Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Food is too cheap ?

261 replies

Loveshelly · 01/10/2021 23:08

Food has never been cheaper, meat is unbelievably cheap. Even with a conscious move towards less meat consumption it’s clear that huge consumption of cheap meat is going on.

AIBU to think that we all need to spend more on our produce, especially in the wake of brexit, we clearly cannot rely on cheap labour anymore. So we are going to have to pay more.

All I tend to see on MN is people desperate to get food bills down, then on another thread people fretting they can’t keep heating on all night.

Have we become totally skewed about what are the things we should be spending more and less on.

OP posts:
Loveshelly · 02/10/2021 09:35

I am absolutely not proposing people go hungry. I think it’s a disgrace people will have to chose between heating and eating.
I think it’s a disgrace that people have to use food banks.

We punish the poor in this country.

But if we paid food processors a decent wage, then they wouldn’t need UC top ups. The jobs would be filled, but the food would cost more.

I agree with a couple of people on here that we want a lot of cheap things, and are fine when the production doesn’t affect us. But it’s going to now.

Also that the gap between rich and poor is staggering. Yet we all have to eat, we all shop in roughly the same supermarkets.

As a country we spend one of the lowest amounts per household on food. That’s not simply because we are poorer than all the other countries we are not. We are much richer than many of them.

OP posts:
minipie · 02/10/2021 09:27

Might have been better if you’d said other costs need to come down so that food prices can come up.

That I agree with

Porcupineintherough · 02/10/2021 09:25

YANBU and we should not expect to buy food so cheaply that the people in the food production and supply chain cant earn a living wage and/or work in reasonable conditions.

SushiGo · 02/10/2021 09:22

@EagleOrIgel

Re a £22 shop - depends if it was 'yellow label' or not when we were in food poverty I was going to the nearest supermarket at mark down time most days to buy as much as I could for 10p each. Loaves of bread, veg etc Ok, I understand that. But do you not see that a loaf of bread for 10p cannot be feasible if you think about what went into it's production? You wouldn't get anything for 10p where I live. The cheapest loaf of bread on mark down is about 50p.
I feel like you have massively missed the point. Obviously bread does not normally cost 10p. But someone spending very small amounts of money on food is probably doing so due to eating practically everything at expiry date, either as a moral choice to reduce food waste or due to poverty. They aren't buying full price food for such little money. So the fact that they've done it on such a small amount says nothing at all about the cost of food generally or how much they think it should cost.
Newmumatlast · 02/10/2021 09:21

Food may be cheaper here than elsewhere and there are still lots of offers however alot of food has increased in price. I have noticed it when doing my online shop - sugar snap peas now 1.20 at my local big store up from 1.00 very recently.

For me, I can afford increases as I've room in budget. For many others, they can't. This is why the country is full of food banks and community organised schemes. Rather than judging people for their priorities why not just be thankful that you don't have to worry

martingrowler · 02/10/2021 09:13

I do think in this country we don't like to spend a high proportion of our wages on food. I see it on threads about how much people spend on their weekly shop and you get people saying they have plenty of money but proudly only spend £40 a week or whatever. I think we should be spending the most we can afford.

However, YABU because food is not cheaper than ever and if it were any more expensive then many would t be able to afford to feed their families

Simonjt · 02/10/2021 09:12

Cheapless is relative to budget, time, facilities and cooking skills.

I don’t spend a huge amount on food shopping, but I have the luxury of both time and skill so I make the majority of our meals. Thats a luxury that isn’t available to a lot of people.

We’re at our little holiday home so I’ve done an aldi click and collect for the whole week, rather than my usual ocado, although I didn’t factor taking the frozen stuff home Sunday evening.

