Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Food is too cheap ?

261 replies

Loveshelly · 01/10/2021 23:08

Food has never been cheaper, meat is unbelievably cheap. Even with a conscious move towards less meat consumption it’s clear that huge consumption of cheap meat is going on.

AIBU to think that we all need to spend more on our produce, especially in the wake of brexit, we clearly cannot rely on cheap labour anymore. So we are going to have to pay more.

All I tend to see on MN is people desperate to get food bills down, then on another thread people fretting they can’t keep heating on all night.

Have we become totally skewed about what are the things we should be spending more and less on.

OP posts:
Popoloco · 04/10/2021 14:54

@queenofarles Yep agree with you there. I am so grateful for Jamie Oliver programmes as it never occurred to me when I was a young adult not to use a jar of sauce for cooking. Never really saw much cooking much from scratch in my childhood. It was all packets and jars. When you don’t know any different, you aren’t empowered to cook from scratch. It takes time, effort and money to learn.

Sadly many families in this country don’t know how to cook, parents have not passed on skills and knowledge to their children. If you think about it, here in the U.K. we eat cuisine from around the world. Whereas regional cuisine is king in much of Europe. They’ve held onto their roots and cookery skills get passed on through generations because it’s part of their cultural identity- whereas it isn’t really for many people in the U.K.

Popoloco · 04/10/2021 14:43

@MatildaIThink Well they have big supermarket chains in Europe, so that doesn’t explain it. Off the top of my head, Carrefour in France, Aldi and Lidl in most European countries now (German origins).

Everyone knows the supermarkets set the price of farmed basics low to get consumers through the door (milk, eggs). Perhaps in Europe farms are better unionised / organised to demand higher prices so the supermarkets don’t have as much power? I don’t know what the reasons are - I haven’t looked into it.

BUT economists will tell you that consumer willingness to pay has an impact on quality/ utility/ prices set. I think UK consumers culturally have a higher tolerance for poor quality food, again don’t have evidence except we’ve always been known for our poor cuisine compared to mainland Europe. If you want quality, you have to pay more for it in the U.K.

Europeans that I know (french Spanish Italian German) have all pointed out (and find it weird) how our supermarkets aligns to our class system and the quality/ price varies accordingly. Apparently that’s not the case in their home countries (don’t know how true this is- just what they’ve said to me).

queenofarles · 04/10/2021 13:46

In Italy almost everyone cooks from scratch, you will not find them buying a jar of pasta sauce, most Italians would regard it as almost inedible. Cooking from scratch is also far cheaper
Cooking from scratch is cheaper in the long run, after buying spices , pots and pans and gain some knowledge in cooking simple . delicious yet cheap meals, for anyone switching from ready meals to home made will spend a bit more at first. That’s why some find it more expensive.

MatildaIThink · 04/10/2021 12:28

@Popoloco

I don’t agree

Housing costs are crippling for working age people in many parts of the U.K. our percentage of income spent on housing is considerably higher than it is in the rest of Europe. We pay less than food than European counterparts.

You’re wrong about the house building. We are building houses, but too many are being purchased by investors.

That’s the root cause of why we have families dependent on food banks and living off tomato sauce and pasta. I’ve spent a lot of time in Italy. Cleaners, chefs, everyday working folk are NOT reliant on food banks. They’re buying lovely fresh food in supermarkets/ markets. They can afford to do so because they are not paying over huge amounts of money for rent. It makes a huge difference to what you can afford to eat.

Do you have any data to support your assertions, because your previous ones on wages were wrong.

I don't think you understand economics if you think that food is cheap because property is expensive, that is now how market forces work. Food is cheap because it is a highly competitive market, if everyone's wages went up 20% food prices would not suddenly rise.

I am not wrong on housing, it is basic supply and demand. Yes there are investors buying up million pound apartments in central London, but that does not impact the overall housing market. We are building at a rate which means that the housing stock is increasing at a lower rate than population, that creates a shortage (supply and demand) which drives up prices. In areas where there is far less pressure on the housing stock prices are lower, in London and the South East where it is particularly intense then prices are higher.

In Italy almost everyone cooks from scratch, you will not find them buying a jar of pasta sauce, most Italians would regard it as almost inedible. Cooking from scratch is also far cheaper.

Most food bank usage in the UK is driven by the five week wait for UC to kick in, it is a (deliberate) design flaw in the system, which accounts for the majority of food bank usage.

Popoloco · 04/10/2021 11:45

@Wazzzzzzzup yes! I credit Jamie Oliver for learning to cook with spices and herbs - if it weren’t for him I’d be eating shite!

flipflopping · 04/10/2021 11:45

Food is too cheap, housing is too expensive.

