Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Extortionate increase in insurance after passing test

132 replies

Daisyhoney · 02/10/2021 09:06

My son aged 19 passed his driving test recently - first time so really proud of him. But then came the kick in the teeth. He rang his insurance company to update them and (he had the phone on loud speaker) the man said and I quote ' it'll just be a little bit extra ' . How much extra ? my son asked only to be told £3002!!!
I thought I must have misheard but no that figure was correct and the monthly payments would go up by £350 per month 🥴
I feel so bad for him, he's done so well buying his first car and passing first time. I know he's now deemed as a higher risk but surely this just isn't fair on the youngsters. Why can't there be a cap on how much insurance companies can charge?

OP posts:
TheUndoingProject · 02/10/2021 11:49

It sounds like you haven’t done an awful lot of research. By shopping around and putting you and your husband on the policy as named drivers he could probably bring it down a lot. Have a look on a price comparison site and play around with the variables.

AllThatFancyPaintsAsFair · 02/10/2021 11:44

@PassTheDutchyUpYrLeftBackside

Definitely worth a try, OP.

For what it's worth - insurers don't pick premiums out of thin air.

They have complex formulas that tell them the potential risks of every combination of driver, car, area, job and more.

In most cases, damage or theft of the car is hardly even a consideration- it's what damage could be DONE with the car that's the issue.

It's almost always the potential power of the car and not the value that is the consideration for young drivers. The liability of your son injuring himself or others as a result of recklessness and inexperience is what insurers factor in ( not that he would, but their historical figures tell them this demographic has a higher chance).

Obviously there are people who are exceptions to the rule, n

I was going to post something similar. There is a bit of naivity on this thread about how car insurance works

And to the posters saying things like I'm with Tesco and it costs £900 like it's one price for everyone Confused.

No one can possibly say whether there's a cheaper quote available but for sure you won't find out if you don't do the proper research. Hopefully cancelling won't be too costly if you do find a cheaper policy.

NightPrancer8204 · 02/10/2021 11:43

50s insurance is £150 per year = low risk

80+ insurance is £500+ per year = higher risk

Teenager up to 21/25 high, high risk

He has 14 day cooling off period, but the insurance may charge an admin fee to cancel

Shop around on comparison sites

PassTheDutchyUpYrLeftBackside · 02/10/2021 11:35

Definitely worth a try, OP.

For what it's worth - insurers don't pick premiums out of thin air.

They have complex formulas that tell them the potential risks of every combination of driver, car, area, job and more.

In most cases, damage or theft of the car is hardly even a consideration- it's what damage could be DONE with the car that's the issue.

It's almost always the potential power of the car and not the value that is the consideration for young drivers. The liability of your son injuring himself or others as a result of recklessness and inexperience is what insurers factor in ( not that he would, but their historical figures tell them this demographic has a higher chance).

Obviously there are people who are exceptions to the rule, n

VeganVeal · 02/10/2021 11:31

@Cantgetausername87

Theres a 14 day cooling off period as long as no claims made if you do find a better deal - its a legal requirement Smile
Doesnt that apply to new polices? He's only made a change to an existing one, not sure it would count?
Daisyhoney · 02/10/2021 11:30

He's insured fully comp. I'm definitely going to look into Tesco black box as several people have now mentioned it.

OP posts:
PassTheDutchyUpYrLeftBackside · 02/10/2021 11:27

My son is insured with Tesco 'Insure the Box'.

He's had the policy for 3 years as a provisional young driver as he dithered with lessons and learning, then Covid put an extra 18 months on getting the actual test.

He actually passed this week and the premium only increased by £95 in total (which we were very surprised about).

Worth trying them?

WhoWearsShortShorts · 02/10/2021 11:25

Also is he covered comprehensive or is he on Third Party Fire and Theft? Often comprehensive is the same cost if not cheaper than tpft. Or it was when I worked in insurance!

Orla1970 · 02/10/2021 11:24

It’s always been like that. I passed my test at 17, 34 years ago! My dad bought me an old car and he insured it for me. 3 years later I bought a wee turbo diesel Clio which was deemed the ‘hot hatch’ against my dad’s wishes as he felt it was too fast. He warned me if I bought it I would have to insure it in my own name. I ignored him Grin and went ahead. My insurance premium in 1990 was a whopping 1800 quid! But I did love that car! Grin

BananaPB · 02/10/2021 10:56

My dd has a black box policy and there's no time restriction in it- she's been out at night in the dark.

Don't forget to add commuting. Somebody on here had a teen who had a crash on the way to work but wasn't insured for commuting. Commuting brought down the cost of DD's insurance but that might be because she's currently a barista so works during the day.

LindaEllen · 02/10/2021 10:55

@Wazzzzzzzup

Yeah. They don't want to insure him. I saw a quote for 10k once... Real!

