Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is this selfish?

215 replies

cantbuylilt · 02/10/2021 08:00

Just reading on another thread about a couple where the man is a higher earner, and the woman is scraping by, with lots of people saying it's selfish of him to keep the money to himself.

I've been living with my partner for 6 years, together for a lot longer. We're not married yet, but are engaged. I am the higher earner. He used to earn more, but reduced hours gradually since we moved in together.

We each get paid into our own accounts and transfer money to the joint account. It works out at roughly 1/4 of outgoings is paid by him, and 3/4 by me. His wages vary month to month, depending on how much work he has picked up, or turned down.

Anything 'big', like kitchen appliances, holidays, new boiler etc is paid for by me. I also pay the water bill by myself, in one go for the year.

He recently cancelled an eye appointment, because he said he couldn't afford to buy new glasses. He lives in his overdraft most of the time and has no savings. For a while, about 3 years ago, he didn't work for a year and I paid for everything by myself during that time.

I know I do a lot, and pay my way. But just reading that other thread made me feel guilty, that I have plenty of money saved, but he is struggling to afford new glasses. Our old oven broke earlier this week, and I just bought a new one- he said he'd never be able to do that. However, he is capable of working more and could pick up more hours easily. He just doesn't want to.

AIBU to not pool our money?

OP posts:
RaisedByPangolins · 02/10/2021 08:44

I voted YABU because I would feel like crap if I was struggling to buy essentials like glasses while my DP was living his best life. However your update about 2 hours work a week puts a different spin on it! He needs to prioritise better and I wouldn’t be marrying him unless he showed a bit more ambition.

I work very hard - self employed - and earn a tiny fraction of what my DP earns. His job isn’t hugely taxing or responsible but he has certain skills & knowledge that mean he’s worked his way up and is now indispensable at his company, so gets paid very well for a comparatively low pressure job. Conversely I’m earning less than NMW and haven’t actually been to bed yet (9am!) as I worked all night as well as all day yesterday Grin

In some relationships the ebb and flow means that someone is always bringing in a bit more or less and for me a partnership means that you both do what you can to help each other out - even if not strictly 50/50 - not see each other struggle. However, if he can afford to vape and doss about all day rather than work and contribute then that’s on him.

HouseOfFire · 02/10/2021 08:39

@cantbuylilt

His hours do vary. It's between 2 and 10 hours per week, roughly.

He buys music and hardware for his computer, vapes and he buys his own lunch from the corner shop, although we always have food in the house he could have instead.

I'm not extravagant at all. Before I met him, money was really tight for me and I was literally living on pennies. The memory of that has made me a bit wary of overspending.

wow - he's a keeper - why the hell would you want to be with someone who is basically lazy? and a sponger

He regularly has contacts asking him to work, enough to fill an entire working week. He is good at his job, fast and accurate, so he's often in demand. However, it is freelance, so can be unpredictable.

He hasn't come right out and said that he just can't be bothered to work, but he has said that it's nice to have my steady wage coming in every month, that it takes the pressure off.

DDiva · 02/10/2021 08:37

He is not paying his share and that is his choice. Work /life balance is important but he is an adult and needs to take responsibility for doing his share and paying his way. Do not marry him you'll be subsidising him for life!

Whentheydontmeanwhattheysay · 02/10/2021 08:36

@cantbuylilt

His hours do vary. It's between 2 and 10 hours per week, roughly.

He buys music and hardware for his computer, vapes and he buys his own lunch from the corner shop, although we always have food in the house he could have instead.

I'm not extravagant at all. Before I met him, money was really tight for me and I was literally living on pennies. The memory of that has made me a bit wary of overspending.

WTH?!

Even with a disability that leaves me floored after working I work more than double his hours!
Isn’t this close to cocklodger territory?

Aprilx · 02/10/2021 08:35

When we met I was by far the largest earner, in fact DH was unemployed for the first six months or so. When we married I was still the largest earner and I also put the full deposit down on our house. I would never have seen my husband unable to afford glasses, when I found out he had a credit card debt because of my engagement ring I immediately paid it off. I do not understand why you are planning to marry somebody if you do not wish to pool money with them. As far as we are concerned our finances are joint.

The big but here though, is that there is a difference between my DH and this man you are thinking of marrying though. My DH did not choose to be unemployed when I met him nearly two decades ago, was desperate for work then and has since carved out a good career for himself. A man who chooses to work between 2 and 10 hours a week wouldn’t be somebody I would want to marry.

Skyeheather · 02/10/2021 08:32

@cantbuylilt

He's not disabled, and we don't have children, so he's not caring for anyone but himself.

He regularly has contacts asking him to work, enough to fill an entire working week. He is good at his job, fast and accurate, so he's often in demand. However, it is freelance, so can be unpredictable.

He hasn't come right out and said that he just can't be bothered to work, but he has said that it's nice to have my steady wage coming in every month, that it takes the pressure off.

But it's not "taking the pressures off" - he's always overdrawn, has no savings, can't afford a new pair of glasses that he needs". He needs to work more hours.

I hope he's doing all the housework, laundry, cooking etc if he's not working more than 10 hours a week?

cantbuylilt · 02/10/2021 08:31

Thanks, everyone. I'm a bit of a worrier and can be prone to overthinking!! Reading froggy's thread made me wonder if I was being unfair to him.

Someone asked our ages.. we're not young. I'm late 30s, he's late 40s.

