Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Time in lieu for travelling to work

166 replies

Snyder86 · 30/09/2021 13:27

Maybe someone can provide with some help or guidance.

I work for an online company where everyone works from home. Every couple of months the company does a company wide "get together" where they rent out a large accommodation and we are all expected to travel to this location and work together usually for 2/3 days.

The travel itself is reimbursed for mileage and any expenses. However travel time is not. We have a work meeting coming up in a couple of weeks and the location has been set at a whopping 6 hour drive from my home. After alot of persuasion the company has agreed to pay for 1 nights accommodation on the Sunday night so I can travel down on the Sunday afternoon. Instead of having to wake up at 2am to travel 6 hours in order to be onsite to work at 8am. However when we finish work on Wednesday 5pm. I'm expected to drive home for 6 hours after a full day work then be available to start the next day at 8am.

In my work contract it does state something along the lines of "you must be flexible as from time to time, you may be required to work reasonable additional hours for the proper and effective performance of your duties."

I think it is under this clause that they are saying that travel time is not reimbursable. However something about this seems inaccurate. All employees work from home, this isn't a choice. It's how the company runs, we don't have a work office as everything is based online. So my home is my fixed place of work. Surely travel to a compulsory meeting, if the mileage and expenses are covered than the travel time to and from the location should also be covered? I appreciate that in some contracts it says something along the lines of "additional work is not paid" when you are a salaried employee. However you can't be expected to work for free so in these instances you are given time back in lieu which is what I would have thought to be appropriate in my circumstances however I am unable to find any information to either support or dispute this.
It's a shot in the dark but maybe someone here has more of an idea as to whether I am out of line to ask for the 12 hours in total I will be driving to be given back in lieu.
Thanks in advance

OP posts:
gogohm · 01/10/2021 18:34

Whilst it sounds tough, most people travel 30-60 mins each way every day so you are better off than most and knew the situation before you joined. Dp travels on Sundays often (well ore pandemic) and so time off extra though his boss did pay for me to come too once including my hotel expenses eg meals so not complaining

DriftingBlue · 01/10/2021 18:27

@Foolsrule

What happens if traveling on a weekend means you have to pay for childcare? Who covers that cost?
All part of professional life. You have to figure out child care, pet sitters, etc. At one job, I had a colleague who had his mail collected by a service, kept no perishable food at home, and lived in a flat with no plants because he traveled so much. I quickly realized I did not want to aspire to be him or any of the other star players at the firm who all had their own versions of lifestyle modification. For most of them it was a soon to be 2nd ex-wife who took care of everything.
Mollymoostoo · 01/10/2021 18:23

Get advice from someone trained in employment law. Personally I think the travel is classed as work as it is necessary to get to the location and it would be dangerous for you to be expected to drive 6 hours after a full day at work. However you might have to book time off the next day if you wanted rest as that technically is your normal working pattern.

EileenGC · 01/10/2021 18:18

Forgo to say. Daily allowance + accommodation + travel all paid by the company as well, unless specified.

cherish123 · 01/10/2021 18:17

Totally unreasonable! Are you in a union?

EileenGC · 01/10/2021 18:17

I don't get paid for the time I spend travelling - unless it's an overseas performance tour of 2-3 weeks, where we'll get a flat rate on top of the usual salary.

But, it's specified in my contract and it's the rule in my industry. It's normal for us to get in at 1am from the other side of the country, and be up, out the door and ready for work, by 8am the morning after. Work is always out of the home and not always in the same venue or with the equipment provided by the contractor.

It's just the rule in my particular area of work.

Sarbears28 · 01/10/2021 18:14

With my job we are expected to travel 4hours to a meeting but anymore we get to stay overnight prior and if it was a couple of days say Monday to Tuesday, we would be allowed to leave after 1pm on the Tuesday or if that wasnt possible and we had to stay until 5pm we would also stay that night in a hotel and travel back first thing Wednesday morning. The Wednesday would be classed as a half day unless we went back to work after travelling then we would be paid a full day. We also get a daily allowance for food and travel is paid for by my company.

Mumontour85 · 01/10/2021 17:50

I would definitely expect the hotel to be paid Sunday through Weds, and for a late start at work on the Thursday, but not the rest.
How far is everyone else travelling? Are you the furthest away? Could you get a train? Might be faster and less exhausting than driving that long. And if you have no meetings on the Thursday morn, what's to stop you starting late if you WFH anyway?! I sometimes don't start until 11 at home, so I just work through til 7 instead of stopping at 5...

SirChenjins · 01/10/2021 10:53

@TheSmallAssassin

This reminds me of those threads where it slowly dawns on a woman that her partner is actually awful, as people weigh in to say that what he is doing is not normal. But here we have people arguing that it's right that some people are treated less than well by their employers, we should expect it! We deserve more, folks! Lots of companies manage to treat their employees with respect and value their time, expect more, not less!
Agree. Stop being complicit in your own subjugation - it shouldn't be a competition to see who can do the most unpaid work for their employer.
TheSmallAssassin · 01/10/2021 09:12

This reminds me of those threads where it slowly dawns on a woman that her partner is actually awful, as people weigh in to say that what he is doing is not normal. But here we have people arguing that it's right that some people are treated less than well by their employers, we should expect it! We deserve more, folks! Lots of companies manage to treat their employees with respect and value their time, expect more, not less!

