Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Food is too cheap ?

261 replies

Loveshelly · 01/10/2021 23:08

Food has never been cheaper, meat is unbelievably cheap. Even with a conscious move towards less meat consumption it’s clear that huge consumption of cheap meat is going on.

AIBU to think that we all need to spend more on our produce, especially in the wake of brexit, we clearly cannot rely on cheap labour anymore. So we are going to have to pay more.

All I tend to see on MN is people desperate to get food bills down, then on another thread people fretting they can’t keep heating on all night.

Have we become totally skewed about what are the things we should be spending more and less on.

OP posts:
Hawkins001 · 03/10/2021 16:26

When you look at other items that people consume e.g. Fags, booze, sky, packages, ect people still buy those products ect even when the prices go higher.

Hawkins001 · 03/10/2021 16:24

@Loveshelly

www.theguardian.com/business/2021/oct/01/uk-pig-industry-warns-butcher-shortage-mass-cull

This is what I mean by too cheap. I don’t mean that I have no concept of how people struggle to feed themselves on a low income.

The people who would usually eat these pigs expect to buy it at a certain amount (too cheaply) which is why they’re all going to die.

I’m talking about what people used to call “mondeo man” who go to Tesco and expect to be able to buy an animal for less than they would spend on a couple of lattes at costa.

This is very much cultural, mondeo man is not poverty stricken.

From reading the article itself, it sounds like the reasons for the excess animals is due to the consolidation of supermarkets so they have the purchasing power to offer less to the farmers, so yes you could blame the consumer, but if all the prices were raised on the shelf for the meat, then would people shop elsewhere or would supermarkets and businesses have to accept the price s and pass the costs onto the consumer ? As is it not the supermarkets and other e.g. Restaurants that set the prices for the consumers ?
orangeautumnleaves · 03/10/2021 15:36

I don't know as don't have much comparison with meat as been veggie for 25 years. But I now cook meat for my mum and my kids. What I pay for meat is not cheap but I don't trust cheap meat, especially chicken, as I imagine it's full of crap! so tend to buy from a decent butcher and only twice a week as no way I could afford to buy any more that that. It's certainly not cheap! I guess what I pay is what to expect in the future?

I don't have a problem with paying more for goods and services as long as wages move in the same direction for everyone!

Loveshelly · 03/10/2021 15:04

www.theguardian.com/business/2021/oct/01/uk-pig-industry-warns-butcher-shortage-mass-cull

This is what I mean by too cheap. I don’t mean that I have no concept of how people struggle to feed themselves on a low income.

The people who would usually eat these pigs expect to buy it at a certain amount (too cheaply) which is why they’re all going to die.

I’m talking about what people used to call “mondeo man” who go to Tesco and expect to be able to buy an animal for less than they would spend on a couple of lattes at costa.

This is very much cultural, mondeo man is not poverty stricken.

OP posts:
CuriousaboutSamphire · 03/10/2021 14:47

The problem is that cooking from scratch is more expensive in other ways: time, cooking fuel, recipe knowledge, planning, freezer space etc.

I batch cook. Occasionally buy a bottle of ready made sauce if I want tea before I make the next batch. We can do that cheaply because we have a large freezer and long standing habbit of freezing back knobby ends and soft fruit and veg for later use. That isn't an easy habit to get if you are looking at nigh on empty cupboards or a food bank bag.

I often think about that Eat Better For Less programme and think how much better, if less entertaining, it would be if it was Eat Cheaper and Better By Cooking - where every family gets given a large freezer if they don't already have one and a week with a bookmaker who will leave them with a decent spreadsheet.

Belledan1 · 03/10/2021 14:19

I started cooking a lot more from scratch instead of say a aldi jar tikka sauce 70p. I was thinking when buying all the ingredients for various dishes. Yes can use this again like the rice wine vinegar that was 2.50 I used in 3 different recipes and got lots of portions out of it plus lots other basic ingredients but if I was on a tight weekly budget which I have been I go for 7op sauce

CuriousaboutSamphire · 03/10/2021 14:08

@Tubbytenbums

Farmers were able to accept the prices given to them for their goods as they received EU funding. Not sure what will happen now............
Nope! Tha's not quite right either! It's a hold over from the 'rich farmer bashing' of about 30 years ago.

