Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Cultural appropriation...how bad is it?

495 replies

malificent7 · 02/10/2021 10:58

So Rhianna is under fire for braiding white model's hair. What if a black model wanted to straighten and bleach her hair?
I love african wax print fabric but don't want to be accused of cultural appropriation if i wear a bit of it. I also own sari fabric clothes.

Aibu to ask mn who may or may not be from different ethnic backgrounds would they consider Rhianna or my behaviour inappropriate and what constitutes real cultural appropriation?

This is not a racist thread as dd is mixed race.

OP posts:
DriftingBlue · 02/10/2021 20:57

I think the world was on track to be a much kinder place during the melting pot years. There was a long way to go obviously, but the blending of cultures helps bind us together.

That said, people are obviously bothered by behavior that has been classified as cultural appropriation, so I try to be careful to not engage in any behavior that would cause offense. While I find the current approach somewhat flawed, I can understand how people have come to this stance and I will respect that.

TintinIsBack · 02/10/2021 20:57

@YourFinestPantaloons

I'm also very much in the "just fucking listen" camp. If POC en masse are telling us cultural appropriation is damaging, how about we listen to them? Would that be so hard?
It would be easy if the message was aways the same.

So we have braided. hair being a No-No but wearing the traditional Japanese outfit is OK according to Japanese people who are actually happy to see their traditional outfit worn by others.

Then you had the fact that people have travelled. So I spent all my childhood overseas, dressed ‘like the locals’ because I saw myself as one of them. But according to most people in the U.K. that would be cultural appropriation regardless of my background, life experience etc…

We’ve had people who use sunbeds and that’s ok. But if you use a subbed and your skin gets naturally darker then it’s cultural appropriation.

Tbh no wonder people are confused.

wombatspoopcubes · 02/10/2021 20:47

brill.com/view/book/edcoll/9789004380172/BP000005.xml

But if you read here the african wax prints have dutch/ indonesian heritage. So is that offensive for javanese if africans keep wearing wax printed clothes?

Or are we maybe a bigger melting pot than we realise?

MiddlesexGirl · 02/10/2021 20:46

Yes. Obviously I wouldn’t be making money but it’s really never been acceptable in my life time (if ever) for white people to braid their hair in black styles.

I've never noticed it being a problem here. Less prevalent than a few years ago but plenty of white women and girls had their hair braided or with cornrows and I never heard any negative comments.

MarineBlue33 · 02/10/2021 20:42

@Blackredblack your post shows you clearly do not understand what cultural appropriation is.
Read the first page of this thread.

usernamechanger123 · 02/10/2021 20:41

I'm a WOC.

I find that around me it's white people, so called allies, who create a fuss around cultural appropriation and who are indignant on our behalf, when most of my poc friends and family couldn't care less. I find this insulting and infantilising tbh. If we care enough we can say it for ourselves.

My race is a part of who I am, but it's not the only thing that defines me.

Iamnotminterested · 02/10/2021 20:36

@VladmirsPoutine

My 17 year-old daughter was aghast. We guessed he was actually Lee from Salford.

Great Username BTW.

SparryG · 02/10/2021 20:35

Cultural appropriation isn't even a thing for African people....or at least african people i have spoken to....they laughed at it being nonsense. But to black Americans and black British its a thing. Go figure.....

DingleyDel · 02/10/2021 20:28

Do you really think black women would be looking at you seeing appropriation rather than just someone doing a sensible style for their hair type?

Yes. Obviously I wouldn’t be making money but it’s really never been acceptable in my life time (if ever) for white people to braid their hair in black styles.

Siameasy · 02/10/2021 20:28

[quote GoOnDoAnASEyeroll]@beastlyslumber You reminded me of Chelsea handler who said something similar to 50 cents. I had to look it up to confirm because I don't pay much attention to social media and entertainers. Here's the link.

Interestingly, something she said about 50cents "influencing and entire swath of people" reminded me of something someone said on the feminism sex and gender board about Kemi Badenoch influencing people. I think some of these people sing from the same hymnsheet.

www.themix.net/2020/10/chelsea-handler-launches-racist-attack-on-50-cent-over-trump-support-i-had-to-remind-him-hes-black/[/quote]
God there’s a lot about that I dislike. The arrogance of CH thinking she knows better than him and can tell him what to think.

UsedUpUsername · 02/10/2021 20:25

@Siameasy

I’ve often wondered if it is considered inappropriate by the online thought police to wear a headscarf as I have shit hair and in any case, I think they look elegant.
Westerners used to wear headscarves, you can see this in a lot of black and white movies
TheCountessofFitzdotterel · 02/10/2021 20:23

@DingleyDel

I mean it’s not that hard for white people to just not wear their hair in braids is it? I have incredibly frizzy hair and it would solve a multitude of problems for me but I’d never consider it because lots of black people find it offensive for white people to braid their hair, end of argument. Even worse when people are profiting off it, blackfishing is a big thing.

I think it’s harder to define cultural appropriation when people are actually from the culture they are supposed to be appropriating. In this case obviously Rihanna is a black woman so surely it’s up to her (or more likely her management) how her models appear. I also remember reading a ridiculous article (in a well known publication) about how Ed Sheehan was ‘appropriating’ Irish music…his father is Irish! Is he not allowed a homage?

Your not braiding your hair if it would genuinely ‘solve a multitude of problems’ for you just shows how bonkers the whole thing has become.

Do you really think black women would be looking at you seeing appropriation rather than just someone doing a sensible style for their hair type? It’s not like you would be making money out of or disrespecting their style.

