Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Food is too cheap ?

261 replies

Loveshelly · 01/10/2021 23:08

Food has never been cheaper, meat is unbelievably cheap. Even with a conscious move towards less meat consumption it’s clear that huge consumption of cheap meat is going on.

AIBU to think that we all need to spend more on our produce, especially in the wake of brexit, we clearly cannot rely on cheap labour anymore. So we are going to have to pay more.

All I tend to see on MN is people desperate to get food bills down, then on another thread people fretting they can’t keep heating on all night.

Have we become totally skewed about what are the things we should be spending more and less on.

OP posts:
COOKFORD · 03/10/2021 12:46

I do agency work and believe me our pay is down massively from the past, we aren't allowed to claim for food, rent, travel etc anymore.

martingrowler · 03/10/2021 12:44

The boots theory definitely applies to food. If I had a pound for every time my wealthy (doesn't give me a penny) father has told me to shop in Costco because they save a fortune bulk buying... well... I'd be able to afford to shop in Costco!

When my dd and I were given permanent accommodation I was given a very small fridge freezer by a local charity. Obviously I was extremely grateful but it just couldn't hold takeaway cartons full of homemade pasta sauce etc. I certainly don't have the cash or the storage room for 40 toilet rolls or whatever.

It is expensive to be poor.

Cornettoninja · 03/10/2021 12:41

Well it’s a simplistic, scaled down explanation of a bigger scenario isn’t it? Those small differences add up the more people being catered for. You’re starting with the presumption that the person in our scenario has the initial £5 outlay to make the macaroni cheese.

Presuming they have £5 they could make a pot of macaroni cheese and cover 3-4 meals or buy five ready meals and gain an extra two or three meals. It’s not an unrealistic scenario.

In fairness macaroni cheese isn’t the best example because the price difference is minuscule and it could be said that person could just buy a bag of oats for the week. Swap that to a meat containing meal or one that provides more balance in veg and the differences increase. No one can, or should, just be living in macaroni cheese or porridge.

Claudyapples · 03/10/2021 12:14

@Cornettoninja

I disagree *@Claudyapples*.To bulk buy raw ingredients that make more portions and can be used for other meals requires an initial outlay that isn’t something everyone has. That prepared £1 ready meal may cost more when it’s broken down but the immediate cost is lower because you’re only purchasing a portion of a prep related larger bulk.

Over time the person who can only afford to spend £1 at the time will pay more than the person who can afford a bag of pasta, milk, flour and cheese. Then you can look at the ability to store food in bulk and the person who can afford to purchase and run a larger freezer has a distinct advantage over the person who only has a tiny freezer compartment.

Yes I agree about bulk purchasing and storing foods, but in this scenario who is getting paid daily instead of weekly, and travelling to buy a ready meal everyday?
Hawkins001 · 03/10/2021 11:23

@ImaBraveNhsHero

Yeah if Socrates was on Mumsnet he'd sound exactly like you. 🙄
"Socratic questioning (or Socratic maieutics) was named after Socrates. He utilized an educational method that focused on discovering answers by asking questions"
Cornettoninja · 03/10/2021 11:16

I disagree @Claudyapples.To bulk buy raw ingredients that make more portions and can be used for other meals requires an initial outlay that isn’t something everyone has. That prepared £1 ready meal may cost more when it’s broken down but the immediate cost is lower because you’re only purchasing a portion of a prep related larger bulk.

Over time the person who can only afford to spend £1 at the time will pay more than the person who can afford a bag of pasta, milk, flour and cheese. Then you can look at the ability to store food in bulk and the person who can afford to purchase and run a larger freezer has a distinct advantage over the person who only has a tiny freezer compartment.

ImaBraveNhsHero · 03/10/2021 11:01

Yeah if Socrates was on Mumsnet he'd sound exactly like you. 🙄

Hawkins001 · 03/10/2021 10:57

[quote notthemum]@Hawkins001.
Just read a post from you ? Like another pp said, please have a bit of respect for others and not post on things you don't know anything about.
I don't smoke, I don't drink. I don't go out. I can't walk very far.
Luckily for me I am on loads of medications and one particular one means that I do get them for free, otherwise I could not afford to buy them. I can drive but can't afford to. I certainly can't afford £50 a week on food as a pp said that is what they spend. After losing my job, health and home I am definitely on the bones of my arse. I am staying in a friends spare room but I have nothing to contribute. [/quote]
All the best, I'll admit my suggestion was a sweeping one, yes I don't know everyone individual situation, I only attempted to phrase my posts as questions similar to the ancient philosopher Socrates, in that it's up to the individual as to how they interpret the information, all I asked was if a person's budget was tight , could they have other expenses that could be trimmed to free up more of their budget to spend x amount on food, with all due respect to all, I was just asking a question and I know everyone has their own situation.

Claudyapples · 03/10/2021 10:38

Bit*

Claudyapples · 03/10/2021 10:38

@Cornettoninja

But the ingredients would last for more than one meal so it's not really equivalent, people are unlikely to buy a one person portion (which is what the ready meals are) of pasta or cheese, and many have milk in the fridge already

And then we’re in the territory of the ‘boots theory’.

Not in this example we aren't, no, we are now into the territory of being a not ridiculous to try and prove a point.
elbea · 03/10/2021 10:07

Food in Britain is subsidised through the government with the Basic Payment Scheme, ELS and HLS schemes. With the end of these schemes farmers will no longer be provided with a basic income, added into the fact that they can’t get farm workers - I’d expect food prices to rise.

Additionally supermarkets have ‘loss leaders’ things like cheap milk and chickens. The prices don’t reflect the cost of production, packaging and transport. The supermarkets take a loss because they’ll upsell you other things to make up the loss.

