Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is this selfish?

215 replies

cantbuylilt · 02/10/2021 08:00

Just reading on another thread about a couple where the man is a higher earner, and the woman is scraping by, with lots of people saying it's selfish of him to keep the money to himself.

I've been living with my partner for 6 years, together for a lot longer. We're not married yet, but are engaged. I am the higher earner. He used to earn more, but reduced hours gradually since we moved in together.

We each get paid into our own accounts and transfer money to the joint account. It works out at roughly 1/4 of outgoings is paid by him, and 3/4 by me. His wages vary month to month, depending on how much work he has picked up, or turned down.

Anything 'big', like kitchen appliances, holidays, new boiler etc is paid for by me. I also pay the water bill by myself, in one go for the year.

He recently cancelled an eye appointment, because he said he couldn't afford to buy new glasses. He lives in his overdraft most of the time and has no savings. For a while, about 3 years ago, he didn't work for a year and I paid for everything by myself during that time.

I know I do a lot, and pay my way. But just reading that other thread made me feel guilty, that I have plenty of money saved, but he is struggling to afford new glasses. Our old oven broke earlier this week, and I just bought a new one- he said he'd never be able to do that. However, he is capable of working more and could pick up more hours easily. He just doesn't want to.

AIBU to not pool our money?

OP posts:
DrinkFeckArseBrick · 02/10/2021 09:32

This is a completely different scenario. This has gone too far the other way and he is taking advantage of you. It takes the pressure off him knowing you have a steady wage coming in - yea because it's all on you.
Most people that worked 2-10 hours a week and couldn't afford new basics like glasses would just increase their hours until they could afford glasses. He pays what he can afford- I'd agree with that if he worked minimum wage full time and was trying his best. No, he actually pays what he can be arsed to earn.
He must be a perfect house husband and amazing in bed for you to put up with subsidising his whole life. I really hope if you share ownership of a house that you've protected you're share of what you've put in.

IceCreamAndCandyfloss · 02/10/2021 09:31

That wouldn’t be for me personally, there’s no way id live with someone who only did a token few hours and didn’t pay their half of costs let alone marry them.
Salary for me is irrelevant, it’s about a work ethic and not expecting another adult to pick up the costs of another.

HalzTangz · 02/10/2021 09:30

If he is struggling he needs to stop turning down work or find another jobs that gives both the hours and money

I wouldn't feel guilty for someone turning down jobs

Neveratruerfriend · 02/10/2021 09:28

I've been there myself, almost word for word. Married him. Divorced him (no children). He knew his rights - entitled for 50% of everything.

DON'T MARRY HIM.

DoItAfraid · 02/10/2021 09:25

@cantbuylilt

He's not disabled, and we don't have children, so he's not caring for anyone but himself.

He regularly has contacts asking him to work, enough to fill an entire working week. He is good at his job, fast and accurate, so he's often in demand. However, it is freelance, so can be unpredictable.

He hasn't come right out and said that he just can't be bothered to work, but he has said that it's nice to have my steady wage coming in every month, that it takes the pressure off.

Wow!! Shock

This would not work for me at all. How entitled.

What does he do for you?

nameswap48 · 02/10/2021 09:25

Him choosing to work less for personal reasons and the other OP taking care of a baby are two very different scenarios, it's not comparable.

But I have to say I wouldn't be marrying your man, my mum was in a very similar dynamic and it didn't end well, lots of built up resentment.

LivingLaVidaBabyShower · 02/10/2021 09:24

@cantbuylilt

He's not disabled, and we don't have children, so he's not caring for anyone but himself.

He regularly has contacts asking him to work, enough to fill an entire working week. He is good at his job, fast and accurate, so he's often in demand. However, it is freelance, so can be unpredictable.

He hasn't come right out and said that he just can't be bothered to work, but he has said that it's nice to have my steady wage coming in every month, that it takes the pressure off.

An able bodied man in good health only working 2-10 hours per week and expecting another adult to sub him?

No, thankyou. I could not respect/have sex with/marry a man like that.

And strongly advise against marriage to protect yourself if you want to continue the relationship

cantbuylilt · 02/10/2021 09:20

@Orla1970, the reduction in hours happened because the office started hot-desking and it became easier to just work from home instead, but that meant he became more picky about jobs accepted, rather than filling the three days in-office he used to work.

There's some mental health issues- he had a breakdown caused by work stress before we met, so work has always been a contentious issue for him.

The split of our financial contributions just evolved. He pays 'as much as he can afford', and I cover the rest. With me getting ill, and then Covid happening, I was just grateful that he was paying something rather than nothing.

OP posts:
Kuachui · 02/10/2021 09:20

Personally what's mine is my husbands and vice versa, I couldn't imagine not helping my husband out just as he's about to help me out with a big purchase next week.

Fireflygal · 02/10/2021 09:15

we're not young. I'm late 30s, he's late 40s

What are his plans for pension? If you two separated how would he cope financially.

Are you completely happy with this arrangement as you'll be working to support an adult who chooses not to financially look after himself.

Big difference if he was taking care of children or the house so that you both worked similar hours. If he has way more leisure time than you then it's a choice or lifestyle on his behalf.

I would love to work less, but I can't afford to so I don't.

