Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

"Only women have cervixes"...

141 replies

Yetano · 01/10/2021 13:30

So, I was as pissed off as most and thought Fuck off Starmer, how the hell do they make someone a cervix? etc, especially after the outrageous "bodies with vaginas" article. However...

Have just been reading that the whole argument originated with Trans men not being able to get cervical smears and people ending up having to have a colcoscopy due to delays in screening.

Trans men, do, of course start with a cervix, and presumably retain one. Apparently, the computer systems make it difficult or impossible to book a smear.

I've often thought that Trans men get a raw deal in the whole trans debate. It mostly seems to be centred around trans women's wants and needs and that this is yet another example of women, or in this case, former women's needs being sidelined and not heard.

OP posts:
TheWeeDonkey · 01/10/2021 21:04

Its not comments on this thread that have offended Elodie77 which is why they cannot reference them, but if we spend this thread talking about the feelings of one poster then we get distracted from talking about the gynecological health of female people who are taking high volumes of testosterone and how that makes them even more vulnerable to gynecological issues.

I don't know who benefits from that,

CuriousaboutSamphire · 01/10/2021 21:04

Start your own thread. You may get a taker.

But if it's too much trouble, I am sure we'd understand.

elodie77 · 01/10/2021 20:59

*Can you quote the posts that have been "bullying" "abusive" or "bigoted"?

Not tonight, Josephine, am too tired to go back through all those threads, but maybe tomorrow!

I would be interested in debating many of these issues in a slightly more measured way though if you're up for it another day!

Kittii · 01/10/2021 20:54

Yes that's why I'm interested to see what she considers "abusive". Would be interesting to compare it to being called a cervix haver or a body with a vagina. If that's not abusive I don't know what is.

WitchOftheWestCoast · 01/10/2021 20:51

Ah but @Kittii it’s what she “considers abusive” which is just about as subjective as it gets. Just because something offends, it doesn’t make it de facto abusive.

Kittii · 01/10/2021 20:48

Can you quote the posts that have been "bullying" "abusive" or "bigoted"?

TheWeeDonkey · 01/10/2021 20:48

Deliberate and obvious.

For me this is about gynecological health and how to get best outcomes. There should be no obfuscation, this isn't a matter of opinion. This is about people registering themselves correctly so that they can receive the best medical care and support available.

elodie77 · 01/10/2021 20:44

Disagreement is not abuse. No, of course not, and I'm really happy to debatec, but there have been comments here in the last couple of days that I consider abusive.

PurgatoryOfPotholes · 01/10/2021 20:44

Was the topic that it's the female type of human whose health suffers while politicians opine on radio stations about how "transwomen are women" and might develop cervixes after hormonal treatment?

RufustheBadgeringReindeer · 01/10/2021 20:42

@AlfonsoTheDinosaur

What a coincidence, that being the topic of the thread and all! Grin
Id quite forgotten what the subject of the thread was!

I hate it when i have to go back to the title and check

ShrillSiren · 01/10/2021 20:41

Disagreement is not abuse.

AlfonsoTheDinosaur · 01/10/2021 20:39

@WitchOftheWestCoast

Suspect the detail about “white feminism” was deliberate. There is a concerted effort now amongst TRAs to conflate gender critical views with white supremacy and the far right. A very dark, very deliberate, smear tactic.

@elodie77 think you should check out Allison Bailey, a black lesbian criminal law barrister and gay rights activist - also a founder of LGB Alliance - who has been targeted by Stonewall.

Yes, the derail is deliberate.
WitchOftheWestCoast · 01/10/2021 20:38

Suspect the detail about “white feminism” was deliberate. There is a concerted effort now amongst TRAs to conflate gender critical views with white supremacy and the far right. A very dark, very deliberate, smear tactic.

@elodie77 think you should check out Allison Bailey, a black lesbian criminal law barrister and gay rights activist - also a founder of LGB Alliance - who has been targeted by Stonewall.

AlfonsoTheDinosaur · 01/10/2021 20:37

What a coincidence, that being the topic of the thread and all! Grin

CuriousaboutSamphire · 01/10/2021 20:37

Sonia also has a cervix!

WitchOftheWestCoast · 01/10/2021 20:35

Re: “White Feminism”,Sonia Sodha has this right:

www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2021/sep/26/white-feminists-are-under-attack-from-other-women-here-can-only-be-one-winner--men

AlfonsoTheDinosaur · 01/10/2021 20:32

The conversation about only women having cervixes is interesting, isn't it?

elodie77 · 01/10/2021 20:29

Yes, PurgatoryOfPotholes, and there was another good one in the Guardian the other day saying that criticism of white feminism played into the hands of men and patriarchy, which I do agree with in that we shouldn't fight with each other while men get away with so much, but...I have found it disturbing that it seems to be impossible to express differing viewpoints to the 'received opinions' here without abuse, and have been taken aback by the astoundingly small-minded, bigoted insults about trans people, or the shouting down of black women I saw earlier today. I also received persistent, unpleasant hounding on another thread because I disclosed some of my personal life choices.