I’ve got
Olives 150g £1.59
15 Eggs free range £1.79
Dark chocolate 70% £1.49
Cannellini beans 45p
Kidney beans 49p
Black beans 49p
Green lentils 49p
Passata 64p
Oats 1kg 75p
Crisps x6 55p
Baked beans x4 96p
Penne pasta 29p
Garlic 39p
Butternut squash 95p
Cauliflower 79p
Sweetheart cabbage 47p
Broccoli 47p
Courgettes £1.15
Onions 1kg 50p
Grapes £1.06
Radishes 43p
Celery 29p
Peppers 92p
Toms 64p
Cucumber 43p
Bagged salad x3 £1.71
Sweet potatoes 1kg 89p
Potatoes 2.5kg 89p
Easy peelers 600g 69p
Pears 5 57p
Peas 900g 55p
Apples 6 60p
Bananas 10 £1.38
Fine beans 1kg frozen 55p
Veggie fingers 16 £1.39
Coconut milk 55p (this has got really expensive elsewhere)

That came to just shy of £32 before the £4 click and collect fee. It is a cheap shop, but only if you have the skills, resources, confidence and time to cook it all. I work part time, my husband works part time, I’m a good cook, I’m not stressed, I’m not worried about money, I have a fully equipped kitchen, I’m not in fuel poverty.

If I look back to about 12-15 years ago, I didn’t have access to a proper kitchen, I had two jobs, I was at university, funds were very very short, I was stressed, I didn’t have any cheaper local supermarkets. Lunch was generally tesco value supernoodles minus the flavour sachet and some frozen mixed veg.

Yes, food is generally cheap, but the people needing the cheaper food often don’t have the resources, time etc to take full advantage of cheaper food.

Popoloco · 02/10/2021 09:12

Much of the new housing where I live has been purchased off plan by Chinese property investors. We have many properties that are empty, no intention of renting out as it’s a bank to the Chinese with guaranteed intruding prices.

They are exploiting out housing crisis for investment returns. Meanwhile we have homeless living in sheds. People can’t afford to rent and many of the homes being built are not accessible to local people let alone affordable.

Our biggest local agent has an office in China ffs!

This has a knock on impact on the whole property market and how much money people have left for food.

It’s a fucking disgrace. I don’t believe many countries would facilitate such behaviour?

LaurieFairyCake · 02/10/2021 09:06

Yes food is far too cheap - it should rise about 30% so we don't have shit food and shit welfare standards

And obviously wages need to rise and housing costs need to come down so people can afford the above ^^

We need a massive affordable house building programme and businesses need to pay people more

The gap between the CEO and the ordinary worker used to be maximum 80% in the 1970's - it's now hundreds of percent

The rich have got MUCH MUCH richer

And that's why food is so cheap - a nice panacea for the masses with its corn syrup, poor health, cancers and obesity - so they can then blame YOU for it

So you get to be poor, shit food, cold and have poor housing - and then you can get told if you'd only worked harder you would have what they have

NEWSFLASH - you can never have what they have but they will show you the tiny percentage that 'pulled themselves up by their bootstraps' in that 'levelling up' conspiracy so that you can all then blame each other for not being able to

Your place is to always be in the wrong, it's always YOUR fault

SaraSidleWillows · 02/10/2021 08:54

@FrenchBoule

Depends on how much is your food budget,what can you afford?

I’d rather eat less but better quality(and more expensive) than cheap shit,I’d rather buy mince from the butcher than supermarket (huuuge difference).
Saying that I’m still enough financially comfortable to avoid it(might be not for long though)

I have been in my life on absolute bones of my arse so I appreciate the luxury of still having a choice.

Different areas of UK will have different prices/wages, accessibility and affordability.
What really annoys me is the amount of processed shit in the shops and how cheap it is compared to more nutritious food.(packet of biscuits v pack of apples)
I’m not happy with the “beauty standards” of fruit and veg sold to people. Even so called “wonky” fruit and veg in the supermarket still doesn’t eliminate the waste that farmers compost every year when so many people go to the food banks.

I think it actually would be good for people to go hungry for a while. It would make them appreciate more the food they have readily available but still moan about colour/shape/use by date.

Right so I can’t afford to feed myself and my daughter. She eats at nursery and the cost of meals is packaged into the costs, so I can’t just feed her packed lunches and cut back there. It’s the only nursery around open 8-6 and I’m a university student so I can’t get a job.

