Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask DP to move out because of his cat…

110 replies

CatWoesman · 30/09/2021 13:56

DP and I have been together for 2 years.

We decided 5 months ago to move In together.

DP was renting a flat whilst I own my house, so we decided that for now, DP would move in with me and we would look to buy a place together next year.

So far, living together has been great, I love having him around and we are getting on so well.

There’s just one BIG problem.. his cat, Betty!!

He’s had Betty since she was a kitten, she’s now 7 6 years old.
She’s always been an indoor car (her choice) and I’ve always been pretty fond of her.

When I suggested he move into my house, I of course expected Betty to come too.

She’s never been an issue, always well behaved at DP’s house so I didn’t expect any issues from her at mine…. 🙄

The first week of her moving in, she began to pee outside of her cat tray.
She had a trip to the vets, several £100’s later and it was determined that there was no medical reason why, and that it must be behavioural.

We bought her some cat friendly plug ins Incase she was feeling a bit stressed with the move.
We bought an additional cat litter box so she could take her pick.

None of these things have worked and Betty is continuing to piss all over my house.
It started off as just on my landing, but now it’s wherever she fancies.

Not only is she pissing, but she’s also taken to scratching my sofa (which was brand new only last year) and is regularly sick which seems to always be on my rug.

My house is really starting to stink because of her.
I had a friend over a few days ago and she commented on how bad it was.(it really is bad, not matter how much cleaning we do)

We’ve since taken Betty back to the vet and again paid for more tests (including another urine sample) but all is well.

She was nothing like this at DP’s house so I can only assume she doesn’t like her new home.

It’s been 5 months now and she’s still not settling down.
She gets lots of attention, we both wfh several days each week so she has company, she has several cat beds to sleep on (one which she used as a toilet so we threw away) and always has ample supply of food and fresh water.

I’m not going to be that person that asks DP to rehome his cat, nor would I ever want or expect him to.
But honestly I don’t want her in my house anymore.😣

DP is good, he cleans up after her and I know he feels bad about her behaviour, but I don’t feel there’s many more options other than asking them both to leave.

I’ve never personally owned any animals as I think this is the reason why.

I’ve always been very house proud and now
I’m extremely embarrassed by the smell.

I’m at my wits end.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Roseyleaf · 01/10/2021 06:53

We had a rescue cat who did this.

Daughter suggested Jackson Galaxy advice of giving him his own furniture) a big indoor cat tree with hidey holes to retreat to).
Now he's a clean contented boy.

violetbunny · 01/10/2021 04:40

Also if she's scratching the sofa, try placing a cat scratching post directly next to the area she scratches most. We also have clear plastic scratch guards pinned into the sofa on the section they were scratching the most. This in combination with the post placed next to it has meant they no longer claw the sofa.

Cats have scent glands in their paw pads. If they like you then they will want to mix their scent with yours - naturally the sofa has your scent if you spend a lot of time sitting on it. So that's a big reason for wanting to scratch the sofa.

violetbunny · 01/10/2021 04:35

Please don't confine her to one room, at least not in the long term.

  • Cats are creatures of habit and don't like change. If medical reasons have been ruled out then it's likely stress causing her to toilet inappropriately.
  • It's essential to use an enzyme based cleaner in the spots where she has peed. Soap and water won't cut it - she will still be able to detect the smell and so it will signal to her that it's a toileting spot.
  • Other things that may help include some "safe" spaces for her - ideally up high (like a cat tower). Also giving her plenty of stimulation - not just petting but play sessions, an interesting view ( bird feeder outside the window is one our cats love), etc. Look up Jackson Galaxy and his videos on "catification".
  • When she pukes, what does it look like? If the puke contains fur balls then she may need to be brushed more regular and to be switched to a different diet to help specifically with hairballs. If no hairballs - there may be another reason.
Selttan · 01/10/2021 04:29

I also suggest a vet behaviorist. She may need to go on some anxiety medication.
Zylkene is something you can try yourself as it's a natural substance.

Lemonlady22 · 01/10/2021 04:26

Set her up with Alan, he can be her toyboy lol

PuppyFeet · 01/10/2021 04:23

What are you using to clean up where she has peed? If you’re using cleaning chemicals or bleach that may also not be helping…. There is a pet product called simple solution which removes the underlying smell to help stop them remarking in the area. You may need to go back over everywhere she has peed with that solution but it may help remove the smell for her (and you)… the issue now is the longer it’s gone on for the more the habit is ingrained..

I have animals and like you that would drive me to distraction… nothing worse than an overly animal smelling house… you have my sympathy.

Furries · 01/10/2021 02:48

Firstly, Betty is gorgeous!

I agree with others, she’s had a massive change in circumstances - 1 bed flat to larger house is a huge change. Added to that, a garden. You say it’s front and back garden, with back door left open as you’re at home. That is a HUGE shift in the scope of “her” territory. Let alone the increase in indoor space, there’s now a whole new world outside that she will have no experience of. Her whole system is going to be overloaded with stress levels.

I wouldn’t confine her to one room though. Is there anywhere in the house where she could be “shut off, without being just one room? Basically, just trying to create the amount of freedom she had in a 1 bed flat.

And knock the outside access on the head until she’s settled and “normal” in the house. And, when you d9 let her outside, I’d only do so if she’s supervised in the garden. I’ve missed how old she is. But if she has a few years of no outside access, she’s in no way going to be street smart or road savvy. So, she gets to spend time in the garden when you’re out there.

And yes to checking your cleaning products.

Thank you for caring enough to ask. And bollocks to those posters who just say get rid.

altiara · 01/10/2021 00:43

I think Betty is going to manage the OP out of her home.
Don’t trust cats #TeamDog
(I had 16 years of evil cat, how do you get a nice one?!)

