Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not be sleep training baby?

120 replies

Willowrose63 · 01/10/2021 18:05

Hello there!

My baby is nearly 8 months old. At night it takes about 45min to settle to sleep(combo of cuddles,nursing,crawling around our bed,singing and then we transfer her into her own cot). There's no crying and it tends to be a lovely snuggly time. She tends to wake up 3 to 4 times per night and wants to breastfeed back to sleep. There were were few occasions when she only woke once or twice but I couldn't figure out if I'd done anything different on those days. My husband has tried settling her various times but she gets more and more worked up. She did have about one month when she would nap in her cot but now has gone back to only contact napping or in pram or car. Naps total 1.5 to 2.5 hours per day. This I do find draining because it means I have no time apart from baby during the day, I do bedtimes and she only wants me(boobs) during the night. I have been feeling OK about her nighttime sleep just because it is so much better than she was for the first few months of her life and she doesn't take long to settle when she does wake up.

Met up with a couple of Mums from my mums group today and one said that her baby had woken up twice during the night TOTAL in the last 2 weeks and otherwise had slept through every night. Tbh it did take the wind out of my sails a bit. All the other mums in our nct group have done some form of sleep training/ controlled crying and rave about it. Some are saying that their babies fall asleep within 5 mins and settle themselves for naps and everything.

We had been thinking that our experience is pretty common. Feeling a bit like the odd ones out and she's our first baby so don't have any comparison.
My Mum says that breastfed babies just don't sleep well and that's the way it is.

Would love to hear others experiences!

OP posts:
Boshmama · 01/10/2021 22:09

Sleep training divides mums almost as much as the breast/bottle debate

My point is mums should listen to themselves and their gut and not some ‘baby whispering expert’ or other. If you’re gut instinct is to sleep train your baby then crack on.

Yes @NatriumChloride I can’t see how anyone can think it’s anything other than a biological milestone? Some babies get there quicker than others same as rolling, walking, talking etc

NewMum0305 · 01/10/2021 22:08

Those who believe sleep training is cruel and just teaches children no one comes if they cry, do you believe, then, that once a child is sleep trained, that’s it - they never call out for a parent ever again because they are too emotionally scarred and damaged. How exactly do you think it works. I’m fascinated.

OP, do what’s right for you - if you’re happy with your child’s sleep, don’t worry about it. If you’re not, then there are a whole range of options option to you.

I did controlled crying at 9 months and my daughter sleeps 7.30-7, with a 2 hour nap consistently now at 2.5 BUT if she needs me or her dad because she feels ill or teething or just wants a cuddle, she will always call us. It’s just that she doesn’t need us there to fall asleep or settle if she wakes in the night. She gets a full night sleep and wakes up happy, my husband and I get our evenings and undisturbed nights. We’re happy and it works for us.

Some people are perfectly happy patting their child to sleep for an hour at age 3. I would not be one of them. x

Briarshollow · 01/10/2021 22:03

There’s some absolute corkers from total and utter dingbats on here whose babies clearly slept like shit and to make themselves feel better they’re spouting the biggest load of guff. 😂

Boshmama · 01/10/2021 22:02

@BridgetGetTheGin it goes against the cultural norm of sleep training but that doesn’t make it bullshit. Lots of worries around normal infant sleep have been created by so called experts who very often have no children of their own and no qualifications. There is no research to support sleep training (and yes also none against it except the instinct of mothers) so these experts are the ones spouting bullshit.

NatriumChloride · 01/10/2021 22:01

@Boshmama

You can’t train a baby to sleep, it’s a biological milestone

You can teach them to stop asking for help from their parents - but that’s not the same thing. You’d just be teaching her that you don’t respond when she’s upset once the sun goes down

Trust your gut and parent how you would if you’d never read a parenting book/ listened to those who had read parenting books!

“A biological milestone.”

Jesus wept.

Briarshollow · 01/10/2021 22:01

@seaandsandcastles

YANBU. I don’t agree with sleep training.

They can rave about it all they want, but the reality is that their baby doesn’t cry simply because they have learnt it’s pointless. They have learnt nobody is coming to comfort them when they’re hungry/cold/hot/sad/just want a hug.

So they can pat themselves on the back for a piss poor job while neglecting their baby when they need their parent the most if they want 🤷‍♀️

Don’t ever doubt yourself. You’re there for baby when they need you. Parenting was never going to be easy, but it is worthwhile Flowers

Get. Bent.
BridgetGetTheGin · 01/10/2021 21:55

@Boshmama

You can’t train a baby to sleep, it’s a biological milestone

You can teach them to stop asking for help from their parents - but that’s not the same thing. You’d just be teaching her that you don’t respond when she’s upset once the sun goes down

Trust your gut and parent how you would if you’d never read a parenting book/ listened to those who had read parenting books!

