Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To have shouted at dog?

89 replies

RubiMurray · 02/10/2021 07:08

I went for a walk along the riverbank yesterday. It’s quite isolated and peaceful, just farms etc - rarely see anyone. Suddenly a Dobermann comes running out of nowhere, no owner in sight. It spots me and stops dead just staring at me. I stop in my tracks hoping an owner is around. Then it bolts towards me barking. I shit myself and start move backwards knowing full well I’m not going to be able to outrun the bloody thing. It reaches me and stands in front of me barking and growling at which point I start shouting “help!” The dog gets more hyped and and is jumping around all heckles raised barking and air snapping. Finally a woman comes running shouting at me to stop shouting (!!??), she’s calling the dog who isn’t taking a blind bit of notice. She finally reaches us, puts a lead on the dog and starts to drag it away (it’s still barking at me) and as she turns to walk off she says “shouting at a dog will only wind it up!” I reply “well I’m sorry but having a big fuck off Dobermann barking and growling at you is rather frightening! Why isn’t it on a lead??” She replied “did he bite you? No so what’s your problem? Stop being dramatic” !!!

WIBU to panic and shout??

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
waybill · 02/10/2021 15:24

@Deathraystare

What is it with these stupid fucking dog owners? If it is like this with people it doesn't know it should be on a lead. Some people are really scared of dogs, mainly because of their twattish owners.
Yes. Exactly it in a nutshell.
Watchingyou2sleezes · 02/10/2021 15:20

Wield arrgh c**ty auto correct

Happenchance · 02/10/2021 15:19

@CatOfTheLand

So what are you supposed to do then if you genuinely think you're going to be attacked by a dog? I'm not talking about a dog coming over to you, but if you're in OP's situation and the dog is at the point of attack
I wouldn't say that this dog was at the point of attack.

Most dogs are aggressive because they are scared, so the best thing to do is replicate dog body language to show that you are not a threat, i.e. calming signals. My go-to body language when I'm in this situation is to look away from the dog, remain still but relaxed and do big slow yawns (without covering my mouth). Without looking directly at the dog, I observe it for signs that it is relaxing in response to my calming signals, i.e., offering calming signals of it's own. E.g., the last time I was threatened by an off lead dog, the dog stopped barking and moved towards me in a zig-zag whilst sniffing the ground, clearly indicating that he was coming in peace. I continued my calming signals until he had finished sniffing me and continued on his way.

Watchingyou2sleezes · 02/10/2021 15:19

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk guidelines.

MissMaple82 · 02/10/2021 15:04

We only have one side of the story here..

WiddlinDiddlin · 02/10/2021 15:00

What a twat.. her not you.

If that happens again though - stand still, back up if you must but DON'T RUN... fold your arms up, tuck hands away under armpits and try to turn sideways on to the dog rather than staring directly at it...

And if you have to shout, telling the dog to FUCK OFF or SIT! or DON'T YOU DARE is likely to be better, using your absolute best voice of doom.

Shouting or screaming in a high pitched way IS likely to make matters worse, yes - which is still NOT your fault, its still the owners fault, because her dog absolutely was 'dangerously out of control in a public place' and exhibited behaviour that gave you 'reasonable apprehension of injury'.

If you have any way of reporting it to the police or dog warden, id do so , but it isn't easy if you don't know where the dog lives.

Sommernacht89 · 02/10/2021 14:55

There are twatish dogowners,twatish non dogowners,twatish children,twatish parents,twatish catowners etc etc. The dog owner in your case has an anxious,nervous Doberman and is not aware of the potential danger and thinks in shouting at you will make HER problem go away.It is true though,shouting at an aggitated dog is a very bad reaction.Try,if you can to ignore the dog and simply walk on without any shouting or any attention to the dog.I know,this is difficult to do when you are frightened,but belief me, you are much safer in this way to pass the dog.Of course it should not be your job to have to do this,but the reality is,there will always be twatish dogowners,as well as non twatish dogowners.you were unfortunate to meet a twat.I have to extremely well behaved and friendly Border Collies and belief me,I have come across some very twatish children and parents.Luckily 97%of people and dogs are friendly,albeit not very well trained!

FateHasRedesignedMost · 02/10/2021 12:07

This terrifies me as a reactive dog owner. If he would have approached us while out walking my dog albeit muzzled would have gone for the kill. And ultimately one or both would have had to be put down

If an off lead dog attacks your on-lead one, your dog is acting in self defence even if he kills the other dog.

I keep mine leashed but not muzzled as he can’t defend himself muzzled. He’s fine with humans, even kids scooting into him or trying to climb on his back unnoticed!

But if a large dog came at him aggressively he’d also go for the kill. I’d have to drop the lead, but ultimately the lead would still be attached and is proof yours was under control and the other wasn’t.

vivainsomnia · 02/10/2021 11:34

You acted in justified fear in this instance. She should have apologised not berated you.

ImaBraveNhsHero · 02/10/2021 11:30

The type of owner that lets their dog run around barking at people always says shit like that ime. Like, you wouldn't have been shouting if the dog wasn't out of control. But they don't see it that way because they don't like taking responsibility. For anything, probably.

ThanksIGotItInMorrisons · 02/10/2021 11:26

As a dog owner I hate these fucking morons. I’m sure had the dog encountered a small child who ran away in fright screaming , or went towards it to pat it ( heavens above!) that she would still have had the same attitude. Some people deserve to be eaten by their own dogs while they sleep.