The insurance in UK is a masaive rip off.

I know someone who paid £6,000 for their son's first year because they didn't shop around and just went with their own insurer. They must have been rubbing their hands together when they saw that go through!
Daisyhoney · 02/10/2021 10:55

@justasking111

Find a local insurance broker go into their offices they'll do all the legwork and advise you. They're always cheap and will sort out any problems for you
That's a good idea I hadn't thought of that - thank you 😊
OP posts:
LindaEllen · 02/10/2021 10:55

It's because it's the first time he's driving on his own with no supervision and - often - young lads can go a bit wild when this happens, speeding round, messing round picking mates up, and a huge number of them crash within their first year of owning a car.

That's not to say that your son wouldn't be sensible, but insurance works only on averages. The sooner it's paid, the sooner he'll start getting his no claims bonus and it will come down. Black boxes are often the best way to go - and it gives you the peace of mind that he has to be careful!

Wazzzzzzzup · 02/10/2021 10:54

Yeah. They don't want to insure him.
I saw a quote for 10k once... Real!

The insurance in UK is a masaive rip off.

justasking111 · 02/10/2021 10:51

Find a local insurance broker go into their offices they'll do all the legwork and advise you. They're always cheap and will sort out any problems for you

BananaPB · 02/10/2021 10:48

My 18yo dd passed a couple of months ago and is with a different insurance company compared to the one she had while learning. She has a black box on her Fiesta and pays less than £2k iirc (£150pm)

Badabingbadabum · 02/10/2021 10:39

Yes to adding another driver on though, it makes a difference to the cost.

EmmaGrundyForPM · 02/10/2021 10:39

My son passed first time aged 17. I rang my insurers to add him as a named driver on my 6 year old basic hatchback and they quoted £5000.

I rang round and the cheapest quote I got was almost £4k. In the end, and against all our principles, we bought a Fiat Panda for £2k and had a black box fitted. This brought the insurance down to £850. It was more cost effective for us to do this than to put him on my insurance, especially as DS2 passed his test at 17 and inherited the car. As they were the main drivers it also helped them to start building their no-claims bonus.

I had always judged people who bought their teens cars, but then completely got it when doing it for our two saved us about £4k in total. Which is madness.

Badabingbadabum · 02/10/2021 10:37

Dh passed when he was 26 or 27 and he was paying over 2k to begin with. It's gone down a lot in the ten years since. I am having driving lessons and need to arrange getting put on his insurance but know it is going to go up after I pass - which makes absolute sense as after you pass you can drive on your own, until then you have always been supervised. I'm hoping it won't be too bad though as a nearly 40 year old woman!

icedcoffees · 02/10/2021 10:34

Insurers charge high amounts when they don't want to insure you.

I had an accident last summer (my fault) and my insurance rocketed this year. But a quick search on CompareTheMarket meant I could more than half my monthly costs.

I know I'm not a 19yo boy but generally if you shop around, add another driver (your DH in this case) and maybe use a Black Box policy, you should be able to bring the price down at least a little bit.

Grenlei · 02/10/2021 10:32

Go onto price comparison sites.

My colleague insured her DC through one of the very well known insurers for £1000 with telematics (the black box referenced above). However when I got a quote for them for my DC it was double that! Same age, similar car but colleague lives in a better postcode clearly!

However we shopped around on price comparison sites and managed to bring it down to £1300.

3 years on it's about £600.

notsorighteousthesedays · 02/10/2021 10:31

Actually it's young women who take the biggest financial hit - cos it would be sex discrimination to just make young men pay higher premiums because young men (as opposed to young people) have more accidents.

It's always cheered my daughters up to know they are helping their male contemporaries out.... Gin

MsWarrensProfession · 02/10/2021 10:31

A teenager giving a lift to a group of other teenagers can easily cost their insurer millions in injury compensation if the worst comes to the worst. Happens regularly.

3cats4poniesandababy · 02/10/2021 10:30

Defiantly look at putting DH on as a named driver. Make sure your son is still the main driver otherwise he could find his insurance voided. A black box may also be worth it but only if he drives carefully.

The reason young people are expensive is because they are more likely to cause accidents. Unfortunately some young males pass their tests then think they own the roads.

If he drives well for a few years then he should find his insurance costs plummet once he proved he isn't a high risk to an insurance company.

Daisyhoney · 02/10/2021 10:30

@Jammysod

How do they pay claims if they don't charge adequately? Young drivers are statistically much more likely to be involved in an accident. If they hit another car, the insurance company has to pay for both cars, plus any injuries. That is likely to be far costlier than the £3k your son has paid in premium.
But the same applies if an older driver who's paid a lot less hits another car so your arguement is pointless. By your reckoning everyone should pay sky high premiums to cover both cars and injuries.
OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread