Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is this selfish?

215 replies

cantbuylilt · 02/10/2021 08:00

Just reading on another thread about a couple where the man is a higher earner, and the woman is scraping by, with lots of people saying it's selfish of him to keep the money to himself.

I've been living with my partner for 6 years, together for a lot longer. We're not married yet, but are engaged. I am the higher earner. He used to earn more, but reduced hours gradually since we moved in together.

We each get paid into our own accounts and transfer money to the joint account. It works out at roughly 1/4 of outgoings is paid by him, and 3/4 by me. His wages vary month to month, depending on how much work he has picked up, or turned down.

Anything 'big', like kitchen appliances, holidays, new boiler etc is paid for by me. I also pay the water bill by myself, in one go for the year.

He recently cancelled an eye appointment, because he said he couldn't afford to buy new glasses. He lives in his overdraft most of the time and has no savings. For a while, about 3 years ago, he didn't work for a year and I paid for everything by myself during that time.

I know I do a lot, and pay my way. But just reading that other thread made me feel guilty, that I have plenty of money saved, but he is struggling to afford new glasses. Our old oven broke earlier this week, and I just bought a new one- he said he'd never be able to do that. However, he is capable of working more and could pick up more hours easily. He just doesn't want to.

AIBU to not pool our money?

OP posts:
Tistheseason17 · 02/10/2021 12:53

Wow!
I earn double what my DH does but that happened over time and he still works full time. And he still does 75% of house chores as I work longer hours.
He could retire in 5 yrs and we have discussed that if he does, I will, too, as I'm not working my ass off to pay for the nice holidays etc whilst he chills.
Thankfully, we are on the same page and have always been.

He would never drop hours to live off me!!

Get out now, OP, before your pension gets taken, too!!!! He's a freeloader.
Or, get a solicitor in to protect your financial position.

KatharinaRosalie · 02/10/2021 12:49

Ask him what will happen if you also want to go freelance and work 2 hours per week. If he says you can't, why does he think he should have that option and not you?

BoredZelda · 02/10/2021 12:41

If you are married and committed to sharing a life together, YABU.

If a husband decides to stop working, just because he feels like it, a wife is being unreasonable if she chooses not to fund his lifestyle?

Phobiaphobic · 02/10/2021 12:37

If you're not married and in a casual relationship, YANBU. If you are married and committed to sharing a life together, YABU.

Seeingadistance · 02/10/2021 12:37

@Martinisarebetterdirty

Sorry but do not marry this man. He will be entitled to half of everything. He’s choosing to not work and you’re paying for so much.
I agree.

Don’t marry him.

MayorGoodwaysChicken · 02/10/2021 12:34

Wow do not marry this man!!! He’s a lazy freeloader, why on earth are you even tolerating this in a boyfriend never mind considering marrying him!! This is his behaviour before he has the legal security of half your assets-how on earth do you think he will behave AFTER marriage! Honestly this is one of those threads where I’m just astounded at what some people put up with…to coin a mumsnet favourite, he must have a solid good cock.

There’s being a lower earner and there’s just not working for no reason other than he can’t be arsed Confused Honestly, raise your bar.

theDudesmummy · 02/10/2021 12:32

It works fine when the woman earns more (or my case all) as long as the man has an equally important contribution to make. DH can't earn the money I can. I can't do any of the millions of things he does. It works fine.

LadyVersacee · 02/10/2021 12:31

What exactly does he bring to this relationship, OP? It must be something pretty fantastic that you’re willing to overlook him working TWO hours a week whilst you fund this life style?

UmbrellaDrops · 02/10/2021 12:30

In my experience it never works when the woman earns more, especially if his spending habits or lack of ambition translates into you not being able to enjoy the money you earn or save. A marriage imo should be an equal partnership. All the best op.

BoredZelda · 02/10/2021 12:23

If he is choosing not to work and live off your earnings, then it’s not fair that you subsidise him. If he can’t work or is providing childcare and enabling you to earn more then it is fair that you subsidise him. If he were on a low wage and working full time but he just happens to be in a lower paid job, but because you are living together he can’t top up with benefits then you would chip in too.

I honestly can’t believe you need to ask the question.

Muchmorethan · 02/10/2021 12:21

Op - a lazy man is so unattractive... He sees you as his bank now and Pension later.

Is this really what you want from a relationship?