OP posts:
seven201 · 02/10/2021 08:31

I couldn't be with someone like that. If you both worked normal full time hours then you could both retire earlier. He's expecting to be kept. Fine if he were a stay at home dad or something and you both wanted that. All the pressure is on you. I think the new glasses would be the last straw for me. He should just work a day or whatever and then get new glasses instead of cancelling appointments!

You need to have a serious chat about all this. I would resent my husband so much! He sounds lazy. I hope he at least does all the house admin, cleaning and maintenance?

timeisnotaline · 02/10/2021 08:29

I don’t think I could even be in a relationship with a healthy adult who worked 2-10 hours a week just because they felt like it. I certainly wouldn’t feel like helping them buy glasses. That is a completely different scenario to two people working full time who happen to be in different careers with different incomes - in that scenario I pool money. Ditto the scenario where one earns less because they have taken on parenting responsibilities- in that scenario everyone who doesn’t pool money or otherwise support their partner to care for their child isn’t fit to be in a relationship with.

AnneLovesGilbert · 02/10/2021 08:28

Is he doing 3/4 or more of the housework?

cantbuylilt · 02/10/2021 08:26

@MintJulia, I was ill about two years ago- ended up in intensive care and then had 6 months off to recover. Luckily, I was paid fully during that time, but there were moments when I didn't know how we could cope if I couldn't return to work before my sick pay ran out.

OP posts:
traintraveller · 02/10/2021 08:25

You know fine well you're not being selfish and you're drip feeding comments that will make all of MN agree with you that he's a cocklodger. So just split up.

Atalune · 02/10/2021 08:25

@cantbuylilt

He's not disabled, and we don't have children, so he's not caring for anyone but himself.

He regularly has contacts asking him to work, enough to fill an entire working week. He is good at his job, fast and accurate, so he's often in demand. However, it is freelance, so can be unpredictable.

He hasn't come right out and said that he just can't be bothered to work, but he has said that it's nice to have my steady wage coming in every month, that it takes the pressure off.

run, run for the hills! Do not have children with him. Get him out
MintJulia · 02/10/2021 08:23

So you're working full time and he's got his feet up. There is nothing wrong with him except he's lazy. Doesn't he have concerns about loading everything on you? What happens if you get ill or lose your job?
You've allowed this workshy freeloader to become a dependent.
Whatever you do, don't marry him. You deserve better.

Sparklfairy · 02/10/2021 08:23

He hasn't come right out and said that he just can't be bothered to work, but he has said that it's nice to have my steady wage coming in every month, that it takes the pressure off.

Thats an appalling attitude tbh. He won't change. He's happy to have you subsidise him. Are you sure you want to continue this relationship?

Limer · 02/10/2021 08:21

He hasn't come right out and said that he just can't be bothered to work, but he has said that it's nice to have my steady wage coming in every month, that it takes the pressure off.

Nice to have your steady wage coming in = he can't be bothered to work. Cocklodger.

MoiraRose4 · 02/10/2021 08:21

I couldn’t respect a man who chose to work 2-10 hours a week, with no disability or caring responsibilities, and yet couldn’t afford to buy himself new glasses or pull his financial weight in the household. I cannot understand why you would be ok with this.

Milkshake54 · 02/10/2021 08:17

Me and my DH were more financially independent from each other (although our salaries were very equal) until we had a baby. Then it went to proportional splits and pooled together a lot more money - because we need to. So it may change as life progresses?

cantbuylilt · 02/10/2021 08:16

He's not disabled, and we don't have children, so he's not caring for anyone but himself.

He regularly has contacts asking him to work, enough to fill an entire working week. He is good at his job, fast and accurate, so he's often in demand. However, it is freelance, so can be unpredictable.

He hasn't come right out and said that he just can't be bothered to work, but he has said that it's nice to have my steady wage coming in every month, that it takes the pressure off.

OP posts:
LemonTT · 02/10/2021 08:15

Some of the breadwinner and indeed homemaker issues are black and white. But there are grey areas particularly when either one of a couple isn’t pulling their weight in one or both of the roles. The question is of course, can they pull their weight and if so why aren’t they.

If you don’t like the answer and you resent being the person who subsides the other person it needs to confronted. In reality a lot of men and women subside their OH and never resent it. Or at least not until it breaks up.

My values would make this impossible for me to accept. I expect to pay my way in life not rely on anyone else to do it for me. Subsidising me is not an act of love and I find the concept abhorrent. I wouldn’t respect your DP because my values wouldn’t let me. I would feel the same if the genders were reversed.

Atalune · 02/10/2021 08:15

Does he have a mental or physical illness that prevents him from working? Or caring duties?

What you have is a cock lodger.

Sparklfairy · 02/10/2021 08:14

Why does he turn down work? What does he do with the rest of his time?

Do not marry him!

FinallyHere · 02/10/2021 08:13

AIBU to not pool our money?

Can you honestly not see any difference between supporting someone who is available for full time / better paid work and just doesn't work that much...

And someone who takes time off for maternity leave and then reduces their hours in order to look after joint children?

MattHancocksSexTape · 02/10/2021 08:13

He sounds a right catch. 2 - 10 hours a week and doesn’t pay his fair share.

Fireflygal · 02/10/2021 08:12

How old are you both? If he's at home more does he do all the chores? If he is choosing not to work or contribute to the house then YANBU.

Will you really continue to respect a person with such a work ethics? I would struggle with it.

Are you aware that your assets, savings, pensions, equity will be shared 50:50 if you marry and divorce?