Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Time in lieu for travelling to work

166 replies

Snyder86 · 30/09/2021 13:27

Maybe someone can provide with some help or guidance.

I work for an online company where everyone works from home. Every couple of months the company does a company wide "get together" where they rent out a large accommodation and we are all expected to travel to this location and work together usually for 2/3 days.

The travel itself is reimbursed for mileage and any expenses. However travel time is not. We have a work meeting coming up in a couple of weeks and the location has been set at a whopping 6 hour drive from my home. After alot of persuasion the company has agreed to pay for 1 nights accommodation on the Sunday night so I can travel down on the Sunday afternoon. Instead of having to wake up at 2am to travel 6 hours in order to be onsite to work at 8am. However when we finish work on Wednesday 5pm. I'm expected to drive home for 6 hours after a full day work then be available to start the next day at 8am.

In my work contract it does state something along the lines of "you must be flexible as from time to time, you may be required to work reasonable additional hours for the proper and effective performance of your duties."

I think it is under this clause that they are saying that travel time is not reimbursable. However something about this seems inaccurate. All employees work from home, this isn't a choice. It's how the company runs, we don't have a work office as everything is based online. So my home is my fixed place of work. Surely travel to a compulsory meeting, if the mileage and expenses are covered than the travel time to and from the location should also be covered? I appreciate that in some contracts it says something along the lines of "additional work is not paid" when you are a salaried employee. However you can't be expected to work for free so in these instances you are given time back in lieu which is what I would have thought to be appropriate in my circumstances however I am unable to find any information to either support or dispute this.
It's a shot in the dark but maybe someone here has more of an idea as to whether I am out of line to ask for the 12 hours in total I will be driving to be given back in lieu.
Thanks in advance

OP posts:
cloudyrain · 30/09/2021 15:10

To me it sounds a really badly thought up plan. Either everyone else has a easy travel distance and you should at the very least be allowed to stay over Wednesday night and travel home on Thursday, paid as a working day. Or if the place is remote and many are travelling why did they not run from Monday lunchtime to Thursday lunchtime to allow for travel?

Do they realise that not all people can travel on a Sunday?
I would not be able to get up at 2am and drive for 6 hours to then do a full day, and I definitely could not drive safely for 6 hours leaving at 5pm after a full days' work.

I am a business manager, paid well and would not accept that. DH is a very senior manager and paid very well, he does travel (when permitted) but any weekend travel is always TOIL and if he gets home late he won't necessarily go in early the next day. In addition whilst he is expected to fly around the world they would never expect him to drive for 6 hours before a full day meeting or to do this after a full day.

Chloemol · 30/09/2021 15:10

If it’s a 6 hour drive why can’t you fly? Or get a train?

NotDorothy · 30/09/2021 15:08

I wouldn’t expect to get paid for the time.

However, I wouldn’t be able to do the full day of work and then the six hour drive into the night. It’s just beyond what I can handle physically. I certainly wouldn’t be capable of showing up to work the next morning it I did arrive home safely. I would push back on that aspect of it. I would either want to leave earlier in the day on the last day or stay on a hotel the last night and drive back the next day.

KatherineJaneway · 30/09/2021 15:06

I've been given time in lieu for travel time before. For example I had to leave the house at 8am one Sunday to travel internationally for my role. I was given a whole day in lieu back for that.

However you need to check your HR manual, it will be laid out in there what you are and are not able to claim back.

Deliaskis · 30/09/2021 15:06

I'm also quite surprised at this. I travel a lot for work and we always get travel time allocated for TOIL, 5 is a day.

HarebrightCedarmoon · 30/09/2021 15:06

I get half a day's extra leave if we have to "work" (eat canapes and drink free wine) at the event of an evening.

But it's the only place I've worked where I have, and it's bloody brilliant.

imnottoofussed · 30/09/2021 15:04

When I had to occasionally travel in my previous job I could claim the travel time that was longer than my usual commute. Not sure how it would work with you having no usual commute, I'd expect paying or having time off in lieu for the travel time personally

TheSmallAssassin · 30/09/2021 15:00

And it doesn't matter that they pay for overnight accommodation, how could they not!? If it's a one off or an irregular occurrence, then that's even more reason for employers being able to stand the TOIL hit.

TheSmallAssassin · 30/09/2021 14:58

I am a salaried manager (but my contract specifies a certain number of hours per week, don't most?) If I have to travel further than my daily journey to work, then the extra time is generally counted as TOIL. Seems the fairest way to do it, to me, but there are always a few on here who want a race to the bottom.

For those trying to argue about the evening time, you are free to spend that as you please, as you normally do, so that's no different than your usual working day.

Dixiechickonhols · 30/09/2021 14:55

As a one off I’d do it and probably not say anything assuming they are generally ok re time off for dentist etc. Swings and roundabouts. If you were challenging it I think your best angle is too short time between shifts - supposed to be 11 hours rest. Plus risk assessment angle - is it safe to expect an employee to work 9 hours then drive 6 hours when tired. If you crashed on way home killing or injuring yourself and others potentially your employers could come under scrutiny in terms of an Employer’s liability claim.

HunterHearstHelmsley · 30/09/2021 14:50

I work from home.

