Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To say there are some decent men

717 replies

Poppyscone · 30/09/2021 15:31

I know there are many threads about how shit men are. It may be a shit partner not helping, abused by a stranger, sexism etc etc etc.

But to say some men are decent. My DH said this morning re the policemen just sentenced “we men are mostly basically shit aren’t we”
I told him he was one of the good ones and the good ones need to carry on trying to challenging these men who basically hate women
My DH had challenged many men over their behaviour towards women including dropping friendships.

I have epilepsy and DH had always had my back and supported me. Done more then his fare share with kids including most night feeds as well as working full time which I can do. Letting me sleep and recover after a seizure and taking charge without complaining.

He always make me feel good about myself, never pesters for sex and is a good dad.

Yep sure he had his faults he is a bit disorganised and he seems to think dirty clothes belong on the bedroom floor (but does pick them up when asked)
He snores like a machine gun and I have to wear earplug but on the whole he is a decent bloke and I am sure there are many more out there. I would just like to here about them

OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
MareofBeasttown · 01/10/2021 17:26

@FourTeaFallOut

Remind me again what NAMALT jumps we leapt through to get from vawg to the reading skills of white working class boys?
Gymastics worthy of Simone Biles. Dont give a flying fuck abt the reading skills of white working class boys just now when Met Police is trying to victim blame women.
youvegottenminuteslynn · 01/10/2021 17:26

It is great that girls are doing so well but, equally, problematic that boys aren’t

It is great that NAMALT but, equally, problematic that 9/10 killers in England and Wales are male, 98.5% of rapists are male, in 2020 the ONS estimated that 4.9 million women have been victims of sexual assault in their lifetime, 1.4 million of whom were raped and one in 40 women under the age of 24 said they had been raped.

Those figures don't even take into account sexual harassment, which a recent poll by YouGov for UN Women reported was experienced by 7 out of 10 women and 9 out of 10 young women. One in five women have faced indecent exposure. Four out of ten have been groped. 50% have faced sexual harassment at work.

Have a think about those figures and think about why women might be invested in voicing their anger at the way THEY are treated without having to always caveat it with an issue men face too.

When someone is fundraising for breast cancer research do you accuse them of monopolising public sympathy and tell them they should always mention cancers more frequently experienced by men at the same time they fundraise for predominantly female cancer types? After all, why should womens cancer charities get money that could go to men's ones too? Of course you don't. Because it would be ridiculous.

Pallisers · 01/10/2021 17:26

so when you said that you have given examples of female behaviour damaging males you meant something entirely different that has nothing to do with misandry. right.

CandyLeBonBon · 01/10/2021 17:23

@FourTeaFallOut

Remind me again what NAMALT jumps we leapt through to get from vawg to the reading skills of white working class boys?
We're jumping through ALLLLL the hoops on this one! The mental gymnastics are exhausting. Tell me again it's our fault as a mothers that men rape and kill!!! 🙄
FourTeaFallOut · 01/10/2021 17:20

Remind me again what NAMALT jumps we leapt through to get from vawg to the reading skills of white working class boys?

TheReluctantPhoenix · 01/10/2021 17:07

@Pallisers and @youvegottenminuteslynn,

It is not girls performing well that damages boys. That, in itself, is great.

It is the acceptance of failure that is problematic. The attitude that comes through loud and clear is that boys failing is intrinsic and, in fact, some form of victory.

There was a lot of support put in for girls when they underperform and, in certain areas, such as STEM, that is still the case.

The lack of reading by boys, and particularly white working class boys, is only just starting to be tackled.

It is also an increasing attitude in schools that girls work hard and boys are lazy and naughty that then becomes a self fulfilling prophecy.

It is great that girls are doing so well but, equally, problematic that boys aren’t.

youvegottenminuteslynn · 01/10/2021 16:50

@Pallisers

I have given you examples of where female behaviour damages males:in schools, in workplaces and, I suspect, in some homes here where sons are brought up feeling potential violent bullies and rapists.

I read that article. I find is astonishing that you believe that girls performing well in school in and of itself damages men. You aren't even trying to hide what you feel about women. And you have the gall to say men and women don't divide equally into two classes - clearly you divide them like that and you put them in a zero sum game where female achievement damages men because men then aren't the winners as they should be.

👏👏👏
Pallisers · 01/10/2021 16:49

I have given you examples of where female behaviour damages males:in schools, in workplaces and, I suspect, in some homes here where sons are brought up feeling potential violent bullies and rapists.

I read that article. I find is astonishing that you believe that girls performing well in school in and of itself damages men. You aren't even trying to hide what you feel about women. And you have the gall to say men and women don't divide equally into two classes - clearly you divide them like that and you put them in a zero sum game where female achievement damages men because men then aren't the winners as they should be.

