Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Children going into care - ten year high

82 replies

romaarco · 02/10/2021 08:20

I read a few weeks ago that the numbers of teenagers going into care has steaily increased over the last ten years and is now at a ten year high.

Does anyone know what is behind this - is it parents not coping or parents being abusive or poverty or more mental health problems in teens because of social media etc?

This applies to children of all ages, incidentally. But the second highest group of children being taken into care is 10 years up. The highest is 0 - 2

I know from experience that children very rarely do well in care. It is very rare that they find adults who care about them and give them support and there is a high chance they will be not given the emotional care they need and also that they will be exploited.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
romaarco · 07/10/2021 17:59

@Kneesaregood I apologise, I stated the first paragraph in bald terms but should have said "I think" and "as I understand it" - ie this is the situation as I understand it, - I am not an expert - sorry if it comes across as somewhat pontificating, that is more to do with me bashing it out quickly than me thinking that I know everything!

The bit about pedestal is more to with my own personal experiences, and being somewhat hacked off about the term, however.

OP posts:
romaarco · 07/10/2021 17:50

@Dddccc

Ok I grew up in care and I am still involved with teens in care, early intervention would not have worked for my case but it may for other none violent cases, I was removed and placed in Foster care and after being moved 8 times was finally placed in a group home which was probably the best place I could have been put, I went to college and even have my own business, out of the 12 teens that were in and moved on 6 ended up serving some form of prison sentence, 3 of us went to college and 4 teen pregnancies all had children removed, all of the ones who ended up in prison had family contact which caused more harm then good, 4 pregnant teens were all abused by family, I was technically want people call a normal one but really I had amazing carers who listened and helped me, they still listen years after leaving and being no contact with family was the best outcome for me
I am pleased you had an amazing carer! I think it makes such a difference. Thank you for posting about your experiences.
OP posts:
romaarco · 07/10/2021 17:48

@Kneesaregood sorry for the delay in reply.

Basically in relation to using clinical psychologists or psychiatrists who specialise in developmental trauma, there have been developments in the last decade in relation to developmental trauma which your average therapist or social worker wouldn't be aware of. The sort of therapy and also the environment suitable for a looked after child will depend on their specific experiences - and so getting that input right from the outset is crucial, I think, even if it is initially guidance about a child's specific needs. For example - where the trauma occurred at the time the limbic brain developed, the therapy would be different from where the trauma occurred at say age 10 or 11 in an otherwise securely attached child – this is just two examples – there would be many other potential scenarios - the initial therapeutic work for each would look very different. A clinical psychologists specialising in developmental trauma will be aware of the problems with communicating with children who are unable to trust adults, or attachment problems, and understand how that fits in with other aspects of the child's developmental trauma, and would be able to explain how the caregiver, school, doctor, everyone in the child's life need to work together right from the outset. It quite possibly wouldn't involve talking therapy at the outset.

I think that trying to get them settled in a placement first, without getting professional input, is putting the cart before the horse. Where things are done the right way round, the outcomes will be different.

The idea that children put their parents on a pedestal is not really understood either, I don't think. The children you are talking about here will love their (biological) parents, even if their parents are not great parents, and they will want to see their parents, but they will still
be capable of understanding that their parents were not great parents – the two things go hand in hand. I think that the problems arise because of really poor communication with children, a certain amount of incompetence, and a real lack of understanding of how these children feel and why their home life was as it was from the vast majority of people involved including social workers which is the problem. The reason why they may resist being put into care is because even without abuse, they will be living day on day with micro aggressions, from other kids, from staff or foster carers who aren't up to the job, without any escape or any let up, and it is really, really tough on a child. But fundamentally, a child can love their parents and want to see them at the same time as recognising that they were not caring for them properly and suggesting it is putting them on a pedestal is not helpful, in my experience.

You mentioned adults not yet being able to delve into things – I know similar adults – basically, if they had had the sort of help which some children get to learn to process and come to terms with things as they happened, they wouldn't nearly so much to delve into, I think (based on my own experiences). Does that make sense? It isn't so much that these things cannot be delved into, it is more that if they have been left a long time memories are fractured, multiple losses and trauma will have been tangled up, there is a lot more to unravel – this doesn't happen where children are taught to process and deal with things from the outset, whatever has happened in their early life.

I have also known adults who have taken advantage of current therapies in relation to old trauma or intergenerational trauma, and vastly improved their happiness levels! The problem is partly that not everyone knows what help is available, and partly that there is not enough expertise to go round, possibly.

