Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU: the half-cup of tea brigade

239 replies

Shedbuilder · 30/09/2021 21:29

My late MIL used to turn every offer of a cup of tea or a biscuit or sandwich into a major performance. Just half a cup/ half a biscuit / a quarter of a sandwich not a drop or crumb more because 'I can't manage any more than half a cup yada yada yada...' Everyone knew she had a small appetite so we automatically gave her tiny portions — but if you were foolish enough to ask her if she'd like something to eat or drink you'd get the full performance. And once you delivered the tea/ biscuit/ sandwich there'd be a cheery telling-off. 'Oooh, this is far too much. Call this half a cup? I could drown in this sea of tea...' So no matter what you did with the intention of being kind and supportive, you were always in the wrong.

It irritated everyone, even though her family all loved her to bits. This evening I offered my DP some leftover apple crumble and got the full MIL treatment. 'Just a tiny bit: think half of what you'd have and then halve that. And don't go drowning it in custard, I know what you're like with custard...' So I served a teaspoonful of apple crumble in an eggcup with a tiny blob of custard and as I set it down in front of DP I said jokingly 'You're turning into your mother!' Cue a huge row about me insulting the sacred memory of MIL and doors slamming.

What's the half-cup-of-tea things really about? I have no problem at all with someone saying they're not very hungry, they'll just have a mouthful of whatever. Or a small cup of tea. But there's a point at which it slips into controlling behaviour. Or AIBU?

PS Perhaps I should add that my DP isn't on a diet or anything.

OP posts:
GoldenOmber · 01/10/2021 18:21

But they don’t seem to realise that what would be helpful is to just simply tell me what they would like to drink when I offer!!

True master-level “oh I don’t mind”-ing is doing it with takeaway menus. “Oh, I don’t mind, whatever’s easiest.” JUST PICK ONE I DON’T KNOW WHAT YOU WANT ARGH!

Siriisatwat · 01/10/2021 18:15

[quote HeadNorth]@Siriisatwat annoyingly for my MIL, I am both slim and I eat (I love to exercise) - which is just as well or she could have given me a right complex over the years. I just find it so sad that her main goal and victory in life is to be the thinnest person in the room - and make sure everyone notices, too. I think she has spent her life as a 'functional anorexic' and it is playing havoc with her body now she is in her 70s.[/quote]
Yes, mine too.

She’s been told a few times by doctors that she should gain a little weight now she’s 70. That horrified her.

Pl242 · 01/10/2021 17:53

I also notice the generational thing in the response to simple questions. This is a typical conversation with my in laws when they come over.

Me: can I get you a drink MIL? Tea? Coffee? Water?
MIL: oh I don’t know love, whatever is easiest
Me: well they are all easy for me to make, what would you like?
MIL: (says name of) FIL, what are you going to have?
FIL: I don’t know. What are you going to have?
MIL: maybe a coffee? But only if you’re having one
FIL: well I was going to have tea
MIL: well I better have the same
Me: mil, I’m happy to make you whatever you’d like. What will you have?
Mil: oh I’ll have a tea, just a small one mind. Shall I make it?
Me: no, it’s fine. Not a problem. Ok. So two teas
FIL: actually I’ll have a coffee if that’s ok
Me: sure, what type would you like [we have a machine, have done for yonks]
Fil: er, I don’t mind
Me: a latte?
Mil: no, we’ll just have instant
Me: I thought you wanted tea
Mil: well I’ll have coffee if fil is having one
Me: honestly it’s as easy for me to make you a latte as it is instant
Mil: ok then. A latte then. For you too fil?
Fil: alright then, yes please.
Me: ok, 2 lattes then.

Spoiler alert. They always have 2 lattes. We just do this dance every time. I realise I should probably just preempt it and say “2 lattes as usual then?”

They are both lovely people and hate to put people out. My mil especially is a perennial helper.

But they don’t seem to realise that what would be helpful is to just simply tell me what they would like to drink when I offer!!

HeadNorth · 01/10/2021 17:40

@Siriisatwat annoyingly for my MIL, I am both slim and I eat (I love to exercise) - which is just as well or she could have given me a right complex over the years. I just find it so sad that her main goal and victory in life is to be the thinnest person in the room - and make sure everyone notices, too. I think she has spent her life as a 'functional anorexic' and it is playing havoc with her body now she is in her 70s.

Siriisatwat · 01/10/2021 17:24

@HeadNorth my mil is the same. Staying the same dress size all her life is her main glory - she will offer that up before mentioning anything else, even her children,

She once said she’s glad i’m plump as she doesn’t have to compete with me. Ok, weirdo.

HeadNorth · 01/10/2021 17:14

@lottiegarbanzo

Indeed. Eat what you like. Be a good host to your guests. No need for a massive performance about what or how much you, or anyone else eats. That is the point.
Yup, a big attention seeking drama with a side order of judginess at women that aren't as dainty and thin as them. My MIL's crowning achievement is being thin. Honestly, a woman could find the cure for cancer and my MIL would comment she was 'a bit stout, she needs to watch herself' with the smugness of the perpetually underfed.
Siriisatwat · 01/10/2021 17:00

"Oh I don't mind at all ... Whatever works best for you ... We can just fit in with you ... oh no, that's completely fine ...") My God it's annoying - Have an opinion. Have a preference. The world isn't going to end because you dare to set a boundary.

