Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Extortionate increase in insurance after passing test

132 replies

Daisyhoney · 02/10/2021 09:06

My son aged 19 passed his driving test recently - first time so really proud of him. But then came the kick in the teeth. He rang his insurance company to update them and (he had the phone on loud speaker) the man said and I quote ' it'll just be a little bit extra ' . How much extra ? my son asked only to be told £3002!!!
I thought I must have misheard but no that figure was correct and the monthly payments would go up by £350 per month 🥴
I feel so bad for him, he's done so well buying his first car and passing first time. I know he's now deemed as a higher risk but surely this just isn't fair on the youngsters. Why can't there be a cap on how much insurance companies can charge?

OP posts:
JetRocket · 02/10/2021 09:36

It just is what it is I’m afraid. Insurance companies run algorithms to decide how risky someone is to insure and that determines their premium.

Age, experience, locations, annual mileage…etc those things all impact highly. It’s not wrong that someone with a high chance of having an accident pay 6x more than someone with a very low chance. That’s how the whole insurance industry works. Imagine how annoyed you’d be if you were paying the same house insurance premiums as someone living in a £5m house in a high crime area of London.

Fwiw I work in insurance, I’m now in my late twenties but I had to drive in my late teens/early twenties for my full time job and some years my monthly insurance payments were 1/3 my monthly wage! It was brutal but now I pay about £200 a year and would decline the opportunity to pay more to subsidise a load of new drivers.

Mumoftwoinprimary · 02/10/2021 09:36

What do you mean 'who should pay?' surely insurance companies just shouldn't charge so much in the first place especially as these are their future business.

Insurance basically works on a “pooling” system - we all pay into the pot and those that need it receive out of the pot. If your son is to pay less than his fair share (which is “expected cost of accidents plus admin by the insurer plus profit by the insurer) then someone else has to pay more.

In fact - from what I remember of the general paper (which I took over 15 years ago - I don’t work in general insurance) there is already significant cross subsidies in favour of the young. Their “true” cost is even higher than is charged.

Since the 20th December 2012 there is also a massive cross subsidy in favour of men. This is because on that date “gender neutral pricing” came in which means that you have to charge a 19 year old male and a 19 year old female the same even though a 19 year old male is massively more likely to crash.

If he can make it through the next year without a crash then his costs will go down massively - it is the first year post passing that is really dangerous for drivers.

(Alternatively - tell him to get married! Dh and I got married very young and were shocked to find that once we informed the insurance company our premiums fell by quite a lot. Probably a bit extreme a solution though….)

Rainbowshine · 02/10/2021 09:35

What do you mean 'who should pay?' surely insurance companies just shouldn't charge so much in the first place especially as these are their future business.

So how do you expect an insurance company to pay for the compensation and legal costs of the major claims that younger and typically younger male drivers create? The money reflects the risk that driver in that vehicle poses of a claim and how costly the claim is likely to be. Those that pose a higher risk pay more, that’s simply how any insurance works. If you have a larger house with lots of valuables it costs more to cover due to the risk of a larger claim based on the underwriting company’s risk analysis. Cars and drivers are no different.

I’d suggest that your son shops around and looks at black box policies as others have said.

Pinkchocolate · 02/10/2021 09:34

Do you live in area with a high crime rate? This could be contributing too. I’ve been driving for over twenty years and I pay around £700 a year. My car is 10 years old and every insurance company I looked at wanted at least another £3k to insure my 19 year old DD. Sadly I think it just stops them driving.

daisypond · 02/10/2021 09:32

@Daisyhoney

Daisypond ( love the name btw ) he only bought a cheap second hand car so he could get in practise before his test but he didn't check out what the insurance might go up to after he passed. We were both a bit shocked tbh.
Ok, so who did he practise with when he was practising? Can he add them to the policy? That should help.
Daisyhoney · 02/10/2021 09:32

@daisypond

surely insurance companies just shouldn't charge so much in the first place especially as these are their future business.

Insurance companies don’t pluck figures out of the air. It’s to do with the risk they face. A 19-year-old male new driver is very high risk to them and they don’t particularly want to insure them. They don’t care about “future business” at this time.

I think you may be right.
OP posts:
daisypond · 02/10/2021 09:30

surely insurance companies just shouldn't charge so much in the first place especially as these are their future business.