Upamountain43 · 01/10/2021 08:49

Everywhere i have worked this would automatically be TOIL - you could not have the first and last hour as it was expected that this was a reasonable commute time but everything else was TOIL whilst traveling. Overnight stays varied between two hours per overnight and 1/2 a day.

I have never worked anywhere where you were expected to do it all in your own time.

TractorAndHeadphones · 01/10/2021 08:42

You should get time off in lieu. Maybe not the exact hours but come into work late

HollaHolla · 01/10/2021 00:23

@Foolsrule

What happens if traveling on a weekend means you have to pay for childcare? Who covers that cost?
I’m assuming childcare can be claimed for, for essential work travel; but a colleague did once try to claim for a cat sitter. Not sure if that was signed off, though!
TheSmallAssassin · 01/10/2021 00:14

That should be your employer, @Foolsrule, but no doubt someone will be along to tell us we should just suck it up.

Foolsrule · 30/09/2021 20:29

What happens if traveling on a weekend means you have to pay for childcare? Who covers that cost?

BashfulClam · 30/09/2021 19:42

My husband drove from Glashow to Telford, leaving at 4am and getting home at 11pm. He wax paid mileage and expenses but nothing back for travel. I went to London for several
Weeks over 3 to 4 days and it was justvexirbses no extra pay or toil for travel.

tiktokdrama · 30/09/2021 19:22

I used to fly a lot for work, often Sunday evenings, I never got nor expected TOIL. Always made sure I expensed nice meals while traveling though

united4ever · 30/09/2021 19:22

I would expect to get the time back if not paid. I flew long haul for work a few time and got every hour back from leaving my house to the destination hotel. Around 30 hours for the return trip so had nearly 4 days to take as flex in that month. I think that is unusually generous though but as my boss kindly said 'well you could have been doing other things I suppose'. Was great.

Sandinmyknickers · 30/09/2021 19:18

Is it your choice to drive, or is there a train/ flight option that us quicker but that you are ignoring because you prefer driving?
I think that would be a factor when considering whether your request is reasonable. Tbh u can't think of many 6 hoir driving journeys that could only be driven and wouldn't allow you time for sleep/recuperation

Taswama · 30/09/2021 19:13

@takenforgrantednana

i would just tell them yo need to leave at12. due to the time needed for returning back to your normal place of work i.e. home. then go for lunch and just not come back and go home. the other would be if you had gone on the train you could have said your train leaves at......... and if you miss that then they will have to book you into a hotel at there cost
I think this is a good solution. You miss a bit of the working day but are not travelling late into the night. Money aside, it is unreasonable to expect you to drive a long way after a full day at work. You haven't answered as to whether the train is an option, although I've worked at companies where you were expected to drive as it was cheaper.
christinarossetti19 · 30/09/2021 18:55

I think it partly depends on whether locations are varied, so that different staff are inconvenienced each time tbh.

If they are varied and sometimes you only have to travel a short distance/time, that's different to you (and some other staff) having to spend 12 hours travelling every couple of months, while some staff never had these long commutes.

Although this could be covered in the part of your employment contract that you quote in your OP.

schoolhelp22 · 30/09/2021 18:36

Civil service here, I would be able to claim that back if I was travelling to a place I wasn't "pinned" to.

takenforgrantednana · 30/09/2021 18:22

i would just tell them yo need to leave at12. due to the time needed for returning back to your normal place of work i.e. home. then go for lunch and just not come back and go home. the other would be if you had gone on the train you could have said your train leaves at......... and if you miss that then they will have to book you into a hotel at there cost

Puffykins · 30/09/2021 18:14

Was it outlined that this would be expected when you joined the company? If yes then it is part of your role, if not then you may have an argument. For instance, I used to work in fashion - we did not get time off in lieu for fashion shows (so two months of the year we'd be working weekends and week days and be abroad - and as a writer I'd be filing copy at night.) However if something else happened at a weekend - such as having to travel to interview someone - we could take time in lieu. But there was also an expectation that we would work however many days/ hours needed to get our jobs done - and there was a quantitative amount we had to do, ie x number of features a month. We only got the time in lieu IF we had done that. Does that make sense? Is there a quantifiable aspect to your work output that means you can argue a day in lieu for travel?

ChrisS36 · 30/09/2021 18:08

Financial compensation is reasonable for fuel costs, accommodation etc. The clause in your contract would cover extra travel time however that would be reasonable to expect you to do that occasionally. Certainly any company I’ve worked would not give me time off though I’ve flown to Madrid to train staff then worked in London the next day. It’s tiring but part of my job.

Can you travel by train if it’s a 6 hour drive?