Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Food is too cheap ?

261 replies

Loveshelly · 01/10/2021 23:08

Food has never been cheaper, meat is unbelievably cheap. Even with a conscious move towards less meat consumption it’s clear that huge consumption of cheap meat is going on.

AIBU to think that we all need to spend more on our produce, especially in the wake of brexit, we clearly cannot rely on cheap labour anymore. So we are going to have to pay more.

All I tend to see on MN is people desperate to get food bills down, then on another thread people fretting they can’t keep heating on all night.

Have we become totally skewed about what are the things we should be spending more and less on.

OP posts:
CardiganAddict · 02/10/2021 07:54

Food, clothes, housing and electricity should be cheap or at least have cheap options in our society.
It's not up to poor people to pay extra to solve the issues that we have with animal welfare and sustainability.
Our system should be built, instead to sort it out

SushiGo · 02/10/2021 07:52

@EagleOrIgel

Food is, and has been for at least the past 15 years, extremely cheap in the UK. I'm almost astonished about all the threads saying "I can do my monthly shop for £xx" when it would cost me that for a week. There was even someone saying she done a 2 week shop for £22 the other day. That stuck in my head because something must be seriously wrong if food for (one person?) for two weeks, or even one week if I've remembered incorrectly, is only £22. How can that cover decent production and transport costs?
Re a £22 shop - depends if it was 'yellow label' or not when we were in food poverty I was going to the nearest supermarket at mark down time most days to buy as much as I could for 10p each. Loaves of bread, veg etc
Ploorfuzzle · 02/10/2021 07:50

However, food production was heavily subsidised by cheap labour and literal subsidises from the EU.

The government have reformed subsidies to farmers to be fairer (EU was largely about how much land they owned, rather than about how much was utilised to actually produce stuff etc), but farmers will still receive one.

SushiGo · 02/10/2021 07:48

Did you grow up rurally? The reason many farms go bust is also because of property costs.

Farms where the farmers own the land typically do fine, and are often extremely wealthy. Those where the farmers are tenants have massive rent bills to pay and can struggle.

So the fact that housing/land costs are expensive for everyone can't be untied from whether food is too cheap or not.

However, food production was heavily subsidised by cheap labour and literal subsidises from the EU. Most farmers voted for brexit. You reap what you sow.

silentpool · 02/10/2021 07:48

I get what you are saying, OP. In other countries food prices are more reflective of the cost of production. Wages in the UK have been held down by massive movements of labour in the last 2 decades and the subsidy of low income workers, through the tax system.(allowing employers to pay less)

Cheap labour meant food prices could be low. However, the stagnation of wages across the board, while everything else has gone up massively, means that people can't absorb the real cost of food. When I was still living in London, my rent was 60% of my take home pay - it doesn't leave much room to absorb rises.

What's the answer? Wages have to increase and so does the cost of money to stop asset inflation. Will it though? I'm sceptical.

bogeythefungusman · 02/10/2021 07:35

We pay (or did pay before the current inflation shit show) far less than our European counterparts for food, a far smaller proportion of our income. We pay far more for less secure housing.

We also have the highest fuel bills in Europe.

We as a country can't feed ourselves which is what I find worrying. We produce about 65% of our food requirements. The artificially low price of food means farms/food producers going out of business which means we rely on food imports more. Dangerous and costly.

lurker69 · 02/10/2021 07:02

I do not agree we just accept inflation in other areas we simply have no choice but to pay it, for many people if cheap food was not available they could not eat! we are forced to pay massively high rent, utilities and so on and a very large portion of the population of this country are now literally just working to live and that's it its quite depressing really.

onelittlefrog · 02/10/2021 06:41

You do know that food prices are only rising because of Brexit, right?

They're not rising because we are suddenly deciding to give more money and recognition to the farmers and people who produce our food.

They're rising because the UK stupidly voted to screw up our trade deals.

We are not becoming more moral. All that's happened is we've kicked ourselves in the shin.

Tombero · 02/10/2021 06:27

OP I caught a little bit of Prue Leith on the Food programme on radio 4 this week where she touched on this issue briefly. I’m sure it’s still available to listen to.

She was talking about the relative percentage of household income that’s been spent on food over time and how low it is now. You and her raise some interesting issues.
But I’ve no idea what the solution is. Especially while we have increasing numbers of people with no choice but to rely on food banks as a result of the other fixed (housing, utilities, council tax) costs of living being so high.

EagleOrIgel · 02/10/2021 05:49

Food is, and has been for at least the past 15 years, extremely cheap in the UK. I'm almost astonished about all the threads saying "I can do my monthly shop for £xx" when it would cost me that for a week. There was even someone saying she done a 2 week shop for £22 the other day. That stuck in my head because something must be seriously wrong if food for (one person?) for two weeks, or even one week if I've remembered incorrectly, is only £22. How can that cover decent production and transport costs?

Hawkins001 · 02/10/2021 05:31

@BiLuminous

Theres absolutely no respect in that comment, Hawkins. Your assumptions that the poor are poor because they smoke fags is really showing your ignorance and lack of understanding. Educate yourself before you speak on things you dont know shit about.
I tried not to assume, and the way I tried to phrase the question was by asking have other areas been looked at where savings could be achieved, and I said fags, sky ect as examples, yes there maybe more factors involved but when writing research assignments, we was taught when looking at e.g. What may of caused x or contribute to cause x, was to consider all possibilities,
CBUK2K2 · 02/10/2021 04:00

Food is cheap because we massively subsides the production of it with subsides funded by the tax we pay.

