Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To have shouted at dog?

89 replies

RubiMurray · 02/10/2021 07:08

I went for a walk along the riverbank yesterday. It’s quite isolated and peaceful, just farms etc - rarely see anyone. Suddenly a Dobermann comes running out of nowhere, no owner in sight. It spots me and stops dead just staring at me. I stop in my tracks hoping an owner is around. Then it bolts towards me barking. I shit myself and start move backwards knowing full well I’m not going to be able to outrun the bloody thing. It reaches me and stands in front of me barking and growling at which point I start shouting “help!” The dog gets more hyped and and is jumping around all heckles raised barking and air snapping. Finally a woman comes running shouting at me to stop shouting (!!??), she’s calling the dog who isn’t taking a blind bit of notice. She finally reaches us, puts a lead on the dog and starts to drag it away (it’s still barking at me) and as she turns to walk off she says “shouting at a dog will only wind it up!” I reply “well I’m sorry but having a big fuck off Dobermann barking and growling at you is rather frightening! Why isn’t it on a lead??” She replied “did he bite you? No so what’s your problem? Stop being dramatic” !!!

WIBU to panic and shout??

OP posts:
Birdkin · 02/10/2021 10:23

Situations like this are my nightmare.

I was chased by an aggressive dog as a child and I am scared by even friendly dogs jumping at me now let alone being growled at by an angry doberman! People need to keep their uncontrolled dogs on leads

Cheesepuff1 · 02/10/2021 10:21

@FateHasRedesignedMost that would be a big risk to take with a doberman and disasterous if it backfired. but in any case shouting "help" is unlikely to have been the firm voice a dog would need.

CollieDug · 02/10/2021 10:20

@Mischance

What do we do? So many dog owners just seem to think they own the world. That every member of the public should put up with anything from their beloved pooch.

I am afraid it induces fury in me. How dare they be so arrogant?

I have a disability + osteoporosis + a balance problem. If a dog jumps up at me I am likely to fall over - and if I do I am bound to break a bone. What should I do? - stay at home?

You are right that so many dog owners are terrible (evidenced by a few of the idiotic responses on here too)

It is my responsibility and mine alone to ensure my dog does not approach people, jump up on people or cause any person to be scared.

It should be no-one’s responsibility to “learn”the correct response to an aggressive dog - it is the owner’s responsibility to control the dog.

You are right to be furious. I am furious too (as my son was also terrified of dogs due to idiotic dog owners thinking that their “friendly” dog jumping all over him was the best way for him to realise that dogs are just fine)

Maverickess · 02/10/2021 10:18

Shouting around an already defensive/ready to attack dog may well cause the dog to get worse. So in the interests of the dog not attacking in that situation, shouting may encourage an attack.
However, OP should not have been in that situation to start with because the dog should have been under control, no one should be in that situation, because all dogs should be under control, and the owner caused the situation because the dog wasn't under control.
The dog, nor the OP were unreasonable, the owner was, and further so by the way she reacted to OP following the situation.
The sad fact is that people are put into these situations because of others lack of responsibility, and in those cases knowing how to respond to hopefully avoid the situation escalating is important, because it's not going to ease the pain and fear of being bitten to know that you shouldn't have to know what to do, because the situation should never have arisen in the first place.

FinallyHere · 02/10/2021 10:18

Your are certainly not being unreasonable.

In any similar situation (to be fair, I've never experienced a big Doberman), I point out that if they can't control their dogs, the dog should not be off the lead .

And am Astonished by just how many dogs are let off the lead without reliable recall.

One of my walking friends is terrified of dogs. I can see that this would completely put them off walking.

FateHasRedesignedMost · 02/10/2021 10:16

by all means shout at the owner once the dog is under control , but to shout at the dog as the OPs thread title suggests will clearly have got her nowhere and if anything she's lucky it didn't escalate the problem

Many dogs will back down and run off if you shout and act like you’re a threat not prey or a plaything to terrorise.

FateHasRedesignedMost · 02/10/2021 10:15

Hope you’re ok, what a horrible experience.

Not U to shout at it, but if a dog ever lunges like that again (barking, growling, air snapping) you’d be better off standing your ground yelling aggressively and angrily at it, rather than screaming and showing fear.

I had to learn fast how to deal with aggressive dogs as my own large dog is dog-reactive (great with people and always on a lead). But other dog-reactive dogs off lead sometimes try to attack him. He can deal with one dog but not a pair of dogs attacking him.

As soon as I see an aggressive dog(s) approaching I start yelling ‘Stop! Get back! Leave it!’ If I’ve got my dog with me he starts barking and growling back, so I shout a warning to the owner to get her dog or I’ll let mine off to defend himself.

If I’m alone and an aggressive dog approaches (very rare but it’s happened a handful of times) I do the same firm ‘no, leave it’ stance and shout to the owner to get her dog before it gets hurt. Funny how they come running when they think their dog is in danger!

I’ve recently taken to carrying an old hunting whip with a lash, as cracking a whip in the air deters most dogs and will stop 2 dogs fighting as they look up to see what the bang was. I’ve never had to use the whip on a dog but I would if one was trying to bite me!