TractorAndHeadphones · 04/10/2021 11:44

@Cornettoninja

I disagree *@Claudyapples*.To bulk buy raw ingredients that make more portions and can be used for other meals requires an initial outlay that isn’t something everyone has. That prepared £1 ready meal may cost more when it’s broken down but the immediate cost is lower because you’re only purchasing a portion of a prep related larger bulk.

Over time the person who can only afford to spend £1 at the time will pay more than the person who can afford a bag of pasta, milk, flour and cheese. Then you can look at the ability to store food in bulk and the person who can afford to purchase and run a larger freezer has a distinct advantage over the person who only has a tiny freezer compartment.

Nobody travel everyday to buy £1 worth of ready meals. Even if you had £1 you could still buy a bag of pasta or rice and have more than the ready meal itself. As a poor student with no fridge/freezer (people kept nicking stuff from the shared kitchen so I had to keep it in my room) I managed on a low budget. Housing is crazy in the U.K. but food is cheap. There will always be people who struggle and can’t afford anything but that’s not because food is expensive. The working poor are hit hard by high rent and utility costs. When a huge proportion of your salary whizzes through your bank account without you even seeing it you won’t have enough to spend on much else.

It’s like trying to save £1 a day for a house deposit. That’s only a few hundred a year and by the time you save enough prices will have gone up. Doubling the saving (lowering food costs) to £2 won’t help much either. And that’s in the BEST case assuming you have a steady few quid to save.

Popoloco · 04/10/2021 11:43

I remember going shopping with my mum in the early 90s (Sainsbury’s) and the bill always being close to £100 pw for family of 4. I was always shocked as that was a lot of money back then.

Fast forward to 2021 and I’d never spend more than £100 pw on my family of 4. It does feel that prices of many basics haven’t really risen. But also some of the convenience foods my mum bought have come down in price (probably quality too!). I don’t buy these convenience foods so my trolley is made up of basics and better quality meat and dairy. My mum didn’t really cook from scratch so might explain the high cost of her shop, but I don’t think the price would be much less now as the convenience foods have really dropped in price.

Wazzzzzzzup · 04/10/2021 11:43

[quote Popoloco]@Wazzzzzzzup I guess I’m comparing to the large European countries which I know better (Italy, France, Spain) and where the med diet prevails over the ultra processed diet.

The food ingredients in Italy are far superior to what you can buy in the UK. You can make a very tasty meal out of simple ingredients. In the UK it’s not so easy because the basic flavour is lacking unless you pay substantially more.[/quote]
Tbf it would be easy in here if people didn't have some aversion to herbs and spices, many of which are incredibly easy to access🙈
(Just actually had an interesting thread on lemons and such).

But yes, compared to these countries, the quality is lacking, I agree!

Popoloco · 04/10/2021 11:37

@Wazzzzzzzup I guess I’m comparing to the large European countries which I know better (Italy, France, Spain) and where the med diet prevails over the ultra processed diet.

The food ingredients in Italy are far superior to what you can buy in the UK. You can make a very tasty meal out of simple ingredients. In the UK it’s not so easy because the basic flavour is lacking unless you pay substantially more.

queenofarles · 04/10/2021 11:37

I get what you mean OP,
There is an interesting clip on YT about Tesco shopping in the 70s , not huge inflation prices on most branded items , today you can find same items In supermarket own brands even much cheaper.
Clothes are cheaper too,

But everything else is so expensive, it makes no huge difference on savings or weekly spending .

Wazzzzzzzup · 04/10/2021 11:32

@Popoloco

We are sold cheap and rubbish food that folk in other European countries wouldn’t consider eating. That’s why we have cheap food and an obesity crisis.
You think that but... Nope. I know worse. The food hase same packaging, same price like in western country, sometimes more expensive actually, yet (for example) meat content in something is 20% less. The quality in here is not the best, could absolutely be better, but no. You don't get the worst rubbish.
Popoloco · 04/10/2021 11:27

We are sold cheap and rubbish food that folk in other European countries wouldn’t consider eating. That’s why we have cheap food and an obesity crisis.

Popoloco · 04/10/2021 11:26

I don’t agree

Housing costs are crippling for working age people in many parts of the U.K. our percentage of income spent on housing is considerably higher than it is in the rest of Europe. We pay less than food than European counterparts.

You’re wrong about the house building. We are building houses, but too many are being purchased by investors.

That’s the root cause of why we have families dependent on food banks and living off tomato sauce and pasta. I’ve spent a lot of time in Italy. Cleaners, chefs, everyday working folk are NOT reliant on food banks. They’re buying lovely fresh food in supermarkets/ markets. They can afford to do so because they are not paying over huge amounts of money for rent. It makes a huge difference to what you can afford to eat.

Upsielazy · 04/10/2021 10:32

Also, none of that is why food is so cheap in the UK, food is cheap in the UK because the market is dominated by several large supermarkets who have largely competed on price and squeezed farmers and producers for several decades. That combined with JIT supply which is far cheaper, but less resilient and the UK public having unrealistic expectations as to what food should actually cost.

