Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

H and prostitutes

236 replies

Ihatevegetables · 01/10/2021 18:14

I want to start this by saying it is probably going to be a long thread, so thank you to those who bear with me and read the whole thing.

My H has always had a strange relationship with sex. We have been together 9 years (no kids) and our sex life has never been what I hoped it would be. The sex is great when we actually do it, however H very rarely initiates and when I initiate, he often says he is too tired. We have gone months at a time without having sex. Over the years I have tried initating myself, calmly explaining to H how important sex is in a marriage and how it makes me insecure and crying and saying that this issue could end our marriage. He always agrees and promises to make more of an effort but after a week or so it goes back to normal.
H is honestly the best husband you could ask for. He has supported me financially and emotionally for 8 years, often to his own detriment, and has continually supported me with my own mental health issues. I have not been an easy person to be with at times. He puts me first in every single way, never gets angry, and truly loves me. I have no doubt of this. He has always been the 'perfect' one, whether it's as a husband, friend or family member. He is a genuinely nice man. However, he had a very fractured childhood and is his own harshest critic, he cannot tolerate himself being anything less than perfect. A few years ago we had just stopped doing long distance and I saw a message on his phone to a friend of his (sent during our time apart) that said he had brought two women back to his flat after a night out. I hit the roof and his explanation was that he had been trying to fit in with a 'laddish' group of friends he had made and had sent the message drunkenly, with no truth to it. I believed him as I do see that he constantly strives to fit in.
Fast forward to last night. We had friends round for drinks and something one of them said (nothing to do with women) raised alarm bells. It strongly implied he had lied about something in order to impress them. This has happened once before and I let it go, however something just didn't sit right and (I'm ashamed to admit) I looked at his phone when he was sleeping. I found numerous whatsapp messages to prostitute hotlines (we live in a country where this is sadly accessable) basically asking for sexual services. In some of the messages he has bartered the price, stated that he would like a discount as he 'had this one before' and has asked for photos of the different women to be sent to him. There are also messages saying he is 'ten minutes away' and asking for their location etc. He lost his wedding ring on a night out about six weeks ago and I saw one message saying that he thinks he left his grandfathers ring at the location the night before and could they please check. I was absolutely heartbroken and confronted him. He completely broke down and eventually explained everything. He found this mortifying as it was a crack in his 'perfect' facade. He said that he sends these messages to different companies when he is very drunk as he is seeking a thrill. When I asked him about why he would need directions etc and why he had asked about his wedding ring, for the former he said that they only send pictures if you confirm you are on your way and for the latter he said that he had panicked the next morning and messaged everyone, including the friends he had been out with, without thinking. He said that he has always had an issue with sex and he is very much 'in his own head', I know this is true and knowing him for 9 years, I can genuinely believe that this is a fantasy he is acting out instead of something he would act on. He was absolutely adamant that he has never actually slept with or met any of these women and never would.

I feel oddly calm, and part of me was almost relieved that this man I had felt for years was too good for me, also had flaws. I am a naturally very suspicious person but I do genuinely believe that he hasnt acted on these fantasies. What I can't get my head around is that our lack of sex over the years has really dented my confidence and caused (the only) major issue in our marriage. I also have spent years thinking he is perfect and too good for me and been completely open with him about my own flaws, and I feel like this has been a lie.

Am I crazy for believing him? If I choose to believe that this is all a fantasy, would anyone else view this as being a flaw that they are willing to overlook (provided it never happens again,) and deem it not that big a deal? I don't know how to feel except that I overreacted, as he is saying that as he never did and never would act on it, it's just a stupid thing he does when very drunk. He also says that he is so ashamed of himself that no matter how angry I am at him, he will always hate himself more. I told him that I forgave him and that we can move on, however he said it didnt matter if I forgave him, he could never forgive himself and I do believe this (ties into him being his own harshest critic).

I'm sorry for this long post, but I feel very confused and I really need some perspective on this. I have certainly made mistakes over the years, like developing a crush on a work colleague (I never acted on it and I think it was due to the lack of sexual attention from H) however I have never cheated on H.

OP posts:
BrendaBubbles · 01/10/2021 19:15

I think he’s lying but at the same time I get the sense you might not hugely care. If sex is literally the only problem you have and for whatever reason you don’t want to end things, have you considered entirely taking sex off the table and both do your own thing in that regard? It’s unorthodox but in these modern times a good spouse does not have to be a good sexual partner and vice versa.

Rewis · 01/10/2021 19:15

Let's pretend he is telling the truth. What is he doing to fix this? Has he promised to go to therapy, suggested couples counselling, sexual therapy? Or is he just saying he is worthless and trying to get you to kick him out so he can be the victim?

Pinklioness · 01/10/2021 19:14

Oh and years ago I was going out with someone who told me he was staying in on NYE to fix his car. I kind of believed him because I wanted to. Looking back it's about as believable as your husband's stories.

Imcatmum · 01/10/2021 19:14

There is literally no way he is telling you the truth. You are just not ready to hear it. I guess you could hunt down the real proof but you are so determined to believe him right now, I'd say he would manage to explain anything away.

Take your time. You will get there but I'm sorry, the end result is the same.

bigbeatmanifesto · 01/10/2021 19:13

He's is no doubt in my mind lying.
I'm sorry OP but the reason he's not sleeping with you is because he's sleeping with prostitutes.

QuentinBunbury · 01/10/2021 19:13

Hes lying
BUT even if he's telling the truth, where does that leave you? Anxious about who he's messaging, what he's doing? Is it escalating, why is he being secretive with his phone, howuch money is he spending?