Understanding intergenerational trauma is also key to understanding why families fail and with that understanding could come better prevention.

Something I do want to say here is that despite my having come to terms with things and gone on to do well, and despite having had a pretty good and stable adult life, and despite my story not being nearly as bad as some others, including that of an older sibling, I still find the memories incredibly upsetting - in my case it was certainly out of the frying pan into the fire and I don't think I am unusual. I spent a decade as a LAC and quite honestly if I think back it is still like some horror experience - and as I said, I don't think my experiences were nearly as bad as others' experiences.

In summary, there are ways to help children with early life trauma and difficult home lives much, much better than before, but I do not think it is happening in practice.

OP posts:
TableFlowerss · 04/10/2021 23:58

@Notimeforaname

A family I know couldn't control their oldest child. Kept running away,punching holes in things generally tormenting the household.

Eventually they were told that if they didn't let him be taken away in to semi secure facility,they would face issues with their younger children as they were 'failing to protect them' by keeping their oldest child in the home Sad it was/is horrendous.

The child now lives in a halfway house type situation and is still just running the streets. The centre call the parents every other evening to tell them he hasn't come ' home' again.

So they still spend most of their time in a state of permanent stress and fear for their child.
It makes no sense

What a sad story 😞
Dddccc · 04/10/2021 23:42

Ok I grew up in care and I am still involved with teens in care, early intervention would not have worked for my case but it may for other none violent cases, I was removed and placed in Foster care and after being moved 8 times was finally placed in a group home which was probably the best place I could have been put, I went to college and even have my own business, out of the 12 teens that were in and moved on 6 ended up serving some form of prison sentence, 3 of us went to college and 4 teen pregnancies all had children removed, all of the ones who ended up in prison had family contact which caused more harm then good, 4 pregnant teens were all abused by family, I was technically want people call a normal one but really I had amazing carers who listened and helped me, they still listen years after leaving and being no contact with family was the best outcome for me

Kneesaregood · 04/10/2021 23:25

Just for info as well, it's fairly standard these days for there to be a specialist person in CAMHS for children in care, sometimes they're based in the council, sometimes in CAMHS, but usually a psychologist who specialises in working with children in care and the related issues that come with that (trauma, attachment etc)
Many organisations that provide care employ people in a similar capacity to consult.
So its not that those specialisms don't have input, but as others have said that isn't usually direct therapy to the child. Occasionally so, but more commonly it's to give advice to those caring for the child, or advice about specific things such as more complex life story work, that would be undertaken by other people.

ducksalive · 04/10/2021 23:05

Having worked as a therapist for some time this is our policy.
The only times we have relaxed these boundaries it has always proven not be a good idea in the long run.
( we is my organization I'm not pretending I'm the queen)

Kneesaregood · 04/10/2021 23:04

Sorry my comment was directed at @romaarco not at @NeverHomeAlone

Kneesaregood · 04/10/2021 23:02

With respect i disagree about the clin psych input. Those professionals are suitably qualified to assess if a child is ready for direct therapy. How can a child engage in therapy if they don't feel emotionally safe at home? If they aren't at the stage that they can recognise or name their own emotions? If they have parents on a pedestal and can't comprehend that a parent made any mistakes? You can't force a service on a child because the adult would be more comfortable with them having it. In some cases it's applicable but not all. Think it how many adults go through difficult events but aren't ready for counseling until years later.
Most of the children I have arranged counseling for have wanted to talk about usual childhood things - dating, friendships etc - not ready to delve into the big stuff.
For many, that time comes in adulthood, often when they have children of their own. I do believe that we should provide better support to care leavers in that regard.

In terms of the right help, the match is key, and the shortage of places when they're needed is a massive issue. For example you could have an amazing home with on site therapy, access to vocational skills, beautiful surroundings. If it's far from home and a child feels they're being deliberately distanced from family and friends, it doesn't matter how good the home is, it's not right for them. Councils can't negotiate with companies when we're competing to get a vacancy in the first place. We can try and hold them to account but the reality is we don't have an alternative and they know that.

One other aspect is there is a very well publicised shortage of homes that can support children who are at their most vulnerable/damaged - secure beds or equivalent . As homes have too many referrals they can naturally select the young person who is least likely to disrupt others in that home. Which means those who have the more extreme behaviour and the most need are the hardest to find homes for and sadly the most likely to be moved around and not receive the support they need.

