Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think he should resign immediately?

130 replies

Leibham · 01/10/2021 21:15

Zarah Sultana MP has reported that today The Conservative Police and Crime Commissioner for North Yorkshire Phill Abbott has said that Sarah Everard should have ‘resisted arrest’ and that women need to be more ‘street smart’.

Victim blaming her and other women effectively.

OP posts:
donquixotedelamancha · 02/10/2021 08:41

She's an MP, and a woman and I'm delighted that she's used her position to point out that the man in charge of N Yorks police is a victim-blaming cunt.

ZS is actively opposed to women's rights. She's just having a go at him to score political points.

If people think his actual warrant resignation, then fair enough, but don't believe what ZS says he said- it's nonsense.

LakieLady · 02/10/2021 08:35

@adawong

Yes he should resign. But Zarah Sultana has fuck all to do with it.
She's an MP, and a woman, and I'm delighted that she's used her position to point out that the man in charge of N Yorks police is a victim-blaming cunt.

Unlike the Home Secretary, who is in a prime position to do something about the institutional misogyny in policing, but is signally failing to do so.

If only there were more MPs prepared to speak out, that might do something to goad the odious Patel into action.

donquixotedelamancha · 02/10/2021 08:32

What Phil Abbott actually said:

Nobody is blaming the victim what I am saying is that we need to inform women far better of their rights, something I intend to action here in North Yorkshire ASAP.

So women, first of all, need to be streetwise about when they can be arrested and when they can't be arrested.

She should never have been arrested and submitted to that.

Perhaps women need to consider in terms of the legal process, to just learn a bit about that legal process

I certainly think he could have phrased some sentences better but his point that women should resist arrest by lone men who are not in uniform is one that's been made a lot over on FWR.

Selkiesarereal · 02/10/2021 08:25

Appalling victim blaming on show. The police really do need to take a hard look at themselves and drop the “one of us” mentality.

I wonder how many of us would have resisted arrest in that situation, I know I wouldn’t have as I have never had any reason not to trust the police and as I middle aged women thought that I was a little street smart.

TheAntiGardener · 02/10/2021 08:21

Resist arrest if the arrest isn’t genuine - very helpful advice. I’d never have thought of it myself, but then I am female and we all know women are a bit silly and lax when it comes to keeping ourselves safe from harm.

Seriously. Quite apart from the clear victim-blaming of the comments, I’m not sure how being better informed would have helped at all in this case. I think you’d have to have had the knowledge of a currently serving officer in that force aware of how the Covid patrols worked to know he was not legit with such certainty that it would be worth the risks of resisting arrest.

toastfiend · 02/10/2021 08:18

What a horrible, insensitive, victim blaming cunt.

Until this happened it would never have occurred to me to resist arrest or make a scene when being arrested by an an officer with the appropriate credentials. I've never been in trouble with the law, it would shock me, embarrass me, and worry me a lot if I was suddenly being arrested for something and I'd be as compliant as possible in the hope that it would all blow over as quickly as possible. There's no way I'd resist arrest and potentially add to their reasons for arresting me or to the possibility of my actually being charged with something. I imagine that Sarah Everard would have taken a similar approach given that, by all accounts, she wasn't someone who would have had contact with the Police in this way before. I would still struggle to know what to do now because the Met's response is so extraordinarily lacking - they're telling us we can challenge it, but how does that actually work? And what does that mean, exactly? We can shout a bit and if someone has bad intentions they'll probably still be able to overpower us and the public won't intervene because it'll look like a legitimate arrest. Great.

Women already go out of our way to protect ourselves every single day. Why can't the onus be placed on men not to attack us? I feel so angry about this.

YourFinestPantaloons · 02/10/2021 08:08

Especially given high crime rates on public transport these days. People are beaten to a pulp on buses and the driver and passengers just sit there doing fuck all. The 'flag down a bus' advice just shows how far removed from reality these people are

Mumoftwoinprimary · 02/10/2021 08:08

@maddening

The Yorkshire police are very anti women
You are thinking of the West Yorkshire police. This is York and North Yorkshire.

Not saying they are not anti women - but it is West Yorkshire that like to arrest women for thought crime.

YourFinestPantaloons · 02/10/2021 08:07

@DuncinToffee

This advice doesn't seem much better www.met.police.uk/notices/met/our-response-to-issues-raised-by-the-crimes-of-wayne-couzens/

Flagging down a bus had been adviced too earlier.

That's just insulting. Unless you are lucky enough to be at a bus stop, a bus is passing and planning to stop there. It's not Harry Potter, you can't just flag down a bus. And even if you did, why is it all now a bus driver's problem?! What can they do?
ftw163532 · 02/10/2021 08:03

@maddening

The Yorkshire police are very anti women
They all are. It's part of the foundation of the institution.
AntiMaskersAreTwats · 02/10/2021 08:00

If I was her family I would make it my life’s work to get everyone who had let Sarah down either prosecuted or sacked. I wouldn’t rest until every single one of them was punished.

RoseAndRose · 02/10/2021 07:59

@maddening

The Yorkshire police are very anti women
There are four police forces covering Yorkshire. Do you mean all of them?

