Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Time in lieu for travelling to work

166 replies

Snyder86 · 30/09/2021 13:27

Maybe someone can provide with some help or guidance.

I work for an online company where everyone works from home. Every couple of months the company does a company wide "get together" where they rent out a large accommodation and we are all expected to travel to this location and work together usually for 2/3 days.

The travel itself is reimbursed for mileage and any expenses. However travel time is not. We have a work meeting coming up in a couple of weeks and the location has been set at a whopping 6 hour drive from my home. After alot of persuasion the company has agreed to pay for 1 nights accommodation on the Sunday night so I can travel down on the Sunday afternoon. Instead of having to wake up at 2am to travel 6 hours in order to be onsite to work at 8am. However when we finish work on Wednesday 5pm. I'm expected to drive home for 6 hours after a full day work then be available to start the next day at 8am.

In my work contract it does state something along the lines of "you must be flexible as from time to time, you may be required to work reasonable additional hours for the proper and effective performance of your duties."

I think it is under this clause that they are saying that travel time is not reimbursable. However something about this seems inaccurate. All employees work from home, this isn't a choice. It's how the company runs, we don't have a work office as everything is based online. So my home is my fixed place of work. Surely travel to a compulsory meeting, if the mileage and expenses are covered than the travel time to and from the location should also be covered? I appreciate that in some contracts it says something along the lines of "additional work is not paid" when you are a salaried employee. However you can't be expected to work for free so in these instances you are given time back in lieu which is what I would have thought to be appropriate in my circumstances however I am unable to find any information to either support or dispute this.
It's a shot in the dark but maybe someone here has more of an idea as to whether I am out of line to ask for the 12 hours in total I will be driving to be given back in lieu.
Thanks in advance

OP posts:
parietal · 30/09/2021 16:52

My work has the stingiest manager ever and he still said we shouldn't drive more than 2hrs for work and should train or taxi it.

TOIL was not official but everyone would do it unofficially as needed to recover from a trip.

HopeHappy · 30/09/2021 16:51

I have to say I'm surprised by some of the replies here. I run a business where staff have to travel to client sites.

We have a rule where the first 45 minutes of each journey (i.e. each way) is expected to come out of the employee's time, but anything over and above that is counted as hours and they can take it back on TOIL later.

Difference is, maybe, that this is timesheeted and incorporated in to our fees to our client.

icedcoffees · 30/09/2021 16:47

I used to get paid for travel time to anywhere that wasn't my usual place of work.

Last time, i went four hours away from home - I got my travel costs paid for as well and I travelled down during my normal working day so I was was being paid for that too. The same happened on the way back - I travelled back during the working day (leaving the destination at lunchtime) so I wasn't out of pocket.

YANBU at all to ask.

IntermittentParps · 30/09/2021 16:43

expecting someone to be in at 8am sharp if they're not getting home until after midnight goes way beyond a TOiL discussion into a duty of care one.

Thank you, that's what I was trying to say but badly!

TheSmallAssassin · 30/09/2021 16:43

I don't understand why there's all this talk of salaried roles being different? I have a "salaried role", but I am contracted for 37 hours a week. Is this unusual? I am a manager in a professional role, I keep track of all the time I work over (or under) my hours and then make sure I take TOIL if it builds up. But perhaps I just work for a decent employer? Their consideration of my own time as being important means that I am much more likely to be flexible when it's needed.

Skinnytailedsquirrel · 30/09/2021 16:40

I'd say that unless you are a highly paid exec then you should be paid. That's almost 2 working days. Pay for one day and one day of in lieu sounds reasonable if they are too tight to pay 2 days.

They'll think they are doing you a great favour by providing hotel accommodation. I know how some of these companies think.

rookiemere · 30/09/2021 16:35

I wouldn't expect time back for the Sunday overnight, but expecting someone to be in at 8am sharp if they're not getting home until after midnight goes way beyond a TOiL discussion into a duty of care one.
Depending on how busy I was at work I'd be telling not asking my Line Manager that I'd be in at 12 not 8 the next day.

Jsh125 · 30/09/2021 16:27

Wowzers, I must have worked for really nice organisations then. I used to travel long distances every couple of months for work and travel time was included as it's not your normal place of work. I'd be able to take it off as time in lieu. I probably wouldn't ever take the whole amount I was owed but I'd definitely have the majority & only didn't take the whole amount because they were nice to work for & I wasn't that worried.

FluffyTeddyBear · 30/09/2021 16:24

DH used to work for a company that required travel. Never got TOIL for it.

BernadetteRostankowskiWolowitz · 30/09/2021 16:16

So you have to give 12 hours of your time in addition to the 2 day event), for free?

IntermittentParps · 30/09/2021 16:16

The Dickensian 'I go to work on an hour's sleep if my wage lords demand it' brigade are out in force.

It's not at all reasonable to expect someone (unless they're really really senior/responsible, which, with apologies to the OP, I'm assuming she isn't) to arrive home after a 6-hour drive at about 11am and then turn up bushy-tailed at 8am the next day.
If I were a manager I'd rather give TOIL and have the staff member turn up on Monday afternoon rested and keen than see them at 8am, zombie-like after a long drive and a late night when they're unlikely to give of their best.

If you expect travel time why aren't you expecting to be paid for all the hours you're away from home?
What a bizarre question. The 'hours away from home' are work. Confused

Crazycrazylady · 30/09/2021 16:15

In my company, occasional travel time is expected and wouldn't be given as time in lieu.
Given its only a couple of times a year, I think it would give a very poor impression of you as a "clock watcher" to your company.