Bagamoyo1 · 02/10/2021 12:15

@MrsKeats

I have no understanding of a relationship in which you would you would let a partner struggle to buy essentials. Just awful.
Have you read the rest of the thread? The glasses aren’t broken, he doesn’t actually need new ones. He chooses not to work. He spends what little money he has on snacks, gaming and vaping. He sleeps and games and pisses about with music all day. There are no kids, no disability.
Lovemusic33 · 02/10/2021 12:06

He sounds very lazy, he could work more but chooses not too whilst you work full time and pay for everything? He has no reason not to work more, you don’t have young children to care for (chances are if you did he wouldn’t be providing the child care anyway). I would be telling him he need to pay his way or move out.

cakewench · 02/10/2021 12:06

(Sorry OP I've only just seen that you're unable to have children, I apologise I should have read all of the posts but I was just so irritated on your behalf! )

cakewench · 02/10/2021 12:04

Please, listen to your own concerns you have over marrying this man. Money and/or differences in approaches to spending are some of the top reasons for divorce. You are already in this situation and you aren't even married yet.

"Love" changes over time and you're in a partnership for the long haul. He will be like this forever. Is that what you want for your forever?

And if you have children, I suspect he will all of a sudden find work to do in just the times of day when it would be useful for him to be free.

The situations in other threads are often 1) working PT because they are limited because of the childcare duties they have or 2) someone working full time but just on a lower wage. Yes there are other reasons as well, but those are the more common ones, and he is neither. He has no reason to only work 10 hours a week other than he'd rather not. Well, wouldn't we all Confused

His comment about how it's 'nice' that you've got a regular wage coming in is also a bit rage inducing. Just get rid.

optingout · 02/10/2021 12:01

Why are you with this lazy, selfish man @cantbuylilt? It's no coincidence that he dropped his house after moving in with you. I couldn't respect a healthy man with no caring responsibilities who chose to sponge off me. Don't you think you deserve an equal partner who takes equal responsibility for paying the bills?

Ugzbugz · 02/10/2021 11:57

What would happen if you wanted to work 2 hours a week?

Rub for the hills and never marry him.

ScaredOfDinosaurs · 02/10/2021 11:56

@RiverSkater what happened, did you get out?

ScaredOfDinosaurs · 02/10/2021 11:55

He's a freeloader, sorry. He really is taking you for a mug here. If he's healthy and has no other responsibility then why shouldn't he be earning more and paying half?

CaptSkippy · 02/10/2021 11:53

I know I will get a flak for this, but I wonder at some of the posters defending this man. Do they perhaps recognize parts of themselves in his behavior? Because I seriously doubt any of them would want to be mooched off in this way.

Neveranynamesleft · 02/10/2021 11:51

OP after all the posts I seriously hope that you have grasped the general consensus of opinion. He either steps up or steps out. You deserve better, someone who is willing to put more effort into your relationship and not see you as a blank cheque. What exactly do you get out of this set up ???

KaycePollard · 02/10/2021 11:50

He hasn't come right out and said that he just can't be bothered to work, but he has said that it's nice to have my steady wage coming in every month, that it takes the pressure off.

So he’s a lazy cocklodger. Don’t marry him.

If there are no children, does he at least do almost all the housework and domestic admin? What does he bring to the partnership?

Does not sound like a good marriage prospect to me. He seems to assume that you will pretty much pay just for the pleasure of his company.

RiverSkater · 02/10/2021 11:50

@cantbuylilt

He's not disabled, and we don't have children, so he's not caring for anyone but himself.

He regularly has contacts asking him to work, enough to fill an entire working week. He is good at his job, fast and accurate, so he's often in demand. However, it is freelance, so can be unpredictable.

He hasn't come right out and said that he just can't be bothered to work, but he has said that it's nice to have my steady wage coming in every month, that it takes the pressure off.

He is just lazy and plans on living off you.

I was in a similar position. My DP was freelance and if work didn't appear, he just didn't work. He never tried to get work and in quiet times had no work. He loved that I hadn't very good job and paid for everything, deposit for house, everything for the baby. Then I was made redundant. Then one of his freelancing jobs came to an end. He kept saying you can walk into a 50k job anytime can't you and I said errr no, I've just had a baby.
He could not step up to be the responsible one. He would not get a full time job. We'd scrape by every month and I was petrified we'd lose the house, I lost all respect for him. He didn't want a partner or girlfriend, he wanted a mother to look after him.

Don't be me. Don't marry him.

3luckystars · 02/10/2021 11:50

I know it was unusual years ago for people to talk about mental health issues, and having time off work because of it, but it is far more common now. In most cases, with help, people can return to work. It is common enough in the emergency services to have a break, but then go back to work. There is a lot more support now. I’m probably not wording this very well but what I’m trying to say is that, what he went through with work is not that unusual anymore and it might be possible for him to return to work again. A lot of people do. It’s not the end of persons career if they go through a crisis.

What is he doing with the rest of his time?
I just wanted to wish you all the best.

sst1234 · 02/10/2021 11:46

@MrsKeats

I have no understanding of a relationship in which you would you would let a partner struggle to buy essentials. Just awful.
Of course you don’t. Because you spectacularly missed the point of this thread. Did you even read it?