Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

"Only women have cervixes"...

141 replies

Yetano · 01/10/2021 13:30

So, I was as pissed off as most and thought Fuck off Starmer, how the hell do they make someone a cervix? etc, especially after the outrageous "bodies with vaginas" article. However...

Have just been reading that the whole argument originated with Trans men not being able to get cervical smears and people ending up having to have a colcoscopy due to delays in screening.

Trans men, do, of course start with a cervix, and presumably retain one. Apparently, the computer systems make it difficult or impossible to book a smear.

I've often thought that Trans men get a raw deal in the whole trans debate. It mostly seems to be centred around trans women's wants and needs and that this is yet another example of women, or in this case, former women's needs being sidelined and not heard.

OP posts:
lachy · 01/10/2021 19:54

@ShrillSiren, @CuriousaboutSamphire & @PurgatoryOfPotholes

Thank you for the info. I'm ashamed to say that this is an area I know very little about, but an area I want my daughter to be educated about.

She is still only very young, but at 5 years old, she has recently started asking interesting questions and I want to be able to answer her.

elodie77 · 01/10/2021 19:53

I used both examples of the bullying I received for giving a different opinion to the 'received' one here about trans right (and other quite personal things actually) and the abuse the black women got on the braids thread to illustrate that there are quite abusive mobs here on MN who use cheap, bullying tactics to shout down people don't agree with them. I think it gets to the point that people can no longer come here expressing a different viewpoint because they get childish abuse. You should be able to debate in a civilised manner.

I can accept anger and humour but not bullying. I think MN is becoming an echo chamber on many issues and I think the critique I shared on white feminism is quite apt.

PurgatoryOfPotholes · 01/10/2021 19:52

After Joe Biden's successful electoral win, a transwoman tweeted him, asking if women's healthcare could be called something else, saying the term was inaccurate as "I'm a woman and I don't use them"

limitedperiodonly · 01/10/2021 19:49

I dearly want Wayne Couzens the police officer who abducted, raped, murdered and desecrated Sarah Everard to identify as a woman and request a transfer to a women's prison and for Sir Keir "that's not right" Starmer and Shadow Justice Secretary David "dinosaurs hoarding rights" Lammy to explain their position on this. I don't have it in for Labour - Lib Dem, Green and SNP politicians are the same. It's just that I used to vote Labour.

FrankButchersDickieBow · 01/10/2021 19:48

@ProfessorInkling

If a transman, who was not called for a smear, phoned the surgery and booked it, they'd do it. So if you're going to take on the responsibility of having changed your sex marker with the NHS, perhaps you could also bear the responsibility of getting the health checks relevant to your biology.
100%

It's not the NHS's fault.

I also recall a story where a transman was given the incorrect dosage of medication, which nearly killed them.

It was not on their records that they were trans and biologically female and they were saying that healthcare for trans people was appalling.

Well disclose your biology and you will be treated accordingly!

MummBraTheEverLeaking · 01/10/2021 19:40

@AngeloMysterioso

Let’s be honest- the reason TRAs have an issue with the phrase “only women have a cervix” is because it means those with male anatomy (ie transwomen) are not considered to be women. Concern for the welfare of transmen is very much secondary to that point.
This, right here.

This is why women are bodies with vaginas in the Lancet and men in the Lancet are, well, men. This is why we're menstruators but Prostate Cancer adverts tagline is Men, we are with you. As far as I'm aware no one is up in arms about that.

Can you imagine the uproar if there were ads on the telly about Ovarian cancer with the tagline, Women, we are with you. Fuck me, twitter would explode with all the mouth frothing, calls for banning the ad, heads to roll, apologies to be made.

If you change your SEX marker, the onus should be on you to sort out your healthcare. The NHS has bigger fish to fry than to tippytoe around and make sure your gender has to be validated first. You have a cervix to swab, the same as every other cervix to swab that was or will ever be. Job done.

