Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

"Only women have cervixes"...

141 replies

Yetano · 01/10/2021 13:30

So, I was as pissed off as most and thought Fuck off Starmer, how the hell do they make someone a cervix? etc, especially after the outrageous "bodies with vaginas" article. However...

Have just been reading that the whole argument originated with Trans men not being able to get cervical smears and people ending up having to have a colcoscopy due to delays in screening.

Trans men, do, of course start with a cervix, and presumably retain one. Apparently, the computer systems make it difficult or impossible to book a smear.

I've often thought that Trans men get a raw deal in the whole trans debate. It mostly seems to be centred around trans women's wants and needs and that this is yet another example of women, or in this case, former women's needs being sidelined and not heard.

OP posts:
montysma1 · 01/10/2021 16:58

It's their own fault for insisting on registering as the sex which they are not. This means they will be called for screening for cancers and body parts they don't have. And wont be called for screening of body parts they do have.
That's why it's insanity for forms to be filled in with gender and not sex.

MadeOfStarStuff · 01/10/2021 16:55

The solution is obviously to show a persons sex on their medical records and also to record separately how they choose to identify. But it seems maintaining a record that trans people are in fact trans offends them. So instead women have to deal with our biology being denied with this “people who have a cervix” none sense. Because if we’re offended then we’re terfs so it’s apparently ok to ignore us.

Gncq · 01/10/2021 16:39

However women's safety is not in question here or taking away rights from anyone but making life easier for trans men but the safety of women who identify as men absolutely IS in question because an unscientific ideologically derived decision is allowing people to lie on medical records about their sex which makes life more risky for transmen, not "easier".

Whatsnewpussyhat · 01/10/2021 16:36

Maybe "females of all identities have a cervix" would be better?

But that still makes it sound like everyone has a 'gender identity'

All female specific healthcare should be targeted and women or girls first and foremost and use the words women/woman at the forefront on any website, leaflet, etc anything else can be an add on and those who wish to opt out of 'woman' can simply ask their individual GP or healthcare provider to use whatever pronouns they want.

But then we all know it's truely about the males not allowing us any mention of woman, women or female when talking about solely female biology because our pesky biology is a constant reminder that no matter what they demand or remove from us, it won't change their sex.

Whatsnewpussyhat · 01/10/2021 16:15

However women's safety is not in question here or taking away rights from anyone but making life easier for trans men

THEY demanded their sex marker be changed on their medical records then moan when they don't like the consequences.

They KNOW they are female and will require female health care which no one is stopping access to.

Why the bloody hell should a minuscule minority of females, who don't want to use the word woman, tell 51% of the population that we must now all be referred to as body parts in case it upsets them? Seriously?

No.

They can define themselves as they like, but their issue with their bodies, sex, dysphoria or poor mental health are theirs to deal with, not everyone else's to tiptoe around and pander to.

'Making life easier for transmen' should not require the wholesale removal of the words woman/women from female healthcare, because that IS removing our right to name ourselves and our sex class as separate to men, and there is only one sex that benefits from women being dehumanised and viewed as a collection of body parts. It gives men permission to treat us as things rather than people. Things that don't deserve rights or even a name.

Gncq · 01/10/2021 15:45

Quoting myself here bc I might have rushed this part "females of all genders have a cervix"

Maybe "females of all identities have a cervix" would be better?

(Let's not get wrapped up in hysteremies and DSD if you have had a hysterectomy I think you'd well know it, and if you have a DSD you'll find out at your smear if you didn't already know).

Kittii · 01/10/2021 15:44

If you choose to change your sex on your medical records how can you then complain that you are being treated as that sex for medical purposes? It makes no sense.

shouldistop · 01/10/2021 15:38

And that's why someone's sex shouldn't be changed on their medical records. Because you can't change sex. Why not just add a field that they prefer to be known as a man?

Gncq · 01/10/2021 15:38

This is not a reason to say men can have cervixes. Men cannot have a cervix.

Exactly. Or call us the completely dehumanising and offensive term "bodies with a cervix".

Gncq · 01/10/2021 15:36

This thread shows that much of the resistance here and elsewhere to expanding trans rights is in fact motivated by sheer prejudice

It's motivated by sheer unadulterated anger actually. Not AT trans people themselves it's the ideology and consequences of it, and how that impacts everyone.

Transmen are women who identify as men, and are therefore a type of woman, the same as women who identify as NB, and women who don't have a gender identity.

This is why it's crucial to include both sex and gender identity in all confidential documents kept about us. Not just "gender" (most people don't believe in it) and not just "sex" either. Both.

