Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

"Only women have cervixes"...

141 replies

Yetano · 01/10/2021 13:30

So, I was as pissed off as most and thought Fuck off Starmer, how the hell do they make someone a cervix? etc, especially after the outrageous "bodies with vaginas" article. However...

Have just been reading that the whole argument originated with Trans men not being able to get cervical smears and people ending up having to have a colcoscopy due to delays in screening.

Trans men, do, of course start with a cervix, and presumably retain one. Apparently, the computer systems make it difficult or impossible to book a smear.

I've often thought that Trans men get a raw deal in the whole trans debate. It mostly seems to be centred around trans women's wants and needs and that this is yet another example of women, or in this case, former women's needs being sidelined and not heard.

OP posts:
elodie77 · 01/10/2021 18:01

That's exactly what you said. And I just explained what I meant.

CuriousaboutSamphire · 01/10/2021 17:53

@elodie77

by saying its "just silly" that some women don't know they have cervixes you are merely demonstrating your own privilege and ignorance. As I said upthread, the Economist has reported in the last few days that 40% of women do not know what a cervix is.

That's not what I said. I meant that it's very unlikely that the NHS would devise a system whereby women would miss out on smear tests because of they didn't understand the terminology. Just the usual hysterical style on this issue.

It is people like this who cannot cope with anyone having a different opinion.

Except they did, as has been explained.

Sex is not a mandatory tick box, gender is. That is why these mistakes are being made. Gender ideology shaped the NHS data capture and this is the fall out - as predicted by many people over many years.

It has happened before and will continue to happen until someone somewhere calls a halt to the sheer lunacy of being able to opt out of your sex in your NHS data.

Kittii · 01/10/2021 17:51

@elodie77

Whatiswrongwithmyknee You haven't read the thread or my post properly. There is much that is offensive and transphobic in this thread, including in your post, and also just wrong. For example this is just silly some women don't know they are 'cervix havers' so could well not realise that they need a smear.

And not sure what you are trying to say here, but it is clear you haven't understood my post. If you think white women should not be 'shouting down' white women can you tell me why you think it's OK for men to shout down women? I know there is a small pocket of women who feel the same but the reality is the abuse and insulting which happens when women speak about their concerns is largely coming from biological men.

That's exactly what you said.
tilder · 01/10/2021 17:51

has been stated before by those who know, on numerous threads, that the NHS record has fields for both sex and gender

I didn't know this. If people don't fill in forms properly and accurately then it's fairly obvious where the fault lies. If the default for healthcare is gender, then I would ask why.

That both options are there and it still doesn't work says a lot.

AngeloMysterioso · 01/10/2021 17:49

Let’s be honest- the reason TRAs have an issue with the phrase “only women have a cervix” is because it means those with male anatomy (ie transwomen) are not considered to be women. Concern for the welfare of transmen is very much secondary to that point.

elodie77 · 01/10/2021 17:48

by saying its "just silly" that some women don't know they have cervixes you are merely demonstrating your own privilege and ignorance. As I said upthread, the Economist has reported in the last few days that 40% of women do not know what a cervix is.

That's not what I said. I meant that it's very unlikely that the NHS would devise a system whereby women would miss out on smear tests because of they didn't understand the terminology. Just the usual hysterical style on this issue.

It is people like this who cannot cope with anyone having a different opinion.

WarriorN · 01/10/2021 17:47

Marguerite2000
The NHS should never have agreed to change the sex marker on medical records. Absolutely ridiculous.

What's most worrying is that this will be changed on transitioning children's records.

CuriousaboutSamphire · 01/10/2021 17:46

Ooh! I got snarked! 😝

CuriousaboutSamphire · 01/10/2021 17:46

I was going to argue with you @AngeloMysterioso, but then the picture showed up.

Bloody idiots - which is part of what so very many people have been saying for years!

elodie77 · 01/10/2021 17:45

CuriousaboutSamphire

You seem to accuse me of your own failings which is the usual style of those who have poor debating skills!

Logic, research and humour my arse!

DeepaBeesKit · 01/10/2021 17:45

The problem is that transmen will change their gender marker with the NHS. There is no sex marker. Those recorded as men are not called for smears - that bit is common sense. Rather than force 51% of the population to be referred to as “people with cervices” the NHS could add a biological sex marker to the record system. That would also avoid trans women being called for smears they don’t need (for “validation” or anything else).

This. The NHS simply need to record accurate, factual biological information. Eg whether you are XX, XY, XXY etc.

Kittii · 01/10/2021 17:44

@elodie77 by saying its "just silly" that some women don't know they have cervixes you are merely demonstrating your own privilege and ignorance. As I said upthread, the Economist has reported in the last few days that 40% of women do not know what a cervix is.

AngeloMysterioso · 01/10/2021 17:44

Not giving transgender people healthcare appropriate to their physiology = “transphobic”

Giving transgender people healthcare appropriate to their physiology = also “transphobic”

"Only women have cervixes"...
Xenia · 01/10/2021 17:43

Although I don't bnother with smear tests so I doubt it is a big deal for the very few people who are transmen (ex women)

PenguindreamsofDraco · 01/10/2021 17:41

Well they're hardly "former women" are they. What with humans not being able to change sex and all.
But otherwise, the emphasis on men is not a surprise, surely.

CuriousaboutSamphire · 01/10/2021 17:37

@elodie77

Can you elaborate on this section? Which rights need to be expanded?

For example to make it easier for trans men to get a cervical smear as mentioned in the OP.

You mean as in the options suggested in quite a few posts here, and across similar threads?