But I'm not kidding myself that all the activists have worked themselves up over the plight of healthcare in transmen. This has been latched onto because there is a directed effort to remove anything that links the word woman to anything uniquely female. Because there are males who say they too are women, and this upsets them. And further down the line, we can't say female either because it's too triggering for the transmen and non binaries, so guess who gets to claim the word female then Hmm

TheWeeDonkey · 01/10/2021 19:32

@pigsDOfly

It makes no sense for the NHS to allow people to change their sex markers in matters medical.

It's the NHS, an organisation, that must surely have knowledge of biology and must therefore know full well that no one is capable of changing their sex despite what many people want to believe.

I don't understand either. Buck Angel is a prominent transman who has spoken very honestly about the damage testosterone does to female reproductive system. This is really important and another reason why it is essential to be honest and open about biology when it comes to your health.
PurgatoryOfPotholes · 01/10/2021 19:13

Excuse my ignorance...how can any woman not know this? It is basic biology is it not?

Were you born knowing you had a skeleton, a brain, or islets of Langerhans in your pancreas?

I'm going to take a punt on it that the answer is no. Knowledge that you have a uterus and it connects to the vagina, and the connection point is called a cervix is knowledge you acquired.

How many opportunities did you have to acquire it? Was female anatomy covered in detail on a weekly basis, at your school in all attainment streams? Or w2as it more of a one-off thing? What if someone had been off that week?

Realistically, reminding teenagers of cervix placement can't be high priority learning through years 9 and 11. There is so much else to do, and children are still leaving school unable to read. I know this, because I saw it first-hand. (I went to a school with a very high rate of illiteracy due to my own (slightly different) unique educational needs!)

The default person, including when we talk about people with learning disabilities, is male. But women have learning disabilities too. There is also the issue of acquired cognitive disabilities. We are all one incident of bad luck away from an accident that causes irreversible brain injuries, and if the only thing you lose is your knowledge of internal biology, you'll be lucky.

extract

In England, adult literacy is often referred to in terms of ‘levels’ – for example, a 2011 government survey of adult literacy skills found that 14.9% (or 1 in 7) of adults in England have literacy levels at or below Entry Level 3, which is equivalent to the literacy skills expected of a nine to 11-year-old.

More recently, in 2015, the OECD conducted itsSurvey of Adult Skills, known as PIAAC (Programme for the International Assessment of Adult Competencies). This survey found that 16.4% (or 1 in 6) of adults in England, and 17.9% (or 1 in 5) adults in Northern Ireland, have literacy levels at or below Level 1, which is considered to be 'very poor literacy skills'.

(Continues)

Entry Level 3is equivalent to literacy levels at age 9-11. Adults with skills below Entry Level 3 may not be able to understand labels on pre-packaged food or understand household bills.Level 1is equivalent to GCSE grades D-G. Adults with skills below Level 1 may not be able to read bus or train timetables or understand their pay slip.

From: literacytrust.org.uk/parents-and-families/adult-literacy/what-do-adult-literacy-levels-mean/

pigsDOfly · 01/10/2021 19:11

It makes no sense for the NHS to allow people to change their sex markers in matters medical.

It's the NHS, an organisation, that must surely have knowledge of biology and must therefore know full well that no one is capable of changing their sex despite what many people want to believe.

CuriousaboutSamphire · 01/10/2021 19:03

Start here Lachy. I'm on my phone, it's a bit long-winded posting links

www.bbc.co.uk/news/health-40444170.amp

MumW · 01/10/2021 19:00

Let me just say I have no issue with genuine trans-wo/men. It's self-identication that makes me uncomfortable.

However, I have long thought that self-identifying trans-women seem to be the most vocal/controversial and suspect that there is an element of "women have moved towards more equality so (certain) men have found another way to assert their 'superiority ' "

lachy · 01/10/2021 19:00

@ShrillSiren

The survey, commissioned by INTIMINA and conducted by OnePoll, asked American respondents what the menstrual cycle was in their own words

Thank you for the link. Interesting to read. I wonder if the results would be different if conducted in the UK?

CuriousaboutSamphire · 01/10/2021 18:59

My apologies, almost 50%!

CuriousaboutSamphire · 01/10/2021 18:59

As has been said many, many times... Low literacy levels, low education levels, English as 2nd, 3rd language. All sorts of reasons but a recent poll suggested that 40% of wen inthe UK don't know what a cervix is.

