Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Time in lieu for travelling to work

166 replies

Snyder86 · 30/09/2021 13:27

Maybe someone can provide with some help or guidance.

I work for an online company where everyone works from home. Every couple of months the company does a company wide "get together" where they rent out a large accommodation and we are all expected to travel to this location and work together usually for 2/3 days.

The travel itself is reimbursed for mileage and any expenses. However travel time is not. We have a work meeting coming up in a couple of weeks and the location has been set at a whopping 6 hour drive from my home. After alot of persuasion the company has agreed to pay for 1 nights accommodation on the Sunday night so I can travel down on the Sunday afternoon. Instead of having to wake up at 2am to travel 6 hours in order to be onsite to work at 8am. However when we finish work on Wednesday 5pm. I'm expected to drive home for 6 hours after a full day work then be available to start the next day at 8am.

In my work contract it does state something along the lines of "you must be flexible as from time to time, you may be required to work reasonable additional hours for the proper and effective performance of your duties."

I think it is under this clause that they are saying that travel time is not reimbursable. However something about this seems inaccurate. All employees work from home, this isn't a choice. It's how the company runs, we don't have a work office as everything is based online. So my home is my fixed place of work. Surely travel to a compulsory meeting, if the mileage and expenses are covered than the travel time to and from the location should also be covered? I appreciate that in some contracts it says something along the lines of "additional work is not paid" when you are a salaried employee. However you can't be expected to work for free so in these instances you are given time back in lieu which is what I would have thought to be appropriate in my circumstances however I am unable to find any information to either support or dispute this.
It's a shot in the dark but maybe someone here has more of an idea as to whether I am out of line to ask for the 12 hours in total I will be driving to be given back in lieu.
Thanks in advance

OP posts:
Flowersandjellybeans · 30/09/2021 15:58

I don’t think I would be able to claim it back, but rather than talk about time in lieu etc can you not keep it relatively informal?

I.e, block out the morning in your calendar, or the few couple of hours and just say, obviously I’ll be logging in late as I won’t get home til midnight?

I don’t think anyone could consider that unreasonable?

theemmadilemma · 30/09/2021 15:55

I've never been able to claim this type of travel back, no. I'm also full time wfh, if I'm required to travel, then it's at their expense, but my time.

ElephantOfRisk · 30/09/2021 15:55

My employer would generally expect that travel like this is done in work time and where this isn't possible we'd be given back the hours in unofficial ways.

SirChenjins · 30/09/2021 15:55

I would get TOIL for 6 hours - probably not for an hour or so, but that's almost a full working day and I wouldn't expect to do that in my own time, nor would I expect my team to do it.

I really pity some of you - some employers really like to squeeze every drop of blood from their employees.

Tommika · 30/09/2021 15:54

It’s not unreasonable to expect compensation in line with TOIL for travel time
No difference between salaried and hourly paid staff - for salaried staff you should have a contract as to what your working hours are - eg £x per annum working 42 hours per week including 5 x 1 hour unpaid lunch breaks. The hourly rate would be £x / (42 x 52) …. And that must result in more than the minimum wage
Add 6 hours each way and that’s 12 hours additional ‘work’ for free

If there was a normal workplace then HMRC would see any travel expenses as needing the standard home to work commute deducted, and usually that would also apply to travel time
With home based working (as permanent home working as opposed to Covid home working) then the full journey would be valid for reimbursement or TOIL

The relevance of the company being willing to pay for a hotel is that the trip is recognised as work
On another recent thread there was a member of staff being offered a lift by senior management, and in that it is normal that the journey was claimable by the manager - if it had been a lift to work as part of the commute then it’s reasonable for the passenger to contribute to fuel, but as a working journey it’s a business expense

Scrapper142 · 30/09/2021 15:53

It's a shot in the dark but maybe someone here has more of an idea as to whether I am out of line to ask for the 12 hours in total I will be driving to be given back in lieu.

Think this really depends on the company, answers so far have covered the full spectrum. If they weren't great about getting a hotel room chances are they're not going to go for it.