CuriousaboutSamphire · 01/10/2021 20:27

Aye! None so blind, and all that!

PurgatoryOfPotholes · 01/10/2021 20:13

This is not about white feminism. Posts that attempt to derail the thread are not appreciated. This is the second post that tries to do that and it is not welcome.

You're quite right. I shouldn't be fuelling the derail.

Blush
elodie77 · 01/10/2021 20:12

This is not about white feminism. Posts that attempt to derail the thread are not appreciated. This is the second post that tries to do that and it is not welcome.

Are you trying to silence me? This is what I mean, that many people here appoint themselves an authority on topics of discussion or threads!

I have not tried to derail anything, I engaged with the issue and the tone of the OP and used another example that struck me from another thread and was criticised for it so I explained why I had used the second example.

PurgatoryOfPotholes · 01/10/2021 20:11

And this is from Bina Shah, a feminist from Pakistan.

extract

Yesterday on Twitter, I wrote an angry tweet. It went like this:

“I just really need to know how Judith Butler’s definition of women applies to Afghan women who are being beaten on the streets by the Taliban. Have you ever considered that your academics really don’t fit the lives of women in the global South?”

I posted the above tweet after reading about the now infamous Guardian interview in which Butler said that TERFs (trans exclusionary radical feminists) align themselves with right wingers and fascists. I don’t identify as a TERF, or much of anything really (cis? that too feels like an imposition upon me) because this debate about trans rights and gender identity seems so far removed from the lived reality that I and millions of women in the South Asian/Central Asian region experience. I certainly don’t align myself with right wingers and fascists in my thinking, which is different and far more independent from the groupthink or pressure that people in, say, an academic environment face as they adapt to new rules and laws about gender.

But it was Judith Butler’s statement that “we need to rethink the category of women” that got me going. It coalesced from quite a lot of thinking I’ve been doing about gender identity theory as it is being adopted in Western countries. And it comes at the same time as I’ve been watching Afghan women getting beaten by the Taliban as they protest for their rights, for safety and security and for inclusion in the government, and for the freedom to work and study.

I was asked to clarify my thinking about my statement, because it seemed vague or perhaps obtuse to people for whom gender identity theory is far more familiar and agreeable. It’s good to be challenged because it forces you to think harder about what it is you really believe.

In Afghanistan (extreme example) but also in Pakistan, where I live, in India, in Nepal, Bangladesh, Middle Eastern countries, North Africa, women (or people with female bodies) are being abused, harassed, assaulted and killed not just because they have female bodies, but because they refuse to hand those bodies over to men to do with as they please.

Because this possession and ownership of female bodies is absolutely tied to female biology and the production of children and sexual comfort for those men, separating sex from gender completely negates this form of oppression which is hugely insulting to all of us who are still fighting to end sex-based discrimination in our countries and regions.

At the same time a particularly empowering thing for women is the fact that their bodies are capable of producing life. This is something so innate to women’s identities and sense of themselves in Muslim/global South/non-white countries that to insist it is something that does not belong to them is actually a form of mental and emotional violence on them, a double trauma visited upon them by Western Feminists who wish to impose their ideas of gender and sex onthose of us whose understanding and experience of these issues is very different.

Imagine a Muslim woman in the UK who escapes a violent marriage and threats of honor killing. She goes to a shelter where she feels safe because it is a female-only space. Not just because she is away from the realm of immediate male violence, but because as a Muslim woman she does not feel comfortable sharing intimate quarters with a person with a male body. This allows her to reconcile her awful situation as well as her need to feel she is acting in congruence with her identity and principles of modesty as a Muslim woman.

But if a trans woman with a penis is in the same space, then the Muslim woman will be in a terrible conflict about her actions in leaving her home. Suddenly, she is not able to remove her hijab or undress because she cannot do those things in front of a person with a male body who is not a family member. This not a hypothetical, there areMuslim, Sikh, and Hindu women who are now excluded from single sex-only spacesbecause the definition of woman has changed to include women with penises. To call that Muslim woman a TERF because she expresses discomfort is yet another abuse for her.

All this to say that we have yet to negotiate safety and freedom for women with female bodies and not ignore or override minority women in the West or women from my part of the world out of these negotiations. Afghan girls and women have in fact had to disguise themselves as boys and men in order to move outside the home, earn a living or perform vital chores during the rule of the Taliban. Would this be called “performing gender” as Judith Butler calls it, or a resourceful survival strategy that Afghan women adopted in order to be able to live?

I’m afraid the trans rights activists are acting like Western colonisers and imperialists all over again, imposing their ideas of gender and sexuality on us the same way their Empire was imposed on us for a good part of the 20th century. I don’t really want gender colonialism in the 21st century. Do you?

Thank you for coming to my TERF Talk.

From: thefeministani.wordpress.com/2021/09/09/judith-butler-and-afghan-women

AlfonsoTheDinosaur · 01/10/2021 20:09

@elodie77

I used both examples of the bullying I received for giving a different opinion to the 'received' one here about trans right (and other quite personal things actually) and the abuse the black women got on the braids thread to illustrate that there are quite abusive mobs here on MN who use cheap, bullying tactics to shout down people don't agree with them. I think it gets to the point that people can no longer come here expressing a different viewpoint because they get childish abuse. You should be able to debate in a civilised manner.