And if so, why is Yorkshire worse than the rest of the country? I'm not being arsey - just wondering if the comment should have been about the toxic end of police culture everywhere.

maddening · 02/10/2021 07:56

The Yorkshire police are very anti women

RoseAndRose · 02/10/2021 07:55

@Eggmcmuffin

Absolutely disgusting, if he stays in his post it says a lot about the police culture.
Well, that'll be up the the voters of North Yorkshire at the next PPC elections

It's not a decision that can be made by the police force, even if an incumbent is someone they despise.

Nightbringer · 02/10/2021 06:00

@madisonbridges

I think what he said was completely wrong. Even leaving Sarah Everard aside, it's totally unreasonable to suggest we learn the entire legal system or resist arrest.

However, I don't think he should resign. Everything is knee-jerk reactions these days, fuelled by a minority on social media. If he's realised his mistake and apologised, then that should be enough.

See this is where I disagree.

I don't want anyone on this position that needs it explained to him, that what he said is wrong and he needs to apologise.

At the very least it shows very very poor judgment and understanding of the situation faced by women going about about their own business. It shows a distinct lack of understanding that people can't just resist arrest.

To me it shows he shouldn't be in this role.

Nightbringer · 02/10/2021 05:58

I just have no words. Me and my family aren't white.

I am sick if having conversations with my children about shit like this. I am sick of telling them that even though they may do nothing wrong, they aren't safe to just go about their business.

Let's be honest, Sarah's murderer wasn't not just one rogue copper. There's systemic problems and has been for years.

Sarah, couldn't have done anything different. She shouldn't have had to do anything different. She shouldn't have had to 'not walk down that street'. WC was driving around. It could have been on another street or he could have chose a different area.

I feel ill that anyone thinks she should have done anything different. And for them to even open their mouths to say it publicly, just horrifies me.

Theres alot of blame to go around, primarily on WC, but non of it should be directed at Sarah. Not even a hint.

madisonbridges · 02/10/2021 05:26

I think what he said was completely wrong. Even leaving Sarah Everard aside, it's totally unreasonable to suggest we learn the entire legal system or resist arrest.

However, I don't think he should resign. Everything is knee-jerk reactions these days, fuelled by a minority on social media. If he's realised his mistake and apologised, then that should be enough.

xksismybestletter · 02/10/2021 05:06

He was elected by the people of north Yorkshire (not Manchester) he can't be sacked, he can resign but there is no power of recall for PCC /pfccs. He also doesn't work for the police so his organisation may not have signed up to the code of ethics - although he probably has a code of conduct, which will be on the website linked upthread.

I believe he has apologised, and I wonder whether he has gone rogue from his Comms team.

Lex345 · 02/10/2021 05:05

I am so fucking sick and tired of having to modify my behaviour, keep myself safe, teach my daughter how to defend herself, listen to #NotAllMen bollocks, listen to victim blaming and listening to excuses. The fact is the attitude towards women in society is wholly unacceptable and it is men that need to change that not women.

Also, I am sick of hearing "he is not a man, but a monster" "not a policeman, but a murderer". He IS a man. He WAS a police officer. I understand why people say these things, to distance themselves and differentiate themselves from him. But until we start accepting that actually MEN are responsible for these atrocious acts towards women and these men can come from all walks of life (because literally the misogyny in our society is so widespread) then nothing will change.

Tolerance of the mistreatment, disrepsect and objectification of women in our society literally feed a nurturing environment for some men to be able to develop these warped, violent and hateful attitudes towards women. Until we address this at every level and men start calling it out as well, there is no hope of change.

Anon778833 · 02/10/2021 05:00

I agree. Disgusting attitude that I've also heard from women yesterday.

When going about your daily business you don't tend to think 'this police officer might be a murderer'.

themidnighttrain · 02/10/2021 04:54

Begin street smart involves telling the difference between a real police officer and a fake police officer.

He was real.

What the hell was she supposed to have done?

YourFinestPantaloons · 02/10/2021 01:14

100% needs to resign, as does Dick.

Swiftly followed by an overhaul in all police forces - reviewing cases of officers who've committed violent acts, looking into toxic cultures in forces and investigating why the fuck nobody is whistleblowing in a very corrupt taxpayer funded institution

TrampolineForMrKite · 02/10/2021 01:12

Yeah he should, but arguably Cressida Dick’s words around this have been equally ugly and insincere and she’s still on her three hundred and odd K a year. I’d love to see her head roll in amidst all this, but I’m pretty sure it won’t.

Not wishing to make this political, but I do think that these kinds of people are allowed to retain top jobs without question when the government in charge of them is as rotten and corrupt as our current one is. It’s a top-down situation in my opinion and Boris Johnson is an insincere, useless and misogynistic fuckface who sacks no one and has been sacked from 90% of his own jobs anyway. Why would any commissioner of anything step down from their jobs for being incompetent or misogynistic when our Prime Minister is both of those things times ten and still residing in Downing Street?

MaskingForIt · 02/10/2021 01:08

@MaskingForIt

Great victim blaming, sister, you really smashed the patriarchy there.
Quote fail. That was aimed at Mrs “I used to live there and would never have walked down that road alone at night”.
MaskingForIt · 02/10/2021 01:03

Great victim blaming, sister, you really smashed the patriarchy there.

Swipe left for the next trending thread