I think at a minimum you should be allowed to start after lunch on the Thursday.

Merryhobnobs · 30/09/2021 15:53

I work for an institution with several sites. We do take time off in lieu for travel to the place that isn't our normal site, it's done on a more unofficial basis though and time for further away like a conference etc would definitely be done properly and yes we should get it back.

Aprilx · 30/09/2021 15:52

I have done lots of travel for work, including at the weekends. Never have been reimbursed for the time, it is expected in many jobs and I think the clause in your contract about additional hours easily covers this off.

PeonyTime · 30/09/2021 15:51

Christ, I'm glad I didnt work for most of you, and I'm glad DH doesnt either.
I would have got back TOIL for this, ideally taken by working slightly shorter days, still within core hours, over the next few weeks. The people who worked for me would have got travel time over 40 hrs paid at flat rate. Work over 40 hrs whilst away paid at the relevant OT rate (flat rate til 8, time and a half after that or weekends, iirc). Given I used to rack up 70 /80 hrs weeks quite often when away, those that got OT loved those trips!
DH would be expected to travel in working hours, so no TOIL as such, but meetings like yours are usually held from Lunchtime to lunchtime a few days later.

UntilYourNextHairBrainedScheme · 30/09/2021 15:48

My DH used to have a job requiring similar journey times to exhibitions every couple of months and travel time did count as working hours (not his daily commute but the travel time from the office to the exhibitions). He always booked his hours (company policy) despite being salaried so effectively got time in lieu. However he was on a German contract not a UK one, which probably makes all the difference!

I had a salaried job in the UK which I had to do some international travel for back in the mists of time and there was no official time in lieu but very much the unofficial expectation someone who'd got back from New York on the red-eye would go home for a shower and a nap and come in after lunch and that would be completely appropriate. Coming back from Frankfurt late the night before and it'd be fine to come in a couple of hours later than usual. Nothing like all your door to door travel time back but perhaps half or a third, unofficially.

We sometimes travel for work in my current job and travelling is 100% working hours but we actually are working while travelling - we get 16 hours logged per day while away which we get back in lieu, essentially an extra week off - but its very different non office job, German contract.

Kettletoaster · 30/09/2021 15:43

I think it depends on the grade you work at. In my previous role in banking, I regularly (sometimes weekly) had to travel to London from the north of the country. Although expenses were paod, I never once got my travel time back as time in lieu. It was just an expectation that I did it (salary in £40k’s so not a exceptionally highly paid role)

Cameleongirl · 30/09/2021 15:39

@VeryLongBeeeeep Why is it tedious? People are just sharing their own experiences in the workplaces - and it seems that many don't get time in lieu for long travel.

Why is factual information tedious? The OP can certainly ask for time in lieu, but should have realistic expectations about getting it, IYSWIM.

MatildaJayne · 30/09/2021 15:37

I had a job involving a lot of travel, occasional overnights etc. Food, accommodation and travel costs were on expenses, travel time wasn't. I was deemed at a grade where I wouldn't be paid overtime etc, though I was fairly junior in reality.

SirGawain · 30/09/2021 15:35

Not sure you’ll have much luck asking to be paid for travel time, but I thought under working time regulations you had to have 11 hours rest time between shifts.
Does the working time directive apply after Brexit?

VeryLongBeeeeep · 30/09/2021 15:34

@TheSmallAssassin

I am a salaried manager (but my contract specifies a certain number of hours per week, don't most?) If I have to travel further than my daily journey to work, then the extra time is generally counted as TOIL. Seems the fairest way to do it, to me, but there are always a few on here who want a race to the bottom.

For those trying to argue about the evening time, you are free to spend that as you please, as you normally do, so that's no different than your usual working day.

Exactly the same for me. For those who don't have a fixed office base - so contracted homeworkers, or those who split their time between two or more sites - we have a 'reasonable travel time expectation' of 90 minutes, and anything beyond that would be TOIL.