Christ. Please do not comment on this unless you're an expert in the field.

This is absolute bullshit.

mamaca · 01/10/2021 21:55

My eight month old wakens a few times each night and I also settle her back to sleep with breastfeeding - we bedshare, she's my third and final baby and I'm treasuring this time because I know from past experience how quickly it will pass! As long as you're happy with it, I'd just continue to do what you're doing. I always felt like people would talk about their babies "sleeping through" as if it was the pinnacle of all parenting achievements 🙄

Boshmama · 01/10/2021 21:53

Oh and I never did anything except cuddle and feed my 3 year old to sleep until she moved on in her own time. Now she falls asleep in her bed with me sitting next to her for 5/10 mins and we have a chat about the day - she generally sleeps 7-8.

Antsinmypantsneedtodance · 01/10/2021 21:52
  1. Your baby your business. If your current set up is working for you don't change it.

  2. If your current set up isn't working for you then think ablut what changes you would like to make that you are comfortable with. I detest the term sleep training, it's not bootcamp. But you can work towards supporting poaitive sleep habits and supporting your daughter to settle herself to sleep if thats what YOU want. It doesn't mean sleep throughs, as totally normal for any baby, however they're fed, to wake for a feed in the night. But it can reduce them.

  3. Bin the NCT mums. Seriously. They're generally full of a bunch of competitive parents, who like to show off. If you want to continue with them find some friends with similar outlooks and just nod and smile at the NCT lot.

Boshmama · 01/10/2021 21:49

You can’t train a baby to sleep, it’s a biological milestone

You can teach them to stop asking for help from their parents - but that’s not the same thing. You’d just be teaching her that you don’t respond when she’s upset once the sun goes down

Trust your gut and parent how you would if you’d never read a parenting book/ listened to those who had read parenting books!

Willowrose63 · 01/10/2021 21:47

@Nimle yes the pram must not be stationary Grin

OP posts:
NatriumChloride · 01/10/2021 21:45

@seaandsandcastles

YANBU. I don’t agree with sleep training.

They can rave about it all they want, but the reality is that their baby doesn’t cry simply because they have learnt it’s pointless. They have learnt nobody is coming to comfort them when they’re hungry/cold/hot/sad/just want a hug.

So they can pat themselves on the back for a piss poor job while neglecting their baby when they need their parent the most if they want 🤷‍♀️

Don’t ever doubt yourself. You’re there for baby when they need you. Parenting was never going to be easy, but it is worthwhile Flowers

ODFOD.
sbhydrogen · 01/10/2021 21:45

Everybody in our house is much happier since we've sleep trained with the Ferber method. Sure, those initial four nights were tough, but we've now had almost a year of great sleep.

But who cares, do what works for you and your baby.

Michellexxx · 01/10/2021 21:42

@Blackkoala

Yanbu. I could never bear the idea of controlled crying. It goes against every maternal instinct to leave your baby crying, I simply wouldn’t do it.

My (10mo) baby’s sleep has improved enormously over the last couple of months by us helping him learn to fall asleep in his cot on his own. We have never once left him to cry, but we’ve very gradually helped him settle in the cot by sitting in it with him, patting his back, stroking his face etc. He still wakes at least once most nights, but that is miles better than he was. He also naps really well in his cot now. A couple of months ago he would only contact nap or nap in the car.

Sleep training isn’t necessary imo, and you need to keep doing it over and over anyway. If what you’re doing works for you there’s nothing at all wrong with continuing.

Sleep training can be necessary..as proven by your actions. That was a gentle method of sleep training. Others do it differently, and that’s ok too.

Also, you don’t need to do sleep training again and again either. All it is, is teaching your baby to go to sleep independently, as you did..

Ileflottante · 01/10/2021 21:41

In my antenatal group, all of the babies slept through by a year, except one. The mum of this baby quite nastily ‘accused’ us all of sleep training as she didn’t believe babies could sleep through at that age without it. She said she thought it was cruel. Not a single one of us had done sleep training. We were just lucky. But for me personally sleep was essential. It was what I focused on with my baby and I’d have happily sleep trained if I felt I needed to.

Barearseloverofthigh · 01/10/2021 21:39

seaandsandcastles 👍🏼♥️

BridgetGetTheGin · 01/10/2021 21:36

[quote Willowrose63]@Nannylp yes cuddly time is lovely!

Alot of the time I love it and other days I'm tired and a but touched out. I remember reading online(on a desperate middle of the night googling sesh) that babies had to be taught/trained how to get to sleep by themselves. I guess I was getting a bit concerned that she is still waking and wanting to feed to settle because we hadn't taught her otherwise. Also I'll be going back to work when she's around 14months and I do days and nights. So she will need another way to settle back to sleep if I'm not thereConfused.[/quote]
If you wait too long, toddler days will be a nightmare.

