Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Only ethnic minority amongst in-laws

39 replies

SnoutingPiglet · 01/10/2021 14:02

My husband and I got engaged a couple of years ago, and the day after he proposed, we went to spend the weekend with his family. Throughout that weekend, his sister was cold towards me, and made a lot of digs, to the point where it was making me so uncomfortable that my now husband spoke to his sister to see if there was something troubling her about our engagement.

She said she was uncomfortable about the idea of change, and us getting married, the idea of not being number one in his life, and she also called me an ‘outsider’, before having quite an awful hysterical crying fit lasting several hours and requiring their parents to try to soothe her. It is worth saying that a month before, she’d asked my husband for money for a new kitchen extension if she bought a new house, to which his response had been that he felt it was important to discuss with me as he was close to proposing, and she said she didn’t want to do that as I was new to their lives and it wasn’t any of my business - even though it would be potentially our pooled money we’d be giving his sister (he previously gave her £50,000 at her first property purchase so she was able to live mortgage-free with her husband, a luxury neither of us have as we have a mortgage!) She also announced in the middle of the hysterics that she was pregnant, although 2 days later she claimed she had miscarried, but a healthy baby was born 8 months later thankfully, weirdly enough!

His parents didn’t say anything to me about the situation was or even acknowledge how their daughter had acted. It was also suggested that i sleep in a separate building, so i was locked out of the main house and slept alone in a different building, an annex, whilst the rest of the family, including my now husband, were in the main house. I felt incredibly isolated - emotionally and physically.

A few weeks later, I suggested I get together with his sister, go for tea and cake and just try to clear the air and put it behind us and try to move on. I also said I’d really like it if she were a bridesmaid at my wedding, as I thought that might clear the air. She declined, and their father suggested we try mediation, with him as the mediator. This was a pretty awkward process.

Fast forward 2.5 years and we send them gifts on birthdays and Christmas, and they also do the same, but we have not seen or spoken to them since that engagement weekend, other than on our wedding day almost 2 years ago which they attended but kept their distance, and thankfully no hysterics.

Given the efforts to try to resolve this, and the fact that my husband’s family haven’t been hugely supportive of reconciliation or trying to welcome me in, my view is that I’d prefer to keep my distance because of how upset it makes me when his sister has a tantrum or how awkward she makes me feel as an ‘outsider’, but it is of course absolutely fine for my husband to have a close relationship with them if he wishes. I just don’t really want to be called an outsider, made to feel isolated, or have digs thrown my way. I keep wondering if her behaviour is because I’m of Asian background, and his whole family are white and they don’t know have any ethnic minorities in their family, and I can’t help but wonder if the attack on how I’m an outsider was somewhat racially motivated.

It seems really sad as my husband and his sister were close before we married and I was looking forward to gaining a sister, but it seems like our marriage has sadly caused division in their family.

AIBU to put distance between myself and people who cause me distress and don’t make me feel particularly included, though?

Thanks for reading a long post!

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Shelddd · 02/10/2021 04:54

It's so difficult to know by like 3rd hand information if something was racist or not but it definitely sounds like it could have been.... but regardless if it was or not your husband should have stayed with you. It was unreasonable for him not to and you should have probably let him know that isn't acceptable behaviour. That needs to be a hard line that it's you and him first before anyone else (unless you have children).

doubleshotcappuccino · 02/10/2021 04:12

I'm also the only brown girl in the ring as Boney M sang it ( showing my age there) and to be honest I've felt the cold air on both sides. PIL are amazing .. but I keep my distance from SIL as she sounds exactly the same as yours. I also have been frozen out on the brown side of the family by some .. so I just shrug my shoulders and remind myself that racism is the problem of the racist not mine.
Don't give this any air time or energy.. honestly it's not worth it - just build some distance and focus on the positive ..

KeepTwirling · 01/10/2021 19:28

Blaming OP for her SIL’s behaviour is an awful thing to do.