Farmers have been shouting about losing money on their product for decades.

They have been looking for direct outlets for at least 20 years. All whilst in receipt of that funding. Somewhere along the line we were sold a lie, masking the difference between land owners and farmers - most of whom are tenants and don't receive those benefits directly .

CuriousaboutSamphire · 03/10/2021 13:59

@BeepingBB

You're extremely tone deaf.

Well done for not being poor.

Actually I think many posters here are not hearing what OP is saying.

Food production in thsi country has been cut to the bone and beyond. Many producers making a loss when they sell their product on to supermarkets, who make a profit. Becuase we, the shoppers, won't pay more for something.

Take milk. We've been told for years that dairy farmers lose money on every pint of milk. And we shrug our shoulders, not our problem.

With Brexit and covid many other farmers, of meat or fruit and veg, have had to watch their product rot, die, get poured down the drain, because there is no workforce that will work for the pitiful money they can offer (which is usually far more thanthe famer will pay themselves). And we shrug... until the supermarket shelves are empty. Then we start to shout about how disgraceful it is.

I agree with you @Loveshelly Something has to be done to support our farming industry. The clever farmer finds a local outlet, sells direct, supermarkets will lose their stranglehold on pricing and then what?

  1. We will all need to start thinking about eating more seasonally for a start
  2. Might have to start looking beyond the convenience of a home delivery or one big shop
  3. Hopefully we will have to start buying locally - can you imagine the resurgence of the High Street?

I am seeing it here - way out in the sticks. We have long had a weekly fish van. We now have a monthly market in a van. Our greengrocer buys direct from local farmers, has been very seasonal for a few years. Whenlocals start to complain about shortages on supermarket shelves they are being directed to the small High Street shops...

Yes, prices are a bit higher. But they come without the commute by bus or car, the plastic, the long supply chain. And because they are local shops and know their customers they have just started a local coop. Place your order, collect from one shop, some delivery available and they know who really needs it.

This is replicable wherever you live. And could be an entirely organic change. But it won't. Because we cling to the convenience and chase that last penny, regardless of the real cost.

Gingerkittykat · 03/10/2021 13:47

@Upsielazy

The 12 portions seems excessive, but 500g of mince for 2 10 year olds I agree is a lot, portion sizes are wild now compared to decades past.
I'm not the poster from the original thread but yesterday I used two 100g steak burgers smushed up to make 4 portions of meatballs in tomato sauce so 50g of meat per portion. The burgers had been an Asda substitute that had been in my freezer for months so I wanted to use them up.

I also used 1/2 a pepper, 2/3 of a courgette, some mushrooms and loads of tomatoes to bulk it out. I don't know if it was much cheaper since to double the meat would have cost £1 and the veg would have cost almost that much. It still made generous portions so it proves you don't need a lot of meat to make a meal.

I'm guilty of big portions myself sometimes, I'd happily eat four extra special sausages (or 300g) for dinner for example so not a judgement call here.

Upsielazy · 03/10/2021 13:42

@beigebrownblue

Let them eat cake... (that was Marie Antoinette wasn't it)...

After all if they can't afford bread.

Either that or a Tory M.P. said not too long ago that

'porridge was cheap'...

Porridge is cheap, and it has a load of health benefits as well. Plenty of people eat porridge through choice because it's healthy and can taste good, yet people seem to think when this is pointed out people are suggesting they should live off of gruel, which isn't the case.
Hawkins001 · 03/10/2021 13:35

How often do people spend £ on costas and takeaway food , could this resource be better spent on better food purchases ?