I sleep trained at 9 months and mine sleep 7-7 and nap for 3 hours in the day consistently every day.

If you hold off, toddler sleep is really hard to nip in the bud. Do it now and you'll honestly thank yourself later on.

Willowrose63 · 01/10/2021 21:35

@FlyingPandas good point about not getting caught up in the all or nothing thinking.
And thanks everyone for sharing what has and hasn't worked for them. Reassuring hearing about how different ways worked for different kids.

OP posts:
BridgetGetTheGin · 01/10/2021 21:32

@seaandsandcastles

YANBU. I don’t agree with sleep training.

They can rave about it all they want, but the reality is that their baby doesn’t cry simply because they have learnt it’s pointless. They have learnt nobody is coming to comfort them when they’re hungry/cold/hot/sad/just want a hug.

So they can pat themselves on the back for a piss poor job while neglecting their baby when they need their parent the most if they want 🤷‍♀️

Don’t ever doubt yourself. You’re there for baby when they need you. Parenting was never going to be easy, but it is worthwhile Flowers

This is not what sleeping training. It's giving them the tools to learn to self soothe.

What a damaging and awful message. Especially for Mums, who's last resort may be to sleep train.

jupitermars1345 · 01/10/2021 21:29

Sleep Training doesn't have to mean leaving to cry alone .
I don't know why people assume that's all it is

DeepaBeesKit · 01/10/2021 21:29

Your experience is not unusual but equally I wouldnt say its that common. DS slept 7 til 7 in his own cot from about 16 weeks, despite being EBF. He was always quite easy to settle. DD was down to one feed at night by 6m and none by 8/9m, but definitely wouldn't have still been waking 4 times a night, although she's a worse sleeper than DS (she still at age 2 regularly, almost habitually, has a litle fuss at 10.30 -11pm but is quick to resettle.

They both go down awake and I just leave the room.

TheMagicDeckchair · 01/10/2021 21:21

My first was a terrible sleeper-multiple wakes, would only contact nap etc. Tried sleep training a couple of times when she was about 8 months and it broke my heart to watch her crying for her mummy. I embraced co-sleeping and despite the multiple wakes we managed ok.

She’s coming up to 4 now and still wakes in the night. She’ll settle in her bed if we lay next to her but almost always wakes and finds one of us at some point in the night. It’s the way she was born. I love the snuggles and as long as she needs that closeness and reassurance I’m happy to give it. I hate the idea of her feeling scared and alone.

I now have 5m old twins. Youngest twin is an active baby, a challenge again at night, but he is formula fed and has a dummy. The oldest twin is a textbook unicorn baby, can sleep through for 10 hours with just brief wakes for feeds. They are being raised exactly the same. If either or both need to co-sleep in the future I’ll let them, provided it’s safe.

All babies are different. All families are different. I’ve found that mums are really quick to talk about the good nights but won’t admit they have bad days. Some babies will respond well to sleep training, others won’t. Some babies and children really need lots of cuddles. Others don’t. Some babies need lots of sleep, others much less.

If sleep training isn’t right for you, then please don’t feel peer pressured into doing it. If you can handle the nights wakings then embrace the cuddles, they won’t want them forever!

Blackkoala · 01/10/2021 21:20

Yanbu. I could never bear the idea of controlled crying. It goes against every maternal instinct to leave your baby crying, I simply wouldn’t do it.

My (10mo) baby’s sleep has improved enormously over the last couple of months by us helping him learn to fall asleep in his cot on his own. We have never once left him to cry, but we’ve very gradually helped him settle in the cot by sitting in it with him, patting his back, stroking his face etc. He still wakes at least once most nights, but that is miles better than he was. He also naps really well in his cot now. A couple of months ago he would only contact nap or nap in the car.

Sleep training isn’t necessary imo, and you need to keep doing it over and over anyway. If what you’re doing works for you there’s nothing at all wrong with continuing.

waterrat · 01/10/2021 21:19

If you are happy with your baby and their sleep then ignore them. If you are broken and exhausted it is also fine to sleep train

I hate the judgement against people who make some effort to get their babies sleeping..when one of mine was 7 months I was weeping with stress at his constant waking

I did sleep training and it worked very very quickly. I would say it was gentle we just tried not to pick him up but would sooth him and he did start falling asleep quicker and not waking.

Please stop.judging mums who are keen to get a bit more sleep ! Obviously if you are fine yoi keep on doing what works for you. I also think night waking are normal at 8 months though honestly an 8 month old doesn't need 4 feeds a night. But they also feed for love and comfort which is totally fine !

Swipe left for the next trending thread