Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Cultural appropriation...how bad is it?

495 replies

malificent7 · 02/10/2021 10:58

So Rhianna is under fire for braiding white model's hair. What if a black model wanted to straighten and bleach her hair?
I love african wax print fabric but don't want to be accused of cultural appropriation if i wear a bit of it. I also own sari fabric clothes.

Aibu to ask mn who may or may not be from different ethnic backgrounds would they consider Rhianna or my behaviour inappropriate and what constitutes real cultural appropriation?

This is not a racist thread as dd is mixed race.

OP posts:
Ibelieveinghosts · 02/10/2021 14:05

[quote BrimfulOfBaba]@Ibelieveinghosts it absolutely isn't, all you need to do is do a bit of research and speak to lots of different types of people. If you are determined to believe otherwise, that's a different matter.[/quote]
Well that’s your opinion if you are absolutely intent on thinking that way, go ahead! But assimilation of different aspects of one culture into another is as old as humanity, it is what has helped it progress.

Different things mean different things to different cultures. Are you so irate about say christianity appropriating gods of one culture and turning them into demons? Have you tackled the Vatican about that? What about drag artists appropriating women’s clothes.

Do you get upset of someone wears a crucifix which isn’t a Tau cross (being an actual representation of the most likely cross of crucifixion) what is the Calvary cross appropriating.

As soon as someone says you can’t wear that they are saying “you’re not one of us” immediate division.

Howareyouflower · 02/10/2021 14:05

I think African wax fabrics are Dutch...

CamillaRose · 02/10/2021 14:05

This is from the same school of thought that posits Yorkshire tea is grown in Yorkshire

www.vlisco.com/about/about-vlisco/

Inform yourself. It’s literally an Indonesian print technique designed and manufactured in the Netherlands and shipped primarily to Africa.

Milkbottlelegs · 02/10/2021 13:59

I can absolutely see why POC are infuriated that something with such significance to them holds no meaning to other people is being used in the height of fashion.

Really? There are plenty of POC on the beaches of Spain happy to charge (mainly) white girls to braid their hair.

VladmirsPoutine · 02/10/2021 13:56

In that case black people should probably stop wearing African wax prints because they’re designed and made by white people in the Netherlands.

This is from the same school of thought that posits Yorkshire tea is grown in Yorkshire.

BeautifulandWilfulandDead · 02/10/2021 13:55

@YourFinestPantaloons

I'm also very much in the "just fucking listen" camp. If POC en masse are telling us cultural appropriation is damaging, how about we listen to them? Would that be so hard?
Completely agree with this. It's mot my job, as a white woman, to decide what should and should not be offensive to a POC. Just as it would be inappropriate for a man to dictate to me what behaviour I should or should not judge to be misogynistic.
BrimfulOfBaba · 02/10/2021 13:54

@worriedatthemoment again, not what I said.

If someone makes a living by taking something from a culture without recognising its history, that's not great. If they do recognise its history, then great.

DecadentlyDecisive · 02/10/2021 13:54

@Biker47

Wear what you want to, do your hair how you want to, eat the food that you want to, do the hobbies you want to; and if anyone tells you any different or that you shouldn't be doing them for some spurious reaching reason, tell them to fuck off and mind their own businesses.
Spot on.

And this is what most people do in real life. It's only when the media wakes up & wants to do a bit of stirring that they roll a story about it....

StateOccasion · 02/10/2021 13:53

According to some posters on here it seems only white people do wrong - everyone else can wear/do whatever they like.

BrimfulOfBaba · 02/10/2021 13:53

@Milkbottlelegs that's not what I said - do you often jump to conclusions without considering nuance?

VladmirsPoutine · 02/10/2021 13:53

Some extremely dodgy history here.

worriedatthemoment · 02/10/2021 13:52

@Milkbottlelegs well my yoga tecaher is black so according to that poster she also shouldn't teach it either as not her culture

bushhbb · 02/10/2021 13:52

@YourFinestPantaloons

I'm also very much in the "just fucking listen" camp. If POC en masse are telling us cultural appropriation is damaging, how about we listen to them? Would that be so hard?

Well not also POC agree. My family is half from Nigeria and people over there are more than flattered if you embrace our culture with clothes, food etc.

It's not a black and white issue, if you'll excuse the pun

I personally find it depends on the situation but generally partaking in others culture is fine, it's not a threat to my identity.

DecadentlyDecisive · 02/10/2021 13:51

@Funnylittlefloozie

Most accusations of "cultural appropriation" are basically total bollocks. Its really not a thing in normal life. My white English mother used to wear a sari when she visited my Indian father's relatives. Thats not CA.

Cultural Appropriation is a nasty woke version of 'stay in your lane'.

Exactly.