MatildaIThink · 03/10/2021 13:30

@Wazzzzzzzup

For fish i can highly recommend simple frozen fish. I get white fish for basic cooking and it's lovely and super cheap.
Absolutely this, more than 90% of "fresh" fish in the UK has been frozen on boat then defrosted, if it is from a supermarket all of it will have been frozen then defrosted.
beigebrownblue · 03/10/2021 13:24

Let them eat cake...
(that was Marie Antoinette wasn't it)...

After all if they can't afford bread.

Either that or a Tory M.P. said not too long ago that

'porridge was cheap'...

Wazzzzzzzup · 03/10/2021 13:24

Some frozen fish is weird texture after, but many are absolutely acceptable. Basa is good. I got some in a freezer currently.
From fresh fish, coley was great and really affordable fish. Sadly I am not seeing it anywhere again here. Asda used to have them on fishcounter.

thatsnotmyzoo · 03/10/2021 13:23

Just because some people struggle doesn’t mean food is expensive. It’s not , the OP is right, it is cheap.

Get yourselves over to France or the US where food is more expensive.

MrsSkylerWhite · 03/10/2021 13:20

Today 13:14 Wazzzzzzzup

For fish i can highly recommend simple frozen fish. I get white fish for basic cooking and it's lovely and super cheap“

Yes, agree, great for recipes, fish pie/cakes, etc. Basa is good value.
When you just want a simply turned fillet, though, we find the freezing process does something to the texture, it’s just not firm enough to eat that way, for our tastes anyway.
Fresh prices can be eye watering.

Wazzzzzzzup · 03/10/2021 13:14

For fish i can highly recommend simple frozen fish. I get white fish for basic cooking and it's lovely and super cheap.

MrsSkylerWhite · 03/10/2021 13:12

Have sympathy with both arguments.
Cheap meat is cheap: fatty old braising steak, 20% fat mince that renders down to slush, chicken legs with fat and skin snd little actual meat.
Good quality, low fat meat (and fish): chicken breasts, lean cuts of meat, aren’t affordable for many people.

Wazzzzzzzup · 03/10/2021 13:08

Sorry for typos... Unachievable, food, etc...

Wazzzzzzzup · 03/10/2021 13:07

@Upsielazy

Not all healthy food is expensive though, some is very cheap, I'm not sure why people get defensive over this fact.
It is surprising.

Also, I remember thread talking about healthy food and how it's unachieved for poor and then when people talked about soaking pulses overnight because it shortens cooking time considerably a person arguing about people not being able to afford dood came in with (paraphrasing) "who the fuck can be bothered to soak chickpea overnight"....
Healthy food is absolutely achievable on very low budget in UK.

femfemlicious · 03/10/2021 13:00

@Upsielazy so true. a healthy portion of meat for an adult is 90g. That was way too much meat for a 10 year old

femfemlicious · 03/10/2021 12:58

Ermm @SisyphusDad peppers are 3 for 82p in tesco😁.

Upsielazy · 03/10/2021 12:56

The 12 portions seems excessive, but 500g of mince for 2 10 year olds I agree is a lot, portion sizes are wild now compared to decades past.

Upsielazy · 03/10/2021 12:54

Not all healthy food is expensive though, some is very cheap, I'm not sure why people get defensive over this fact.

Gingerkittykat · 03/10/2021 12:53

There are still basic foods that are cheap - eggs, seasonal fruit and veg, flour, oats, eg. Op seems to be focussed on meat though. I don't buy or eat meat myself but I get the impression that many people make meat the main part of their meals now, whereas it used to be the smallest part. If you want to eat a lot of meat then yes, a lot of people won't be able to afford decent quality meat and will buy cheaper processed meat instead

There has been a thread on here in the past couple of days asking if two under 10s eating a 500g pack of mince in bolognese was too much. I was amazed at all of the people saying it was not too much and also mocking the poster who would make that meat stretch to 12 portions by bulking it out.

I just googled and milk cost 22p a pint in 1985 and I've just added four pints of milk onto my Asda order for £1.10. The bank of England inflation calculator says my 22p milk would now cost 68p so it is relatively a lot cheaper now than then.