Maybe read what has actually been posted rather than arriving with a preconceived idea and slapping down whatever it was you had to say, without reading anything

It'll make you seem less daft, for a start!

elodie77 · 01/10/2021 17:34

Whatiswrongwithmyknee You haven't read the thread or my post properly. There is much that is offensive and transphobic in this thread, including in your post, and also just wrong. For example this is just silly some women don't know they are 'cervix havers' so could well not realise that they need a smear.

And not sure what you are trying to say here, but it is clear you haven't understood my post. If you think white women should not be 'shouting down' white women can you tell me why you think it's OK for men to shout down women? I know there is a small pocket of women who feel the same but the reality is the abuse and insulting which happens when women speak about their concerns is largely coming from biological men.

CuriousaboutSamphire · 01/10/2021 17:34

@herculesoffline

I've often thought that Trans men get a raw deal in the whole trans debate

Trans men don't seem to draw the same story of ire from transphobes who sensationalise.

No. Instead the inequity they experience illustrates perfectly the dangers of gender ideology that we, us nasty TERFY gender critical women, have been shouting about for years.

So come and talk to is about it, instead of plopping down your one line of supposed cleverness.

We will be waiting, patient as ever, to engage with logic, research and humour.

You never know, you might like it.

ditalini · 01/10/2021 17:33

It has been stated before by those who know, on numerous threads, that the NHS record has fields for both sex and gender.

However, only one of these is mandatory and pulls through when these screening decisions are made, and that's GENDER.

Now, that didn't happen by accident did it? Someone didn't just stick a pin in and see which of those fields they'd make the important one, and which one would be left to go mostly unpopulated.

Given the vigorous campaigning to get gender to take presidence over sex by certain groups I think transpeople should know exactly whos feet to lay their complaints at.

When you pretend that sex doesn't matter any more and try to erase it from the records of public life, don't be surprised when sex-linked issues bite you hard on the arse.

I fully expect anyone who gives a shit about trans healthcare to demand that the field for sex is populated in medical records without exception, with an optional field for gender to be used in cases where the patient's gender identity is important to them to facilitate person-centred care.

Sparklybanana · 01/10/2021 17:28

For medical purposes, people should be listed as their sex and not gender. If you identify as something else then that should be explained in your notes. Transmen need cervical smears and transwomen need prostate exams. These things require the medical profession to know if you are an owner of one of these body parts. You can shout 'I'm a woman' all you want and suppress your hormones but at the end of the day, no one is changing your sex regardless of what surgery you've had and how loud you shout otherwise. Gender is fluid. Sex is genetic.

Whatiswrongwithmyknee · 01/10/2021 17:22

Yes @Kittii

So the only way to consider that 'not a risk to women's safety' is to think that it doesn't really matter.

Kittii · 01/10/2021 17:21

The Economist reported that 40% of women don't know what a cervix is. So women's safety is at risk, and it's often those with English as a second language or from lower socio-economic sections of society that will be harmed.

Whatiswrongwithmyknee · 01/10/2021 17:20

Maybe "females of all identities have a cervix" would be better?

I don't have a gender identity. Do I still have a cervix? Putting it like this perpetuates the idea of gender identity being universal which, given the damage it's doing to many people's wellbeing is not helpful.

Whatiswrongwithmyknee · 01/10/2021 17:18

[quote elodie77]Interesting. This thread shows that much of the resistance here and elsewhere to expanding trans rights is in fact motivated by sheer prejudice.

I received quite a bit of bullying and name calling on a thread when I suggested that the debate needed to be more nuanced and that trans people also deserved rights and dignity. I was told women's safety was more important, and that is a valid point.

However women's safety is not in question here or taking away rights from anyone but making life easier for trans men, and yet posters make offensive remarks about trans people, mainly trans men here, and question the validity of transsexualism full stop. That sounds very much like transphobia.

Also following the braids thread with interest, with many white women shouting down black women for pointing out where the problem lies and demanding the right to continue to wear braids.

I'm beginning to agree with those who see a problem with white feminism, and I say that as a white feminist.

www.nbcnews.com/news/nbcblk/koa-beck-dismantling-persistence-white-feminism-n1253555[/quote]
You are absolutely wrong. Of course trans people deserve rights and there is nothing here to suggest any single person disagrees with you. But the 'rights' argument does not include the right to put others at risk as you well know.

Women's safety IS in question here both directly (some women don't know they are 'cervix havers' so could well not realise that they need a smear) and indirectly (reducing a woman to her body parts and disrepecting her buondaries is at the heart of much of the physical, sexual and emotional violence women suffer). What has anyone said that you find offensive? Do you find it offensive when the simply biology of femaleness is pointed out? Or do you find it offensive when people question the mental wellbeing of people who believe things which are patently untrue? (i.e. that 'a woman is a man' - which is quite different from 'a woman is a transman').

If you think white women should not be 'shouting down' white women can you tell me why you think it's OK for men to shout down women? I know there is a small pocket of women who feel the same but the reality is the abuse and insulting which happens when women speak about their concerns is largely coming from biological men.

It is hugely offensive of you to say that women's safety is not in question. It's arrogantly dismissive of women's legitimate concerns. But you can keep on hiding behind the transphobia slur if you want rather than entertaining for even a moment that anyone who disagrees with you might have a valid point.

Siameasy · 01/10/2021 17:16

They could have a marker of “trans man” so that when they turn up and look like a bloke the practitioner knows what to expect. But for medical reasons, their actual sex must be listed. Even if they don’t like it.

Swipe left for the next trending thread