageVan · 02/10/2021 11:59

Would anyone like to buy a MN 'is this racist?' bingo card from me?

Squares include:

Woke
They shouldn't be so sensitive
They shouldn't be so ungrateful
My friend is black and says it's fine
Whataboutery
White people are victims of racism too

inmyslippers · 02/10/2021 11:59

I can't get mad at someone wearing braids. Surely that's appreciation? As for African wax fabric as long as it's bought from an African tailor I don't see the problem.

JudgeJ · 02/10/2021 11:57

@Loveshelly

Is it the same as an English person wearing clan tartan. Because i have done that and not thought twice about it
I've worn lots of things in my 73 years that I'm sure could be said to be from other cultures and I couldn't care less! In no instance has there been any form of 'mockery' but I'm sure that the forensic offence seekers would find something! Tough.
maddening · 02/10/2021 11:57

I don't think that Africa is the only origin of braiding hair.

Funnylittlefloozie · 02/10/2021 11:56

Most accusations of "cultural appropriation" are basically total bollocks. Its really not a thing in normal life. My white English mother used to wear a sari when she visited my Indian father's relatives. Thats not CA.

Cultural Appropriation is a nasty woke version of 'stay in your lane'.

2389Champ · 02/10/2021 11:54

Couldn’t you use the same argument and say it’s offensive by those that wear massive crucifixes as a fashion statement even though they’re not practising Christians? Surely that’s appropriation too?

I was brought up with the expression, “imitation is the sincerest form of flattery” Maybe the fact that styles are copied by all cultures is a positive thing?
I have no dog in this fight, just interested in where the line could be drawn.

sst1234 · 02/10/2021 11:52

@NovemberWitch

Are you a spokesperson for traditional cultures? If so, which ones?

sst1234 · 02/10/2021 11:50

OP, the fact that you even had to justify your point by adding that you daughter is mixed race says a lot. It is telling off how crazy the woke mob are. And to be honest it’s not even minority communities who complain about their cultural aspects being adopted by others, their is actually some pride in other people adopting them. It’s actually white savior syndrome which perpetuates these ridiculous notions such as cultural appropriation. Absolute madness.

CamillaRose · 02/10/2021 11:46

There are black-owned British companies who sell African wax print fabric clothes. They’d be screwed if only black women bought their clothes because their market would only be 1-2% of the population. And if you exclude black women not of African heritage their market would be even smaller! They’re happy to sell their clothes to white women and frequently post photos of white women wearing their clothes. So I don’t think cultural appropriation is an issue here. Especially because the fabric is manufactured in the Netherlands in the first place before it’s shipped to Africa!

NovemberWitch · 02/10/2021 11:46

@YourFinestPantaloons

So Rhianna is under fire for braiding white model's hair. What if a black model wanted to straighten and bleach her hair?

From what I understand (I am not a WOC but my DC are mixed race so I do try and keep abreast of things like cultural appropriation) - the oppressors (in this case, white people) should not appropriate the oppressed (in this case, POC) because it just perpetuates and increases the oppression issue. Whereas there will be no real harm when done the other way round. Also, blond hair is not a key part of a culture. most white women with blonde hair have that colour because they've dyed it

But there’s harm when done the other way round as well. Traditional cultures are losing their identifying markers, skills, arts, languages, and defining characteristics as they adopt a mishmash of stuff from cultures not their own.
VladmirsPoutine · 02/10/2021 11:46

What if a black model wanted to straighten and bleach her hair?

This is a redundant argument because for centuries Black women have been told their natural hair is untidy, unprofessional and ugly thus have been conditioned to relax it with perms, straighten it etc from an early age. White women haven't faced such criticism about their hair. A lot of Black women wear wigs, weaves and do all manner of other things to 'tame' their natural hair.

Rihanna isn't the first and the Kardashians basically make their living out of pulling stunts like this.

Noeuf · 02/10/2021 11:45

My understanding is that if you are using something that has caused hurt or holds cultural/spiritual/religious significance as fashion it’s not on. So hair styles for example - white women can choose to have braids whenever but black women have used them to control natural hair which has been traditionally treated as undesirable. It makes sense to me not to tread where I’m not sure of the ground.

JesusInTheCabbageVan · 02/10/2021 11:45

@YourFinestPantaloons

I'm also very much in the "just fucking listen" camp. If POC en masse are telling us cultural appropriation is damaging, how about we listen to them? Would that be so hard?
Nailed it.
BrimfulOfBaba · 02/10/2021 11:42

@vivainsomnia Well isn't it good to seek a diversity of opinion? Not all black/indian/native American people etc have the same opinions as each other. Make diverse connections, read up about things, and use sound judgement.

MarshmallowSwede · 02/10/2021 11:41

I think their issue is that whenever black women do something with their hair it is called ugly or seen as “less than”, but once white women start doing it then it’s acceptable. That’s their issue.

I have some very close friends who are black American women that I met when I studied abroad in the states, and according to them their issue is mainly with things that they do being called “ghetto” or seen as trashy but as soon as white women appropriate it, then it’s somehow acceptable.

You have to decide for yourself if you want to wear it and risk being called out for cultural appropriation.

I wouldn’t wear the dress of another culture personally, mainly because I think when white people wear distinctly cultural dress from POC it looks ridiculous and like you’re trying a bit too hard to appear “cool”.

Also- having mixed race children does not mean that you can’t be racist or engage in questionable behaviour. Want to point that out because people for some reason think that having sex with people of colour and having children with one automatically gives them a pass to do certain things. No it doesn’t. If anything, you should be especially careful so as not to engage in these behaviors considering you’re raising a person of colour.

I’m not saying you’re racist OP. Only that people often say this as a disclaimer and as a pass.

I think if you want to braid your hair then fine and wear what you want. But be prepared that there are going to be people who do find it offensive.

It seems to be more of an issue in America as they have an especially brutal history with race. So I think it’s also important to keep that in mind too. Is this from the perspective of black American women? Then they have a point.. as they had laws about how they could wear their hair and being ridiculed about their hair etc.

Not saying it doenst happen in Europe, but black Americans have had in my opinion a much more brutal and insidiously racist nation to deal with than European racist.

Europeans are definitely racist… but we never had Jim Crow, the KKK, or laws telling black women that they either could not show their hair (tignon laws) or how they could wear their hair.

But it’s best that if we look at this from the perspective of black women to understand that it’s about that whenever they wear something it’s deemed bad.. until white women do it.

So I assume this is what it’s about. In general, when a WOC tells me something is offensive I tend to believe them. For various reasons I wouldn’t know all the nuance of why cultural appropriation bothers them, but I would assume enough bad history is behind it to just not do the offensive behaviour.

Seems much easier to me at least.

DillonPanthersTexas · 02/10/2021 11:41

ComtesseDeSpair

Interesting. Before I met her my wife spent time working in Senegal. She immersed herself in the culture, could speak passable Wolof and came to have a deep understanding of the traditions and culture of the Wolof people. We still visit the country as she has friends there. She started to include certain fabric prints as part of her wardrobe when living there. Back in the UK she still occasionally sports 'funky' prints that were gifted to her by her Senegalese friends. She is white Irish. She has been criticized by some (white people) in the past for cultural appropriation despite I imagine her understanding of the significance of what she is wearing far surpassing that of the supposedly offended person. Either way she is not going to stop wearing such items anytime soon, and why should she?