BiLuminous · 02/10/2021 02:05

Theres absolutely no respect in that comment, Hawkins. Your assumptions that the poor are poor because they smoke fags is really showing your ignorance and lack of understanding. Educate yourself before you speak on things you dont know shit about.

Hawkins001 · 02/10/2021 01:55

@IAmTheLovechildOfYvesAndIsabel

I know, food is so cheap - all these people must be going to food banks for the fun of it. All these people who will have to choose between buying food or heating this winter, I expect that's not a concern for you OP is it?
With all due respect, and I'm only posing the question, which is, would some people be better off if they looked at what other expenses are they funding, e.g. Sky , fags, booze ect as these different expenses have to be looked at to see where people can make improvements
IAmTheLovechildOfYvesAndIsabel · 02/10/2021 01:27

I know, food is so cheap - all these people must be going to food banks for the fun of it.
All these people who will have to choose between buying food or heating this winter, I expect that's not a concern for you OP is it?

Loveshelly · 02/10/2021 01:24

It’s not* even

OP posts:
Loveshelly · 02/10/2021 01:23

Yet the supermarkets are making huge profits.
It’s the suppliers and the workers.

If most people (I don’t mean extremely poor) I mean average people are faced with a wall of chicken, most will chose the £5 one. Not the £12 one.

OP posts:
Hawkins001 · 02/10/2021 01:22

@Loveshelly

Food has never been cheaper, meat is unbelievably cheap. Even with a conscious move towards less meat consumption it’s clear that huge consumption of cheap meat is going on.

AIBU to think that we all need to spend more on our produce, especially in the wake of brexit, we clearly cannot rely on cheap labour anymore. So we are going to have to pay more.

All I tend to see on MN is people desperate to get food bills down, then on another thread people fretting they can’t keep heating on all night.

Have we become totally skewed about what are the things we should be spending more and less on.

If prices were raised in most cases the extra profit would just go to the corporation that is selling the products, unless all farmers agree to fix prices at e.g. X price , but given reality some farmers would im guessing charge less to undercut the other farmers, which pretty much results in the same current situation.
Ploorfuzzle · 02/10/2021 01:18

I agree, lots of food is cheap to the point that someone is being exploited in the supply chain for them to still turn a profit. I mean a packet of chicken thighs for £2, ham for 50p, carrots for 21p- who's being paid a fair wage? It started with the supermarket wars when every last penny was being squeezed out to try and be competitive with one another, ask a farmer if they get a fair price for their milk for example. The cost of living elsewhere has crept up and that's what the struggle is for most.

TractorAndHeadphones · 02/10/2021 01:14

I agree OP. Not in a ‘fuck the poor’ way but in that the meat industry has been artificially propped up and it’s about to collapse.
We’re lucky enough to be in a fortunate position but I’m already changing the family diet to be bits of meat for flavour, bulked out with veg. Use bones for stock. Nothing wasted.

Cocomarine · 02/10/2021 01:06

@Loveshelly

The point about the bloody pigs is we pay people shit, because we can’t price the pork more. So it’s a fucking vicious circle.

At some point we either pay people more which makes pork more expensive or we live in this spiral of cheap labour and people on UC that actually work but need top ups because of the shit labour and wage condition.

We were sold a lie

I get your point. I don’t think you’re saying that a person who can only afford a £2 chicken now should pay £20 tomorrow. I don’t think you’re tone death or stupid. The point is, if people were paid a fair wage*, and housing costs were astronomical for many, then they could afford to pay more for food which in turn would mean that those in the food industry were paid a fair wage. I don’t know how you step in to fix that… but I don’t think the OP meant that the first stage was just to put prices up tomorrow.

*I don’t know what a fair wage is, but I certainly think it’s one that doesn’t have to be propped up by in work benefits

CorianderAndCream · 02/10/2021 00:55

[quote Loveshelly]@CorianderAndCream
I agree. I pay rent. It’s 60% of my earnings. Which is shocking.

But yet I see other industries booming, there is a huge amount of spending on other things. Like fashion.

Maybe I’m wrong, maybe no one is spending money on clothes. Yet ASOS is worth ten times more than the poultry industry. And I think most people eat poultry.[/quote]
I mean I can't help you with the meat idea. I'm a vegetarian so my food shop is likely considerably cheaper. Chickpeas are cheap :').

I do buy clothes a few times a year and probably spend too much on shows/events etc. But we shouldn't have to spend 99% of our wages on just food, shelter, water. That's surviving not living.

Loveshelly · 02/10/2021 00:46

All the farmers should have just become landlords. Probably better odds

OP posts:
RAFHercules · 02/10/2021 00:43

I agree re the cost of property means that there is little left over for food. Our youngest pays £159 a week for a room in a student house. I mean Shock, 6 years ago my DD was at the same uni and paid £75 a week for a similar standard property.
DS goes to Morrisons every night to buy reduced veg to make soup but hey at least his landlords doing OK Hmm

ImaBraveNhsHero · 02/10/2021 00:40

Btw gas wasn't artificially cheap previous to this month. What's happened this month is that both our main sources of gas have realised the UK has got fuck all gas reserves and no bargaining power now we're not in the EU.

It's a bent as fuck market anyway. The suppliers are just different arms of the wholesalers. I mean they're selling to their fine fucking selves half the time. (And the other half they're Putin ...)

So talk about the cost of gas is misleading.