In the past 4 days I’ve eaten a pasty. That’s it. That’s all I could afford. How much hungrier do you think I could get before it started to seriously affect me?

AveryGoodlay · 02/10/2021 08:41

I think it actually would be good for people to go hungry for a while. It would make them appreciate more the food they have readily available but still moan about colour/shape/use by date. plenty of people are already going hungry. Do you live under a rock?

OP people are already struggling to afford the basics. Children will be cold this winter. You're proposing they go hungry too as their parents are priced out of being able to afford to feed them.

MakingM · 02/10/2021 08:35

@Ylvamoon

I think we are currently having a huge price adjustment in goods and services. Bye bye to the cheap, low wage economy and hello to the real cost of of our goods and services! Also known as Brexit and conveniently blamed on The Pandemic. Granted, wages will be moving at a snail pace while everything else will race ahead at 200 mph. But things will even themselves out in the shape of a recession.
…real cost of our goods and services?

I think that is somewhat unrealistic.

What seems more likely is that we will import more food from areas of the world with lower levels of product and employment regulation because it will be cheap and people will demand it and happily chow down.

Services that can move online will move online and thus be delivered in the same way by people based in countries of lower regulation.

There is unfortunately a tension between people’s demand for protectionism and their willingness to pay the prices that our high cost of living and high regulation causes.

The demand for cheap stuff has always previously won out in that battle and people are more strapped for cash now so I see no reason why that demand would change now.

Lampzade · 02/10/2021 08:29

Let something be cheap FFS.
As others have said, everything else in this country is expensive

MakingM · 02/10/2021 08:26

People can’t spend what they haven’t got.

Until enough homes are built to bring the cost of housing down to affordable levels, the demand for cheap everything else will continue.

Households don’t have magic money trees like governments. They can’t simply create more money to pay more for things simply because it is deemed desirable to pay more.

flowerycurtain · 02/10/2021 08:25

Totally agree food is too cheap.

I'm a farmer producing something many people would buy in their supermarket shop once a week. We've just been informed our prices are being cut by the supermarkets because of rising costs. I spat my tea out when I read the letter. Our electricity prices have near on doubled. Nitrogen - I used to buy for £280 a Ton. Today it's more like £480. Staff pay rises are due next month and we like to try and keep up with inflation if we can. The houses we pay for our staff to live in have their council tax, electric and water going up. My husband is currently living in our caravan on the farm as there is Covid at the kids school and he can't afford to be ill. He's been there for 3.5 weeks now and this is the third stint he's done over the pandemic. Our staff are fantastic but there's so few of us and we cannot find more good people. We have shifts in school hours. The media says to people like us pay them more - I'd love to but we can't if the supermarkets won't put the prices up which they won't id Joe public won't pay 10p more for their milk/bread/eggs/chicken.

But we get a price cut.

There's also a huge dichotomy beteeen how the public shop and how they want to shop. Everyone says they want free range organic etc but the reality is for a lot of people is they can't afford that. The reality of that production system is cheap Labour from abroad. You can't have high wages and cheap food/transport/clothing. Or you can if people are prepared to pay for it.

Upthread someone mentioned the cost of land affecting farmers as well. This is so true. The government need to get rid of Rollover (farmers sell land for a shit load of money, have 3 years to buy more Ag land and you don't pay tax on it.) Also IHT needs reforming. As
Jeremy clarkson says "why buy a farm? Somewhere to put the money I've made where the kids won't pay tax on it"

I find it shocking the government is so blasé about food and energy supplies. Everyone needs water, food and warmth. The fact our country cannot sustainably produce two of those three is quite scary.

ClareBlue · 02/10/2021 08:21

You are correct in that post war feeding a family took up around 50 percent of income and housing around 20 percent. People rarely ate out and takeaway was a treat. The rest in health, travel and education. Leisure hardly registered. Now housing and travel and leisure dwarf food. Food has never taken up less of our income than now. But, as people say, any savings have been completely taken up with housing costs and transport. We spend more on commuting, eating out and electrical goods.
EU legislation creates huge barriers to entry in the food sector (deliberately) and production is centralized and intensive to lower production costs to lower costs to supermarkets. Whilst some might be able to avoid cheap protein from chickens etc, the vast majority have to buy cheap food because their other costs of living are so high.

