Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Cultural appropriation...how bad is it?

495 replies

malificent7 · 02/10/2021 10:58

So Rhianna is under fire for braiding white model's hair. What if a black model wanted to straighten and bleach her hair?
I love african wax print fabric but don't want to be accused of cultural appropriation if i wear a bit of it. I also own sari fabric clothes.

Aibu to ask mn who may or may not be from different ethnic backgrounds would they consider Rhianna or my behaviour inappropriate and what constitutes real cultural appropriation?

This is not a racist thread as dd is mixed race.

OP posts:
DingleyDel · 02/10/2021 21:43

So, just to clarify, black people who don't say what you think they should say don't matter to you? Do you make all your decisions based on your perception of what the 'right kind' of black people think?

This all seems like a lot of mental gymnastics. Tbh I have never known or seen a black person who says they think white braids are acceptable, let alone ‘great’, and I discuss hair a lot with mixed race friends because we have very similar hair type. There are times when the idea of ‘cultural appropriation’ are taken to extremes by the ultra woke (the Ed Sheehan thing would be an example) but white people not adopting black hair styles hair is a fairly mainstream viewpoint now, at least in my circles. Offending one black person wouldn’t justify me having a hairstyle for my convenience.

CatsArePeople · 02/10/2021 21:42

Do you not understand that these people, who will have been bottom of the rung in Algeria and Morocco (because of the extreme darkness of their skin, in part) and fled north in the hope of better prospects, are obliged to sell a part of their heritage, their history, a fibre of their identity, for a few euros apiece? Do you think this is a chosen career?

For those looking to make a couple of Euros doing braids or henna tattoos, its the least consern about how first worlders feel about heritage.

Siameasy · 02/10/2021 21:39

I was at a “do” and of the school mums (she’s from Ghana) offered to do one of her DD’s friend’s (European) hair in the future. Should the Ghanaian lady be cancelled?

A little girl I know who has one black grandparent, so father mixed race, Mother white currently has cane rows. Is that allowed? Who decides?! How do you answer without being racist?

PeriChristmas · 02/10/2021 21:39

@Iamnotminterested

There is a white, dread-locked young man who sings Bob Marley songs in a thick Jamaican accent outside the Arndale Centre in Manchester.
Maybe he's Jamaican. There are White people there too you know. With the local accent & everything.
VladmirsPoutine · 02/10/2021 21:39

@DdraigGoch

How about ... using Chinese characters as tattoos if you aren't Chinese? I think that the Chinese had the last laugh when people end up with tattoos which translate as "Illiterate Foreigner", "Fat Dumb American", "Translator Server Error", "Circumcised Squirrel", "I don't speak this language", or "Goldfish Man" (the last is a term used for sleazy creeps).

Apparently Chinese tattooists hate this sort of thing but revenge is permanent!

Haven't there been countless things like this of young men (predominantly) getting tattoos which ostensibly mean 'Strength' or 'Brave' but turn out to mean Egg fried rice! It's actually wild!
DillonPanthersTexas · 02/10/2021 21:35

Correct, Iron Age fossils in Northern Europe show evidence of hair braiding. It is a practice which has taken place for thousands of years all over the world.

Clearly appropriated from the Great rift valley during the migration north 2 million years ago.

fucknuckle · 02/10/2021 21:35

i’m a middle-aged white woman with dreadlocks, but that’s because i’m a terrible old crusty with difficult hair. i’m aware that white people with dreads are generally reviled but they’re historically a pretty widespread thing amongst many different cultures, including European ones.

also i love them and they’re not going anywhere.

Sl33py · 02/10/2021 21:34

I am white and I had my hair braided on holiday when I was a teenager. Came home and was racially abused by a group of black girls in London. Most terrifying thing I’ve ever been through.

DdraigGoch · 02/10/2021 21:34

How about ... using Chinese characters as tattoos if you aren't Chinese?
I think that the Chinese had the last laugh when people end up with tattoos which translate as "Illiterate Foreigner", "Fat Dumb American", "Translator Server Error", "Circumcised Squirrel", "I don't speak this language", or "Goldfish Man" (the last is a term used for sleazy creeps).

Apparently Chinese tattooists hate this sort of thing but revenge is permanent!

2389Champ · 02/10/2021 21:29

@BeenThruMoreThanALilBit

Really? There are plenty of POC on the beaches of Spain happy to charge (mainly) white girls to braid their hair.

This is so lacking in humanity it’s gross. Do you not understand that these people, who will have been bottom of the rung in Algeria and Morocco (because of the extreme darkness of their skin, in part) and fled north in the hope of better prospects, are obliged to sell a part of their heritage, their history, a fibre of their identity, for a few euros apiece? Do you think this is a chosen career? How can you in any way consider them to be as equal to you as to pass such a callous remark?

Are they also obliged or is it also part of their heritage to flog fake French fashion goods to those same gullible tourists? Get real. Those Algerians and Moroccans you are referring to are trying to make money. They’re not going home and weeping about how they had no choice but to prostitute their culture; they’re supplying a demand. The same way any other business works.

If you want to take it to extremes, you could argue that they’re appropriating French culture by producing cheap, fake and inferior quality designer goods.

CatsArePeople · 02/10/2021 21:28

I guess its bad taste if you take religious or otherwise sacred sybols and turn them into scheap fashion. But hairstyles? Give it a rest.