Cornettoninja · 03/10/2021 10:05

But the ingredients would last for more than one meal so it's not really equivalent, people are unlikely to buy a one person portion (which is what the ready meals are) of pasta or cheese, and many have milk in the fridge already

And then we’re in the territory of the ‘boots theory’.

Food is too cheap ?
FreedomFaith · 03/10/2021 09:55

Aw thank you @Loveshelly for offering to pay for my weeks shopping forever.

Unless you're willing to put your money where your mouth is, I wouldn't be giving opinions on expecting people to pay more for food. Some are struggling enough as it is. Hmm

MatildaIThink · 03/10/2021 09:51

@Jijithecat

I agree with you OP but I appreciate if you're struggling to pay the bills it won't be a popular opinion. I grow some of my own vegetables but it's so much cheaper to buy them in the supermarket. If you think about the length of time it takes to grow a cauliflower - up to 5 months, the amount of space they take to grow and the fact that I can buy one in my nearest supermarket for 79p, I struggle to see how anyone can make any money from it.
We grow veg and I agree it takes time and is certainly not something we could make money on, I am not sure we even break even on it (seeds, plant feed that is safe for food consumption etc.) but it is more about teaching our kids on how food grows than money.

We are also lucky that there are two large apple trees and three cherry trees in out garden which are probably as old as I am and produce huge amounts of apples and cherries every year for free. We eat plenty, freeze loads (for crumble, pie etc.) and give loads away, but I can't claim any credit for the trees, they were the when we bought the house.

Jijithecat · 03/10/2021 09:38

I agree with you OP but I appreciate if you're struggling to pay the bills it won't be a popular opinion.
I grow some of my own vegetables but it's so much cheaper to buy them in the supermarket. If you think about the length of time it takes to grow a cauliflower - up to 5 months, the amount of space they take to grow and the fact that I can buy one in my nearest supermarket for 79p, I struggle to see how anyone can make any money from it.

Wazzzzzzzup · 03/10/2021 09:38

I am always bit baffled why people drag berries into this. I suspect it's because that is basically the only support for "fresh food is expensive"?

LadyCatStark · 03/10/2021 09:37

Maybe food is artificially cheap but how are people supposed to just afford to pay more? I’m public sector and my pay was frozen for over 10 years. Then I have received tiny pay rises for the last few years and now it’s frozen again. Oh and then there’s the National insurance rise so actually it’s a pay cut.

MatildaIThink · 03/10/2021 09:28

@CatsArePeople

There are still basic foods that are cheap - eggs, seasonal fruit and veg, flour, oats, eg. Op seems to be focussed on meat though.

A punnet of berries costs more than a multipack of Snickers. Milk or mineral water costs more than an energy drink.
Good meat and fish are expensive. I don't mean £2 chickens.

You don't need a punnet of berries and a 1kg bag of apples (10-12) or a bag of ten oranges costs £1.50-2.00 depending on the time of year, a multipack of nine Snickers costs £2.00-2.50 depending on offers.

Milk costs £0.51 per litre, energy drinks range from £1.40 to £4.50 per litre and are bad for health. Tap water is so cheap as to be effectively free for drinking purposes with a cost of £0.00138 per litre, the whole of the UK has a potable water supply and bottled mineral water is incredibly damaging environmentally.

MatildaIThink · 03/10/2021 09:17

@CatsArePeople

Sure crating a meal out of those isn't always possible or appealing

That's the main problem. Cooking from scratch involves shopping from scratch. You can buy a mac'n'cheese ready meal for £1 in Iceland. Try to do your own will cost at least £3

The thing is for that £1 you would get one meal. For that £3 (I think probably £3.50-4) you could get at least ten portions, potentially more, so only 30-40p per meal. This is why when on a low budget meal planning and store cupboard management is so important, but there are loads of guides online to help with this.

It is the same with takeaways, people say a takeaway pizza is a cheap treat, yet to feed a family of four it would cost £30, to do that from supermarket pizzas would cost around £8, it would cost a similar amount to do it from scratch but you would have ingredients left over that could be used for other meals.

Tubbytenbums · 03/10/2021 09:10

Farmers were able to accept the prices given to them for their goods as they received EU funding. Not sure what will happen now............

notthemum · 03/10/2021 09:08

@Hawkins001.
Just read a post from you ? Like another pp said, please have a bit of respect for others and not post on things you don't know anything about.
I don't smoke, I don't drink. I don't go out. I can't walk very far.
Luckily for me I am on loads of medications and one particular one means that I do get them for free, otherwise I could not afford to buy them. I can drive but can't afford to. I certainly can't afford £50 a week on food as a pp said that is what they spend. After losing my job, health and home I am definitely on the bones of my arse. I am staying in a friends spare room but I have nothing to contribute.

Claudyapples · 03/10/2021 08:23

@bellaweir

Cheese is expensive
Some cheese is, yes. Some is not.
bellaweir · 03/10/2021 01:52

Cheese is expensive

Peridotty · 03/10/2021 01:47

Food is extremely cheap in the U.K. Try paying £5 for a bag of oranges, £4 for a stick of butter, £5 for a loaf of bread, £20 for a chicken, £4 for one cauliflower, £1 for one tomato here in the US (regular supermarket).

cigarettesanddisappointment · 03/10/2021 01:40

Food may be "cheap" but the actual cost of living is high. I earn an average salary, have 2 DC at home and 1DC at uni and every month is a struggle; we eat more pasta/rice dishes than are necessary. I'd love for food to be at a better price for those that make the produce but until housing/utilities/fuel become affordable it's not going to happen. It's very naive to think anything else, unless you're earning a lot of money.