MrsColon · 30/09/2021 16:14

I think a company that cared about its people would allow the time back - if they don't, then it tells you what you as an employee mean to them.

SpiderinaWingMirror · 30/09/2021 16:13

I would expect accommodation the last night and travelling back in company the next day. I think I'd suck up the Sunday assuming that sometimes it will be closer

Wheelz46 · 30/09/2021 16:13

A member of my family WFH but is occasionally expected to travel, including abroad. They get travel expenses paid but not travel time.

LittleMysSister · 30/09/2021 16:13

I have never been in any (office/home-based) job where you would be expected to be at work at 8am the day after a work trip like this?

Whenever I have had to travel for work, all of my managers have said to start a couple of hours later/start at midday, or similar.

I wouldn't expect to get back every minute of time spent travelling, but I think it's normal to give some flexibility to acknowledge the amount of your own time you've spent engaged in a work event/travelling to it.

At the very least they should be giving everyone in the team the morning off when they know everyone is having to travel home the evening prior.

Leftbutcameback · 30/09/2021 16:12

Is it likely to be a regular thing? If all meetings are likely to be you traveling the furthest I would be having a discussion about that. If not I think for a one off I would just put up with it, and ask your boss for the relevant rest time (as mentioned by a pp - 11 hours) between arriving home and your start time the next day.

theleafandnotthetree · 30/09/2021 16:11

In my work - granted in the not for profit sector - you absolutely do get time off in lieu for travel time. It would be very difficult to get people to travel to things like conferences or meetings at a distance otherwise! I would not want to regularly put in 12 hour days on my salary unless I could get at least some of that time back. If what you are describing was once or twice a year I would suck it up as you have no commuting time normally, but if you were expected to clock up an extra 12 hours every two months or so, that might be a bit much. Does sort of depend on the salary level too though, if very well paid you probably won't get much satisfaction from raising it.

edwinbear · 30/09/2021 16:10

I used to travel a fair bit for work, travelling on a Sunday afternoon wasn't unusual, I wouldn't get TOIL but I didn't mind that. If I was working somewhere 6 hours away from home though and travelling back the same day afterwards, it was absolutely expected that I'd leave a bit early, somewhere between 3pm-4pm, so I'd be back home before 10pm. I'd expect the same from colleagues travelling from their homes in the North, to attend London based meetings.

sasparilla1 · 30/09/2021 16:09

I've often travelled several hours away the day before an exhibition, travelled back late and on some occasions worked an exhibition on a Sunday. I've generally been paid extra for working the Sunday, but not for travel time.

A lot of what you're complaining about is part of being salaried - travel costs, but not travel time.

However, I really do think that they need to cough up for another night's accommodation if you have a particularly stressful or onerous job.

But I also think suddenly coming down with Covid suddenly (as mentioned up thread by a pp) would be really poor form, especially as you've already high-lighted that you have an issue.

scarpa · 30/09/2021 16:07

I wouldn't get paid for this, but equally if I was getting home that late I'd be going in at 10 the next day and nobody would mind.

I think it's just part and parcel of the role, I'm afraid. I'd schedule an email to go at about 1am the night you get home saying "Traffic on the way home, just got back from [location] - will be in at 10 tomorrow!" and then at least you'll get a reasonable amount of sleep (assuming you'll get home around midnight with faffing/saying goodbye/a stop to stretch your legs).

MiddleParking · 30/09/2021 16:07

I’m ordinarily home based too but my organisation just wouldn’t have me driving six hours after a full day’s work. It would probably be another night in a hotel then travel home during work hours the next day. It would be the train there and back though and I’d be working on it. I’d take some time in lieu too - not the exact number of hours, probably, especially if that was 12 hours because that’s nearly two days and I struggle to take all my AL as it is, but I’d certainly get a day’s TOIL out of it if I wanted. I’d probably take that on the Friday if I could rather than banking it for later. When I was more junior this would all have been a more formal arrangement and someone would have ensured I took all the hours I was owed and documented it properly, now I’m relatively senior it’s more flex on both sides and me being responsible for managing my own workload and hours.

Chewbecca · 30/09/2021 16:07

I think it depends on the level of seniority tbh.

Contractually, neither I, nor my staff would be entitled to pay or lieu time.

I wouldn’t expect to get any pay / time in lieu but I would offer it to someone in your situation if they were quite junior and I felt they were going above and beyond what I reasonably would expect from someone of that pay grade.

Dixiechickonhols · 30/09/2021 16:00

Just thinking out loud. Is there a contractual requirement for you to be a driver/have a car for business use? Just thinking if not and you say you’ll get train it might not be feasible to travel back Tuesday night depending on train times and course location. Then you’d be travelling back on their clock day after (could work on train) Obviously another night away. Many reasons why you might prefer to use public transport including not feeling safe to drive 6 hours at night after full days work.

WellTidy · 30/09/2021 15:59

I see this in the context of my work as attending an annual/twice yearly conference type thing in a different part of the country to where I live.

I would expect to travel the evening before (so either a Sunday evening or outside business hours on a weekday), attend the conference (working day) and then travel back afterwards (that evening).

If I’d got in late, I would just go into work an hour or so late or work from home the next day. This element would be under the radar but a discrete and mutual understanding between me and my employer.

Travel time wouldn’t be given as toil but travel expenses would be payable.