Ps thank you for your comments, it is an ethical quandry to work in a system with such flaws, the alternative of walking away feels wrong too. So I just try to be realistic and change and influence what we can, which I think is broadly in line with a number of my colleagues.

NeverHomeAlone · 04/10/2021 22:59

I am a foster carer. I'm not sure if this is an across-the-board policy, but I'm my area children won't be seen for therapeutic input until they're in a stable placement that is able to support them.

The young person is already going through so much trauma bouncing from one carer to the next, not forming any significant attachments, unsure if "home" will still be "home" next week, potentially changing schools and losing friends along the way.

They can't begin to deal with their past traumas until their present situation isn't terrifying.

ducksalive · 04/10/2021 22:59

Some clinical psychs are going to be up to date in this field, others not so much in my experience.
I think working in a multi-disciplinary way is more valuable than relying too much on any one professional group.

romaarco · 04/10/2021 22:49

sorry, I meant private sector are good at negotiating and the chances are there is not value for money.

OP posts:
romaarco · 04/10/2021 22:42

@Kneesaregood

Also I know your question about clinical psychs and counselling wasn't directed at me, but very few of the children I've worked with have been ready for that input in childhood. More usually it's therapeutic parenting - to help with the real basics, such as recognising their own emotions, building small amounts of trusts in relationships. It's common for children to be in homes where a clinician will advise the carers on how to best support and respond to the child. Many of the children we work with have a younger emotional development age due to trauma, and attachment/trust issues with the people they live with, along with all the other issues that come with being a young teen generally. It's got to be at the child's pace.
Thank you so much for your other post. What you have said here about clin psychs isn't right - the children really need this input from the outset, much of the therapeutic parenting is out of date - attachment forms part of developmental trauma and the help the child should get will depend on when the trauma happened, and it needs a clin psych to assess that - without that and proper help the child will get worse.

Children just are not getting what they need.

But what you described sounds just horrendous - it must be really tough dealing with that day to day. I have worked on commercial private/public projects and my concern is that the private sector and really, really good at negotiating contracts with LAs - I hope that I am wrong but the changes are there is not value for money and the dc are not getting the help they need.

OP posts:
Kneesaregood · 04/10/2021 22:35

Also I know your question about clinical psychs and counselling wasn't directed at me, but very few of the children I've worked with have been ready for that input in childhood. More usually it's therapeutic parenting - to help with the real basics, such as recognising their own emotions, building small amounts of trusts in relationships. It's common for children to be in homes where a clinician will advise the carers on how to best support and respond to the child. Many of the children we work with have a younger emotional development age due to trauma, and attachment/trust issues with the people they live with, along with all the other issues that come with being a young teen generally. It's got to be at the child's pace.

Ponoka7 · 04/10/2021 22:28

I have a relative who decided to go into care at the age of 14. She wanted to hold the family to ransom, basically. She went into a teenage hostel. A lot of the teenagers were in there because they could be. They were fully supported to leave home. Compared with the teens who'd I'd worked with during my time as a CP SW, they mostly didn't leave to escape a terrible home life. The rise in numbers will be partly because of poorer mental health, issues being amplified because of lock down and better intervention. As said by a pp, if there's younger children in the house, parents aren't given the option of the young person remaining in the home.

christinarossetti19 · 04/10/2021 22:28

Well, except that plenty of abuse and neglect goes on in care as well.

I imagine (hope) that it is far less now than historically, but it's not true to say that care doesn't and can't cause its own damage.

Kneesaregood · 04/10/2021 22:27

Op I don't want to give too many outing details, but I work in an authority where the two biggest reasons for child protection plans are neglect and harm relating to domestic abuse (usually emotional neglect category).
There are a few reasons identified for the massive increase in children coming into care, particularly older children in our area, but in our area it's a very specific legacy of local authority cuts. The govt changed how childrens services were funded which meant deprived areas (like ours) that used to get an extra boost, were essentially told to be good little capitalists and generate our own income. Not very easy to do when you've got very limited options (not much real estate we can make money from where I work!)
That meant for 5-10yrs we batted away a LOT of neglect cases due to lack of social workers, lack of people to even pick up the phone. Signposted them to charities that were also on their knees. Colleagues in health were also limiting what they were doing for the same reason. And police. Children had repeat child protection plans. Things were bad.

A few years later things got bad enough that our authority was able to 'prove' things were dangerous. Cue reinvestment (via our authority knowingly going into debt) More social workers. More assessments. More children coming into care, but specifically more older children who had experienced lower level but grinding neglect.

