Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Furlough ending and lots of jobs available

112 replies

MLMbotsno · 30/09/2021 12:19

Ex colleague on furlough since the start moaning that furlough ends and may lose job. Had a whole year of staying at home paid furlough and knew this was a possibility did nothing to train or look for alternative to travel industry role of cabin crew.

Some sectors are calling out for staff but feels since cabin crew not all back should keep being paid. In normal times excess staff are laid off redundancy etc and have to go source another job.
In my opinion furlough has gone on long enough aibu? Cannot pay people to sit around anymore look fir another role.
Yabu furlough should continue for cabin crew etc to wait until sector fully recovers.

OP posts:
Minfilia · 30/09/2021 18:04

I work in the aviation industry. I know at least one airline is keeping all their staff on 80% pay despite furlough ending, mainly because they are already facing being understaffed for the summer 2022 period.

A friend of mine (cabin crew) was made redundant, placed in a hold pool, went to work elsewhere and was offered her job back from the hold, but told she had to start in two weeks and on a six month temporary contract. She took it, because if she didn’t, she’d lose her place in the hold pool and would not be offered her job back when things picked back up. It’s risky, but that’s her career, it’s not just a job.

I’ve never met anyone (pilots or crew) that haven’t loved their job. Anyone in aviation lives and breathes it, it’s your life and identity, not just a job. And unfortunately if you can’t be called back at short notice, you likely won’t be called back at all.

So I fully understand why people hold on to the possibility of going back and don’t ruin their prospects by working elsewhere.

Weepingwillows12 · 30/09/2021 18:04

Furlough was set up to support businesses through covid impact. Whilst for many areas the economy is up and running again, that is nowhere near the case with the travel industry in UK and Ireland although promising signs. I have sympathy for the cabin crew because maybe they like their jobs and don't want to change career. Conversely the cost of furlough to the country is huge and cannot go on forever.

Firmly on the fence here

icedcoffees · 30/09/2021 18:00

There are jobs available, but most of them are for minimal hours for minimum wage.

A recent job advertised here was four hours per week. That's no use to anyone and for many, the pay would be swallowed up by travel costs and childcare.

Oblomov21 · 30/09/2021 17:56

Agreed. Could of and should of at least been looking to see what transferable skills could lead to. Because we live near Heathrow, I know many many BA staff from school, and many have already found other jobs.

choixx · 30/09/2021 17:48

It's also more complex than the headlines of "millions of jobs available" suggest. There are lots of low paid jobs with bad conditions available for example. Ending of furlough is not necessarily reduce the labour shortages. There's no reason why the cabin crew worker in the OP has to take the fruit picker job.

HalzTangz · 30/09/2021 17:47

@MLMbotsno

Ex colleague on furlough since the start moaning that furlough ends and may lose job. Had a whole year of staying at home paid furlough and knew this was a possibility did nothing to train or look for alternative to travel industry role of cabin crew.

Some sectors are calling out for staff but feels since cabin crew not all back should keep being paid. In normal times excess staff are laid off redundancy etc and have to go source another job.
In my opinion furlough has gone on long enough aibu? Cannot pay people to sit around anymore look fir another role.
Yabu furlough should continue for cabin crew etc to wait until sector fully recovers.

They are BU, if they haven't been unfurloughed by now (let's face it flights have been running for months) it's unlikely they will return to work, they are likely to be made redundant. He or she should have been sensible and did some retraining for aback up plan in the event of redundancy
Tilltheend99 · 30/09/2021 17:44

You have no idea what your colleague has or hasn’t been doing during this time. He was/is employed, if he had changed employment before now and their had been another lockdown he would not have been eligible to be furloughed and would have no income. There are plenty of jobs about but mostly insecure work. Presumably he would also loose out aim any redundancy if he quit. Sounds like you are just salty that he was at home despite you presumably being in a better position by earning the full 100% of your wage.

MLMbotsno · 30/09/2021 17:34

@DeepaBeesKit

Yanbu. There are tons of retail and distribution jobs going. If people pick up these jobs as a stop gap there's nothing to stop them returning to cabin crew later on
Exactly. Better to employ people where there are shortages.
OP posts:
MLMbotsno · 30/09/2021 17:32

@luckylavender

What a nasty thread this is. Some people showing their true colours.
It's not nasty, it's just an opinion that it has been long enough now. I totally supported furlough and think it was one of the best things at the beginning but it cannot go on forever. We don't all have to agree.
OP posts:
DeepaBeesKit · 30/09/2021 17:26

Yanbu. There are tons of retail and distribution jobs going. If people pick up these jobs as a stop gap there's nothing to stop them returning to cabin crew later on

choixx · 30/09/2021 17:22

I cannot fathom why people are so nasty about furlough.