TheReluctantPhoenix · 01/10/2021 15:47

@CandyLeBonBon,

Me too, the people, not their sex.

MakingM · 01/10/2021 15:45

@MakingM

Yes, of course, there are a lot of good and decent men. Thing is many of the men you hear about on here treating their partners poorly are probably not that bad most of the time either, or they may be quite decent with the right person. I’m sure my husband could identify specific incidents that would make me sound like a complete bitch too. It’s just a moment in time. It doesn’t mean all men are dreadful, it doesn’t even mean that these particular men are dreadful all the time by any means.

It’s a very small minority of women who hate all men all of the time.

Oh,... and a correspondingly very small minority of men who hate all women all of the time.
CandyLeBonBon · 01/10/2021 15:44

[quote TheReluctantPhoenix]@CandyLeBonBon,

Women are not solely to blame, men are not solely to blame.

Men and women just don’t separate neatly into two classes, as many here seem to believe.[/quote]
I'm afraid I plant the blame for raping and murdering women solely at the feet of people doing the raping and murdering.

MakingM · 01/10/2021 15:42

Yes, of course, there are a lot of good and decent men. Thing is many of the men you hear about on here treating their partners poorly are probably not that bad most of the time either, or they may be quite decent with the right person. I’m sure my husband could identify specific incidents that would make me sound like a complete bitch too. It’s just a moment in time. It doesn’t mean all men are dreadful, it doesn’t even mean that these particular men are dreadful all the time by any means.

It’s a very small minority of women who hate all men all of the time.

TheReluctantPhoenix · 01/10/2021 15:42

@CandyLeBonBon,

Women are not solely to blame, men are not solely to blame.

Men and women just don’t separate neatly into two classes, as many here seem to believe.

CandyLeBonBon · 01/10/2021 15:34

Men don't learn sleazy locker room talk from their mothers. They don't learn to jokingly discuss whether a woman is fuckable and to rate her out of 10 for her body parts from their mothers. Women don't learn to watch violent porn from their mothers.

CandyLeBonBon · 01/10/2021 15:13

[quote TheReluctantPhoenix]@CandyLeBonBon,

I find it fascinating that so many people don’t think one of the most important influences (if not the most important) on boys is their mother.

It is as if mothers just want to step away from their sons’ behaviour and blame other men.

Society is complex and we all have lots of things that make us who we are.

This idea that women are minnows in a shark tank, when most choose to live with and breed with the ‘sharks’ and that we can cut a neat line between the sexes and blame men for male behaviour even though most of us have brought them up..,..

It is just, to me, fascinating…[/quote]
So women are to blame for poor male behaviour?

Oh look. We've come full circle!

🙄

IamtheDevilsAvocado · 01/10/2021 14:51

@TheVanguardSix

Everyone thinks their brothers/fathers/sons/partners are the decent ones though

Yep! Currently- and this'll bring some sunshine to the day- my SIL, my daughter's godfather, and a close male family friend have all rallied around my STBXH as he cries 'poor me! After 30 years of being an upstanding GP, I got caught sexually abusing my own daughter. Nobody knew for 4 years and now I'm in big trouble because I got caught. Boo hoo! Poor widdle me!'

As for my abused daughter, not a soul on her father's side of the family is supporting her. He's a 'good brother' they keep saying... a good uncle... a good man. He has a good side!! He's not all bad. This sexual abuse is a bad part of him but the whole of him is good. Yada fucking yada yada yada.
I want to stab myself in the eyes!
Where's that Lee Evans 'talking shit, talking shit, talking shit' meme when I need it?

Jeez how awful for your daughter and you...Flowers.

Really hope the detractors see your STBXH who he ACTUALLY Is, rather than theur fantasy of him.

And this kind of proves the point.. Of the NAMALT threads... Yes we KNOW that... But the issue we can't tell... Event those we live with, under our noses can be mysogynist abusers.

LizzieW1969 · 01/10/2021 14:46

Everyone thinks their husbands/sons/brothers are the "good ones". Clearly some people are wrong.

My DM certainly was wrong. My F was sexually abusing my DSis and me under her nose and she knew nothing about it. She’s a very intelligent woman, too, so if she can have the wool pulled over her eyes, so can anyone.

I do trust my judgement where my DH is concerned; he’s never given me reason to think otherwise. But he doesn’t expect me to jump to his defence whenever male violence is spoken about; he doesn’t get defensive as he knows that we’re not talking about him but about men as a class.