You're projecting. Nowhere have I blamed OP for her sil's attitude. Also, OP isn't being abused by her husband so that's an irrelevant comparison.

I'm saying she's complaining about her sil's attitude as if it started today. It didn't, so what's new? It's better she ignores it and not hope for a reconciliation, like I also wrote.

DriftingBlue · 01/10/2021 19:27

The loss of her cash cow of a brother is a possible explanation for the SIL’s behavior. He grew a spine and she couldn’t take advantage of him anymore. Anyone who would expect so much money from a sibling is not a rational person. I would want as little to do with her as possible.

There may also be racial issues at play. Op, you are the one in the situation so it’s your call to decide if they are an issue here.

choli · 01/10/2021 19:26

Sister was furious at the realization that the gravy train had come to the last stop. Be thankful you don't have to see her.

Porcupineintherough · 01/10/2021 19:19

By annexe do you mean guest house or some kind of outbuilding/shed. Because if ots the former Im not sure that constitutes a heinous crime.

Beyong thst though keep your distance, they are clearly nuts.

BoredZelda · 01/10/2021 19:16

I can't quite shake the feeling that banishing you (the one Asian person in the room) to sleep alone in an annex while the rest of the (all white) family including your fiancé sleep in the main house is actually a tiddly bit racist. Almost like sending you out to sleep with "the help". It just makes me feel very uncomfortable that does.

Possibly. Or, the parents have a “not under my roof” rule for non married partners sharing a room. My parents did similar when my brother brought home his first serious girlfriend to stay and there was no room for them to stay in the house.

BoredZelda · 01/10/2021 19:14

It's interesting that you saw what this family was like - especially after he left you to stay in the annex alone - and still married into it. Not sure why it's something to complain about now.

This is a shitty attitude. Would you say the same to a woman who was abused by her partner? If you love someone and are prepared to marry them, should it really be the case you have to give that up because of a sister with questionable morality? Blaming OP for her SIL’s behaviour is an awful thing to do.

StoneofDestiny · 01/10/2021 18:07

I'd be telling your SIL to get a job if she needs money, or talk to her own husband.
I'd run a mile from this nonsense and never offer free money to a spoilt and unhinged relative.

Harlequin1088 · 01/10/2021 17:36

I can't quite shake the feeling that banishing you (the one Asian person in the room) to sleep alone in an annex while the rest of the (all white) family including your fiancé sleep in the main house is actually a tiddly bit racist. Almost like sending you out to sleep with "the help". It just makes me feel very uncomfortable that does.

Your sister-in-law sounds batshit crazy and something of a spoiled brat. Your parents-in-law sound utterly spineless for permitting her to get away with such carryings on.

gannett · 01/10/2021 17:19

I'm also the only non-white person in my in-laws' family. They've been totally normal but I know that feeling of wondering "is it racial? is it not?"

Like many POC I've talked to I've learned to trust that gut feeling about a situation stemming from racism. So I absolutely wouldn't dismiss your suspicion. The "outsider" comment is enough, frankly.

Having said that the sister does sound like she'd have reacted in a batshit way if your husband had married a white woman. The two are not mutually exclusive.

I would thank your lucky stars for the distance you have between them. Don't hope for a reconciliation, hope for further distance and as little interaction with them as possible!

KeepTwirling · 01/10/2021 17:16

It's interesting that you saw what this family was like - especially after he left you to stay in the annex alone - and still married into it. Not sure why it's something to complain about now.

My opinion was going to be "Dont marry him" but since you really wanted to and did already, then make of it what you will. No need to wait for a reconciliation. Why would you even think that?

nothingcanhurtmewithmyeyesshut · 01/10/2021 17:09

I cannot believe you married this man after he let them make you sleep alone in the annexe. Ffs have some respect for yourself because they clearly don't and neither does your husband.