It's illogical, the idea that 9 mill people would not be able to do their jobs & be put onto benefits with little warning without any fuss is ridiculous. The gov wanted to keep people complacent & at home.

luckylavender · 30/09/2021 17:22

What a nasty thread this is. Some people showing their true colours.

choixx · 30/09/2021 17:19

People on furlough are also taxpayers

exactly, & some would have been spending, moving etc i.e all helping to push the economy out if the slump.

YANBU, furloughers have basically been on paid leave for a year and a half, the party has to end sometime.

I'm happy I didn't get a invite to that party.

choixx · 30/09/2021 17:16

This might sound harsh but claiming that their training has to be paid for by taxpayers when they had more than a year with no work to do is not really fair.

But why is it fair that I worked & didn't get a salary cut & have a fairly secure job?

choixx · 30/09/2021 17:15

happen!

choixx · 30/09/2021 17:15

I'd like to see a lot more money being made available to help people in this position to retrain.

This is a good idea, won't happy though.

choixx · 30/09/2021 17:14

This attitude annoys me, why shouldn't people be paid to "sit around & do nothing" if there place of work was ordered to close?

minipie · 30/09/2021 17:12

I can understand their reluctance to give up on a career they chose and trained for.

I also think that furlough needs to end. And as a pp said this may lead to a lot of redundancies which at least will help people retrain.

There are going to be an awful lot of painful adjustments over the next few years, not just for those whose jobs have disappeared but perhaps most obviously for them.

MargosKaftan · 30/09/2021 16:58

It is sad when anyone loses a job. And its safe to say, if you have lost your job at the end of furlough, unlike in the past you could go elsewhere to do a similar role, the chances are your job isn't viable anywhere and you will have to start again. So easy to say "retrain" but many have been clinging on to the hope of a return to 2019 jobs.

I do think it must have been obvious if you were one of those still on furlough at this point, it was because your job is no longer needed and they were just giving you as long as possible before the inevitable redundancy.

TheKeatingFive · 30/09/2021 16:11

I cannot fathom why people are so nasty about furlough.

No one asked to be put on furlough and these industries took the hit to lessen the impact of covid on the country. I’d be devastated if I now knew that the job I loved and invested many years in was going up the Swanee.

sst1234 · 30/09/2021 16:07

I am sure the freebie brigade will be along to tell you that you are cruel for not wanting people to be paid to do nothing even though the economy opened up long ago. The same freebie brigade complains that inflation is on the rise and everything costs more. When you pay people to sit at home and do nothing when there is labour a go shortage, that ls what happens - unchecked inflation.

People who have left it until now and have been sitting around on furlough should quit moaning.

trappedsincesundaymorn · 30/09/2021 15:39

You are allowed to work n another job whilst on furlough though so need not be on 80% 'waiting ' as you say fir redundancy

I wasn't. Unless it was voluntary, my (now ex, because the factory closed with the loss of 400 jobs), employer told us that we could not have any paid employment within our usual working hours 6am - 6pm as we were still contracted to them for those hours.

Tinpotspectator · 30/09/2021 15:22

I suppose OP, that you'd be quick to jump into a role packing frozen poultry in a freezer if you were made redundant from an aviation role.

LovelyLovelyWarmCoffee · 30/09/2021 14:58

@Fancymice I know they are also taxpayers, no need for the eyeroll. By asking for the govt to fund their training they are asking every taxpayer to fund it instead of paying for it themselves. So they are asking to pay only a tiny amount (price of training / number of taxpayers) instead of paying for all of it themselves.
I thought it was clear, but apparently not…

What training am I expecting them to do? Well this was in response to the poster who wrote
If your income has suddenly been cut to 80% of normal, it is unlikely you will have spare funds to train yourself so I don’t know, ask them? I understood it as a training for a different career if your previous field is not going to recruit for a while, so really it depends on what every individual is interested into, what they think they could do etc.

And finally I’m not sure to understand what you meant by
I imagine people gave stayed on furlough if they're in an industry like travel so they can get redundancy payment before looking for another job as people were allowed to take another job during their furlough so no impact to redundancy. I know the employer could object to this second job but from what I have read/heard employers allowed it in a large majority of cases.

TheKeatingFive · 30/09/2021 14:51

Most people still on furlough have had eighteen months to assess their skill set and work out (and apply for) alternative employment paths that their existing skills and experience could be useful for

I expect many still on furlough expected or hoped to return to their original job. It may have taken some people a while to realise that wasn’t going to happen.