ProfSprout · 02/10/2021 11:11

Have taught my dc to turn their backs, heads down, stay quiet & still & tuck their fingers / hands in.

Am glad they know what to do but find it incredibly frustrating that I should have to teach them this - if dogs don’t have perfect recall they shouldn’t be off lead, full stop.

Purplecatshopaholic · 02/10/2021 11:02

@Deathraystare

What is it with these stupid fucking dog owners? If it is like this with people it doesn't know it should be on a lead. Some people are really scared of dogs, mainly because of their twattish owners.
This! And I am a dog lover and owner. People like this that give us all a bad name
NoSquirrels · 02/10/2021 10:56

How terrifying, OP. I hope you have reported to your local police or dog warden.

I love dogs, I have a huge soft spot for Dobermans and Rottweilers in particular, having never met a nasty one, but they’ve always been well trained soppy buggers. But they only get well trained through good, responsible, intelligent owners who understand that a poorly trained dog of these breeds is an absolute danger.

As PPs said - if a barking dog approaches turn away/to the side, don’t make eye contact, keep very still - definitely don’t run away. But I you can’t be unreasonable for panicking in that situation. Flowers

longtompot · 02/10/2021 10:51

This has been recommended, not sure if on here or on FB

I've shouted at dogs who run at me and my dog, generally shouting AWAY! It's instinct to do so I think. The owner was unreasonable letting their dog just wander around especially if it's known to bark at people like that.

www.police-supplies.co.uk/k917-dog-deterrent-spray?gclid=CjwKCAjwyvaJBhBpEiwA8d38vJ84W-Y8dXzjmzWQHV0TDYMYsRRBMCVx65dGZMUunsPJ8cFZvNZ5ShoCXh0QAvD_BwE#product-tabs

icedcoffees · 02/10/2021 10:46

YANBU at all. Her dog was totally out of control and she could actually be reported under the Dangerous Dogs Act.

The law changed a few years ago, and it now states that a dog no longer needs to bite to be considered a danger - if you feel threatened by a dogs' behaviour (growling, jumping at you, snarling, snapping) then you can report the dog and owner.

I hope you're okay Flowers

Scautish · 02/10/2021 10:46

[quote Cheesepuff1]@CollieDug . trying to make this about sexual violence is dispicable and YOU should be ashamed of yourself[/quote]
You clearly don’t understand the point I’m making but I’m going to put it down to ignorance rather than malice.

Doodle2021 · 02/10/2021 10:45

This terrifies me as a reactive dog owner. If he would have approached us while out walking my dog albeit muzzled would have gone for the kill. And ultimately one or both would have had to be put down.
I take no prisoners now with people that have their dog off lead with no recall. Their one fucking job is to ensure their dog comes back when called if they are let off lead. I do and have regularly kicked their dog to get it away from mine.

The dobermans owner one day will realise this when their dog approaches a reactive dog and gets its face torn off.

People should have licenses to have dogs and i think there widely needs to be the law that dogs remain on lead unless in a designated dog park.

Cheesepuff1 · 02/10/2021 10:44

@CollieDug and you've actually argued against yourself with your comment. if you froze when u were assaulted then u went quiet and still to limit to effects and damage u thought someone was going to do to you. exactly what someone dealing with an aggressive dog would be advised to do.

Summersnake · 02/10/2021 10:43

Also ,walking sticks ,for actual walking ,my dh has some for hills .
Take them with you on all walks ,you can use them to keep some distance between yourself and a dog ,or hit the dog if it goes for you ..I say that as an owner of 3 dogs ..one of mine won’t come back ,so he doesn’t get let off unless we are in the enclosed area alone

Cheesepuff1 · 02/10/2021 10:38

@CollieDug . trying to make this about sexual violence is dispicable and YOU should be ashamed of yourself

Summersnake · 02/10/2021 10:38

Next time get your phone out and film the dog and owner ..hand over to police / dog warden.

FateHasRedesignedMost · 02/10/2021 10:35

that would be a big risk to take with a doberman and disasterous if it backfired. but in any case shouting "help" is unlikely to have been the firm voice a dog would need

I agree it could be disastrous if it backfired, but the dog was already jumping and air snapping at her so it sounds past the point of de-escalation.

I guess I’ve developed a firm no-nonsense ‘dog’ voice from training my own large breed, so other dogs hear the authority in it.

OP another technique in that situation (where a bite is imminent) us to put something between yourself and the dog (your handbag, jacket, umbrella, anything that will protect you if it does lunge for a bite).

CollieDug · 02/10/2021 10:35

[quote Cheesepuff1]@CollieDug your comments are as ridiculous as suggesting for example that people shouldn't learn basic self defence , as no 1 else in the world should ever attack them.. its completely idealistic and of no help when something actually goes wrong.[/quote]
Doubling down on the victim blaming I see.

Yes you have made me see I was an idiot for freezing when I was sexually assaulted and not putting into practice my brown-belt in ju jutsu (which I have, I’m not being rhetorical).

  1. No we shouldn’t live in a society where are blamed for not have learnt the optimal way to response to aggression
  1. Fight or flight - how we respond is not alway within our conscious control even if we have a theoretical understanding of what we should do.

I find your views despicable.

Cheesepuff1 · 02/10/2021 10:23

@CollieDug your comments are as ridiculous as suggesting for example that people shouldn't learn basic self defence , as no 1 else in the world should ever attack them.. its completely idealistic and of no help when something actually goes wrong.