I can accept anger and humour but not bullying. I think MN is becoming an echo chamber on many issues and I think the critique I shared on white feminism is quite apt.

This is not about white feminism. Posts that attempt to derail the thread are not appreciated. This is the second post that tries to do that and it is not welcome.
PurgatoryOfPotholes · 01/10/2021 20:03

Here's a critique of the term "white feminism".

extract

When I was in grad school, I got into a heated debate with a classmate who insisted that “white feminism” was a serious problem in the women’s movement. The man (who was white and from the United States) argued that, “white feminism” meant that the women’s movement had centered the lives and experiences of only a select few — privileged white women in the US who traveled mainly in academic circles — “for most of its history.”

I told him I thought the term functioned as a tool to dismiss second wave feminists, glorify the (very problematic) third wave, and encourage infighting among feminists, creating divisions in a movement where collective struggle is crucial. His claim was at odds with the grassroots movement I’d grown up with in the Dominican Republic, which was obviously not led by women in the US (and certainly not by upper-class white women or academics). There are legitimate problems within feminism in my home country, particularly around class difference, but there is far more solidarity than animosity, and Dominican feminism has been consistent in addressing the struggles of rural, working class, and immigrant women.

Notably, during my time as an immigrant in the US, most of the people who complained to me about what they called “white feminism” were white themselves. I felt tokenized; like they wanted me, as a Dominican woman of colour, to validate them and their feminism. I became suspicious of all white people who used the term. Criticizing “white feminism” seemed to be a way for white people to present themselves asdifferent, betterwhite people — as cool, “intersectional” feminists who just happen to be white.

Now that I am back in the Dominican Republic doing shelter work, I believe my friend from grad school was right about one thing: white feminism is real. It is epitomized by gender identity ideology.

The current trend among third wavers, as well as among progressives, is to argue that we can ignore whether people were born male or female and insteaduse language like“genderfluid,” “multi-gender,” or “genderqueer.” But there’s a massive gap between this language — popularized within Gender Studies classrooms in the West — and the realities of marginalized women in countries like mine.

I’ve been thinking about what gender identity means in the context of the Global South. What does gender identity mean for women and girls who look like me? What does it mean for Dominican women and girls who are marginalized not just by sex, but by poverty, race, and xenophobia?

Recently, the Dominican Republic has been debating whether or not tooutlawchild marriage. The country hasthe highest rateof child marriage in the Latin American and Caribbean region. According to a2014 survey, 37 per cent of women who are between 20 and 49 years old got married (or became common law partners) before they were 18. The survey also shows that one in five girls between 15 and 19 are in a relationship with a man who is at least 10 years their senior. There is a strong correlation between child marriage and teen pregnancy, which can result indangerous health complicationsfor girls, like blood poisoning, obstructed labour, andhigh blood pressure. Indeed, teen pregnancy is thenumber one cause of deathfor teen girls worldwide. This is particularly worrisome because the Dominican Republic prohibitsall abortion, even in the cases when the mother’s life is in danger.

Plan International, a children’s rights organization,published a studyin March, looking at child marriage on the south side of the Caribbean island. They interviewed men who married underage girls, as well as the girls who “chose” these marriages. Almost 40 per cent ofthe men interviewedsaid they preferred younger girls because they were “more obedient and easier to control.” The study also revealed that many girls marry older men hoping to escape family violence and poverty, but then face violence from these men once they are married. One 15-year-old girl who was interviewed for the study said:

“I got married because I needed to run away from home. They were beating me. They used sticks. They wouldn’t trust me. One day I said: ‘I don’t want to live like this anymore.’ At home, there was a lot of fighting, one day in front of everybody, they beat me, in the middle of the street. So, I started working at a household. I was 11 years old. It was even worse there, the violence increased. I had to do all the chores, including washing all the clothes by hand. They wouldn’t even let me go to school and they never paid me because they said that they already gave me food. I was suffering a lot. I felt imprisoned I couldn’t even go to the park. I wanted to get married to leave all of that. I thought that if I got married I was going to be in a calm house, that I would be able to eat, sleep and go out. I didn’t know it wouldn’t be like that, like another hell.”

In the Dominican Republic, boys are not expected to clean or help raise their siblings — that is the responsibility of girls. Prior to marriage, 78 per cent of the girls who participated in thePlan Internationalstudy said they were put in charge of doing household chores like cleaning and caring for their younger siblings. When girls were asked what it means to be a woman, most said that it meant being a mother and a wife.

Continues: dgrnewsservice.org/civilization/patriarchy/gender/white-feminism-thing-gender-identity-ideology-epitomizes/

womaninatightspot · 01/10/2021 20:03

I think that all systems should be updated to record sex and gender. Prisons/ police/schools/hospitals it'd make for much better statistical analysis. I don't know how we can support the people who need it most when we simply don't record the relevant information.

Swipe left for the next trending thread