Noone in our sector wants to focus the money on the expenditure on children's homes - we're often frustrated by the costs and the lack of good matches - putting children where there's a vacancy instead of where is the best fit for them. In our area they are investing in the preventative services but it's going to take a few years, especially as our charity services are still decimated. Many went under and funding is so hard to get in that area that the things we want - befriending services for vulnerable parents, mentoring services for teens, children's centres that provide parenting courses on how to handle teens, support for dads etc - just don't exist.

romaarco · 04/10/2021 22:20

@MrsPworkingmummy What you say here is really helpful, thank you. Are the children all assessed and supported by clinical psychologists and do they all get therapeutic input advised by psychs? Does psych input into developmental trauma etc inform how you work with the children? Do the children see their birth families and do they all get counselling to help them come to terms with their birth family circumstances and early life experiences, and their experiences with foster families/adoptive families?

Sorry, a lot of questions!

OP posts:
romaarco · 04/10/2021 22:09

@SlidDownTheElephantsTrunk

This bull shit about kids in care really gets on my nerves. Yes kids in care have poor outcomes across the board but that because they have been neglected and abused - not because they have been or are in care.

Actually kids in care have far better access to a wide range of service's to try and boost their outcomes - but fundamentally, its the parents fault. Not being in care.

26 years experience working with looked after children as a social work manager.

To answer your question. Asylum seekers have raised some of the numbers of the 10+ Yr old. 0-2 have risen because its proven that young children have better outcomes if they go into care, sooner rather than later.

Your 26 years don't tally with the testimony of the adults I know, who went into care because of neglect, but only experienced serious physical abuse, sexual abuse, pscyhological abuse and emotional neglect after going into care.

My question was only about the 10 plus - thank you for your input there, however, that asylum seekers have raised numbers.

OP posts:
romaarco · 04/10/2021 22:03

Thanks to everyone who responded.

For some children the only option is removal, but I believe that for many families (or the majority possibly) having more effective interventions in the home would be better for the children. I am not sure the comparison with cin works in fact as there will be a difference between a CIN/their family getting effective home intervention and a CIN/their family who do not. The problem is not just funding, though funding is a huge problem, it is also how effective the offered interventions are.

I was speaking to a social worker who worked with families just before removal not long ago and I asked her if there was a place for a charity which went into homes in crisis and gave practical and emotional support to help hold them together and she said it was an amazing idea and that it would be welcomed across the board.

Vast amounts of public money are channelled in the direction of care and I feel could and should be diverted to helping at ground roots and I think that there is a lack of general awareness of.

But I don't think it is just to do with money. I don't think the lives of people living in the poorest and most dangerous and most deprived and isolated communities (whether or not there is DV and substance abuse) are well enough understood by services, and it means that the help being provided or offered is not effective help.

I have said "many/majority of families" above because that is the impression I get from talking to people who are directly involved, but I wanted to get wider opinions, hence this thread.

OP posts:
gogohm · 04/10/2021 22:02

We run a child contact centre, several users are parents whose children are in foster care, all are in foster care due to addiction. Addiction is such a problem and so many children's lives are ruined by it

Guineapigbridge · 04/10/2021 22:02

The way out of this mire all starts with free, accessible contraception and decent maternity and early childhood care. Societies that fail to care for mothers and allow them real choices will see these consequences 10 years down the line.

Oldtiredfedup · 04/10/2021 22:00

Austerity

MrsPworkingmummy · 04/10/2021 21:59

I am a leader in an SEMH school and around 60% of our intake are young people in care. The school is owned by a private company which also runs numerous other similar schools, secure units and children's homes around the country. Many of our students have been placed in one of our children's homes because foster/adoptive placements have broken down. The young people have usually suffered horrendous abuse in their earliest years and have been placed in the case system because of that, often living in 5-10 Foster homes before coming to us . Children attend our school from age 5 to 18. Our young people can be incredibly volatile and often dangerous. Many already have criminal records. There is loads of self harm. Ultimately, they are just lonely kids who are desperate for love and they often idolise their birth parents/mums without acknowledging the horrific abuse they suffered. Our young people have sooooo much potential and we push them to ensure all year 11 students leave with 5 qualifications including GCSE English and Maths.

Resilience · 04/10/2021 21:52

I think part of the rise might be improvements in safeguarding. Most public services have a statutory responsibility to flag any concerns about children and frontline staff in these services are better trained than ever to pick up on neglect/abuse. It's not perfect and cases are still missed, but it's a lot better than 20 years ago.