OneTC · 01/10/2021 16:16

tbh my mum didn't let me and my partner sleep in the same room (at her house) despite the fact we'd been living together for a decade and were both 30, and it's 110% because she's Asian, maybe locking you in a separate house was similar bat shittery Grin

But the sil thing, who knows if it's behaviour that's affected by your race but she sounds like fucking tedious hard work

BoredZelda · 01/10/2021 16:07

You’ve taken away her cash cow, now she has to stand on her own two feet.

There could also be a racial element to this, you probably aren’t wrong to assume it has something to do with it.

Either way, it seems unlikely it is anything to do with anything you have personally done and therefore won’t be able to do anything to fix it.

Aquamarine1029 · 01/10/2021 15:48

It was also suggested that i sleep in a separate building, so i was locked out of the main house and slept alone in a different building, an annex, whilst the rest of the family, including my now husband, were in the main house. I felt incredibly isolated - emotionally and physically.

It is absolutely shocking that you went on to marry this man. I hope you're right about how "wonderful" he is, because I doubt that very much.

Lollypop701 · 01/10/2021 15:37

Sil is very unhappy that her additional income stream has ceased…

Notaroadrunner · 01/10/2021 15:34

Hope of reconciliation? Why on earth would you ever want to see them again? I wouldn't want their names mentioned to me again. Keep them well out of your life and if you have children keep them away from Dh's family. They sound toxic.

GianaSister · 01/10/2021 15:32

@WhoNeedsaManOfTheWorld

Did he stay in the annex with you? Shocking behaviour. I wouldn't have anything to do with any of them again and your H is lucky to still have you You owe them nothing
The OP said he stayed in the main house with the rest of the family.

TBH this is appalling behaviour OP. I am also in an interracial relationship and my partners family are all white and I’m not, but they have been nothing but kind and welcoming towards me, like any normal people would be. I don’t know if it’s a racial thing or not as I’m not you, but sometimes you just feel it in your gut, the looks, etc, so I get it. Even if it’s not a racial thing it’s still disgusting and I wouldn’t have anything to do with them. If your husband wants to repair his relationship with his sister let him try and crack on, but I’d be telling him it takes place well away from your home, and to not throw you under the bus in his attempt at reconciliation either.

JelliedHeels · 01/10/2021 15:30

She sounds either unwell or nasty. Just leave them to it and stop trying.

Etinox · 01/10/2021 15:24

Sorry i was confused by the refusing to be a bridesmaid part. 🤞he continues to have your back.
Flowers

LobsterNapkin · 01/10/2021 15:20

Your SIL sounds like a complete nutjob. It could be a race thing but my inclination is to say that someone behaving that way is kind of possessively crazy and also would have been just as put out by your husband marrying anyone.

I wonder a bit if the parent's issue is a result of having to manage her over the years, they've lost touch with what's normal or are always trying to keep her from flying off the handle, but then sometimes whole families can be quite strange, and some never really accept people who have married in.

I would tend to keep some distance from them as well, personally.

WhoNeedsaManOfTheWorld · 01/10/2021 15:04

Did he stay in the annex with you?
Shocking behaviour. I wouldn't have anything to do with any of them again and your H is lucky to still have you
You owe them nothing

Etinox · 01/10/2021 14:56

@TheQueenOfDreams

How did your husband not put his foot down when you were banished to the annexe? You should have left them then and there. Awful family.
This. I’d not be getting married to someone who treated me like that.
SammyScrounge · 01/10/2021 14:49

@LaBellina

They sound like hard work and your SIL sounds immature, spoiled, selfish and attention seeking. I would be happy in your shoes that I could avoid any trouble by avoiding them. I think YANBU at all. Enjoy your drama free life Smile
I agree with this. You have put up with a lot and tried to be a peace maker in a family that doesn't make the slightest effort to make you feel included. They have been incredibly rude to you. From now on, let them hang as they grow.
Swipe left for the next trending thread