Insurance companies don’t pluck figures out of the air. It’s to do with the risk they face. A 19-year-old male new driver is very high risk to them and they don’t particularly want to insure them. They don’t care about “future business” at this time.

Parky04 · 02/10/2021 09:30

Forgot to add that put you and any partner as named drivers as this also reduces the premium.

Parky04 · 02/10/2021 09:29

You need to shop around. My DS19 bought a Toyota Aygo and premium was £750 without a black box. Will go up this year as he crashed it!

Daisyhoney · 02/10/2021 09:29

It's a Vauxhall Corsa not sure of the engine size and it's old so not worth a lot. We both knew that the cost would go up after all like pps have said he's now a much higher risk driving on his own - I'm not disputing that - but it's the sheer amount of the increase that I really can't believe. It really was a shock to hear that figure.

OP posts:
LagneyandCasey · 02/10/2021 09:28

What is the car and engine size?

My ds had a black box for one year in a 10 year old one litre Fiesta. The first year was £1300 with me as named driver. After the first year it dropped to £800 with the black box removed. 3 years in it's around £450.

So it does drop quite dramatically once they've done a couple of years with no incidents.

BluebellsGreenbells · 02/10/2021 09:23

He will also get a refund pro-rata if he moves companies - however this may affect his no claims bonus depending how far through the year he is.

What car is it? Engine size? That will make a difference

Daisyhoney · 02/10/2021 09:22

@AgentJohnson

Why can't there be a cap on how much insurance companies can charge?

And who do you think should pay for the cap?

What do you mean 'who should pay?' surely insurance companies just shouldn't charge so much in the first place especially as these are their future business.
OP posts:
WhoWearsShortShorts · 02/10/2021 09:22

Since he can now legally drive on his own and isn't guaranteed to have a qualified driver with him then the risk will have increased hence the massive hike in premium. Put your DH on as a named driver and it should bring the cost down.

When is his policy due for renewal? You could shop around but you'll have to pay the cancellation fee if its not due yet which is usually about 50 quid. A drop in the ocean compared to the potential savings.

Whatever you do don't put your DH down as the main user or insure it in his name with your DS as the named driver. I know nobody at all in this thread has suggested it but its called fronting and is fraud (just in case someone suggests it in real life) Adding your DH as a named driver to your sons policy is completely fine

JasonMomoasgirlfriend · 02/10/2021 09:21

There hopefully is a cooling off period. I can't believe he went forward with that quote!

SudokuWillNotSaveYou · 02/10/2021 09:21

@MintyGreenDream

I only passed 3 months ago and my annual insurance is 850 a year with Admiral.
Presumably, you’re not a 19-year-old male.
Abouttoblow · 02/10/2021 09:21

The amount they charge young people is absolutely ridiculous but the reason it goes up after they pass their test is because they are no longer required to have someone in the car with them at all times.

Hankunamatata · 02/10/2021 09:21

I think statistically males under 24 are something like 7x more likely to have an accident. Of course it will go up as he is driving unsupervised. He needs a black box insurance

Cantgetausername87 · 02/10/2021 09:20

Theres a 14 day cooling off period as long as no claims made if you do find a better deal - its a legal requirement Smile

SudokuWillNotSaveYou · 02/10/2021 09:20

A 19-year-old male is about the worst thing you can be, according to a vehicle insurance company. The second worst thing is a 19-year-old male in car that’s newer than 10 years old with more than a 1L engine.

Dilbertian · 02/10/2021 09:19

Of course it makes sense - they're driving on their own without the starting influence of an older, more experienced driver beside them. Or, worse, with a car-full of fellow youngsters distracting them or egging them on to take risks.

Dc1 added me as a named driver, and that reduced his premiums substantially.

Daisyhoney · 02/10/2021 09:19

Daisypond ( love the name btw ) he only bought a cheap second hand car so he could get in practise before his test but he didn't check out what the insurance might go up to after he passed. We were both a bit shocked tbh.

OP posts:
AgentJohnson · 02/10/2021 09:18

Why can't there be a cap on how much insurance companies can charge?

And who do you think should pay for the cap?

MintyGreenDream · 02/10/2021 09:18

I only passed 3 months ago and my annual insurance is 850 a year with Admiral.

CointreauVersial · 02/10/2021 09:17

We didn't go for a black box, because DS had a job at the time which required him to drive late at night, and a lot of the black boxes penalise you for that. Worth bearing in mind.

Swipe left for the next trending thread