Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU

56 replies

Chatterboxxy · 30/09/2021 22:35

A friend has a big birthday coming up. She's asked for a gift from our group that would be £30 each. Would it be unreasonable to message and ask her to choose something else, because we are only willing to spend £20 each

OP posts:
Chloemol · 01/10/2021 00:35

@Chatterboxxy

Thanks for these comments, it's really helped me get my head straight. I agree this dilemma is weird, and I had no one to talk it over with that's why I brought it here. I'm upset that we can't sort out a simple thing like this, which should be joyful. We wouldn't normally buy expensive gifts, but it's a big birthday and that's what stuff costs these days! I think the incident has revealed that one of our group has a problematic attitude to money. She thinks everything is too expensive, and she always says she can't afford stuff. She's becoming tight, and it's really impacting things. I think our friend would be highly embarrassed and probably hurt and disappointed if we tell her we aren't willing to chuck in £30 each for a once in a decade treat!
Hmm bit of a nasty comment there

She may not always be able to afford stuff, prices on everything are going up, and fast, I don’t see that as a problematic attitude to money, she may simply not be able to afford it,it’s not that she is ‘becoming tight’

She may not wish to discuss that with the group,

My friendship groups don’t discuss money, but i would say if I can’t afford to do something, it’s accepted and we do something different, same for others in the group depending on what we do

We also agree a ball park figure for anything we are going to share so no one is put in this position

You are not coming out of this well with these comments about a friend

HalfShrunkMoreToGo · 01/10/2021 00:28

Why is the item, have you looked around to see if it can be bought elsewhere for £10 cheaper or with a discount code as that would resolve the issue?

PurpleDaisies · 30/09/2021 23:42

£30 is absolutely normal in my circle of friends for a big birthday.

Chatterboxxy · 30/09/2021 23:37

Thanks for these comments, it's really helped me get my head straight. I agree this dilemma is weird, and I had no one to talk it over with that's why I brought it here. I'm upset that we can't sort out a simple thing like this, which should be joyful. We wouldn't normally buy expensive gifts, but it's a big birthday and that's what stuff costs these days! I think the incident has revealed that one of our group has a problematic attitude to money. She thinks everything is too expensive, and she always says she can't afford stuff. She's becoming tight, and it's really impacting things. I think our friend would be highly embarrassed and probably hurt and disappointed if we tell her we aren't willing to chuck in £30 each for a once in a decade treat!

OP posts:
Notimeforaname · 30/09/2021 23:24

Let her pay the 20 ..then the o 4 of you can pay the extra £2.50 each, to make up for the tenner she doesn't want to spend. It's not that awkward

Unreasonabubble · 30/09/2021 23:24

Cover the extra yourself as you said you are not worried about it. Why ruin your friend's significate birthday?

SleepingStandingUp · 30/09/2021 23:19

you set a precedent now that will have to be followed for them all and this is the thing about 20 or 30. It's actually £100 or £150.

Whywhenwhat · 30/09/2021 23:17

Is this the first big birthday the group has had, if so you set a precedent now that will have to be followed for them all.
Can you put vouchers or cash towards the gift instead of buying the whole thing? Although if I was willing to put in £30 I'd just put in £32.50 and split the extra tenner between the rest of us.

SheSaidHummingbird · 30/09/2021 23:15

Everyone contribute as much as they are comfortable with towards a single gift card which the birthday friend can redeem towards the item she wants.

SleepingStandingUp · 30/09/2021 23:10

It's a bit cheeky picking a £150 present

Limejuiceandrum · 30/09/2021 23:10

I would personally make up the difference between you all.

Burnamer · 30/09/2021 23:09

What’s normal for your group OP? That really matters here. If you’re all HMWI and normally spend £500 on each other then yabu but if you normally spend £10 well the. Birthday is the CF.
Context is everything.

SleepingStandingUp · 30/09/2021 23:09

If you're all happy to pay £30 plus x/10 then get it, but clearly don't tell friend "but Emily said she's only putting in £20"

Chatterboxxy · 30/09/2021 23:09

I agree we should have given a price range. It's thrown everything pear shaped! There are 5 of us, and only one thinks £30 is too much. I would happily cover the extra myself, but then that becomes awkward too!

OP posts:
WorraLiberty · 30/09/2021 23:08

I don't think it's 'tight' because people have different disposable incomes.

But it was really badly organised and the woman should've been told the budget.

She might be mortified if the OP gets back to her and tells her to choose something cheaper.

SleepingStandingUp · 30/09/2021 23:08

This is why if there's a grotto of you who buy each other, you agree a budget

Limejuiceandrum · 30/09/2021 23:07

Weird
All of it

ThinWomansBrain · 30/09/2021 23:07

Don't see the problem
I chose something I really really wanted for my 50th (v unusual for me & friendship group).
People put in what they wanted, we used one friend's membership card to get a discount and I made up the difference.
Then took everyone for afternoon tea at a hotel near the museum.

Howshouldibehave · 30/09/2021 23:06

How many of you are there?

PinkSyCo · 30/09/2021 23:05

I’m far from well off but would be more than happy to put £30 towards a gift that my friend really wanted for a big birthday. I think you’re being a bit tight to be honest.

HeddaGarbled · 30/09/2021 23:04

Sounds like you’d be willing, between the rest of you, to make up the shortfall from the person who can only afford £20, so that’s what I’d recommend. People have different incomes and circumstances - it’s OK to chip in different amounts.

WorraLiberty · 30/09/2021 22:59

But surely the poor woman would be embarrassed?

Tbh, whoever asked her to choose a gift should've given her a rough price range and the person not wanting to contribute more than £20, should've said so before she chose.

MissBattleaxe · 30/09/2021 22:59

Nobody should ever be shamed for not being able to afford something. £30 might not sound much but if you've got a ton of other birthdays to pay out for then it can all add up.

Chatterboxxy · 30/09/2021 22:56

We asked her what she wanted, and she sent a pic. On discussion one person in our group said she would only out in £20, although the rest of us would be happy to pay the extra. It's just an awkward situation now. I think she has her heart set on it.

OP posts:
WorraLiberty · 30/09/2021 22:56

Sorry, I can't get my head round her asking for a gift.

How did that come about? Is it normal in your circle of friends? Did anyone ask her to choose something and get back to you all?