I'm more bothered how people mess up ethnic foods though. If you want to make a disgusting muck in your own kitchen, you're welcome. But don't put mayonnaise on sushi and call it Japanese.

beastlyslumber · 02/10/2021 21:26

@DingleyDel

‘Siameasy’ I did say in my original post that some black people find it offensive , I would never generalise to all. But that should be enough to not do it.
So, just to clarify, black people who don't say what you think they should say don't matter to you? Do you make all your decisions based on your perception of what the 'right kind' of black people think?

Why can't you make your own mind up what you think and act accordingly?

Funnylittlefloozie · 02/10/2021 21:22

How is wearing a cheong sam to prom "cultural appropriation "? That's the sort of thing that makes people roll their eyes in disgust

Siameasy · 02/10/2021 21:22

@DingleyDel

‘Siameasy’ I did say in my original post that some black people find it offensive , I would never generalise to all. But that should be enough to not do it.
But why “should that be enough”? Some black people may think it’s positively brilliant that white people may wish to wear black hair styles. Do their opinions not count, should they also not be enough? This is a matter of correct and incorrect opinions. Of course, objectively, there are no such things.
DdraigGoch · 02/10/2021 21:21

@maddening

I don't think that Africa is the only origin of braiding hair.
Correct, Iron Age fossils in Northern Europe show evidence of hair braiding. It is a practice which has taken place for thousands of years all over the world.
Skysblue · 02/10/2021 21:19

I’ll start getting worked up about cultural appropriation when men stop doing gender appropriation and shoving drag onto every prime time channel.

TintinIsBack · 02/10/2021 21:18

Is there any POC on this thread who is saying they have an issue with while people wearing their clothes, braiding hair etc..?

I think so far I’ve seen people saying it was ok. (Unless I’ve missed a post)

Shall we listen to them instead of splitting hair in two between ourselves?

DingleyDel · 02/10/2021 21:14

‘Siameasy’ I did say in my original post that some black people find it offensive , I would never generalise to all. But that should be enough to not do it.

DdraigGoch · 02/10/2021 21:11

@YourFinestPantaloons

I'm also very much in the "just fucking listen" camp. If POC en masse are telling us cultural appropriation is damaging, how about we listen to them? Would that be so hard?
Are they though? I remember there was an American teenager who wore a traditional Chinese dress to a prom. Plenty of white activists were accusing the poor girl of cultural misappropriation but when the supposed victims of this (Chinese people) were actually asked what they thought, they said that actually they were delighted that she found their culture beautiful.
Siameasy · 02/10/2021 21:08

@DingleyDel

Do you really think black women would be looking at you seeing appropriation rather than just someone doing a sensible style for their hair type?

Yes. Obviously I wouldn’t be making money but it’s really never been acceptable in my life time (if ever) for white people to braid their hair in black styles.

The thing is that this is subjective. It’s not acceptable to you. It’s not acceptable to some black people. Fact is, anyone can wear their hair as they choose since it isn’t illegal. Who decides what is “acceptable”?

If you find it unacceptable don’t do it -isn’t this what keyboard warriors like to say (seen it a lot on here re:abortion and surrogacy)?

Evesgarden · 02/10/2021 21:08

@MiddlesexGirl

Yes. Obviously I wouldn’t be making money but it’s really never been acceptable in my life time (if ever) for white people to braid their hair in black styles.

I've never noticed it being a problem here. Less prevalent than a few years ago but plenty of white women and girls had their hair braided or with cornrows and I never heard any negative comments.

in the 90s most of my white teenage friends braided their hair - christ I used to go Tennerife as a kid and get my hair braided on the beach!
Redcart21 · 02/10/2021 21:06

As a POC, I love white people and other races enjoying my culture, wearing our clothes, eating our food (even if they anglicise it). It can only be a good thing for people to take interest in others cultures?

GoOnDoAnASEyeroll · 02/10/2021 21:04

I can't deny that there are instances of cultural appropriation but they are fewer than what's mentioned online and more are on an institutional scale, not for Joe/Jane Public going about their business doing/buying/wearing what they actually admire.

I think most instances of cultural appropriation accusations (not the real ones) are reactions to what POC have had to go through. It reminds me of when we were little and my brother was told to shut up so others could get a word in, and later when told it was his turn to speak, he'd refuse to speak at all and grudgingly say he was told not to speak when he wanted to, so now he's expected to, he's not going to speak.

May not be the best analogy but...
In this case, POC have had to deal with so much regarding hair, clothes, culture, etc so now that people are showing admiration for it, some have decided 'nope you can't have it now because you turned your nose up at it before'.

I understand it but it's a reaction to racism rather than it being about respect for any culture. It's just been given a name and allowed to ride on the coat tails of profiteering and exploitation.

It doesn't help anybody.

TintinIsBack · 02/10/2021 21:00

@DingleyDel

Do you really think black women would be looking at you seeing appropriation rather than just someone doing a sensible style for their hair type?

Yes. Obviously I wouldn’t be making money but it’s really never been acceptable in my life time (if ever) for white people to braid their hair in black styles.

I’m sorry but as a child, I remember many of my friends wearing their hair like this. It was never seen as an issue.
TintinIsBack · 02/10/2021 20:59

@usernamechanger123

I'm a WOC.

I find that around me it's white people, so called allies, who create a fuss around cultural appropriation and who are indignant on our behalf, when most of my poc friends and family couldn't care less. I find this insulting and infantilising tbh. If we care enough we can say it for ourselves.

My race is a part of who I am, but it's not the only thing that defines me.

Thank you!

It’s nice to see the pov of a woc.
I also get your point of all the fuss being infantilising.