MrsSkylerWhite · 02/10/2021 10:14

Do you have a camera phone? If it’s possible, go with a friend for the next few walks. If you see this woman and her dog again, photograph and report to dog warden, detailing your previous interaction. She needs a talking to and the dog needs training.

WoodchipNightmares · 02/10/2021 10:14

The dog owner was a twat.

BUT if this ever happens to you again it's worth knowing that the best way to deescalate the situation is to turn away from the dog, keep your hands in (hug yourself) and be quiet. Basically, do your best impression of a tree. The dog is much less likely to perceive you as a threat and therefore is less likely to bite.

While I can understand why you shouted, it's going to escalate the situation as the dog will perceive you as more of a threat. Running is going to trigger a chasing instinct in the dog and will be futile anyway as the dog can run faster.

Cheesepuff1 · 02/10/2021 10:13

@echt OK you're just being an idiot now. if your aim is to get bitten then yes fuck what the dog thought ...

echt · 02/10/2021 10:12

The OP clearly says *It reaches me and stands in front of me barking and growling at which point I start shouting “help!”

She was calling for assistance.

Fuck what the dog thought.

Peace43 · 02/10/2021 10:11

I have a dog and love dogs and that would have freaked me out!

Mischance · 02/10/2021 10:09

What do we do? So many dog owners just seem to think they own the world. That every member of the public should put up with anything from their beloved pooch.

I am afraid it induces fury in me. How dare they be so arrogant?

I have a disability + osteoporosis + a balance problem. If a dog jumps up at me I am likely to fall over - and if I do I am bound to break a bone. What should I do? - stay at home?

Cheesepuff1 · 02/10/2021 10:08

@echt so what? who whole point of the post is that the woman says this:

"Finally a woman comes running shouting at me to stop shouting (!!??)... and as she turns to walk off she says “shouting at a dog will only wind it up!”

shouting at any dog you are worried is going to attack you will of course wind it up and put you in danger , so whilst the dog SHOULD have been on a lead an not able to do this, the OP has done the wrong thing for her own safety in the situation she found herself in.
by all means shout at the owner once the dog is under control , but to shout at the dog as the OPs thread title suggests will clearly have got her nowhere and if anything she's lucky it didn't escalate the problem.

billy1966 · 02/10/2021 10:03

I hope you got a photo.
Definitely report.

Cherrysoup · 02/10/2021 10:00

I’d shit my pants and I have dogs! I find Doberman’s very scary and any dog galloping at you barking sounds terrifying. I remember picking my two up from the kennels one day and the owner’s new Rottweiler pelting at me (for cuddles, as it turned out). I was very worried!

echt · 02/10/2021 09:55

[quote Cheesepuff1]@echt yes the dog doesn't know what someone is shouting for do they.. they just see shouting[/quote]
So what? The person was alone and needed help.

DrinkingWishingSmokingHoping · 02/10/2021 09:54

@RickJames

Pepper spray. It will save you and doesn't injure the dog, just disables it temporarily. You can get the sprays from outdoor stores, its specifically for animal attacks - just remember to only carry it in the wilderness and not take it shopping, to pubs etc.

Im so sorry this happened. I'd have been terrified.

Pepper spray is illegal in the UK. What a stupid comment.
Cheesepuff1 · 02/10/2021 09:53

@echt yes the dog doesn't know what someone is shouting for do they.. they just see shouting

echt · 02/10/2021 09:41

[quote Cheesepuff1]@CollieDug if you bother to read the actual responses in the thread you will see I said whist it's not unnatural and understandable that she did it, its not the safest response and could have out her in more danger[/quote]
She was calling for help. Read the OP's OP.

Or is calling for help provoking the dog? Hmm

echt · 02/10/2021 09:40

[quote Cheesepuff1]@echt
the title is AIBU to have shouted at a dog.... so based on it being dangerous to have done so, the point is yes she is being unreasonable.[/quote]
But the body of thread said something more nuanced.

HelloChompy · 02/10/2021 09:38

I've been a lifelong dog owner and work with dogs now and I am of the opinion that a significant proportion of people should not own dogs. This woman is one of them. She clearly had no control of her dog and probably got so defensive because she was embarrassed.

Blah1881 · 02/10/2021 09:29

I’d be reporting this to the local police. Imagine if you were a child or young adult walking on your own encountering this. This owner is taking no responsibility for her dangerous dog and the dog will 100% do this again. YANBU. Sorry this happened to you, you must be shaken.

Etonmessisyum · 02/10/2021 09:18

Dog is an arsehole owner a total dick honestly who thinks it’s ok to allow a dog who behaves like that off lead and out of sight with no training/recall THEN shout at someone their dog scared the shit out of I like dogs but it’s would be lucky all I did was shout at it. I have a very bouncy retriever hes 1 that’s what they do, but he’s kept on lead because people don’t want muddy paws and a licky dog face in their faces - he’s tall and loves people he’s much calmer but it’s a work in progress and he’s not allowed to practice bad behaviour so is under control.

Cheesepuff1 · 02/10/2021 09:18

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk guidelines.