The anger comes from the awareness that all our women-centred language and rights are being destroyed, rather than anyone applying some bloody common sense. No one is looking at the impact that a largely incoherent, extreme and unscientific belief system is having on people from ALL walks of life, ie the majority of people, not just one group. We're seeing the consequences now and we're angry and shocked.

It's really easy to say "females of all genders have a cervix" instead of pretending this isn't true.

Chewieboora · 01/10/2021 15:34

Exactly @tilder

tilder · 01/10/2021 15:21

Surely they have a right to a smear test already? Every biological woman who has a cervix has this right. Nobody is denying that transmen have a right to sex appropriate healthcare.

The issue as I understand it is about Not receiving notification that a smear test is due.

Notification is sent to registered female patients on a timescale determined by their age and risk. I understand from friends who have had a hysterectomy that removed the cervix, that they get a letter telling them they will no longer be called.

Incidentally I know lots of women who do not receive a reminder that their smear is due. And I know lots more ignore it or don't understand what it is or why it is important.

The problem seems to be if you are registered male with your GP, you don't get included on the smear reminder list.

So solutions are an NHS database upgrade (which we all know is cheap to do and always goes smoothlyHmm), remaining registered by biological sex for health reasons or taking personal responsibility.

None of which will appeal to everyone.

tilder · 01/10/2021 15:08

@Whatiswrongwithmyknee

There is a common sense solution - accept that a transman is a woman. Call yourself what you want but biologically you are a woman. There are two sub-sets of women, people who call themselves women and people who call themselves a tranman. They are all women.
I am not a subset of 'women'!! I am a woman. No subset. No prefix. Just woman.
Rugsofhonour · 01/10/2021 15:05

This reply has been deleted

Withdrawn at the user's request

elodie77 · 01/10/2021 14:57

Can you elaborate on this section? Which rights need to be expanded?

For example to make it easier for trans men to get a cervical smear as mentioned in the OP.

WhoNeedsaManOfTheWorld · 01/10/2021 14:52

It's about taking responsibility for your own decisions and health. The system automatically sends out appointments to females of a certain age for smear tests. If you choose to change your sex marker the system cannot pick you up
If you choose not to tell a HCP your actual sex at an emergency admission you are putting yourself at risk
Male and female physiology is completely different. Personal responsibility

Chewieboora · 01/10/2021 14:49

This thread shows that much of the resistance here and elsewhere to expanding trans rights is in fact motivated by sheer prejudice.

Can you elaborate on this section? Which rights need to be expanded?

elodie77 · 01/10/2021 14:48

Interesting. This thread shows that much of the resistance here and elsewhere to expanding trans rights is in fact motivated by sheer prejudice.

I received quite a bit of bullying and name calling on a thread when I suggested that the debate needed to be more nuanced and that trans people also deserved rights and dignity. I was told women's safety was more important, and that is a valid point.

However women's safety is not in question here or taking away rights from anyone but making life easier for trans men, and yet posters make offensive remarks about trans people, mainly trans men here, and question the validity of transsexualism full stop. That sounds very much like transphobia.

Also following the braids thread with interest, with many white women shouting down black women for pointing out where the problem lies and demanding the right to continue to wear braids.

I'm beginning to agree with those who see a problem with white feminism, and I say that as a white feminist.

www.nbcnews.com/news/nbcblk/koa-beck-dismantling-persistence-white-feminism-n1253555

SirVixofVixHall · 01/10/2021 14:26

@Marguerite2000

The NHS should never have agreed to change the sex marker on medical records. Absolutely ridiculous.
Agree.
Patapouf · 01/10/2021 14:23

@Chewieboora

What difference does gender make to health needs?

Surely only sex matters for those? Trying to think of something where gender would impact medical treatment.

Mental health services perhaps 👀
Patapouf · 01/10/2021 14:23

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk guidelines.

Whatiswrongwithmyknee · 01/10/2021 14:05

There is a common sense solution - accept that a transman is a woman. Call yourself what you want but biologically you are a woman. There are two sub-sets of women, people who call themselves women and people who call themselves a tranman. They are all women.

Marguerite2000 · 01/10/2021 14:04

The NHS should never have agreed to change the sex marker on medical records. Absolutely ridiculous.

Yetano · 01/10/2021 13:58

YES, what tilder said.

OP posts:
tilder · 01/10/2021 13:55

@herculesoffline

I've often thought that Trans men get a raw deal in the whole trans debate

Trans men don't seem to draw the same story of ire from transphobes who sensationalise.

Transmen never feature in TRA arguments. This is a reflection on TRAs, not feminists.

The NHS website (and the lancet) refers to men when it talks about male specific health issues. It is only women that are erased.

It's misogyny. Place the blame where it belongs.

Swipe left for the next trending thread