The "I don't get that so nobody else should either / consider yourself lucky your employer hasn't chopped your legs off without anaesthetic and made you walk there on the stumps OP" posters are so predictable but so tedious.

FateHasRedesignedMost · 30/09/2021 15:32

I don’t think the travel time is reimbursed or given back as time in lieu, many jobs expect you to travel for meetings or conferences now and then. I’d only expect reimbursement if you have to stay in a hotel or travel abroad.

RJnomore1 · 30/09/2021 15:32

What does your contract say is your place of work?

On another note, I’d not feel safe driving 6 hours after a full day of work. 3 or maybe 4 yes but 6 is a long long drive.

funnelfanjo · 30/09/2021 15:28

Have never had it paid, but have had unofficial TOIL when travelling transatlantically over a weekend to be able to do normal office hours at the destination because generally I've worked for mangers who had discretion and common sense. The exact form depended on my manager at the time, but it has varied from an explicit "don't come into the office tomorrow", or some late starts/early finishes, or WFH with a light day - ie no meetings and just keep an eye on email for urgent issues.

In your case, as it's UK travel I'd expect that you'd have to swallow the travel for a regular meeting. However, you have nothing to lost by discussing with your boss and proposing a later start the day after your return.

LyingWitchInTheWardrobe · 30/09/2021 15:21

My job scenario parallels yours, OP. I can ask for (and will always get) hotel accommodation and I'm expected to travel in work time, not my own. That said, work time is often spent doing work and I can't realistically spend too much work time travelling as I'm busy.

It's not ideal but it's part of the arrangement. I don't mind it myself but I can see how this is awkward for you. If it's not too frequent I'd not make a fuss and I'd never recommend 'work to rule'. That's the beginning of the end.

Cameleongirl · 30/09/2021 15:20

As they're paying for an overnight stay, I don't think you can expect time in lieu. As PP's have said, people often travel for work at the weekend and don't get the time.

My DH, for example, is flying over 6 hours on a Sunday in a couple of weeks, for meetings beginning on Monday. All his expenses are covered, but he won't be getting time in lieu for missing out on Sunday. If you can negotiate it, great, but it's not standard practice, I'm afraid.

emmathedilemma · 30/09/2021 15:15

My travel time for meetings, training etc has never been covered. However, it would be frowned upon in our company to drive for 6 hours at the end of a working day so they would undoubtedly agree to you staying over that night, or travelling part way and staying over. If i was giving up my Sunday afternoon I'd be finishing early on the Friday!
Can you not get a train or fly if it's that far?

Triffid1 · 30/09/2021 15:14

I think there are a lot of things to be considered here. For a start, what kind of work is it in the first place because if you're on minimum wage for example, being paid by the hour, then yes, I'd expect to be reimbursed in some way vs chief marketing officer of a FTSE100 company.

Having said that, when I worked in a big corporate, while we certainly didn't get overtime or time in lieu on a formal basis, the company DID see it as their responsibility to make the experience as painless as possible. So, in a situation like yours, we absolutely would be offered the hotel on the Sunday night and on the Thursday morning no one would expect us to be at our desks bright and breezy at our standard 8am. I used to travel to the Middle East quite a lot, usually on overnight flights landing at 6am local and I'd get a hotel room booked from the night before so I could shower or even nap, and no one blinked if the first day in the office I left a bit earlier. Similarly, on the way back, my flight would usually land early London time and I'd either work from home or go into the office but head home early. That was considered perfectly normal.

Abouttimemum · 30/09/2021 15:13

I don’t have the answer but I’d get this back at my place. They’d say just start later the next day or knock off early on Friday / when convenient for you and when the the team to cover.

EgonSpengler2020 · 30/09/2021 15:12

Working times directive states you should have 11 hours between shifts, so they can not expect you to work at 8am unless YOU choose to opt out of the WTD

Dixiechickonhols · 30/09/2021 15:12

www.allianz.co.uk/news-and-insight/insight-and-expertise/driving-when-tired.html
If you scroll down to employers responsibilities it covers your exact scenario of travelling to place you don’t usually work.