Yes, this is my Dad.

It’s all for attention with him though. Because actually, he is manipulative and demanding. But putting on a frail voice and saying “I don’t want to be any trouble, what ever is easiest for you”, deflects from that.

He’s particularly fond of doing that around strangers/dh family, so that when I’m in tears over his nastiness they will think I’m the arsehole, as all they see is the little old man who won’t say boo to a goose.

So manipulative.

InvisibleDragon · 01/10/2021 16:50

My grandmother is a bit like this - increasingly so as she gets older - and it is sometimes quite irritating.

She's struggling to maintain her weight, so it's really important that she eats healthy, nutritious meals. But if I serve her a meal she is always surreptitiously checking how much everyone else is having and making sure she has less. If it's just the two of us it's particularly hard, because I have to serve myself more than I actually want to make sure she has anywhere near enough. If it's a big family meal she usually relaxes a bit because she can see all of us having a normal sized portion so feels comfortable to have something only slightly smaller.

The funny thing is that if we go out for coffee and cake somewhere, she'd be horrified at the idea of eating a whole slice Shock, but if you buy two different ones and cut them both in half she'll happily have both halves.

I think it's about not looking greedy for her. She's talked about going to restaurants with my grandad when they were younger and she would always be served a smaller, lower quality portion than him. She hated that, but I think the social conditioning that a woman should be self-effacing and self sacrificing and not want things is deeply ingrained.

My mum isn't a food martyr and gets really irritated about my grandma's fussing. Unfortunately she's like this with just about everything else ("Oh I don't mind at all ... Whatever works best for you ... We can just fit in with you ... oh no, that's completely fine ...") My God it's annoying - Have an opinion. Have a preference. The world isn't going to end because you dare to set a boundary. And it's not actually helpful or kind to do this all the time - it just pushes all the work of planning and all the emotional labour of making sure everything is okay onto someone else.

FluffyWhiteBird · 01/10/2021 16:42

@UntilYourNextHairBrainedScheme

Some posters are missing the point that it isn't in any way small appetites or bladder weakness which are annoying, its the attention seeking fuss and drama and the shaming of women who don't join in the "I couldn't possibly drink a whole cup of tea, any hint of having an appetite would be unbecomingly masculine or greedy!" performance.
Yes! Totally this.

If someone has a bladder weakness, why make that their hosts problem? All this "half cup" nonsense Hmm, just moderate yourself, drink half the tea and leave the rest. Teabags aren't new, they've been around decades! I've never made loose leaf tea in a teapot in my entire life.

Ditto those with issues from childhood about not wasting food. Those are their issues so why try to transfer them onto their host? It's blooming rude making out people have done something wrong, when all they've done is offered an ordinary amount of food.

Sometimes people need to look around and realise the world has changed. It's common knowledge these days that only eating as much as you want to and leaving the rest is fine. If a host does find that annoying, they'll know for next time that that guest doesn't have a large appetite, so they can feed them smaller quantities to avoid waste. There's absolutely no need for all the posturing that goes on around it from the person who isn't very hungry. Especially if it really is all an act and they're later caught stuffing their faces when they think nobody's looking!

Siriisatwat · 01/10/2021 16:40

@caketiger

Did you not know that when someone dies they instantly become a Saint. No matter how awful they were in real life.....
Ha! yes.

The way people speak of my mother - it’s like living in a parallel universe.

I always tell my children to remember I was a cantankerous dickhead, don’t remember me a the lovely person I wasn’t 😁

thewinehasgonetomyhead · 01/10/2021 16:38

This was a family member's. They passed away last year and I had such fond memories of it when I was a child I had to keep it ❤️

AIBU: the half-cup of tea brigade
caketiger · 01/10/2021 16:38

Did you not know that when someone dies they instantly become a Saint. No matter how awful they were in real life.....

GreatPotato · 01/10/2021 16:35

My Grandad always used to say "just half" if you offered him a second cup of tea. He always drank the full one though.Grin

His sister bought him a cup that was actually half a tea cup (I.e. with one flat edge) so it's obviously common for such a thing to exist

lottiegarbanzo · 01/10/2021 16:34

Indeed. Eat what you like. Be a good host to your guests. No need for a massive performance about what or how much you, or anyone else eats. That is the point.

GoldenOmber · 01/10/2021 16:31

@UntilYourNextHairBrainedScheme

Some posters are missing the point that it isn't in any way small appetites or bladder weakness which are annoying, its the attention seeking fuss and drama and the shaming of women who don't join in the "I couldn't possibly drink a whole cup of tea, any hint of having an appetite would be unbecomingly masculine or greedy!" performance.
Yes!

“I’ll have a small piece please” - not the issue.