Dutchesss · 02/10/2021 08:14

I get your point, people as a whole consume way too much. Too much meat, too many clothes, too many things are replaced before their time.
I look at t shirts for £3 and wonder how on earth it gets made, transported and shelved for £3. Most people I know own more clothes and trinkets than they will ever use. Wages/living allowances need to increase for the poorest and things do need to cost more to cover their production and to stop so much waste. You hear of people chucking tonnes of unused food every week- that wouldn't have happened with the older generation.

EagleOrIgel · 02/10/2021 08:11

Re a £22 shop - depends if it was 'yellow label' or not when we were in food poverty I was going to the nearest supermarket at mark down time most days to buy as much as I could for 10p each. Loaves of bread, veg etc
Ok, I understand that. But do you not see that a loaf of bread for 10p cannot be feasible if you think about what went into it's production? You wouldn't get anything for 10p where I live. The cheapest loaf of bread on mark down is about 50p.

Maskless · 02/10/2021 08:10

Whether people consider food to be cheap surely depends entirely on how much their income is, where their priorities lie, and a great many other variables.

Two years ago I had a lodger who repeatedly whined to me that the dole didn't give her enough to live on, and once or twice she even went to the food bank.

One day when she was out I put a lot of time and thought and effort into researching food prices (using online supermarkets) and then working out a week's menu for her that would cost her no more than £25.

When she arrived home I approached her to give her the printout of the menu and budget, and saw that she had a Chinese takeaway swinging in a bag from one hand and a bottle of wine in her other. She'd blown £10 on one meal plus £8 on the wine. When I remonstrated with her, she said £18 "wasn't all that much" for a meal she really enjoyed.

And the moral is we all see things differently! Our priorities are different, our judgments and values and upbringing, etc are all different.

There is no way I would waste £8 on a bottle of wine, because I don't like it. For a treat I'll buy myself a £3 pack of smoked salmon, and someone will comment that I'm being "extravagant".

DaphneduM · 02/10/2021 08:10

@Hawkins001 - suggest you vary your reading matter from the Sun and Daily Mail. This is a fallacy trotted out by the right wing press to gullible, self-righteous people. If you had actually been in the situation of not being able to afford decent food I'm sure you would soon revise your attitude.

MrsHuntGeneNotJeremyObviously · 02/10/2021 08:03

People who are buying really cheap meat are doing it because they have no choice. Most would prefer to buy a free range chicken. But this is what happens when supermarkets have bulk buying power (hence the price of milk) and we have successive governments who screw every other penny they can get out of us by allowing basics such as housing/utilities/travel to be so expensive.

SaskiaRembrandt · 02/10/2021 08:03

I tried not to assume, and the way I tried to phrase the question was by asking have other areas been looked at where savings could be achieved, and I said fags, sky ect as examples, yes there maybe more factors involved but when writing research assignments, we was taught when looking at e.g. What may of caused x or contribute to cause x, was to consider all possibilities,

You used to write research assignments?

esloquehay · 02/10/2021 07:57

@Hawkins001, flipping heck, you've thrown out some banal stereotypes, haven't you? It's a shame when being taught to write assignments, you weren't educated upon the danger of a) sweeping generalisations and b) your poor quality of written English. 😎

Lockheart · 02/10/2021 07:57

@CardiganAddict

Food, clothes, housing and electricity should be cheap or at least have cheap options in our society. It's not up to poor people to pay extra to solve the issues that we have with animal welfare and sustainability. Our system should be built, instead to sort it out
It's not just animal welfare - the people who produce food, clothes etc should be paid properly and they should be produced in an environmentally friendly way rather than in the disastrously wasteful fashion that lots of cheap clothing is produced.

How do you square the two? If you pay your workers properly you can't afford to sell your products for peanuts.

marieantoinehairnet · 02/10/2021 07:55

Go away Rishi