IWillFindYou · 01/10/2021 14:01

@Pffffft

PS OP - I agree that there are more good men than bad and it saddens me that women are just turning against men because of some absolute monsters in the world.
He’s not a monster, he is a man.
Brefugee · 01/10/2021 13:56

However, I have heard people complain about man-splaying and misonyginstic language which I would not have categorised in that way

Look if you can't understand that a man calling out another man shouting "phwoar! i want some of that" is what is required here, i don't know how to make it plainer.

What is "man-splaying" is that a typo for mansplaining? Women tackle that themselves, i hope by saying "i know that Roger, i wrote the actual book you're quoting" and so on.

If it's a weird way of describing manspreading - well, again, that's not what we'Re talking about.

We'Re talking about "show us your tits" to any woman who walks into a pub full of drunk football fans (example)
Or passing round photos in a whatsapp group of their selfie with two dead bodies - reporting that to a superior officer.

How difficult would it be for the men in our lives to do that? Not very, that's what.

TheReluctantPhoenix · 01/10/2021 13:52

@CandyLeBonBon,

I find it fascinating that so many people don’t think one of the most important influences (if not the most important) on boys is their mother.

It is as if mothers just want to step away from their sons’ behaviour and blame other men.

Society is complex and we all have lots of things that make us who we are.

This idea that women are minnows in a shark tank, when most choose to live with and breed with the ‘sharks’ and that we can cut a neat line between the sexes and blame men for male behaviour even though most of us have brought them up..,..

It is just, to me, fascinating…

twelly · 01/10/2021 13:51

As a society we should value both genders, one isn't "better" than the other. This case is tragic it is unusual - the actions need to ensure this does not happen again. I don't believe we should be setting males against females, society is not inherently bad

CandyLeBonBon · 01/10/2021 13:48

[quote TheReluctantPhoenix]@AnyFucker,

You are doing a good job in channeling your inner Paxman!

I have given you examples of where female behaviour damages males:in schools, in workplaces and, I suspect, in some homes here where sons are brought up feeling potential violent bullies and rapists.

I don’t have to provide you with anything at all! You can read my posts, agree or disagree and respond or ignore-as I can to yours. That is equivalence.[/quote]
That's not female behaviour damaging males.

"While males still tend to predominate at the very highest level of academic testing, females on average score much higher than their male counterparts. And fourth, there are more than one million more men than women incarcerated. Prison populations skew towards the younger age range and many more college-age men are likely to be behind bars."

Women working harder at school and college and trying get ahead in jobs is not damaging males. Males not working harder is damaging males. Toxic male influence is damaging males. Women are not responsible for men beating up other men and ending up in prison. I don't understand how you can argue that's even a thing!

CecilieRose · 01/10/2021 13:46

[quote TheReluctantPhoenix]@CecilieRose,

So do boys and men just work harder or have more intelligence in STEM subjects?

It is funny how, when men outperform, it is the ‘system’ and when women outperform it is just intelligence and hard work.

There is little actual evidence for either section being more intelligent.

Have you not read Animal Farm?

We should strive for both sexes to achieve their potential, that is the way ahead for a successful society.[/quote]
Women have been excluded from STEM subjects for decades. Girls now outperform boys in STEM subjects at school, so what does that tell you? It was never about intelligence or aptitude, was it? It was women being excluded and discriminated against because men wanted to keep it blokey and cliquey.

Women were the ones who originally had all the programming jobs, then men decided they wanted them and became all gatekeepery about the entire industry. I faced nothing but people trying to put me off going into tech when I showed an interest as a teenager. I don't know any man who wasn't encouraged.

TheReluctantPhoenix · 01/10/2021 13:40

@CecilieRose,

So do boys and men just work harder or have more intelligence in STEM subjects?

It is funny how, when men outperform, it is the ‘system’ and when women outperform it is just intelligence and hard work.

There is little actual evidence for either section being more intelligent.

Have you not read Animal Farm?

We should strive for both sexes to achieve their potential, that is the way ahead for a successful society.

Ledition · 01/10/2021 13:38

Men actually blame women for this, too. Apparently girls are favoured by teachers and the 'system'. It could never just be that girls work harder and strive for better things. It could never be that women could have achieved all this all along had they not been subjugated by men. No, no, it's all a conspiracy to keep the poor white men down.

Yes Cecilie and the underperformance of working class white boys is often said to be due to them having no "strong male role model" but instead of actually placing the blame for that on useless, absent fathers the people who get vilified are the single mothers who are the ones who actually stick around and put the work in! Single mothers work harder than most any other contingent in society with pitiful support and they get the "blame"?? It's utter madness and it turns my stomach.