Yes precisely this. Its not to do with wages or the cost of living, people would always need need buy food, it's the greed of supermarkets to gain market share.

MatildaIThink · 04/10/2021 10:20

@Popoloco

This is why food in the UK is so cheap.

www.statista.com/statistics/722905/average-residential-square-meter-prices-in-eu-28-per-country/

We’ve got the highest housing costs in Europe (exc Monaco) yet among the lower average wage in larger economies.

Average salaries in Belgium, Scandinavian countries and Switzerland are so much higher than ours. Yet their housing costs are a fraction of what we pay.

Because we’re the worlds investment bank. It’s a disgrace.

That is not true though, the average monthly salary in Belgium is €2,262, in the UK it is €2,664, the average is Belgium is 15% lower. Also for reference in "Scandinavian" countries they are not "much higher", even in the top of that list which is Denmark, they are only 33% higher. Norway €3,313 (24% higher) Sweden €2,802 (5% higher) Denmark €3,562 (33% higher)

Also, none of that is why food is so cheap in the UK, food is cheap in the UK because the market is dominated by several large supermarkets who have largely competed on price and squeezed farmers and producers for several decades. That combined with JIT supply which is far cheaper, but less resilient and the UK public having unrealistic expectations as to what food should actually cost.

The reason that property prices are high in parts of the UK (mostly London, the South East and South West) is that London and the SE has one of the highest population densities in the world (only really beaten by the likes of Manhattan, Singapore, Tokyo and Hong Kong) and that the South West is highly desirable as a holiday location. UK population growth has outstripped the home building since the seventies, but it was especially out of sync in the early 2000s.

We need lower population growth and more homebuilding, if that is sustained for a decade then house prices will fall.

Belledan1 · 04/10/2021 08:24

Yes but if you are in a budget and can get a chicken for 3.33 and can make a dinner for it why wldnt you. I went to a farm shop to get veg and saw the chicken was 9.00. Yes it would be nicer but if you can get literally get say mince, to make cottage pie, whole chicken for a dinner and say chicken breasts for a curry all for a 10.00 - 3 for 10
00 you would go for that. I have started to go to a butchers van he owns a shop in the next village.

Popoloco · 04/10/2021 08:20

This is why food in the UK is so cheap.

www.statista.com/statistics/722905/average-residential-square-meter-prices-in-eu-28-per-country/

We’ve got the highest housing costs in Europe (exc Monaco) yet among the lower average wage in larger economies.

Average salaries in Belgium, Scandinavian countries and Switzerland are so much higher than ours. Yet their housing costs are a fraction of what we pay.

Because we’re the worlds investment bank. It’s a disgrace.

Upsielazy · 03/10/2021 21:00

Jars of sauces aren't necessarily bad, some are laden with salt and sugar, but some aren't- I've actually found own brands/basics are often full of less crap than the big brands. Just like freezer food isn't bad if its part of a balanced diet.

Willyoujustbequiet · 03/10/2021 20:20

It's more expensive and going up and up and up so your reality sure as hell isn't mine Hmm

NeverDropYourMooncup · 03/10/2021 19:42

@Loveshelly

The thread about roast dinners just proves my point. That people really don’t give a rats arse as long as they can buy a fucking chicken for £3.33

We are fucked, we will end up like America before we know it.

At least land and housing can be relatively cheap there. And petrol. And electricity. Even their (fairly shit) public transport is significantly cheaper. What is expensive for them, however, is medical care.

Make the other living expenses in the UK lower and I'm sure we'll all be less likely to baulk at paying a score for a chicken, even if it's actually due to a misguided moralism that we should be paying more because food is an indulgence, rather than something we need to live.

Loveshelly · 03/10/2021 18:32

@PickUpAPepper
Well exactly, people think that it’s simply about the welfare of the animal. It’s not that simple.

OP posts:
PickUpAPepper · 03/10/2021 18:23

A lot of it is down to distribution and the huge separation between production and destination. Again. Distribution, or lack of it, is Britain's biggest curse.

Loveshelly · 03/10/2021 18:14

The thread about roast dinners just proves my point. That people really don’t give a rats arse as long as they can buy a fucking chicken for £3.33

We are fucked, we will end up like America before we know it.

OP posts:
CuriousaboutSamphire · 03/10/2021 16:30

I'll try and find the weird contracts most farmers end up with when they supply supermarkets.

They get orders for organic veg. When the supermarket decides they have enough organic they buy everything else as 'normal' veg at lower prices. The farmer has no idea how much of which the buyers will take. And they can't sell it elsewhere, that is not allowed. It's also why a high % of the nonorganic labeled veg in a supermarket is actually organic.

It is also why there are many more farm shops and smal enterprises springing up.