TikTokNutcases · 30/09/2021 23:52

Oh gosh I really feel for you OP. I just couldn't put up with this.

My DM had this problem with her pets and it made my home life miserable. The place stank and I was so embarrassed to bring friends home.

So I could never put up with it. Betty would be out, with or without the DP.

HopeHappy · 30/09/2021 23:26

@tiggerwhocamefortea

A tortie! That explains everything then! You won't win against her you know OP
I was coming back to post this exact comment. Should have known it'd be a tortie!

Naughty Tortie as my vet calls them.

Strangely enough the peeing cats referred to in my PP are also torties!

WTF475878237NC · 30/09/2021 23:24

I agree you need to think like a cat not a human!

AramintaLee · 30/09/2021 23:18

Betty looks like such a pretty cat. Also I love the name.

I know this sounds really basic but I assume you've already checked the most common stressers ie. you haven't changed the type of litter tray (like from an open one to a closed one with a flap) or the type of litter? Also are you making sure the litter is far away from her food and water? Cats don't like using trays that are in close proximity to food.

I know this is quite a yucky suggestion but maybe try popping some urine in her litter tray (seriously, get your DP to pee in it a bit) A vet suggested that to us when we got a new cat who wouldn't use her tray and it worked wonders. I think sometimes they need the scent to direct them to it and if she's peeing elsewhere in the house, she'll be following that scent and not the one that leads to the litter.

I hope you are able to sort it out because rehoming a cat is always upsetting.

Voice0fReason · 30/09/2021 23:08

This was a poorly managed move, with the very best of intentions.

I agree with a lot of what has already been said and I wanted to give another vote for Jackson Galaxy. His Youtube channel is brilliant and you will find lots of great advice about issues like this.
This is a very solvable problem.

purpleme12 · 30/09/2021 22:56

I think you need to get a cat behaviourist out (or do a video call with them?)

Propertysearch · 30/09/2021 22:48

Poor Betty. I wouldn’t care about the furniture or the flooring. I would just want Betty to be happy again.

carlycurly · 30/09/2021 22:43

We had this with dps cat. It was horrific. The worst phase was pissing on our bed if we ever left the bedroom door open so the whole thing was soaked. We got through so many duvets. And on rugs. It was utterly grim and the smell used to make me feel sick.

I think a key element was massive jealousy of me and in the end a relocation overseas meant the cat had to be rehomed temporarily. He then died and sad though it was, I have to confess I was very relieved.

liveforsummer · 30/09/2021 22:23

@Flipflopfoodle

When I have dealt with cats like this I actually use a big (wolfhound size) crate with bed tray, food and water. Keep cat in there unless I am physically sat with them for at least 3 weeks.
This is a brilliant idea in the short term to slowly expand from!
GettingItOutThere · 30/09/2021 22:23

i would put her in one room, with her litter tray for a few days, so it is "her" room.

One of mine tried to pull this and shit on the floor, 2 days in a room solved that. Boundaries

she sounds stressed and I am not surprised why

HeckyPeck · 30/09/2021 22:04

I agree with others re it being possible that other cats or even the possibility of other cats could be stressing her out.

It is quite a lot to go from being a house cat to one with access to outdoors.

I hope you can find a resolution OP!

scarpa · 30/09/2021 21:32

Oh she's beautiful. Good luck with some of the suggestions here OP - I hope Betty (and you) are happier soon!

tiggerwhocamefortea · 30/09/2021 21:22

A tortie! That explains everything then! You won't win against her you know OP

Sommernacht89 · 30/09/2021 21:12

Oh,what a beautiful cat.Betty's world suddenly got massive and this causes her stress.Make her living space smaller and she will eventually settle in better.I wish the 3 of you all the best for a happy,pee-free home together.

CatWoesman · 30/09/2021 20:50

PS - Here is Betty.

To ask DP to move out because of his cat…
To ask DP to move out because of his cat…
OP posts:
Sandinmyknickers · 30/09/2021 18:59

[quote CatWoesman]@Aquamarine1029

I just don’t understand why she’d be unhappy.
She’s moved from a small 1 bed flat to a 3 bed house where there’s much more space for her to roam around.
She has a front and back garden, the back door
is always open and she can roam into the garden if she chooses.

She’s a really loving cat and It upsets me to have them both leave, but It’s making me more upset about my lovely home being ruined.[/quote]
OK I think you should have put this in your OP as I was also baffled until you mentioned how much more space she has. Cats are territorial. It sounds like maybe all the extra territory is freaking her out and she feels the need to mark it as her own. If you're willing to spend money on vet fees to sort this out, can you not hire a consultation with a cat behaviouralist who might be able to advise.
In light of your updates this sounds fixable

EmotionalSupportBear · 30/09/2021 18:58

something else you can try is scent soaking. Its about having items that smell of your DP, her, and you. Thats what the peeing is about, its stress, but its also scent marking.

She'll want to merge her scent with yours, if you and your DP confine her to a space for a couple of weeks, give up a couple of old tshirts each, leave them in her space for her to lay on, baby blankets can work too, if you sleep with them for a few nights, then give them to her... leave them around her space, then use them to expand her 'territory' once you open up the house to her again.

The other thing is work out if she's a ground dweller, or a tree dweller.. if she's hiding behind stuff/under stuff, provide more down on her level, if she likes being up, you need more up space.. so cat trees, windowsills, backs of sofas...etc.

The other thing that might be distressing her is outside cats, shut the doors and make her secure in her indoor space first before you even think of expanding it out.

The other thing to do is follow the hunt catch, kill, eat, sleep routine. Play with her if she'll play, for at least 20 minutes before she's fed, she will likely then just go curl up and sleep somewhere :)