“Oh my goodness I couldn’t eat THAT, that’s loads! I wouldn’t be able to walk all day after that, I’d be SO stuffed. No, just the corner of that please, no the LITTLE corner. Honestly I don’t know how you manage eating something that size, that would fill me up for a week! You know what I’m like, I get full so easily. Sauce? Oh well I suppose, if you’re having it, but just a little drop - No a LITTLE drop - oh goodness no not the whole teaspoon that’s enough to drown it, I couldn’t possibly manage all that!” - the issue.

UntilYourNextHairBrainedScheme · 01/10/2021 16:15

Some posters are missing the point that it isn't in any way small appetites or bladder weakness which are annoying, its the attention seeking fuss and drama and the shaming of women who don't join in the "I couldn't possibly drink a whole cup of tea, any hint of having an appetite would be unbecomingly masculine or greedy!" performance.

FluffyWhiteBird · 01/10/2021 16:00

There's something weird about the way some people love drama. Bizarrely, I've been on the receiving end of this and it's always from the fusspot "half a cup/small portion" types.

I'm pescatarian and it's no big deal, lots of my friends don't even know because I don't mention it. I order what I like and eat as much as I want. If someone is hosting I accept what I'm given or just decline saying I'm fine. I don't expect special meals, I'll happily eat the bits I can and leave the meat if there is any. If people ask about dietary requirements I say I'm vegetarian because that solves the problem and means I don't have to trouble my host by explaining what pescatarian is. But the fusspots can't leave it alone. They always have to comment on my vegetarian meal and make a big drama about what to feed me, comments about how I can't possibly be healthy, about it being "unusual", even comments about how the dog food contains meat as if that's somehow going to cause me to express disapproval etc.

I couldn't care less what the dog eats! Or the other people round the table. I've no problems with animals being killed for food. I don't even care if there's meat on my plate, I'll just leave it or perhaps ask if anyone else would like to have it.

Zero drama except the one they're creating, so incredibly annoying. They seem to relish something/someone else to fuss about, it goes on for the whole meal. I find the behaviour very strange. I've not eaten meat for 30yrs and some who've known me longer than that will still fuss over it. I don't understand it at all and try to avoid eating meals with these family fusspots as much as I can.

YANBU OP it's very draining to be around. Storming off slamming doors etc is also bad. I advise ignoring it, these dramatic types want you to obsess over them and constantly worry if they're ok or if you've done something wrong. Life's too short for that.

reluctantbrit · 01/10/2021 15:33

I think drinking out of mugs is a modern thing, as a child I can only remember coffee cups with saucers (German here). Milk and chocolate milk was served in normal glasses we also used for other drinks.

But, drinking wasn’t the “carry a bottle around all the time” either, it was with meals and on warm days inbetween and in the evening watching TV.

My cousin is a nurse and when she worked on the geriatric ward she said most patient were showing signs of dehydration as they never learned to drink when your body asks for it.

Food, yes the body is slowing down and not needing that much. That is fine but then either offer to have food around if you have visitors staying with you and not making strange comments all the time.

merryhouse · 01/10/2021 15:02

"Pensioner's Portions" are a thing in a lot of cafes.

Worth noting that that CSLewis quote was written before the effects of rationing - there is a bit in the "editor's preface" which says that Screwtape obviously wrote that bit before rationing was introduced.

Brefugee · 01/10/2021 14:13

Well of course your appetite declines.

Over here in Germany a "Seniorenteller" is a thing in many many restaurants - it's an older person's portion (so like a child portion but i think a bit bigger?) and they're a bit cheaper.

ElinoristhenewEnid · 01/10/2021 14:08

When people ask for half a cup of tea I ask if they want the top half or bottom half of the cup filled!

bumblingbovine49 · 01/10/2021 14:04

I agree op. C. S lewis calls it the gluttony of delicacy rather then the gluttony of excess

Whilst I'm not religious his take on it really chimes with me

www.intellectualtakeout.org/blog/cs-lewis-deadly-sin-gluttony/

shinynewapple21 · 01/10/2021 13:59

@Hardbackwriter

My mum does this. We went for lunch recently. We ordered the same thing. I ate all of it. Mum ate half and said she'd have the rest for dinner. Then said "oh well. You won't need to cook tonight then after that meal". Ummm... dc will still want a meal and ill be hungry again by then

This is the worst bit of it with my (otherwise lovely) MIL - she insists that it is odd and incredibly gluttonous to eat more than breakfast and one other meal a day even at Christmas. I was shocked speechless the first year at their house when on the evening of Christmas day rather than the cheeseboard and Christmas cake that my family had we had - nothing. Because we'd eaten (a normal sized roast, the dinner isn't some huge multi-coursed affair for them either) at 2pm, so that was that until breakfast. We host Christmas now, thank god!

Can't believe that someone would host relatives for Christmas and then provide no further food after the 2 pm lunch ! Did you actually go to bed hungry or did you ask for an evening snack ?

ScarlettSunset · 01/10/2021 13:47

I don't know anyone who does this. My parents only ate small amounts but they never made a fuss about it.
However, my ex MIL used to decide that tiny amounts were right for me (because she decided I was too fat for her son), and so on the rare occasion I had to eat there, I'd be offered a small triangle of sandwich while everyone else ate normal amounts...

WomanStanleyWoman · 01/10/2021 13:20

Does that make it an After Four? Grin