GoOnDoAnASEyeroll · 02/10/2021 20:23

It was disgusting. Know your place black man and do what is expected of you. This is what some black people are also perpetuating. But it's others who need healing. Couldn't be funnier.

beastlyslumber · 02/10/2021 20:21

@GoOnDoAnASEyeroll OMG imagine saying "I had to remind him he's black" about a black person and thinking you're the anti-racist.

Unbelievable.

DillonPanthersTexas · 02/10/2021 20:17

I just meant don't buy it from Primark..

Which is all great but it is becoming increasingly evident some people will just make a lazy judgement call in their rush to seek offence on someone else's behalf. My Ashanti print shirt was gifted to me by my Ashanti coworkers, I like to think I have a better understanding of Ghanian culture then most. But that does not matter does it, for some, I'm a white dude in a West African print shirt taking the piss. Do you honestly think any nuance or line of enquiry would be opened to better understand why I was wearing that shirt. Of course not, I must have just blindly picked it up down Goldhawk Road because it was nice.

Blackredblack · 02/10/2021 20:15

I’m south Asian and honestly I think cultural appropriation has been twisted to suit every Tom, dick and Harry’s narrative.

I personally love seeing people of different races wearing Pakistani/Indian clothes.
When my grandfather came to the uk he stopped wearing traditional clothes and stuck to western clothes. Is that considered cultural appropriation too? Where do we draw the line? I think it’s fucking bonkers

Seafog · 02/10/2021 20:09

I've worn my hair in a crown of braids most of my life, as did my mother and my grandmother.
I can't see how that would bother anyone.

VladmirsPoutine · 02/10/2021 20:09

@Iamnotminterested

There is a white, dread-locked young man who sings Bob Marley songs in a thick Jamaican accent outside the Arndale Centre in Manchester.
A somewhat local Chet Hanks? Grin
GoOnDoAnASEyeroll · 02/10/2021 20:07

@beastlyslumber You reminded me of Chelsea handler who said something similar to 50 cents. I had to look it up to confirm because I don't pay much attention to social media and entertainers. Here's the link.

Interestingly, something she said about 50cents "influencing and entire swath of people" reminded me of something someone said on the feminism sex and gender board about Kemi Badenoch influencing people. I think some of these people sing from the same hymnsheet.

www.themix.net/2020/10/chelsea-handler-launches-racist-attack-on-50-cent-over-trump-support-i-had-to-remind-him-hes-black/

DingleyDel · 02/10/2021 20:05

I mean it’s not that hard for white people to just not wear their hair in braids is it? I have incredibly frizzy hair and it would solve a multitude of problems for me but I’d never consider it because lots of black people find it offensive for white people to braid their hair, end of argument. Even worse when people are profiting off it, blackfishing is a big thing.

I think it’s harder to define cultural appropriation when people are actually from the culture they are supposed to be appropriating. In this case obviously Rihanna is a black woman so surely it’s up to her (or more likely her management) how her models appear. I also remember reading a ridiculous article (in a well known publication) about how Ed Sheehan was ‘appropriating’ Irish music…his father is Irish! Is he not allowed a homage?

Evesgarden · 02/10/2021 20:01

Sometimes dh jokes that I culturally appropriated him. It's funny, but to be honest, I'm kind of worried that we're only a few small steps away from mixed race marriages being frowned upon.

They already are! Especially when a POC marries a white women.

Iamnotminterested · 02/10/2021 20:00

There is a white, dread-locked young man who sings Bob Marley songs in a thick Jamaican accent outside the Arndale Centre in Manchester.

mellicauli · 02/10/2021 19:58

@DillonPanthersTexas

Personally I think a single wax headscarf bought for a fair price from a business owned by a PoC would be OK - but maybe not if lots of other people did it too

Interesting view. When I was living and working in Ghana I used to love spending time in Kumasi where one of Africa's largest open air markets was based. You could literally find anything there. It was also famous for its fine selection of print fabrics. There is surprisingly a large Lebanese community in many parts of West Africa, including Ghana, and quite a few of them have got in on the fabric business, would it be okay for me, a white Irish bloke, to buy a fabric from a Lebanese vendor, or would it be more ethical to buy it from a local Ashanti trader. There was also the issue of lots of Chinese made 'Africa' print fabrics being sold as well, how does that work, should I only buy from the locally sourced traders, or if I buy Chinese is it okay if it is from a local Ghanian? I had a few funky short shirt sleeve shirts made up, the local chaps on site thought they were brilliant. When I finally had to head back to London my much loved work colleagues gifted me a shirt as they knew how much I liked them. I still wear it in the UK. Not sure if it is made from Chinese or Ghanian fabric, should I have asked so I could work out on the cultural offence-o-meter I stand. Am I allowed to wear it in the UK? Do I really give a fuck?

I just meant don't buy it from Primark..
beastlyslumber · 02/10/2021 19:54

@GoOnDoAnASEyeroll

POC are also speaking here (and everywhere else) but you're probably right - they're not the right type of POC. They haven't the right opinions.
Wasn't it Biden who said if you don't vote Dem, "you ain't black"?

I think we should start calling this what it is: racism. It's racism to consider there's a right way to be a POC, correct opinions to have and attitudes to share. It's racism for white people to say POC have to think or behave in a certain way to be worthy of having white people listen to or care about them.

It blows my mind that people can't see that their "anti-racism" is literally racism. Try treating people as individuals rather than representatives of their racial or ethnic group. Consider people's character and not the colour of their skin.

Dragonpox · 02/10/2021 19:51

[quote VladmirsPoutine]@Dragonpox That's already happened - a British influencer decided to identify as Korean. And of course there's currently a huge blackfishing industry.[/quote]
Yes, I've seen that influencer. I meant it would become more widespread. We will end up having to add it to our email signatures. (she/her/he when wanting more pay/Irish when needing luck/french when choosing restaurants)