Orla1970 · 02/10/2021 09:13

I think this situation is very different than Froggys. Have you had any discussion about him dropping or not picking up hours? So sounds like he doesn’t feel he has to work as you’ll cover everything. He has literally handed over all financial responsibility to you but without any agreement. What happens if you want to reduce your hours? I’m guessing that would be a no as not only are you supporting yourself , you’re supporting him. Is there any reason he does not want to work - depression etc? Seems odd that in his 40s he has just given up on his working life. I think you need a frank discussion with him and agree your expectations about what he contributes to the household. I’d be well pissed off if my husband just decided to reduce his hours so drastically and without agreement. Good Luck OP x

HouseOfFire · 02/10/2021 09:12

@MatildaIThink

You only have to read the comment with "cocklodger", where a man lives with a woman but does not contribute much, but there is no "pussylodger" alternative for the women who don't contribute much and live off a man.
no, it goes both ways - i dont care what sex you are, if you dont pull your weight, with either housework, finances etc then you are a cocklodger, or a fannylodger

Most of the posts here on Mumsnet are from the view of a woman who is asking for advice

DressBitch · 02/10/2021 09:12

He's taking the piss and you know that.

TumtumTree · 02/10/2021 09:11

@MatildaIThink have you seen the bit about how the OP pays the far more than her share of the bills and her DP works between 2-10 hours a week by choice and has no other caring responsibilities? I agree there's no exact female equivalent to cocklodger, but if someone started this same thread with the sexes reversed, posters would definitely be calling the woman lazy and sponging.

HairyScaryMonster · 02/10/2021 09:05

I'd only pool if he was working at least 30 hours per week. He's a cock lodger!

Sparklfairy · 02/10/2021 08:57

@MatildaIThink by default the housework and childcare tends to fall to the woman, so if she's the higher earner and the man is doing fuck all in the house, then yes, he's a cocklodger.

Its all about whether both partners are pulling their weight. This man is actively turning down work and admits he likes having her steady wage to fall back on!

MaeD · 02/10/2021 08:56

How can you possibly feel guilty when he barely works, picks and chooses his hours, contributes far less than you because he’s chosen to barely work and piggybacks off your hard work to live, while spending his money on vaping and computer games like a teenager with a Saturday job.

Why aren’t you furious and ready to break up with. this cocklodger? What are his good points that are so incredible it makes up for this total lack of respect for you and drive to do anything with his life?

Does he do most of the housework? Cook you amazing dinners each night as you’ve been working while he plays video games? Is he constantly supportive, amazing in bed and lightens your emotional and practical load because he has the time and energy to do so since your doing most of the working hours while he gets loads of leisure time?

ScarlettSunset · 02/10/2021 08:53

@MatildaIThink

On Mumsnet, as a general rule, if the man is the high earner people will say he should share, if the woman is the high earner then then people will say she should not share. The biased audience skews the response.
I don't think that's true at all. If a woman could work and contribute but chooses not to, then she's a sponger too. And I've seen lots of posts on here where people point this out. I personally don't like the term cocklodger though, as I suspect financially abusive would be a more appropriate term in many cases
Hugsgalore · 02/10/2021 08:53

He is definitely a piss taker OP. I personally couldn't marry someone who chooses not to work for selfish reasons. I think he would get worse if you do get married. I don't think telling him to work more will work either because he sounds like he is just bone lazy. I don't say this much on here but I would cut my losses on this relationship and dump him.

user1471462115 · 02/10/2021 08:52

How the heck does he pay his half of the bills, the rent, the food, the costs of a trip out or a pint in the pub ???

Can I move in too, and you can pay everything for me.

You situation is so different to the other poster as it could possibly be. Wake up and get him paying his way.

MatildaIThink · 02/10/2021 08:51

You only have to read the comment with "cocklodger", where a man lives with a woman but does not contribute much, but there is no "pussylodger" alternative for the women who don't contribute much and live off a man.

MatildaIThink · 02/10/2021 08:49

On Mumsnet, as a general rule, if the man is the high earner people will say he should share, if the woman is the high earner then then people will say she should not share. The biased audience skews the response.

PerseverancePays · 02/10/2021 08:47

I don’t think he’ll ever have your back. He’s there while the going is good. Is he vaping cannabis, gaming into the night? Not a keeper I’m afraid, he can’t even cover his own basic needs let alone work enough hours to meet you half way. He just has no commitment at all.

MadeOfStarStuff · 02/10/2021 08:46

Ok so he’s a cocklodger then. Do not combine your finances. Do not buy stuff for him that he could easily buy himself if he bothered to get off his arse and work more. Do not marry him unless he starts pulling his weight. He doesn’t need to be a high earner but just choosing not to work because he can sponge off you is unreasonable and not an attractive quality.

It’s a very different situation from someone refusing to support a partner who has had income reduced due to maternity/caring responsibilities, disability or losing their job through no fault of their own but trying to get a new job

EmoIsntDead · 02/10/2021 08:45

He hasn't come right out and said that he just can't be bothered to work, but he has said that it's nice to have my steady wage coming in every month, that it takes the pressure off

Cocklodger alert! Why are you kidding this lazy arsehoke take advantage of you? How on earth can you have any respect for him?