Another stick for the perpetually outraged to beat us with....

worriedatthemoment · 02/10/2021 13:51

@PrincessNutella why ? Some have made valid points ,
What gets me is the white people who try and tell black people etc that they should be offended by something

Milkbottlelegs · 02/10/2021 13:49

See white women positing themselves as yoga experts without acknowledging the origins and gravity of the practice.

So white women can’t be yoga teachers now?

PrincessNutella · 02/10/2021 13:48

Oh, the touchingly ignorant racism of the British pops up its head...

worriedatthemoment · 02/10/2021 13:48

Also not all black people are if african origin etc and even within that there will be many cultures as such

worriedatthemoment · 02/10/2021 13:47

But Rhianna hasn't offended all people has she , black people have different opinions on things as well
Some will see it as one things and others not bothered, why do so many think they can tell others what they should think

CamillaRose · 02/10/2021 13:44

White woman wearing “funky” African tribal print because she personally thinks it looks good
In that case black people should probably stop wearing African wax prints because they’re designed and made by white people in the Netherlands.

Quickchangeartiste · 02/10/2021 13:44

@Loveshelly

Is it the same as an English person wearing clan tartan. Because i have done that and not thought twice about it
I dare say some of my fellow Scots could get themselves in a twist about it, but the truth is that clan tartans are a recent and manufactured thing - and new tartans are ‘designed’ on a fairly regular basis.

The wild highlanders of old wore clothes dyed with whatever grew around them and no way did they weave them into symmetrical checks.

I had English friends at my wedding ( a few decades ago now) who wore kilts and I though it was fun - we took the piss - but it was also a nice gesture. Any man who is willing to wear a kilt for a friend is fine by me.

Couchbettato · 02/10/2021 13:41

@maddening

I don't think that Africa is the only origin of braiding hair.
It's not, no.

But slaves used to braid their hair to signify that they were planning to escape. Sometimes intricate braids would be weft in to show the routes they had planned, so other slaves knew.

It was a tool borne of oppression.

I can absolutely see why POC are infuriated that something with such significance to them holds no meaning to other people is being used in the height of fashion.

I also, probably still naively think... It's just hair.

It doesn't have to mean something to every one, and it's not for one group of people to police what other people do unless it infringes on their rights.

But it is easy for me to say that as I have never been in a situation with that kind of oppression.

BeenThruMoreThanALilBit · 02/10/2021 13:29

Why can’t people just use their brains?

Cornrows on white models by white designer to help sell clothes = cultural appropriation

Cornrows on white models by black designer to help sell clothes = whatever, they look stupid but if you’re the model you’re hardly going to argue with Rihanna about it. Everyone else: if you’re not black (even if you are), just listen to the discussion and see how nuanced it is

White woman who’s never worn a sari before, wearing one to Sikh friend’s wedding = dressing up in a costume rather than wearing your own clothes, but in a basically inoffensive way

White woman wearing “funky” African tribal print because she personally thinks it looks good = depends what you know. If nothing, it’s idiotic and open to ridicule, but the worst of it is ignorance

Anyone from any culture wearing/dancing/saying anything that’s not theirs IN ORDER TO MAKE MONEY OR GAIN INFLUENCE BY VIRTUE OF SIGNALLING AFFINITY WITH THAT CULTURE = cultural appropriation which, even before it was commonly called that, was unacceptable. So, yes, looking at Nike et al.

thecatsthecats · 02/10/2021 13:27

@YourFinestPantaloons

I'm also very much in the "just fucking listen" camp. If POC en masse are telling us cultural appropriation is damaging, how about we listen to them? Would that be so hard?
To be absolutely clear, I'm not saying that in this instance listening to the victims is wrong.

But it is entirely illogical that a victim group automatically possesses the answers to resolving the situation. Especially since there is no such thing as a uniform POC stance on cultural appropriation.

In my opinion, it's not going to help literally anyone to be told they're doing a wrong and bad thing when they had no intent, and not even everyone agrees they did a bad thing. It's all very well sneering at "white fragility", but if you want to solve the problem, the answer isn't making people who have no bad intention feeling defensive. It turns people who weren't the problem into part of the problem.

The girl who copies Beyoncé's braids because she worships her is not the boss who tells someone their braids are inappropriate.

SammyScrounge · 02/10/2021 13:25

[quote Travelledtheworld]@Loveshelly I believe anyone can wear Royal Stewart but otherwise you should wear your Clan tartan, IF you are Scottish.
Not getting into the cultural Appropriation debate though.[/quote]
My local shopkeeper has a son who is intensely proud of being both a Scot and a Hindu. The family was going south to a wedding and he decided to wear traditional
Highland dress :the kilt, the black dress jacket with the silver buttons, the knee socks...he cut a fine figure in his 8 yards of tartan!
He is happy to be Scottish, happy to be Hindu.There is no question of cultural appropriation here. And if we try, he is the future.