I've been there with a husband "addicted" to online sex workers, I stupidly believed him that he gave up, he was lying. But for the 5 years I spent after I found out and chose to believe his bullshit I was constantly anxious because the trust was gone.
You don't need proof he's used prostitutes to leave. It's up to you if you can live with a situation where you don't fully trust your husband. I wouldn't recommend it personally, it will drive you mad

blueskytoday06 · 01/10/2021 19:13

It's over Vegetables, I'm sorry. I don't really think there's any coming back from this.
He's most definitely lying & you will undoubtedly regret it should you choose to stay with him.
He has picked sex for sale over sex with you. How can there be anything to salvage.

Best of luck moving on x x

UltimateBugKilla · 01/10/2021 19:13

You sound lovely, and deserve so much more than a sexless marriage with a 'husband' who would rather pay for sex with a stranger than make love to his wife.

He will now do it in secret.

You can let it go, but almost guarantee in a year or 2, he will slip up and you will realise you wasted more of your life on him.

Sorry OP 💐

elliesmummy19 · 01/10/2021 19:13

He has definitely been having sex with prostitutes. Sorry. The wedding ring gives it away 100%.

Get STI tests.

TaraR2020 · 01/10/2021 19:11

I'm sorry op, I also believe he's lying Flowers

youvegottenminuteslynn · 01/10/2021 19:10

@NotSoNewAndShiny

Someone like this, you'd literally have to catch him in the act for him to 'fess up. Even then, he may try out some more lies if he can get away with it.
This. If you walked in and he wasn't literally inside her, he'd pull the 'I couldn't go through with it' / 'I realised as soon as I got here that it wasn't what I wanted' etc. They're all so predictable it's like the get handed a script.
Keke94LND · 01/10/2021 19:10

He's definitely lying, why would he call your wedding ring his grandfathers ring if he was just 'messaging everybody include his friends he had been out with' ?

Pinklioness · 01/10/2021 19:09

@Babdoc

I agree with all the PPs, of course he has actually been using prostitutes. He may be avoiding sex with you in case he passes on a STD, but I think it more likely that he has a madonna/whore complex. If he strives to be “perfect”, he possibly sees sex as something dirty, only to be engaged in with prostitutes, and has difficulty performing with his clean idealised partner. Personally, I would be leaving this relationship pronto, via the STD clinic for an urgent health screen.
This
godmum56 · 01/10/2021 19:08

I think he may well be lying but I don't think it matters. You haven't got the intimate partnership that you want or you deserve and lets be honest its not gonna happen. Don't waste your time.

NotSoNewAndShiny · 01/10/2021 19:08

Someone like this, you'd literally have to catch him in the act for him to 'fess up. Even then, he may try out some more lies if he can get away with it.

seven201 · 01/10/2021 19:07

Reread your post whilst trying to imagine it's not about you and your dh. He is so clearly lying. The messages on their own are enough but he also messaged looking for his lost ring. He is grasping at straws hoping you'll continue to choose to blind yourself to his infidelity. Please open your eyes and accept that he is not who you thought he was at all. I'm sorry, I can't imagine how you must be feeling right now. You will get through this, cling on to that.

Bunnyfuller · 01/10/2021 19:07

He’s lying.

Notimeforaname · 01/10/2021 19:06

STI check, see a solicitor, make plans to leave. Don't talk to him about any of it as you cant trust yourself to be objective when it comes to him and you will end up screwed over
If you take anything from the responses here today, take this. And run

EishetChayil · 01/10/2021 19:05

His excuses are pathetic.

toocold54 · 01/10/2021 19:05

Wow. He doesn't even have the decency to be honest with you, so he's going to gaslight you instead.

This!!

He lied to you about bringing women back to his flat and now he’s lying to you about prostitutes even though there is proof! He is taking you for a mug! I can only imagine what else he has done and obviously his friends must all know too.

Honestly OP I know this is hard to digest but please stop letting him walk all over you! Tell him he needs to tell you the truth or you are leaving today.

Helpimfalling · 01/10/2021 19:04

I'm so sorry but imagine I was telling you the same story about me

It's a crock of shit

DrinkFeckArseBrick · 01/10/2021 19:03

Normally I like to give the benefit of the doubt in these situations.

But anyone in a jury would believe he was guilty OP.

He doesn't want sex with you because he wants it with prostitutes. Classic madonna whore complex. If he wanted a 'thrill' when he was drunk he could have initiated something with his wife.

It's the flimsiest excuse I've ever heard. Bartering a price down because you've done that before isnt idle curiosity or a thrill. Its the nitty gritty of practical arrangements. Messaging everyone he knows, did you get the same message? Did everyone else? Of course not.

STI check, see a solicitor, make plans to leave. Don't talk to him about any of it as you cant trust yourself to be objective when it comes to him and you will end up screwed over

Notimeforaname · 01/10/2021 19:03

Your*

Notimeforaname · 01/10/2021 19:03

For the photos 'only if you are on your way' ...this is a really shit lie.. its literally the first thing he could think of. He must actually think you are a gullible moron.

He didn't see them..never went to see them but he thought he lost his ring there..Hmm. Jeeeesus.

Come on op.

He was texting around all of his friends looking for the ring and checked with the prostitutes even though he's never been ?

If this wasn't someone's real life, I would laugh.
Please open you eyes.

SummerHouse · 01/10/2021 19:00

OP, if you lost your wedding ring, who would you text and what would you call it?

You would call it your wedding ring and text people you had been with.

No one on god's green earth would accidentally text a prostitute they had only previously messaged.

I am so sorry. Men like this are very good at track covering.