I get any Sunday travel time as time off in lieu. We usually travel back during the day, if not, I get that time too. I'd be expected at work as normal the next day.

MissCreeAnt · 30/09/2021 14:50

@waybill but a daily commute of an hour each way adds up to 10 hours a week, which is of a similar order. I know it's not the same thing.

DeepaBeesKit · 30/09/2021 14:48

My employer are very reasonable but wouldnt reimburse for something like this, on the basis it's a one off.

I travelled to asia for work, I flew out sunday afternoon and went straight to the office from the airport, flew back through Friday night and got home Saturday after lunch. I did not get any TOIL.

Shedbuilder · 30/09/2021 14:47

As it's only occasional travel, and presumably most of the 6 whole-company get-togethers each year are held a lot closer to your area, and as they've agreed to pay for overnight accommodation the night before, you'd be unreasonable to kick up a fuss. Your contract specifies a need for some flexibility and this is one of those occasions when you need to show flexibility.

If you work from home I'm sure you can find ways to claw back that six hours if you really want to do it.

I once resigned from a part-time (18 hours pw) job when I turned out to be required to attend meetings in Huddersfield, Glasgow, London and Leeds each month and the travel time wasn't counted as working time. The shortest journey (to London) involved a total of 5 hours in a day. Glasgow was 14+ hours there and back on the train. The person in charge of the project expected me (and all the others involved) to travel on our own time, not the project's. Our mass resignation put an end to that: our contracts were swiftly changed to make travel time paid. But, OP, that was weekly meetings. Not once every eight weeks.

Beer2bed · 30/09/2021 14:46

I had this with an old company I worked for. Several of us expected to attend a conference in another country (cant drive to it) and head office booked the flights. Not the direct flight which would have taken 4 hours from leaving work at lunch time to conference centre hotel all ready for the next day. No, they went for the cheapest option which included a 3.5hrs wait for a connecting flight in the middle after we had worked the full day. Didnt get into the hotel until after midnight. Was the same length of time on the way back.

I told my manager I was taking the time back in lieu, that they could have booked the direct flight but choose not too. They saved the money but we lost our own time. Wasnt happy but couldnt really argue against it.

Comefromaway · 30/09/2021 14:46

We reimburse for travel time. Employees are expected to stand the first half hour each way(or normal travel time from their home to our office) themselves but get paid at single time afterwards.

Lifelines11 · 30/09/2021 14:45

It's sadly not unusual in some jobs for this kind of travel demand. I don't agree with it but think you'll struggle changing their minds. I changed jobs instead.

Haveyoubrushedyourteethtoday · 30/09/2021 14:43

I work from home and pre-COVID would have to travel to the annual conference. Usually would involve a short flight and airport transfers. I always charged for travel time. Though I am classed as a contractor..

simitra · 30/09/2021 14:42

As an academic presenting at international conferences we were automatically allowed time off in lieu before and after as "packing and preparation" and "travel" time. Less so for domestic travel.

I once flew back from Nepal with a young woman who had travelled onvards from China. The flight from Kathmandu alone was 11 hours and she would have been travelling 24 solid hours by the time we landed. We did not de-plane until 10pm and she expected to go into work the next day. When I urged her to take the day off she said she was quite new in the role and did not like to "make a fuss". I said well all the more important to begin as you mean to go on and not let your employer treat you like a door mat. Get your parent/partner to ring the company next day and tell them you are jet lagged and will be back at work on xx.

If you dont want to attend just be diplomatically ill. But dont mention travel time if you are going to do that.

Shewholovedthethebanhills · 30/09/2021 14:35

I’d get that time back in lieu. But then I work for a lovely company that values and tries to retain its employees. It is a highly-skilled sector though so they need to incentivise us to stay.

waybill · 30/09/2021 14:31

@Geamhradh

Luckily you don't have to travel to work every day.
Nobody would be crazy enough to take a job with a 6-hour each way commute, so hardly relevant...
MissCreeAnt · 30/09/2021 14:20

In my company this would be handled tacitly. For a 6 hour trip you'd come in an hour or two late the next day but fudge your timesheet as if you'd started normal time. This is what line managers told people to do because the timesheet system was a nightnare. But if course they would only say so verbally, not in writing.

It's a pain when work eats into the weekend. The question is how often. Once in a blue moon you just put up with it. If it becomes frequent, that's different.

Hardbackwriter · 30/09/2021 14:19

@SquigglePigs

I'm really surprised at the response here. At my company that time would be covered by the business, as toil rather than overtime but still, it would be on the companies time. If I was feeling generous I might just take the day after off rather than claim back the full 12 hrs but I wouldn't just suck it up, especially losing most of a Sunday.
But what would you expect to get toil for? If the travelling time then why not also the Monday and Tuesday nights?
Cheeseandlobster · 30/09/2021 14:18

Still less commuting than many do over a long period. Yabu

mumofmunchkin · 30/09/2021 14:16

@mumofmunchkin

I wouldn't get reimbursed for this in my job. I've travelled to Germany for a night before, got back on an evening flight, got home late and been in work the next morning - it's expected as part of my salaried role that sometimes I'll do that.
Just to add though, they are reasonable, and if you rocked up an hour late the next morning after a trip like that no one would blink.