Which is why women who do are objecting to the 'inclusive' wording that manages to include, comfort, assuage what, 0.6% of women, same again of men? Whilst simultaneously excluding 40% of the very people in need... Women!

lachy · 01/10/2021 18:48

some women don't know they are 'cervix havers' so could well not realise that they need a smear

Excuse my ignorance...how can any woman not know this? It is basic biology is it not?

Trans Men surely know that they have female biology - including their reproductive and sexual organs, just as Trans Women know that their biology is male?

Our outward appearance can be changed, but our biology cannot. A female pelvis will always be different to a male pelvis. Trans Men are not at risk of prostate cancer, trans women are not at risk from cervical cancer.

Biology tells us that women have cervixes. Your biological sex is crucial information in accessing the correct health care.

AlfonsoTheDinosaur · 01/10/2021 18:47

[quote elodie77]Interesting. This thread shows that much of the resistance here and elsewhere to expanding trans rights is in fact motivated by sheer prejudice.

I received quite a bit of bullying and name calling on a thread when I suggested that the debate needed to be more nuanced and that trans people also deserved rights and dignity. I was told women's safety was more important, and that is a valid point.

However women's safety is not in question here or taking away rights from anyone but making life easier for trans men, and yet posters make offensive remarks about trans people, mainly trans men here, and question the validity of transsexualism full stop. That sounds very much like transphobia.

Also following the braids thread with interest, with many white women shouting down black women for pointing out where the problem lies and demanding the right to continue to wear braids.

I'm beginning to agree with those who see a problem with white feminism, and I say that as a white feminist.

www.nbcnews.com/news/nbcblk/koa-beck-dismantling-persistence-white-feminism-n1253555[/quote]
Nice try at derailing the thread.

stairway · 01/10/2021 18:45

The solution is obvious. Since men can have a cervix too and not everyone knows what a cervix is, everyone of a certain age should be called in for a smear test. A nurse should easily be able to tell during the procedure if the person in question is a cervix haver or not and no one shall be mis gendered ever.

RufustheBadgeringReindeer · 01/10/2021 18:26

For example this is just silly some women don't know they are 'cervix havers' so could well not realise that they need a smear

Its not silly at all

PurgatoryOfPotholes · 01/10/2021 18:23

Why are you, a self-acknowledged white woman, pulling black women's hair into a discussion of how the NHS keeps data?

I have said this before and I will keep saying it.

Black men and women are not a tool for white people to use against white people they don't like.

foxgoosefinch · 01/10/2021 18:17

*Also following the braids thread with interest, with many white women shouting down black women for pointing out where the problem lies and demanding the right to continue to wear braids.

I'm beginning to agree with those who see a problem with white feminism, and I say that as a white feminist.*

Why are you conflating these two issues? Gender critical feminism is not specifically white (in fact many of its founding second wave theorists were women of colour); and why are you assuming it has anything to say about who should wear braids? On gender ideology feminism tends to divide into gender critical, radical or Marxist feminism vs liberal feminism. Neither are specifically "white". In fact, most feminist women of colour in the global South are closer to second-wave or radical feminist thought than they are to liberal feminism.

Kittii · 01/10/2021 18:11

Am I right in thinking that 0.6% of the population in the UK currently say they are transgender?

Kittii · 01/10/2021 18:10

@elodie77

That's exactly what you said. And I just explained what I meant.
Well if you say things you don't mean and mean things you don't say how are we supposed to follow your supposed argument? 🤔
Whatsnewpussyhat · 01/10/2021 18:08

It is people like this who cannot cope with anyone having a different opinion

Oh the irony.

You still haven't explained why you think 51% of the population, who still want to be referred to as women, should define themselves as 'people with a cervix' because a tiny number of females don't want to be called women?

MolyHolyGuacamole · 01/10/2021 18:07

@herculesoffline

I've often thought that Trans men get a raw deal in the whole trans debate

Trans men don't seem to draw the same story of ire from transphobes who sensationalise.

👆🏽
Swipe left for the next trending thread